Sally Taylor
Manager, Investor Relations
Replay available
TransAlta (TSX:TA) Q4 2018 earnings call, held 2019-02-27. Watch the replay and read the transcript on 6ix.

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/transalta-corporation-tac-q4-2018-earnings-call
Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
0:00 Good morning, my name is Mike and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the TransAlta Corporation fourth quarter and full year 2018 results conference call. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After the speaker's remarks, there will be a question and answer session. If you would like to ask a question during this time, press star, then the number one on your telephone keypad. If you would like to withdraw your question, press the pound key. I will now turn the call over to Sally Taylor, Manager, Investor Relations. You may begin your conference.
0:33 Thank you, Mike. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to TransAlta's fourth quarter 2018 conference call. With me today are Don Farrell, President and Chief Executive Officer, Brett Gellner, Chief Strategy and Investment Officer, Christophe Duhout, Chief Financial Officer, and John Kousinioris, Chief Growth Officer. Today's call is webcast and I invite those listening on the phone lines to view the supporting slides which are available on our website. A replay of the call will be available later today and the transcript will be posted on our website shortly thereafter. As usual, all information provided during this conference call is subject to the forward-looking statement qualifications which are set out on slide 2, detailed in our MD&A and incorporated in full for the purposes of today's call.
1:22 All amounts referenced during the call are in Canadian currency unless otherwise stated. The non-IFRS terminology used, including gross margin, comparable EBITDA, funds from operation, and free cash flow, are reconciled in the MD&A for your reference. On today's call, Don, Brett, and Christoph will provide an overview of the past year, an update on our coal-to-gas conversion, and hydro assets, followed by the financial results. After these prepared remarks, we will open the call to questions. With that, let me turn the call over to Dawn.
1:56 Thanks, Sally. And thanks to everyone for joining us on the call today. In just 22 months, the remaining legislated PPAs that were set up here in 2000 to bridge to the full deregulation of the electricity markets will expire. And really, that's not that far away. By the end of 2020, Alberta's transition to a fully competitive market for power generation will be in place. This event creates significant opportunity for investors in companies that hold low cost and competitive assets here in the province. Only producers with strong portfolios of competitive assets can be profitable and TransAlta has that portfolio.
2:41 Today, we intend to assure you that our plan to position for the new capacity market in Alberta is not only well underway, but it's tracking. You will also get the information you need to see that moving to a clean power company is profitable, it's right for the environment, and most importantly, it keeps prices affordable for consumers. Our presentation has been extended so that we have time to outline the significant progress we've made on our strategy. And of course, we want to take the time to share the highlights of our 2018 performance. On performance, you'll hear that 2018 was one of our best years in terms of safety, operational, and financial performance. Lots to be proud of.
3:27 On safety, total injuries declined 44% relative to 2017, a great accomplishment for all our teams out in the field. On operations, we had the best availability at Sundance and Keep Hill since 1990 and 2011 respectively, Again, a great accomplishment from the teams up at Wabubam. On financial performance, the cash we collected in 2018 from our operations, along with the one-time payment for the expiry of the Sundance PPAs, has made a real dent in our debt reduction target. Our performance has also been positively impacted by the Greenlight program. Over 1,600 initiatives by employees generated $70 million of value in our 2018 numbers, value that also rolls forward into 2019.
4:22 In 2019, the program moves into sustainment and becomes a permanent feature in our operating model. On strategy, you'll hear that we're growing the cash flows of TransAlta Corporation with investments in coal to gas, the realization of value from our hydro operations, and through our ownership in TransAlta Renewables. Our strategy is simple and the outcomes of it are measurable for shareholders. By the end of this call, we hope that the many questions around our hydro assets will be answered. We want investors to understand that the change in profitability of the hydro assets here in Alberta in 2021 is real, it's positive, and it's sustainable over the long term.
5:10 You'll also be able to see that the returns in the coal-to-gas conversions are more than compelling and benefits increase to shareholders and customers if we can accelerate that program. The list of things to do is getting shorter as we move towards executing our first investment from coal-to-gas at one of our Sundance units. Finally, we will discuss the growth we landed in 2018, which is not only profitable, but can be financed entirely inside of our TransAlta Renewables entity. This is a critically important point that we really want to land today on this call. Windrise, Antrium, and Big Level are great projects with returns that exceed the cost of capital and that combine together at $40 to $45 million of EBITDA by 2022.
5:58 Today, we've structured the call a bit differently. Brett Gallner has joined us on the call as he is the lead on the coal to gas investments. and he'll also provide you with an update on the hydro front so that you have clear line of sight to what happens when the PPA expires at the end of 2020. Following my remarks and Brett's discussion, Christoph will take you through the details of our financials in 2018. I've provided this slide because I want to talk for a minute about how we strengthened the team here, the executive team here at TransAlta to ensure that we have the amount of focus that we need on our strategy. Some of you have briefly met Christophe Dehout, our new Chief Financial Officer.
6:44 Christophe comes from a large international European energy company, has over 25 years experience in all aspects of financing large infrastructure, and that includes power generation. And you're going to hear from him shortly. Kerry O'Reilly-Wilkes has joined us as Chief Legal and Compliance Officer. Her career in one of Canada's top legal firms and her comprehensive and practical experience in the mining business has allowed her to get up to speed in our industry very quickly. Jane Fedoretz accepted a role as the Chief Talent and Transformation Officer. She brings with her an impressive track record that combines her background in law with her exceptional skills in people development and leadership. Her role is to move Greenlight to sustainment in 2019 and to develop even stronger programs and practices to strengthen and develop our people in this time of intensive change.
7:39 The addition of these talented leaders has allowed the rest of the executive team to really focus on key elements of our strategy. Brett Gellner has built a team to execute the coal to gas strategy. He will take you through the extensive work they've done and also take you through the hydro analysis. John Kousinioris is now is now focused exclusively on running and growing our gas and renewables business. He is ensuring that TransAlta Renewables can fund both the growth we've delivered and what we are planning. Don DeLima is focused on creating an exceptional shared services business so that we can continue to gain efficiencies in our overhead. And finally, you'll see today that having Wayne Collins focus exclusively on day-to-day operations at coal has really paid off.
8:30 This slide outlines some of our key accomplishments in 2018 and congratulations to our employees who did all of this work. This morning we reported strong financial and operating performance in 2018, including our highest free cash flow generation in recent years and an 18% increase over last year. Our focus remains on increasing sustainable free cash flow as our key metric, as we believe that this metric gives investors clear line of sight on the amount of capital available for debt reduction, shareholder returns, and growth. I'm very pleased to be able to say today that we delivered free cash flow that exceeded the high end of our guidance in 2018.
9:17 You all know that we've been focused on paying down debt and strengthening our balance sheet so that we can enter into a new competitive and regulatory environment in our major Alberta market with the financial strength and flexibility we need to be successful. Today, already, we have one of the strongest balance sheets in the industry and strong credits supported by our contracted assets. We have reduced net debt by $1.1 billion since 2015. In 2018, we transitioned our Sundance plant off the PPAs and into the merchant market. The one-time payment from the balancing pool was effectively three years of capacity payments for those units. After consolidating the units, our job was to make the remaining Sundance units profitable without PPAs until such time that they could be bid into the capacity market.
10:11 The coal team in 2018 was able to deliver availability, utilize gas through coal firing, reduce costs, achieve profitable margins, and improve safety. a very impressive outcome. Brett is going to take you through the detail on how far we've come on our execution of our plan to convert units to gas. He will also demonstrate that our units on gas create sustainable cash flows until the 2035 to 2039 timeframe, even at low prices. This next slide talks a bit about the work we've been doing at TransAlta Renewables. TransAlta Renewables has had some nice wins on the growth front in 2018. This past year, we successfully progressed construction of several projects and secured new contracts for other.
11:03 By investing very moderate development dollars in brownfield projects in TransAlta and then taking advantage of the lower cost of capital in TransAlta Renewables, we can finance growth in TransAlta Renewables to the benefit of both sets of shareholders. The capacity of TransAlta Renewables to finance using its credit facilities allows us to hold our 61% ownership and we don't need to allocate cash from TransAlta to this growth. This is a key point on our call today. Growth in TransAlta Renewables benefits TransAlta by ensuring our dividend payment remains steady and it extends our overall portfolio life, which reduces the cost of capital for TransAlta Corporation as a whole.
11:51 Another key point. Last year, we grew TransAlta Renewables by dropping down Lakes Wind, Kent Breeze, and MassFolar projects, generating over $100 million in proceeds that we then used to strengthen our balance sheet at TransAlta. We also completed Kent Hills 3 wind project, and we advanced the construction of Big Level and Antrium wind facilities. Our most recent announcement of the Wind Rise Wind project here in Alberta is an excellent future candidate for TransAlta Renewables. We'll show you today that TransAlta Renewables can fund all of these projects using its credit facilities. Now why is this such an important point? Because it means that the free cash flow at TransAlta can be directed to strengthening our balance sheet, funding our coal to gas conversions, and eventually increasing our ability to return cash to shareholders.
12:50 In terms of our financial highlights, I've already talked about our free cash flow of $367 million, a strong result over 2017. When I sit back and reflect on 2018, the hard work and the perseverance of Wayne Collins and the Alberta Thermal team must be recognized. This past year, they were able to improve availability and safety while transitioning to Sundance Fleet. The team faced many challenges, but they rose to the occasion and they delivered for the company. They found ways to add margin, they lowered fixed costs at the mine and at the plant, they lowered operating costs, and they set up the mine for the coal deliveries to the end of its life, which was around 2023. The rest of the operations, people worked extremely hard and delivered what we thought they would. We did have a nice surprise, a nice upside in the hydro business as prices improved in the market.
13:45 You also see on this chart that EBITDA was slightly down, which is primarily due to a mark-to-market at Centralia, and Christophe's going to take you through that in his section. I do want to take a few minutes to talk about Greenlight because it's been a central transformation for the company since 2016. I want to congratulate the TransAlta team on the extensive work they've all done across this company to make Greenlight a very successful program. Let me remind you The Green Light is a program we've been using across the company since September of 2016 to not only increase our execution capability, but to realize value and cost savings on many fronts. Green Light projects are employee-driven.
14:30 We completed over 1,600 projects with over $70 million of pre-tax value which flowed into our 2018 results. And these projects continue to produce value in 2019 and beyond. Every project in our Greenlight program is tracked, it's auditable, and we can trace the performance of these projects into our financial calculations. The benefits of the program are enormous, and they affect more than our financial results. Greenlight goes after projects that offset any headwinds that we experience after setting our budgets. It goes after future increases in costs from suppliers or service providers, and it delivers incremental new value in assets through innovation.
15:15 Let me talk for a minute about the new value creation through innovation, and these are in our existing assets. Our team at Sarnia found a way to lower the set point on their turbines while running on steam. This reduced their natural gas costs. Our team at Alberta Coal designed a project to utilize the existing gas infrastructure to co-fire gas and reduce greenhouse gas costs. Our team in GAS redesigned their capital program to ensure that only projects with the highest returns and benefits to the company get through their stage gates. Projects in our transformation are not all about cost reductions, reductions in workforce, and direct value creation. They also streamline processes so that we can improve our focus on safety, which you saw results on, and on customers. This is a company-wide program where any group or any single employee can use the discipline in Greenlight to bring their projects to light and gain cross-company assistance for achieving milestones.
16:19 So let me end by saying that I phone employees weekly to gain their insights on why the program works and what we can do to continue to improve it. What they tell me is that we've moved accountability and decision-making to the right levels, people, and teams in the organization. I've included this next slide to reinforce how having two companies with different costs of capital benefit TransAlta shareholders. At TransAlta, we just started using serious capital to complete our coal-to-gas transition. Our investment in the Pioneer Pipeline project was the first serious capital that we put to work to make this strategy a reality. Brett will demonstrate that we will lower our costs significantly and increase our competitiveness in the Alberta market by investing in these conversions as soon as we can.
17:13 By maintaining our hydro assets, we are preparing for 22 months from now when the hydro PPA expires along with the other PPAs here in Alberta. You'll see in Brett's presentation that the combined cash flows of the thermal fleet and the hydro fleet under various pricing assumptions generates cash to 2035 and beyond. This information will demonstrate the value of TransAlta going forward. TransAlta Renewables has a very low cost of capital, which is expected in entities that invest in long-term contracted assets and that return most of their capital to shareholders through their dividends. As a 61% shareholder of that entity, we want TransAlta Renewables to add assets that returns above their cost of capital with long-term contract lengths in diversified geographies and technologies.
18:07 TransAlta applies its expertise to prospect, develop, and construct contracted gas and renewables projects with a view to increasing value prior to a drop-down in trends to TransAlta renewables. We get returns for this effort in TransAlta. TransAlta will sometimes start a project and get it up and running for a future drop-down to TransAlta renewables. Windrise falls into that category. Today, our three wind farms, Windrise, Antrim, and Big Level, can be entirely funded inside TransAlta Renewables. This means cash flow at TransAlta can focus on coal-to-gas conversions. In summary, as we complete our transition off the PPAs here in Alberta and move to the capacity market, as we move off coal and onto gas, TransAlta will have a strong foundation of cash coming in from TransAlta Renewables the Alberta Hydro Assets, and from our thermal fleet in Alberta. This cash will be available for allocation to shareholders through dividend and share repurchases.
19:13 I'd like now to turn the call to Brett, who will take you through all his work on coal-to-gas conversions and who will give you a really good summary of how to evaluate what the value is in our hydro assets once the PPA expires.
19:29 Okay. Good morning, everyone, and thanks, Dawn. So as Don indicated, I'm going to review our coal to gas strategy and the future upside in NBDA from both our converted coal units and hydro assets. In terms of our coal to gas strategy, the first key message I want you to take away is that the economics and benefits of converting to gas is driven by a number of factors, not just carbon policy. Secondly, our strategy to convert is on track and we're targeting the first conversion for the second half of 2020. Finally, we're also evaluating a repowering option for some of the units, which has the potential to deliver significant long-term value. In terms of our hydro assets, I'll walk you through the significant upside in IBTA once we're off the PPA. Our hydro business delivered 109 million of IBTA in 2018, but I'll show you it would have delivered 244 million without the PPA. Finally, I'll show you that there is significant potential upside in the combined converted coal fleet and hydro business in the future.
20:32 So now just turning to this slide, as we've discussed in the past, there are significant benefits to converting the coal fleet to gas. First, if the units are not converted, they have to shut down under provincial and federal government regulations between the end of 2026 and the end of 2029. This impacts all coal units in the province, not just Transaltas. The outside data which all coal units in the province must shut down is the end of 2029. However, if converted to gas through a boiler conversion, the units can run significantly longer under the federal regulation that was put in place last year. How long a unit can run depends on its carbon emission intensity. For TransAlta units, we expect that all the sub-critical units will receive 8 more years and the super-critical units 10 more years.
21:25 As a result, these units will be able to run out until 2034 to 2039. The cost of converting the units and therefore getting the extra years is very low at under $90 per kW compared to a new combined cycle or gas peaker in the range of $1,400 per kW. Another significant benefit of converting is that it avoids the need to invest significant capital in low NOx burners and operating costs for dry sorghum injection in order to meet the provincial NOx and SOx regulations. If the units are not converted, not only would we not get the extra years, we would have to spend over $300 million to meet the NOx and SOx limits.
22:11 The capital and operating costs once converted also declined significantly. Fewer people are required to operate the facilities and the mine capital and operating costs go away. Maintenance capital is also expected to be lower as there is less wear and tear in maintenance on the boilers and equipment due to the elimination of coal and fly ash. In addition, carbon costs are significantly lower burning gas than coal, and there is an abundant supply of gas in Western Canada, resulting in very attractive gas prices at some points in the year. The units are also more flexible on gas, allowing them to be more responsive to changes in load and market conditions. Finally, conversions are relatively low risk projects and are proven. The outage time to do the conversion is expected to be approximately 60 days and these projects have been successfully completed in the United States, some of which we have visited.
23:09 So now in terms of status, in order to fully convert, we need more pipeline capacity into the sites as the existing pipeline is relatively small in diameter as it was designed just for startup gas and heating the buildings. As a result, we entered into the partnership with Tidewater to build the Pioneer Pipeline, a new 20-inch pipeline into Sundance and Quay Pills, and that pipeline is under construction and expected to be in service by the second half of this year. Our overall pipeline strategy is to have two pipes into the site in order to ensure maximum reliability and flexibility and access to multiple sources of natural gas. Therefore, while we have the existing smaller pipeline, we are in discussions with other parties regarding the strategy for the second pipeline.
23:56 While we have been co-firing some of the units since early last year to reduce carbon costs and take advantage of low gas prices, we are limited to how much we can co-fire given the limits on the existing pipeline. Therefore, the Pioneer pipeline will allow us to co-fire even more even before we fully convert to gas. In terms of the boiler convergence, we have received approval for the convergence from the Alberta Utilities Commission and are just waiting for Alberta Environment and Parks approval. We expect to issue limited notice to proceed for two conversions over the next couple of months in order to finalize the engineering work and plan on issuing final notice to proceed on those units by mid this year. We will then proceed with the other units after that.
24:42 We're targeting all of the conversions to occur over the late 2020 to 2023 period with the first one targeted for the second half of 2020. Now, as I mentioned earlier, we have also started to evaluate the potential to repower one or two of the units instead of doing boiler conversions on them. Repowering would involve installing one or more combustion turbines in HRSECs and then using the steam from them to operate the existing steam turbines in the coal units. As a result, the boilers associated with those units would be retired. We have completed an initial study on this opportunity and visited a power plant in the United States that was repowered and has been successfully operating for 10 years. These projects are delivering heat rates consistent with new combined cycle plants, but at a capital cost that is 40 to 50 percent less than a new combined cycle.
25:35 The other benefit is that these units can run as long as equipment will allow, so potentially 20 to 25 years. Therefore, based on the work we've done to date, this opportunity looks promising and we'll keep you posted as our work progresses. This slide compares the cost of the boiler conversion and repowering combined cycle to a new combined cycle and new gas peaker. So as you can see, the boiler conversions and repowering are at a fraction of the cost of new builds because they utilize equipment that is already there. As I indicated, our capital and OM&A costs are expected to decline significantly once the units are fully converted. This slide shows our historical OM&A and capital costs at the coal plants and what we expect them to be once the units are fully converted to gas.
26:25 In the middle, we have also included the average annual cost to meet the NOx and SOx that would be required if the units stayed on coal. As you can see, our costs will go down significantly once converted I should point out that these are annual averages and the amount in each year will vary based on the timing of planned major maintenance outages. So in terms of the Pioneer pipeline, as I noted, it's progressing very well as you can see by the picture. This project is being built at a very competitive cost when compared to other natural gas pipeline projects. On the bottom left, we show the potential IBDA that TransAlta could generate from its 50% ownership in the pipe at different throughput volumes. The range of volumes shown reflect the potential volumes TransAlta will need from the Pioneer pipeline as the units at Sundance and Key Pills convert fully to gas.
27:20 So now I'm going to switch gears and spend a few minutes on the potential upside from our hydro assets once they come off the legislative PPAs at the end of next year. John Kousinioris, who heads up our gas and renewables business, is also here and can help answer any questions at the end of the call. Before discussing the ancillary market and our hydro, It's important to remind people that the Hydro PPA was put in place at the same time as all the other legislative PPAs. While some of those original legislative PPAs have already expired or been handed back to the asset owners, a number of them are still in place, including the Hydro one. As you can see, all of them expire at the end of 2020, at which time the owners of the facilities, whether it's a Coal PPA or a Hydro PPA, will capture all the revenue they generate from the energy, ancillary, and capacity markets they provide to the market and also incur all the associated costs to operate those units.
28:18 Our hydro assets in Alberta, because of their storage capability and ability to respond quickly to market needs, provide energy, ancillary, and capacity services to the market and will continue to provide those services even after the PPA expires. In terms of the ancillary service market in Alberta, this slide shows the size of the market by product and what technologies service the market. In total, the market is approximately 7,800 gigawatt hours in size, and hydro has historically supplied approximately 47% of the active market. As a result, TransAlta's Alberta hydro assets not only generate approximately 1,500 gigawatt hours of energy every year, but also sell approximately 3,000 gigawatts of ancillary services.
29:07 Ancillary service prices per megawatt hour vary depending on the type of product, but on average sell for about 50% of the 24-7 energy price. As well, the 1500 gigawatt hours of energy that hydro generates tends to be during more peak hours. So now to show the upside of the hydro assets once they come off the PPA, we have provided more disclosure in our MD&A under the hydro section. In 2018, our hydro assets generated $109 million in EBITDA, and as I will walk you through now, they would have generated $244 million if the current PPA did not exist, assuming the capacity market was up and running and delivered similar capacity revenues.
29:53 So let me now walk you through this chart. So the first two bars on the left show how much energy and ancillary service revenue TransAlta generated in 2018. Thank you. Thank you. Again, the price of future capacity is unknown at this time, but to put it into perspective, the current payment is under $6 per KW a month when applied to the full nameplate capacity of the Alberta hydro assets.
30:47 The next bar is other revenue we generate from our hydro segment.
30:52 We generate revenue from our other hydro assets in Alberta, BC, and Ontario. Most of those are under long-term PPAs with local utilities. We also receive revenue in Alberta for other services such as Black Start and water management services. And finally, we include in this segment revenue from the very small regulated transmission assets we own in Alberta. Our cost to operate all of our hydro fleet was $47 million in 2018. And when this is deducted from all the revenue I just walked you through, you get the $244 million of VBDA that would have been generated if the PPA did not exist and we were in a capacity market. Under the PPA, however, we paid to the balancing pool in 2018 a net amount of $135 million for energy and ancillary obligations, net of some costs.
31:41 This is the amount that goes away once the PPA expires. I should note that the balancing pool in their public reports do provide the PPA obligation volumes for the energy and ancillary services for hydro. So, as you can see, there's significant upside from our hydro assets in the future. Well, what we have shown here is based on 2018 results. The amount these assets generate in the future will be subject to future energy, ancillary, and capacity prices. Okay, so now I just want to wrap up my section by showing you the potential libidier that the converted coal units and our hydro assets in Alberta would potentially generate under different all-in prices. First, in terms of prices, this chart shows historical prices under the energy-only market, and what one forecaster, EDC Associates, is projecting for prices once the capacity market is fully functioning.
32:37 For the historical period shown, prices averaged approximately $50 per megawatt hour.
32:42 If we exclude 2016 and 2017, a period during which some offers into the market were not being bid on reasonable commercial terms, the average price was just around $60 a megawatt hour. In comparison, EDC is projecting all-in prices in the range of $75 to $80 a megawatt hour once the capacity market is in place. I should also note that the ISO did some analysis about a year ago that provided prices in the low to high $60 range once the capacity market was in place. So this chart shows the potential of a DA from our hydro segment and the converted coal fleet using the price range discussed on the previous chart. As you can see, at an all-in price of $50 a MWh, the assets are expected to generate EBITDA similar to what they generated in 2018.
33:32 Using the more normal historical average of $60 MWh or EEDC's forecast, you can see the assets would generate significantly higher EBITDA. These EBITDAs assume the capacity market is fully functioning and TransAlta's coal-to-gas strategy is complete. Also note that this chart does not include the EVTA from all the other assets TransAlta owns in Alberta and other jurisdictions. So with that, I'm going to now turn the call over to Christon.
33:59 Thank you, Brett, and good morning, everyone. I'm thrilled to be participating in my first TransAlta conference call and look forward to many more with you in the future. I will start with a quick overview of our performance for the fourth quarter of 2018. and our financial results for the full year. Following that, I will take you through the evolution of our debt and capital allocation for both TransAlta and TransAlta Renewables and the impact of our last renewable projects on our future results. First, looking at the quarter. Oil prices in Alberta were strong, averaging $55 by megawatt hour, compared to $22 for the same period in 2017.
34:51 This increase is primarily due to higher carbon compliance costs and improved market fundamentals. As Don mentioned, our fleet availability was stronger during this quarter than it was in 2017 due to lower outages and the rates in Canadian coal. This was partially offset by higher outages at our coal units centrally in the U.S. These factors supported financial results equivalent to the fourth quarter of last year, during which we still benefited from the Sundance PPA. Our fourth quarter EBDA of $233 million was $42 million lower than in 2017, partially due to outages and a negative change of $28 million in the mark-to-market of our commodity hedges for our U.S. coal operations.
35:47 This mark-to-market movement does not impact our funds from operation or free cash flow and we expect it to reverse in 2019. We also saw a reduction of 10 million in our Canadian coal EBDA due to higher carbon compliance and coal costs, as well as lower fixed revenue due to the terminated PPA ascendance. Hydro, Australian and Canadian gas operations, had stronger quarter results and outperformed the fourth quarter of 2017. As you can see at the bottom right of the slide, our 2018 EBDA reached more than $1.1 billion. This amount includes the one-off PPA termination payment of $157 million for some of our Canadian coal assets.
36:37 After adjusting for this amount and the $34 million one-off Our EBDA is slightly below our 2017 results at 966 million. However, this amount also includes the negative mark to market of our commodity hedges for a total amount of 22 million. Without this, our EBDA would reach 988 million. From 2019 onwards, we will report our EBITDA without a mark-to-market of commodity ages as this does not correctly reflect the performance of our operations. I would like to strengthen the fact that we view this 2018 EBITDA result as positive as we have managed to transition away from a PPA environment to full merchant operation for some of our core assets in Canada.
37:34 benefiting also from our investment in gas co-firing. We also saw stronger performance in the Canadian gas segment as well as higher results in wind and hydro, which benefited from higher prices in Alberta, both in the energy and ancillary services. During the fourth quarter of 2018, our total cash flow was higher All operating businesses outperformed last year with the exception of energy marketing and slightly higher corporate costs due to someone of items.
38:20 On a full year basis after adjusting for the UFC payment in 2017 and the PPA termination payment in 2018, our cash flow from our businesses increased by 67 million year over year. This increase was primarily driven by high availability of our units, positive impact of green light initiatives in operations, higher power prices in Canada benefiting our gas, hydro and wind businesses, lower capital expenditures in Canadian coal thanks to an optimum allocation of the units with the end of the PPA agreements, and additional revenues from transmission services in Australian Gas.
39:06 I will now turn to free cash flow, which includes interest expense, taxes, non-controlling interest and preferred share dividends. Our total free cash flow for the year amounted to $524 million. If we exclude the one-off items in both 2017 and 2018, Our free cash flow still shows an increase of $57 million over 2017 to $368 million for the whole year. The increase may be due to the stable funds from operation and lower sustaining capital due to further optimization of capital expenditures in the company with most initiatives developed within the GreenLine program.
39:54 As Don noted, this is the highest free cash flow the company has generated in the past 30 years. As you can see on this slide, through a very strict financial discipline, we have managed to reduce our recourse corporate debt by 1.6 billion over four years. And we still target 1.2 billion by the end of 2020. I will get into more details on this in the next few slides. Our capital allocation reflects our current strategy for TransAlta Corporation and TransAlta Renewables. Both share the same goal, sustaining our businesses. If you now look at each entity for TransAlta Corporation, our focus has mainly been reducing our debt in the last four years, while also investing in developing projects before transferring them to TransAlta Renewables.
40:55 We also pay regular dividends and have opened a program in 2018 to buy back shares. As we near the end of our debt reduction program and as uncertainty is lifted in Alberta, we may also consider investing faster in the coal to gas conversion of our Canadian coal assets. And after 2020, look at shareholders remuneration. At TransAlta Renewables, the picture is simple and will remain consistent. Maintain the dividend distributions, pay back project finance debt, and mainly invest in new projects. As we look forward over the next three years, our capital allocation strategy at TransAlta Corporation will continue to focus on our three key areas.
41:43 Debt reduction, investment in coal to gas, and for the development of projects for TransAlta renewables. And finally, shareholders remuneration. On the balance sheet front, we intend to repay the 400 million bonds maturing in late 2020 with a strong excess cash flow generated by the business, further strengthening our balance sheet. In addition, between TransAlta and TransAlta Renewables, further debt reduction occurs through the mandatory principal payments associated with amortizing project finance debt. TransAlta Renewables will focus on growth and allocate capital to long-term contracted growth opportunities.
42:34 These projects will be highly levered within TransAlta Renewables, which has the capital available to grow its business independently from TransAlta. As Dawn mentioned, the announced growth projects can all be funded with our cash and the existing TransAlta Renewables credit facilities. and will not require any capital investment from Sunzelter or the market. Consequently, we do not anticipate to go to the equity market to finance the current projects. As outlined in the investor day in 2017, our capital collection plan for 2018 to 2020 is underpinned by our ability to deliver at least 1.2 billion in free cash flow during the three-year timeframe of 2018 to 2020.
43:30 This target included the expected PPA termination payment of $213 million of which we have already received $157 million. Our guidance for 2019 of $270 to $330 million of free cash flow takes into account several assumptions. like Albert Hopper prices in the range of $50 to $60 per megawatt hour, log factor of 30% for Sundance coal units, sustainable capital in the range of $160 to $190 million, as well as the full impact of our performance plan green light. On a consolidated basis, the growth from TransAlta renewables will lift our EBDA.
44:20 As you can see on this chart, we already see the benefits of the South Headlands project. In this year and the next, we will start to see the benefit from some of the recently announced growth projects in trans-altar renewables, with long-term contracted assets further strengthening our balance sheet and reducing the business risk on a consolidated basis. So to sum up, you can see we've continued to generate strong cash flow from a highly diversified set of assets and we have one of the strongest balance sheets in the industry, positioning us well for the future. With that, I will now pass the call back to Dawn for the conclusion.
45:08 Thanks Christophe and welcome to Canada and thanks Brett for all of that great information. A couple of closing comments because I'm hoping you're all anxious to get to the Q&A period because I think we've provided you with a lot of information today that you haven't heard before and as you can see we've really advanced. So you heard today that in 2018 we delivered what we set out to do. You've heard that we've advanced our strategy and our execution plan significantly on our coal to gas and are really positioning to advance those conversions into the 2020 to 2023 timeframe. You've heard that we have strengthened our balance sheet and are really set up to go into what will be a competitive market. As you all know, in a competitive market, it's only about cost, cost, cost so that you can deliver value to customers because that's what they expect.
46:08 We've shown you today that Going green is profitable and that it benefits consumers. And that's a significant change in my 33 years in the industry. I think this is really the first time that I can say that clearly consumers can get what they want, which is green and low-cost power. We've shown you that TransAlta Renewables can fund the long-term contracted projects. and we've got John Kousinioris here ready to answer questions on that front and we've been able to find excellent projects. We've shown you that we can take some of the returns of that into TransAlta as we do all the development, the prospecting and really the setting up for those projects.
46:53 I guess the other thing we've shown you is that our strategic plan is extremely simple and it's measurable and you can measure our performance in it. It focuses on converting those plants to gas and creating sustainable cash flows for the next 15 years. Brett's shown you that there's even better opportunities now, that we've looked very deeply at the idea of potentially using one or two of the locations for hybrids, which are significantly more cost effective than anything anybody can put in the ground here in Alberta. We've shown you that the hydro PPA expires just like all the rest of them. and I think our disclosures are excellent now. You can see in our MD&A in black and white exactly how that works and Brett's done a great job of showing that to you. So with that, I think you know what our investment thesis is.
47:46 I think it's changed significantly over the past year and I really look forward to your questions as we go forward because I think we've given you a lot to chew on here today. So with that, I'll turn it back over to Sally.
48:01 Thank you, Don. Mike, if you could please open up the call for questions. At this time, I'd like to remind everyone in order to ask a question, press star 1 on your telephone keypad. To withdraw your question, press the pound key. We will pause for a moment to compile the Q&A roster. Your first question comes from Rob Hope from Scotiabank.
48:24 Yes, good morning, everyone, and appreciate the new hydro disclosure. Not surprisingly, the first question is on the hydro upside. So if we look at slide 18 and the $2.44 million of EBITDA that you outlined, that assumes some sort of capacity market. If we rewind this back to 2018, where there's no capacity market, would it be fair to assume that then kind of the EBITDA you would have generated in 2018 would have been $2.44 or less that 56 million, so closer to 190.
48:59 Yeah, I think I'm going to start with that and then John and Brett can come in. Because I think one of the things you've got to look at, and you can see it sort of on EDC slides, remember in an energy-only market, the capacity price is in the energy price. So I think people in a fully functioning, remember the market today in Alberta is an energy-only market with PPAs. So in a fully functioning energy-only market, if you went back to that, you have to put in place some safeguards and some guardrails to ensure you've got enough capacity, which means that you really have to have capacity prices show up in the energy-only price in order for the market to create enough capacity for reliability.
49:47 So given that the hydro dispatches at prices You know, can dispatch by hour into the highest priced hours. You'd have to expect that under a true energy only market with the right rules in it and with the right capacity response in the energy only price that I don't think it would be that much different. But let Brett and John comment on that.
50:13 Yeah, the only, so to that point, think about those average prices that I walked you through historically so if you say $60 remember 2018 averaged 50 on a flat energy so as I mentioned ancillary gets about half that we get a bit higher because we sell more into peak hours on the energy but even just taking that extra $10 and applying it to the energy and ancillary services that we sell if you assume a $60 you know you would recover maybe not all that capacity price but some of it so it really depends on there are some years as you know where prices have been quite a bit higher than $60 so to Don's point two different markets but I mean technically you are correct it comes out but our view is prices could be higher to overcome some of that.
51:05 Yeah no and Brett I think you've articulated it well I think that's exactly what would probably happen the other thing is unlike other jurisdictions We are capped, you know, from a pricing perspective when you have those high price hours at $999 in other years because you'd get more and that kind of goes to Don's point of market structure.
51:22 Yeah, if you look at true energy only markets where they don't have PPAs or they don't have capacity calls, you cannot run the Alberta market with $1,000 a megawatt hour cap. You'll run out of capacity. You have to be willing to take that cap up to $10,000. 14,000, 15,000, 20,000. The cap theoretically in order to achieve the capacity that you need in the market is the opportunity cost of the first unit that you take off the system. So there's lots of theory that goes behind that. So I think if you want to be conservative you could do that, Rob, but I think you have to really consider what an energy market would have to look like. if it's going to achieve the capacity you need for reliability.
52:12 All right, I appreciate that. And then as a follow-up, just looking at 2019 year to date, your Sundance units have been running ahead of your guidance level. February pricing was $100 a megawatt hour, roughly. I just want to get a sense of how you think you're performing relative to your 2019 guidance.
52:31 Well, you know, we'd love to tell you that, you know, we're going to hit it out of the park. But we also live in Alberta, and of course January was a really low-priced month, and so when we kind of look at January and February together, we're pleased. But it's early in the year, Rob, and certainly as we go through the year, we'll be sure to update you if we see that it's running more positive than we thought.
52:57 Thank you. I'll hop back in the queue. Your next question comes from Ben Pham from BMO.
53:05 Okay, thanks. Good morning. I wanted to follow up some of Rob's questions on the hydro bridge. And no doubt, I mean, there's certainly some EBITDA upside that's hidden here in terms of the future expectations. I'm just wondering, I guess, just some of the assumptions underpinning this, because it seems like this disclosure is not too different than 2017 investor day. But, you know, just doing some quick math, you take energy... Plus Capacity. Doesn't that seem about a $90 all-in-par price, or am I tackling that wrong?
53:43 Yeah, I think so. So remember, you've got to remember the hydro sells the roughly 1,500 gigawatt hours and 3,000 gigawatt hours of ancillary. So two products plus capacity. So when you take the revenue, I don't know which revenues you captured there. but you need to look at it from that perspective. And I would say from a disclosure, I think it is more fulsome. We have broken out more on the buckets on the revenue between ancillary and energy and capacity which we think is helpful because you can take those revenues, divide by your volumes and look at how they compare to flat energy prices.
54:32 and so hopefully that gives you more information for you to use in your modeling efforts. But no, it wouldn't be generating, and without seeing your math, those kind of dollars per megawatt hour.
54:44 I think the numbers actually, Ben, are closer to 60 when you actually do the math. I think as Brett said, there was about 1,500 gigawatts of energy and a bit over 3,000 gigawatts of ancillary services which were sold which are roughly at 50% of what the kind of realized energy price would have been over the period. I think the average, the flat price for the year would have been around 50.
55:10 Okay, so I just want to clarify the, so on the revenue side, we can just take what you've provided here, but the denominator, I shouldn't be looking at $1,600, I should be adding another $3,000.
55:21 Yeah, that's right.
55:22 Think of it, remember, in utility services, you can't sell energy unless you're called to sell that energy. So think of it as you're really offering two products in the market on an hourly, daily basis, one of which flows through the turbines. One is kind of kept on reserve and only used when called upon. And then it gets, you know, it captures energy prices at that time as well. But it's really for the system operator to manage the system for both planned events, but also voltage support and regulation. and that has been going on since deregulation.
56:00 And they're really necessary products here in Alberta. I think the other thing that we've done, Ben, to help people see what this is, is you're getting the disclosure of the volumes of the ancillary services and where you can go find them so you can verify them independently.
56:17 Okay, that makes a lot of sense. It looks like it's more mid-60s, which seems reasonable, versus I think I was getting 180 or so, which seemed really high. Okay. And there's some disclosure around some mothballing changes, and maybe I might have missed some previous disclosures, but maybe just some thoughts on Sun 4, Sun 5, just some changes in the mothball timing.
56:42 I don't think, so Sun 3 and 5 are mothballed currently, and they currently go out to the end of March of 2020, so I think we made that change. Thank you. Your next question comes from Patrick Kenney from National Bank Financial.
57:09 Good morning. Don, just on Windrise, you made it clear on the last conference call that in your view the returns from these rep projects were less than stellar. Just wondering what other attributes either economically or strategically help convince you to allocate the $270 million towards the project?
57:29 Well, be clear, Patrick. In all of our bids, we don't bid to the returns of the market. So we just put in our price. We put in the returns that we require for the risk and return of that project. So we evaluate. We have the site. We evaluate the cost that we can get the turbines at. We evaluate our competitiveness on construction. We evaluate sort of the risk of the counterparty, which in this case was a strong counterparty. And then we put in the actual return that we need to make the project go, and we bid that price. And if we get the project, then it meets our return thresholds, and if we don't, then we let her go.
58:14 And so when we bid projects like this into the first call, we didn't make the cut. but we did make it in the second call so we were actually surprised by that because we had ensured that we got the returns that we needed to achieve our target returns for now we're achieving target returns for long-term contracted assets with strong counterparties with low construction risk remember all of our guys that work in southern Alberta built our wind farms and they can They can build this one. They're static. John is their new buddy. So, you know, we did have advantages there that we've had for a long time. But we were never able to get our projects through the process because the returns, people were willing. They either had lower return thresholds or they had better competitive advantage than us.
59:09 So net-net, that wind rise meets the criteria for sure of our target returns. for TransAlta Renewables, and as I've said, it's sitting right now in TransAlta, but it's a candidate for TransAlta Renewables.
59:25 The only other add was we did develop a site that we didn't have ready for that first round, which is a better site, and that's the one that won, and it had better attributes to it, so the economics were also part of that. So things had changed.
59:41 between the initial rounds and the second round even well and also we've got you know just better turbine prices right right yeah all across the board for the project yeah got it okay that's great that does thanks uh and I might have missed it in the release but maybe you can just confirm if you intend to extend the NCIB beyond March 13th and maybe oh yeah just a comment okay yeah maybe just you might have missed it did we put it in the release okay it's in
1:00:11 Yes, we are.
1:00:12 Maybe just to comment on how the NCIB competes for dollars relative to some of these, you know, contracted renewable projects out there.
1:00:21 Well, let me just, I want to, I really, really want to land this point. So the NCIB is a TransAlta Corporation NCIB. Any sort of contracted assets, you know, they're headed for TransAlta renewables. So then you have to say, okay, How does TransAlta Renewables think about if it had its own NCIB? And of course it doesn't. But how would it compare its capital allocation at TransAlta Renewables? And what I see over there, Patrick, is Renewables is a big dividend company. So it gives its capital back through dividends, which we want at TransAlta. We're making sure that we finance everything that we're doing on those long-term contracted assets over there. So now when you think about capital allocation at TransAlta, you need to think about we've got our cash coming from renewables, and it's fully financed when it comes over. So its debt has already been paid by the project debt over in renewables. And then we have our cash from the rest of our business.
1:01:26 And so then the question around capital allocation is when we think about that NCIB, is it a better use of capital than doing the coal-to-gas conversions? Right now I can tell you that coal-to-gas conversions are a much better return, and you want us to do those. And what Brett's presentation showed you today is that even if we can accelerate those sooner, they even give us better returns. But once they're done, the NCIB is really important because then there's quite a significant amount of capital available for return to shareholders through the NCIB or through dividend uplift. Does that make sense?
1:02:06 That does, yeah, I appreciate those comments, Don. And then maybe just for Christoph, and yes, welcome to these lovely winters here in Calgary. Thank you. As you look to position the balance sheet for the post-PPA era in a couple of years, I just wanted to get your thoughts on the importance of maintaining an investment-grade credit rating, what you feel are the most important credit metrics to focus on, and then also maybe you can comment on slide 25 you're now showing The importance of being investment-grade has been shown on the trading floor.
1:03:01 The fact that we have access to several capital markets, and as you know, the Canadian capital market is slightly different than in the U.S. So for us, it's important to be investing in great. I tend to focus on FFO to debt, I mean, as the rating agencies also do. As far as talking about shareholders remuneration and beyond, I mean, the end of the PPA, I think it's too soon to tell. I think the message here is really the fact that we've been consistent in our capital allocation until now. And certainly we still target to, we aim at the 1.2 billion of corporate debt by the end of 2020. Once, as I said, once the uncertainty is lifted also in the Alberta market, I mean, as we look to convert, I mean, our coal units to gas, Once we've invested and once we've realized also the upside on hydro, we'll then allocate our capital in the best way we think.
1:04:05 Yeah, Patrick, let me comment here because I think Christophe is just really starting to pull things together here and certainly I agree with him entirely that in Canada, investment grade is an important criteria. But the way I've been thinking about it is Brett showed you the EBITDA under various scenarios. What's really important when you think about that chart is that the capital required to maintain the hydro and the conversions is significantly different than the capital that's required to maintain coal plants. So the net cash coming out of that chart is stronger. So when you take that net cash and add it together with the other cash that we have, the way I've been thinking about it is If you start with your FFO, you need an allocation for the sustaining capital so that the assets continue to produce cash over time.
1:05:02 And then you need an allocation to debt repayment. By that time, that's gone away, as you know. Because I think the balance sheet that we're aiming for as we start into the decade is a good, strong balance sheet. And really, no IPPs ever have that balance sheet. They tend to over-lever. We're endeavoring to under-lever at the TransAlta. Corporation level so if you if you think about capital allocation then to me it's it's you got to have money for the sustaining you got to have money for the highest value growth projects and and you really got to be clear about what high value is and what your targets are and Then you've got to distribute cash to shareholders. I think when we get there depends on what the share price is if if the share price is low and For sure, the majority of that capital return to shareholders would be through share buyback.
1:05:56 There may be an opportunity to start increasing the dividend, but I think it'll be a combination of those two, and we'll have to think about what is the amount that shareholders can depend on coming from us as a return of capital for their investment.
1:06:15 Okay, that's great. Thanks again, everybody.
1:06:17 Okay, thanks, Patrick. Thanks. Your next question comes from Mark Gervie from CIBC Capital Markets.
1:06:24 Good morning everyone. I wanted to quickly go back to the ancillary revenue services. What do you guys think how that trends under capacity market if that's different at all versus the energy only?
1:06:38 Yeah, we've done a bit of modeling, Mark, on that going forward and candidly we don't I see that changing significantly when we do the work that we do both internally and when we look at people from an external perspective that help us. We see it broadly continuing and when Brett went through his slide and he talked about kind of the notion of capacity value that would be there for the fleet, that kind of $6-ish sort of per kilowatt month kind of value, we think that that isn't an unreasonable sort of proxy for what we expect. in the capacity market as well. So in general, we think it is more of the same. And one of the reasons we used that 2018 kind of bridge is just when you look at kind of the pricing in that bridge, it's not an unreasonable kind of snapshot of what you can expect on a go-forward basis. It's a reasonable proxy, I think.
1:07:28 Okay. And then in terms of market share where the hydro is having nearly 50%, as we see a bit of a shift in the generation mix, a bit more wind and some of the coal coming offline, should that stay flat or is there anything you think will trend differently in terms of Thank you very much.
1:08:04 you know, everything from recreational users to making sure that ice flows are appropriate along the river. So our macro capacity to actually, you know, provide more ancillary services in terms of volumes is a little bit constrained in terms of what we're going to be able to do. So again, what you're seeing is a reasonable kind of proxy for the kinds of volumes I think that we're expecting.
1:08:24 Well, I think the thing you want to think about is in a market that has growing renewables The demand for ancillary services is higher.
1:08:34 Should go up.
1:08:35 Because you, especially in some of the cold days here in February, the wind doesn't blow at all. So it's really important to have capacity in ancillary services and operating reserves and all of that. So I would expect, just given the pricing that you see on renewables, how far down it's come down, I would expect to see more in the systems all across the world. which I think puts a higher value on ancillary services.
1:09:05 Remember, it's the service that kind of matches supply and demand as there's variability during the day.
1:09:11 Right. I just want to pivot to TransAlta Renewables. You guys talked about some of the growth that's happening there and potentially wind rise ending up in TransAlta Renewables. Just maybe update us in terms of what you guys think or what is the return hurdle right now, whether it's sort of an IRR or cash-on-cash yield for R&W investments.
1:09:27 Yeah, Mark, you know, we generally – I'll be honest with you, we generally keep that kind of discussion in terms of what our hurdles are and what we're looking at from IRRs, I think pretty closely guarded to us. I can tell you that when we're looking at drop downs from TransAlta to TransAlta Renewables, we have our independent committee go through it. They do get a financial advisor and they go through a pretty rigorous process to make sure that the value of the asset that comes in and effectively the development fee that they're paying for to TransAlta for that asset is appropriate in light of the cost of capital of the company.
1:10:03 Okay. I'll jump back in the queue. Thanks for the answers.
1:10:07 Thanks, Mark. Your next question comes from Andrew Kosky from Credit Suisse.
1:10:13 Thank you. Good morning. Not to harp on the hydro, but I do appreciate the incremental disclosures in the quarter. and just one maybe easy question to start off with. Do you anticipate any changes to how hydro will be dispatched in the capacity market versus how they are now?
1:10:31 Yeah, it's a good question. We've been engaged with the ISO in terms of the technical rules that they're developing for ancillary services and which are particularly oriented around the hydro. that we have. The short answer to that process is in general we think that the rules that are being proposed are flexible enough to permit us to actually operate hydro as we have been and they've been developed with that in mind given as I mentioned earlier the obligations we have from an environmental and permit perspective to manage the water flows on the river. So I think we're expecting right now a very similar not much of a change in the way that we're operating this thing.
1:11:09 And Andrew we really want you to harp about the hydro a lot. So feel free to ask us a gazillion questions. We'll stay on the phone all day with you, and we'd like everybody to harp about it. So thank you.
1:11:22 Okay, well, I'll continue harping on Hydro later, but I'll show you Hydro now. Thank you. When you think about just the outlook for pricing and the market structure in Alberta, clearly you're doing the coal-to-gas conversions. Initially, they're going to be high heat rate. Thank you very much.
1:12:03 Coal to gas on a pure carbon is quite a bit less than coal. There's quite a bit of savings there on a per megawatt hour. And then now you're down to really your next variable is your fuel charge and that's your natural gas versus coal. But ultimately too, as I said earlier, coal goes away for everybody at the end of 2029. So you've got a bit of what happens over the next decade and then a longer term. But certainly from our perspective, even though they have higher heat rates than obviously a combined cycle or something like that, because of those attributes will continue to dispatch. We expect similar to the way they've been dispatching of late, but if the carbon policy changes and shifts that, that could shift it going forward.
1:12:56 You also have to remember some of the units like the older peakers that were put in place The high heat rates on those are still pretty high and aren't as good as a new peaker that's in place. So again, they tend to only operate certain hours and try to pick off those higher prices. So right now, we don't see a lot of change when we look forward, but again, it's subject to gas prices and other factors, carbon in particular. Okay, that's great. Thank you. Your next question comes from Robert Kwan from RBC Capital Markets. Good morning. Maybe I'll just continue here on coal to gas.
1:13:41 I'm just wondering some of the disclosures here around lengthening the conversion up to 2023, and then there's also a statement talking about some or all of your units. I'm just wondering what's in behind that as well.
1:13:58 Yeah, so the 2023 is really just... As you can appreciate, you can't do all of these in one shot.
1:14:07 I think before we were 22, 23. I don't know if you'd like that. We've actually moved it to 2020.
1:14:13 Yeah, we've moved it in a bit. But it's really somewhat a function of timing and outages, and you're going to do one at a time, as you can appreciate, Robert. And then the sum of all is really back to the comment I made about us evaluating this repowering option. So if we see that as an opportunity, then clearly we may not spend money on the boiler conversion and just move into those instead. So that's the purpose of the summer oil.
1:14:46 Got it. I guess then just moving to wind rise or just using wind rise as an example and really more taking a step back and looking at how you think about growth, risk versus return, growth versus other uses. Based on your EBITDA disclosure for both the pipeline and then the total projects, it looks like you're constructing at plus or minus in the 11 times range. Just wondering how you think about that versus M&A that seems to be going in the 9 to 11 times range, so kind of just constructing it at where private transactions are going.
1:15:27 I'll jump in and then John can jump in. I would say that we are seeing, for some assets, EBITDA multiples even higher. I also think it's very important to look at each market's going to be different depending on whether you have tax attributes, what the tax profile looks like, what the term of the contract looks like. Again, we look at it less than from an EBITDA multiple perspective. We look at the long-term IRRs of the project and then they have to stand and meet our hurdles but then what we do is we also then roll that into our NW because it may have some other attributes for example we may be able to accelerate some of the tax pools from that asset and apply it against aggressive fleet there might be some synergies that we can add to it so it's less about a multiple and more about a return and I can tell you, you know, the stuff we're seeing, Robert, especially on the solar side, but even, you know, you've seen some of the big hydro stuff is very, very low equity returns.
1:16:41 Not a lot to add to what Brett said, frankly. The only thing is, again, you know, every project, whether it's an M&A project or whether it's a development project that we're doing internally, I mean, when we think of the value of it, it's all based on the characteristics of the project everything from the regulatory certainty of the jurisdiction to the quality of the counterparty to the tenor of the contract to the technology that's being used and how comfortable and familiar we are with the technology so it's a much more nuanced kind of discussion and we continue to see in many places a very hot from a pricing perspective M&A market for sure.
1:17:19 And Robert I just want to comment on the pipe because I think you rolled that in near Your comment. The pipe, again, as we tried to show there, you know, once a pipe's in the ground, clearly, there's not much more incremental capital. You know, we might have to do a bit of compression to get it beyond certain levels, but very, very modest. So any incremental volume that gets moved through that pipe, it's just all straight to the bottom line. And that's why, you know, once we start moving volumes that we expect to move through there, you can see it is a very good And then just to the risk versus return part of this question, this $39 to $41 a megawatt hour that the ISO put forward, are there any other revenues that you'd receive as part of that? And if not, how do you weigh that against?
1:18:22 just building merchant energy, carbon credits, capacity prices, especially when you square that up against your slide 19.
1:18:31 The price that we're getting under the PPA is the full price. And the economics that we did in making the decision to proceed was based on that price that had met our whole rates and everything there. There is, you know, there are people that are speculating to your point about whether or not you build something like that in a merchant kind of market and take those kind of assets. That has not been the kind of risk profile that we have had, certainly for TransAlta Renewables and even for TransAlta. We're pretty clear about wanting to have contracted assets as best as we can and having the certainty and predictability associated with those assets, and that's been our focus
1:19:08 today. Yeah, so Robert, let me make a couple comments. So I think that for TransAlta, the mix is important right now. the contracted assets that we'll add from 2018 from Antriens, Big Level and Windrise. And also having the discipline to project finance those with low risk counterparties and to de-risk those cash flows effectively. The combination of that portfolio with what we're going into Alberta with, which will be coal to gas and hydro that will be subject to a market, That mix together gives us a lower cost of capital at the corporate level and allows us to continue to have a strong balance sheet on the investment grade side.
1:19:58 As we go forward into the 2020 timeframe and we look at, if I was to line up the returns of what Brett showed today on a hybrid against a merchant wind project, I would take the hybrid because I think it's going to not only provide capacity to the market and ancillary services but it's going to provide a ton of energy and it's going to be the lowest cost energy in the market because of the heat rate. So we would look at in the Alberta market that investment would be superior to a merchant wind project. Now when you go over to the Australia market where our teams kind of they look over there under John's guidance If you were going to build merchant renewables, you'd go to Australia where the gas prices are $12 and they're still burning brown coal and they're charging people $100 a megawatt hour. That would be the better place to take that kind of risk.
1:20:57 And I would take that risk if I could see us getting our cash back in two to three years. I would not take the risk on a wind farm where you need seven to eight years to get your money back. in a merchant market. Because I think as you'll see over time, and this isn't next week, and I shouldn't even say it because people think it's next week, but over a long period of time as ISOs have to think about what it looks like to have more of these intermittent renewables, they'll have to change rules so that they get enough capacity. So net-net for our portfolio, I think our mix of assets is right. and we like that contracted, we'll have a certain amount of contracted projects in TransAlta Renewables because that gives us a better cost of capital at TransAlta.
1:21:48 I think the one thing we also didn't mention, you know, just in terms of your ability to project finance the asset when it's built, which is something that we focus on, I mean, with a merchant project, that's not something that you're going to be able to do, including with a contracted asset. It fits into that space much, much better.
1:22:05 Yeah, and... Remember, a wind farm in the capacity market doesn't get paid a lot of capacity. It's a very low amount. And also, wind, as you know, tends to get a price at a discount to the average price because of when it blows. So when you factor all that, the risk, the inability to put project debt against it, you know, it is a much higher risk scenario. And you have to think about that when you're looking at those prices that the ASO awarded.
1:22:36 If I can just finish with slide 19 and the energy and capacity, what's the underlying capacity price assumption, 22 plus?
1:22:41 It looks really high. Again, this is from EDC.
1:22:43 I think their capacity price is
1:23:05 What you need to do is, this is all on a megawatt. They're probably in that 15 to even 20 per KW. And you can just basically, if you took that amount on a per megawatt hour, what I usually do is just, there's about 85 million gigs to get to a revenue and divide by a clearing capacity in the 10,000 Once you adjust for UCAP, that'll give you a rough KW a month. Divide by 12, obviously, to get around a monthly. And I think you'll get kind of in that zone. I have the numbers. I just don't have them right in front of me.
1:23:46 And do you have any thoughts kind of from a TransAlta perspective where you think capacity might end up landing?
1:23:56 Like my only comment there is, so again, we think the all-in price is an important way to look at it because especially for plants that are going to run frequently like hydro and fish and coal and are repowering and conversions. But it really comes down to that historical rate of 60 to 65 we think all in is kind of the number to compensate people that are already in the market but also when required attract new capital.
1:24:33 Yeah, I think if you look at where things are going to go through the 20s, you're going to have to add new capacity in Alberta. And I think as an economist, no matter what forecasters show, high prices never persist forever and low prices never persist forever. Because I think there's people that have talked about a $30 price and I'm like, wow, If Alberta doesn't want any power, I guess they'll produce a $30 price. I don't think that's sustainable. I think the ISO, in terms of its capacity market, has been trying to achieve something that ensures that you can get new entry. And they don't, in my view, think of new entry as only coming from the incumbents using their balance sheets.
1:25:25 They have to actually get new entry to be financed by others. and to get it to, when I look at the cost of new entry, it's been in the 60 to 65 range depending on what gas prices are for a long time. So we tend to see that as our, you know, kind of how we think what the opportunity might be for planning purposes. We take the lowest possible price we can dream of and then we drive our cost to that low price.
1:25:53 Got it. So do you know, is EDC then assuming that Cost of new entry is driving the price or the unconstrained bidders versus all of you who are going to be constrained at, I think, 85% of net cone.
1:26:07 Yeah, I think you'll have to pay for their service. We can't give you much more than unfortunately.
1:26:16 All I can say is those numbers that are, if you really want to get a new generator in, though, you have to have some capacity prices that are that high. for some period of time where these guys are coming in and not making any money. We'll put Brett on the phone with you offline, Robert, after with more detail if you want. That's great. Thank you very much. Thanks so much. Your next question comes from Charles Fishman from Morningstar Research.
1:26:47 Good morning. I just had one question left for Brett on slide 12. You show the decision of repowering as a 2019 deliverable. So should we, will that decision occur this year then? Or will you wait, let the capacity market start up and obviously which would have an impact on the energy market, which I would assume would be the driver for that decision. How, you add a little more color there, Brett?
1:27:23 Sure, yeah, for sure. Yeah, no, definitely we're full steam ahead here. And, you know, as I said, we're just close to issuing limited notice to proceed, which really just finalizes the engineering work that we've been done just in more detail. And then we go to limit notice to proceed and we start ordering equipment, which is really the long lead time. The actual outage, as I mentioned, is only approximately 60 days, but we do have to, you know, order the equipment and so on. So yeah, we're, I mean, from our perspective, as I said, there's so many benefits to converting that this is not a, oh, we're still wondering. This is where we're going as a company. And, you know, the timing, as I said, on when and how many and what years is really just us managing our work levels and stuff like that.
1:28:16 And as I said, we're not going to do them all in one year or all in one month and all at the same time. But no, we're full steam ahead.
1:28:23 But the repowering decision, which adds probably, what, $500, $600, $700 to KW, that is, would that be a 2019 deliverable, that decision?
1:28:35 Yeah, yeah, sorry, if that's what you're referring to. So, yeah, look, we want to do a bit more work. As I said, we've done sufficient work that we're pretty excited about it. We need to do a bit more work around things like just on the steam side, on the steam turbine and and some modeling efforts. But that would be a more longer permitted project, you know, no question. It's like a, you know, we had a Sun 7 combined cycle project from a few years ago, combined cycle that we didn't, we got fully permitted. But, you know, by the time you permit and build, you know, you're talking closer to four years all in. But, you know, we hope by this year that we would have advanced that enough to make that call and and lay that out for people.
1:29:25 Okay, thanks for the additional caller.
1:29:26 That's all I have. Your next question comes from Sean Noll from Family Office.
1:29:36 Hey guys, thanks for the great call. I have two questions and I appreciate you taking my time. So the first question is how do you think about like bracketing in the possible political risks to both carbon and capacity markets Given the changes in Alberta politically, how do you sort of frame that range of outcomes in financially? Any color you have there would be helpful.
1:29:59 Okay, so it's Dawn Farrell here. So two things that we think about on the political risk side for the capacity market. You know, I think what we know is that the capacity market Thank you very much.
Follow TransAlta Corporation into a list and get an email when it puts out news.
Manager, Investor Relations
President and Chief Executive Officer
Chief Financial Officer
Chief Strategy and Investment Officer
Chief Growth Officer
Analyst, National Bank Financial
Analyst, RBC Capital Markets
Analyst, CIBC Capital Markets
Analyst, Scotiabank
Analyst, Credit Suisse
Analyst, Morningstar Research
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets