Replay available

Save Canadian Mining presents "Capital Markets Insights For The Pandemic" Part 2: Monetary Metals

Join us for a great event!

Fri, October 2, 2020 at 1:00 PMendedReplay
Save Canadian Mining presents "Capital Markets Insights For The Pandemic" Part 2: Monetary Metals
Company
Save Canadian Mining, Murenbeeld & Co., First Majestic Silver Corp. (TSX:AG)
Date
Fri, Oct 2, 2020, 1:00 PM ET
Replay
Watch the replay on this page · 56 min

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/save-canadian-mining-presents-capital-markets-insights-for-the-pandemic-part-2-monetary-metals

Replay

Transcript

Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.

0:04 Hello everyone, we're live now on the Save Canadian Mining series. Welcome. Today we're going to be talking about monetary metals and we're joined by some great people in that sector that can give us some insight and help us understand that sector and the opportunities there and also understand safe Canadian mining. I wanna introduce my panel. I noticed the last time I did this and I talked about where it is from my perspective, actually by the time it was recorded and sent back, it was different and I looked like a bit of an idiot because everyone's in a different chair. So I'm not sure where you guys will actually end up in the overall scheme of the recording.

0:50 But right now, as I look at the screen above me, I have Brian Boss from Murrenbill. Murrenbill is a fairly esteemed research house and we actually hired them at Safe Canadian Mining to do our research for us. And Brian has a long history. And he was a fore trader initially at the TSE, and then he became a prop trader at Dundee. Then he went down to the biocredit at Dundee. So he's been at this market for many different ways. And now he's on the research side of NeuronGelb and we'll be interested to hear his forecast of gold and silver. On my top right is Keith Neumeier from 1st Majestic Silver. That's the proper way to do it Keith, you got the wave in, we now know it's you. And obviously, you know, silver is rocking right now.

1:38 And 1st Majestic is one of the biggest silver companies in the world. And we'll be excited to hear more about 1st Majestic and Keith's perspective on the silver market. And then to my right is Sean Roussin from Cisco Gold Royalties and other things. But obviously Cisco Gold, the market discovery and their great growth in their Gold Royalties, lots of stuff to talk about with Sean and he's always an interesting and engaging guest. So we're very happy to have them on board. Welcome guys and thanks for coming to the show. Thanks for doing this, Terry. Okay. Yeah, thanks. So how I like to kick things off is sort of, why did we sort of start safe hailing mining? And Jane, if you could post that chart, this would probably be a good time to do it. You know, basically we made the observation that, you know, when the tick test was rolled back in 2012,

2:33 that it sort of changed the fundamental structure of finance in the Canadian markets, not just mining, but we obviously are in mining space, we looked at mining in particular. And one of the things we did when we hired Miren Biala, we said, hey, we think there's been a problem here and we'd like to know what the data says. So we had Brian and his team go away and this is one of the things they produced. If you look at the chart, basically what it shows is that if you look historically, and the reason why the numbers don't go back a bit further is that that's sort of the easiest. The TSX came into being sort of around then. And so it wasn't possible to go back. And then that was part Vancouver, part Montreal, part Toronto. We didn't have the resources to sort of make that historical thing happen. So this is what we put together. And what it showed historically is that typically the TSX metals and mining index traded at or above the commodity index.

3:29 And then now if you look at the chart, you can see that it's radically different. So basically the mining and metal index is, basically at 35 versus say 100 worth of real change. So we're off by 65%, whereas the commodity index was only off by 7. So What that means in layman's terms to investors is that stocks would almost have to triple in mining to get back to normal. So think about your mining portfolio and think about a triple. I think you'd be a lot happier if that happened. And certainly if that happened, that would present a lot more financing opportunities for companies so they could actually invest and grow their companies in productive ways. So this is sort of why we started this. We think there's fundamentally a problem in the structural setup.

4:15 And the tech test might be one of the ways to address that. We're going to talk with several others, but that was sort of the reason. So, Jane, let's lose it, lose the chart now and pop back up. And what I wanted to do is go around the horn here and maybe we'll talk. Start with you 1st, Sean, and ask you, you know, why are you supporting the state of Canadian mining and what are your thoughts on, on, on this problem? You know, I think a lot of issues around the Canadian junior mining market, which has been the healthiest market and the biggest source of capital in the world for exploration and development, which is sort of the primary ingredient to all this. But I mean, I think a lot of things we're going to talk about today are inherent in all the other growth industries like biomed, early incubation tech companies, and the rest of it. And what has happened, I think, is, you know, on a general basis is that the bigger institutional players have pushed pretty hard to make it very hard to be a small company in this market, whereas we used to celebrate that back when we had the Vancouver Stock Exchange, the Montreal Stock Exchange, the TSX.

5:16 And we used to have people that were capable and sophisticated enough to invest in that. Now it's really a generational thing. Millennials really haven't stepped into the place. And we need to create an environment that people can understand the rules, have enough transparency to be able to make these investments and not to get run over by unscrupulous short sellers or other market forces that make it unpalatable to be a shareholder in these smaller companies. Yeah, fair enough. Keith, what are your thoughts? Well, you know, I'm an ex-trader. I was on the floor of the Vancouver Stock Exchange from 1984 to 1989. So a lot of the practices that we're discussing are practices that I actually was involved in.

6:02 But we had very strict rules. And if there was a stock that was trading at 50 cents and that was a downtick and you wanted to short that stock, you had to be on the offer at 51 cents. And that was it, that was the rule. Everyone knew what the rule was. And if

6:19 someone wanted to come in and buy your stock at 51 and you take the legitimate short position and report it to the authorities as a real short position, that's fair game. But under the current rules as a seller, today I could hit that bid at 50 cents, and despite the fact it's a downtick, and the next bid is 48 cents, I could hit that bid. The next bid is 46 cents, I could hit that bid. The next bid is 43 cents, I could hit that bid. I could drive that stock down to 30 cents if I had enough money to do it. And there's no regulations that prevents me from doing it. Back when I was a floor trader, you could not do that. And that protected the Canadian financial markets against the theft that's going on in the current system. And now today it's even worse because we have computers doing it. So you set up algorithms where they take advantage of these low cap illiquid stocks and they have a view. Someone says, okay, there's a finance that's going to happen with this particular company because they're running around Toronto, New York, Montreal, wherever. We know they got to raise 10 million bucks.

7:27 And so we're going to drive that stock down 20% to buy it back on the private placement and we're going to cover our short on the private placement. You know, 15 years ago you couldn't do that. Well, actually 8 years ago you couldn't do that. But today you can do that. So there's abuses that are going on across the system that we have to prevent. And this is not mining, this is right across the Canadian financial industry. We got to protect the Canadian markets against these thieves. Yeah, I'm with you. I agree with you. I think Keith nailed it. Look, the TIC test has been around for over 100 years. It was brought in for a reason. It survived for 100 years for a good reason. And there's no reason why with this world of technology, we can't link all the exchanges or come up with some method of reinstituting the tick test because frankly, it's hurting the smallest companies. And if the smallest companies don't get a chance to grow here, either they never become large or they go somewhere else to do their growing and that hurts everyone.

8:28 I was also a floor trader myself And I completely agree with what Keith is saying here. Everyone knew what the tick was. And now, not only does nobody care because there's no rule on it, but if you wanted to figure what the tick was across all the different trading venues, there's no way to be sure. Because it's not a consolidated tape that delivers that. So I'd love to see the return of the tick test, especially in the sections of the market where

8:57 market efficiency as taught by the Chicago School doesn't really apply. So either the entire country or some portion of market cap that's set really, really high would be the right place to bring it back. And I also want to speak to what Sean said. He's absolutely right. It's not a mining issue. We care because it's mining for us, but this was in marijuana stocks. This is in oil stocks. This is in biocare stocks. This is everywhere. It's a market structure issue for the country. Yeah, I 100% agree. I mean, it was interesting this week, we had the expose of the, I don't know if you've caught it, on the Anson funds and some of the alleged tactics that were exposed in that article. I don't know, I mean, obviously the truth will come out, I guess, in probably some investigation and what will ultimately happen. But I mean, clearly

9:49 the front running, where people were being, stocks being shorted before an issue and then covering an issue, and that's just gotta stop. I mean, that's one of the things the task force to the credit has come out and recommended it as one of the recommendations that they believe they'll be coming forward with is that they'll make that illegal for companies to be shorting a stock before the financing. They'll have to sign some affidavit that they're not doing that and we'll have to put some teeth in that. So that would be a good outcome of the task force. And I see, yesterday, obviously, IROC and OSC put out the whistleblower thing, just whether that's in response to the Anthem situation or if it was already in process, if it was for some sponsorship, you know, Canadian Mining or other people that have been talking about predatory shorts, and we don't know, but I mean, that's a step in the right direction. And obviously, we need more, I think, and we need to

10:48 make it policy because if we don't make it law, these guys, these sharks that are currently out of the water right now, I've talked to a few people saying that they've noticed the bots are out of their market. So it'd be interesting to see if that's actually happening. John, do you have any thoughts on that? Well, I think it's always interesting to me that the regulators take such a high level of interest in protecting the hedge fund guys and the short sellers. I mean, I've had so many experiences where the priorities of short sellers outweighed the benefits of the shareholders of the companies that were the subject of the short. If you do have an incident, IROC is far more likely to side or be scared of the litigation from the short sellers, then side with them, then they are to side with the company that maybe has an incident, you know, a hostage taking or a shutdown of their...

11:43 Some unforeseen incident and these guys are allowed to go in there and rape and pillage, and IROC stands back and lets it go.

11:51 It's been ridiculous that overall Canadian regulators have had an attitude of everything in Canada is too good for Canadians. Let somebody else buy it. They've had a really soft stance on hostile takeovers and short selling. Canada is just bonanza land in the current world of anonymity. We all Canadians as traders, we face this know your client rule, but those are not the people that there's no know your client on the hedge funds that are trading and shorting these stocks right now. There's no, you

12:21 know, other than if you don't live within the Canadian borders, you have no consequence. You can do whatever you want. And, you know, and all the banks are, as Keith said, you know, if you're, if you know, there's a financing coming, you knock the stock down 20%, you and your banker buddies, the bank's collecting a commission on a deal, and they don't have to do anything because they know they've got a short cover lined up. So they take a 3% to 5% piece of conda flesh out of the Junior Target for free, no work. And then the short seller ups gone for the 20% profit, maybe within a few days. And IROC spends all their time investigating the companies and trying to hold them to task, but does little to investigate this, does little to protect Canadian companies, does little to connect IT.

13:07 You know, we've seen so many companies get wiped out in Canada, from BlackBerry to Nortel, to the Avro Aero, to the Renault Depot, and then they tried to take a Cameco in Saskatchewan. And for the most part, the regulators have just like pushed the Canadian companies out of the country and let them be purchased by foreign players. And this short plays and algorithm trading is a good part of not Canadian companies not being able to maintain their valuation, which sets up the whole house of cards. And it's why this country is not benefiting. We don't have a single mining house left except for Techcom Inco. And thank God that they've got a double voting share. But we lost Inco, Falconbridge, Miranda,

13:54 Alcan, all these companies that should have been world's competitors with Rio Tinto, BHP, Valet and these bigger companies have left Canada and sold and essentially due to weak regulation. Yeah, Keith, what are your thoughts?

14:14 So look, I'll go back to the basics. So the reason why there's a regulatory system in place, whether the SEC, the OSC, the BCSC, is to protect the small guy in the street.

14:30 And the regulators have a position within the marketplace to do their job. Unfortunately over time, the banks have got more and more power. You know in the day, you know, when I was much younger, you know, the TSX or the TSX, you know, TSXB was basically 100% of the market. Now we've got multiple markets, you know, and we got all these computer trading, and this has all been driven by the banks. So what has happened in our system is, you know, we started off with the governments actually regulating the system as they should for the benefit of the small investor. But over time, the last decade or decade and 0.5, they've allowed the banks to take control.

15:16 So the banks actually write the rules and the governments through the regulators have stepped back because it's so complex now. I don't even know if the governments even have the capital to

15:27 have the people to watch the system Because the banks are just so sophisticated now and they've got the computer engines behind them where they can just go around the regulators. You see it with all the fines with the banks. You see all the manipulations going on in the world. It's a farce. And the banks have absolutely devastated the retail investor for their own profits and benefits. And the Canadian government through our regulations, through our regulatory bodies have let it happen. And it's time the government actually steps in and puts the rules back in place that protect the investors. Yeah, 100% couldn't agree with you more. I mean, we had Eric brought on, I guess, just around February, March, Sean, when we were at that other event.

16:19 And I know Eric is huge on that point. It's like, you know, the stock markets were created so individual investors could invest in multiple different opportunities and companies could access capital. It wasn't invented so that exchanges could profit or banks could profit by ownership of the exchanges or make commission That's it's turned to ask backwards and we got to get back to fundamental When public that was the end yeah, but yes, I should never been allowed to become a public company. Period. And then the banks own the TSX, which even makes it a bigger joke. Clearly, we're on the same viewpoint on that side of things. Brian, go ahead, you want one last kick at the end? Yeah, just to keep it super quick.

17:07 I always try to be optimistic about the future on these things.

17:12 And you guys are absolutely right, the system is running backwards right now. When I asked myself, given that the Anson document, we'll call it a document, the allegations and the good reading came out, and then within 2 days or 3 days, the OSC reminded everyone of its whistleblower policy, we don't know if that reminder was already planned and it just happened to come 2 days later. The OSC is not going to tell us that. But if it turned out that it was published as a reminder in order to reach out and find the author and say, hey, you should be reaching out to us to help us police these markets, that's actually a little bit of good news compared to in past years where maybe they wouldn't even have noticed at all. The whistleblower policy is not new. At the OSC at least, it's been on the books for years.

18:02 So For them to put out a reminder is a little piece of hope that they're finally getting it. What Terry and Save Canadian Mining are doing is bringing to the light something that has been in the dark for a long time, it probably is not on the radar screen of OSC staff in most cases. As Keith points out, they're busy dealing with the large banks and there's been no voice for the smaller companies and the investors in the smaller companies that could get through to the OSC staff. And I'm hopeful that this is actually a step in the right direction. Yeah, I mean, we're hoping that we can build on some of this momentum and drive this over the next, I guess, 2 months really, where our philosophy at Safe Guinea Mining was that we have to, Ontario had a task force, they were reviewing this issue, or, you know, in terms of the Ontario Securities Act, and, you know, when we lobbied the Fork government to come in and, you know, instruct OSC to reinstate the tick test.

19:05 We were said, hey, look, you gotta talk to the task force and get them on side, because, you know, it's already started and we don't wanna start 2 tasks on this. So we've had a submission with the task force, I'm actually meeting with them again on Monday or Tuesday next week and we'll be presenting our, you know, the most recent data. We met with IROC. We actually got short data from IROC after a little bit of tooth pulling, but we did actually get it. And it shows that there's definitely causality here, that since they changed the rules, that there definitely is a problem. Like 20% of the stocks are short, and that's not been conductive. And we saw it in that chart we posted at the top, what it means in terms of our stock prices. And That's capital that's been stolen, as Guy said, by basically offshore hedge funds and the banks and taken out of our individual investor pocket. So we've got to make the government aware of this, what the impact is to its citizens and make a change.

19:59 Make the change in Ontario first, because obviously security is a provincial jurisdiction in Canada. Federally, it doesn't really hit the scope. So we've got to change it in the biggest jurisdiction in Ontario. And then I'm sure BC and Quebec and Alberta, the rest of the provinces will sign on because it would be productive for their capital formation, for their companies and for their investors. So that's been our approach. So we'll keep on hopefully with your help and the help of other people who are listening today to do that. And Terry, as you know, the data is not always easy to find. We've had to go through different, If you're trying to build time series data to make the kinds of charts and comparisons, when TSX-V hired S&P Global to start running its benchmark, there's not a lot of overlap to the previous TSX-V mining subsector index. And then there's almost no overlap or data set connecting that to the old Vancouver mining subsector. So you can't you can't build a time series of data very easily. It takes a lot of digging and a lot of time And even then you need to make some assumptions, but the data clearly shows

21:03 that there's a problem. Once you get it all pulled together and you can begin to show it around, everyone sees it. Yeah, for sure. So, you know, at this juncture of the program, what we like to do is take a little break and we wanna sort of talk to the audience like we went over to the audience we said, in addition to learning about the short problem and educating people as to that, we'd also learn about some of the great supporters we've got and what they're doing in their own companies. And We're super lucky today to have 2 of the best companies. And on full disclosure, I actually own both companies.

21:36 The guys probably know John Doody from the Stansberry group, the analyst. He's probably my favorite analyst in terms of the big companies. He has a portfolio of basically 15, 10 gold and 5 silver. And basically on my senior mining, sort of chunk of my portfolio, which is the biggest chunk of my portfolio, I have 15 equal positions and I have equal positions in 1st Majestic and Cisco and love those companies. Keith, we're gonna start with you first. Tell us about 1st Majestic and we've had silver rise 70%. We need 1st Majestic to rise 70%, brother. What's going on? I haven't done the math, so I'm glad you are. But first off, Terry, thanks for putting this together.

22:25 This effort to change the regulatory environment in Canada, I think it's a very honorable effort. And with Eric behind us, and some of the press that we're getting and the current review that's going on in Ontario, which of course will affect the entire country. I'm hopeful that these efforts will actually make change that are long overdue. And, you know, because restoring the uptick rule to me is, you know, would be, you know, hugely beneficial for the entire financial markets within Canada. And then take away some of these predators that, you know, we find ourselves unfortunately having to deal with. And a company like Firstman Jessic, the stock trades 5 million shares a day, so it trades

23:14 like $100 million in value a day or something crazy like that. So a company like that, it's not that relevant. But for a lot of my other portfolio, I think I have got a portfolio of something like 30 miners, most of which are are easily less than 100 million dollar market caps. Which are affected every single day. You know by this issue and-

23:36 you know I. I look at these stocks because you know being an ex trader. As that I am I have a my own trading system. And I watch the you know these algorithms. You know through through CIBC which is like probably the biggest black box in the country, just trading these markets on these unlimited 100-share offers that don't seem to ever end. You could buy 100,000 shares and buy, you know, you'll get 1,100 order fills and the offer's still there, right? And you just kind of shake your head, you go like, wow. And it's just all computers right and it's taken away the it's you know it's it's just really you know change the financial environment to the worst in my opinion and you know what and and only the regulators only IROC only the government has access to the back door of what's actually going on in the system.

24:38 But just based on my knowledge, based on my 30, almost 35 years of trading this market, you could tell that there's stuff going on that should not be going on, right? And, but anyways, you know, I don't want to want to get off topic, but, you know, I am very passionate about this and, you know, I, I'm there to support and, and, anyway, so about 1st Majestic, look, I put the company together 18 years ago where we're CEO, founder,

25:09 we're producing something in the order of 24 million ounces. So we're calling it a year, we produce 2 metals, silver and gold. Hold in Mexico, we got like 5,000 employees. We're loving the current metal price environment and we got a lot of growth coming over the next 2, 3 years. And it's a great company to look at. I suggest your listeners look at our website, firstmajestic.com, call our investor relations, look at our PowerPoint and lots of good stuff happening there. Thanks very much Keith, I agree. Sean, now over to you. Yeah, sure. So, you know, we started around a similar time. Well, Cisco started in 2002 and I was a private equity fund manager.

25:50 They called Eurage Holdings, which I had founded. You know, we've evolved through the group. Obviously our big success was the finding Canadian Malartic, which is now Canada's single largest gold producer at about just under 700,000 ounces a year, with the Canadian Malartic Mine, which recently had a 10 million ounce discovery underneath it. So the gift that keeps on giving, and that's really a cornerstone asset in the Cisco Gold Royalties, which is about a $2.5 billion company today. And then within that, we have what we call our accelerator group of companies, which is a lot of incubation and hard work that goes into starting companies that are, you know, basically, you know, small enough that they're subject to the issues that we're talking about today. We've incubated 7 companies there in 6 years.

26:36 Obviously the most successful

26:39 has been Osisko Mining, 2 which we took from an $8 million market cap in 2016 to $1.4 billion market cap today with the Windfall Lake Discovery in northern Quebec. And then a few others that you might not know as much about like Falko Resources with the Horn Mine in Ruan, Orana, Quebec. And then we were the driving force in the financing behind Victoria Gold which has now built the biggest gold mine in the Yukon, and we produce about 200,000 ounces a year. And then on to Barkerville Gold Mines, which we own somewhat within OR right now. And then a few other things that we've incubated along the way, like Nile Bay and Talisker, and a few other juniors that you can see on our website. And we end up fighting this battle that we're talking about today quite often as the largest shareholder of these companies.

27:28 And nothing really makes me happier than catching a guy short on a financing and then putting the squeeze on them.

27:36 It is something that we do celebrate if we can put the squeeze on some of these more or less scrupulous, darker ops guys that are out there lurking around and damaging the Canadian companies and, you know, really sort of more importantly, damaging the biosphere of investment that we work with, because between social media and all the negatives and the amount of, you know, The problem I find with regulators is instead of looking at the actual dark horse or the dark cops guys, often they go after the shareholders of the companies. And that has a much more negative effect in terms of your function in the marketplace than it does, than the going after the real criminals.

28:17 It's a little bit like the cops, you know, having arresting the guy smoking a joint on the corner rather than the Colombian drug cartel, which is a real job and really hard to go after. So that's that's where I see it right now. But I mean, we've set up a business model, you know, where we have a platform, we try to protect our, our invest goes, and we try to make sure that they're not as subject to that game as some others might be. We tend to carry 10 to 20 percent of the equity of the outstanding company when we do come in. And we're always waiting to see if somebody tries that game. Yeah, fair enough, fair enough. Well, listen, it was interesting when last week or 2 weeks ago, we had a group of juniors on and one of the comments that came out was, if we tried to close our stock up 5 days in a row, we'd be in handcuffs and heading to jail.

29:09 But the short sellers, they can close you down 5 days in a row, open you up down every day, and nobody calls those guys. It's sort of like, it seems like it's just not a fair system but hopefully through our advocacy, we'll do that. And thanks guys for your updates on 1st Majestic and Cisco Global Royalties. And for sure, the audience should check those companies out and their webpages are really good spots. We've got a gold silver research firm on the line. It would seem wrong to not explore what our esteemed research team at Murrenbilt thinks about the markets. Brian, why don't you tell us a bit about Muir & Beale and what your thoughts are on the precious metals markets today.

29:56 Sure. Thanks very much and thanks for having us on. We've got a 35-year-old brand as the best, reliable, smartest, clear-thinking forecasting shop in metals in the world. Our customer list includes lots of people who are on this webcast right now. Generally we sell our work to CEOs of mining companies and the asset managers who own them, and occasionally individual investors. You can go to our website, murinbuilds.com. The word is Dutch, so it's a little tricky, I'll spell it out. M-U-R-E-N-B-E-E-L-D.com. Dr. Martin Murenbild's got a PhD from Berkeley in comparative currencies.

30:46 He started in the late 1970s doing forecasts at the request of Niranda. And they would use the forecasts to figure what capital spending they should be taking on or at least as an input to that conversation about capital spending for growth or new projects. Every forecast we put out has AAB and C. So you can think of that as a bare case, base case and a bold case. And then we always give you the probability we think will apply to each of those cases, dropping that down to what is really our probability weighted or expected result. But by giving you all of those cases, you can figure out for yourself what you think the worst case is going to be and adjust your plans accordingly. The other thing we do is we don't forecast a single price. And you hear this a lot in the news, you know, Goldman Sachs is $3,000 gold. That doesn't help somebody who's running a company.

31:44 It doesn't help someone who's making an investment because what if it doesn't get the 3000? Goldman was wrong, but that actually doesn't tell you where Gold's going to go. It also doesn't tell you if Gold's going to go there for a single two-hour stretch 5 years from now and then fall back down. So everything we publish is actually time-weighted average. So right now we generally run about 3 years out. So Right now we're forecasting what we think the average price of Gold will be in the fourth quarter of 2021 and into 2022. We do that for Gold. We've been doing it for Gold for, like I said, 35 years. Just Friday passed, so just 4 days ago, actually September 30th, We've published for the very first time on silver.

32:34 And Keith, I hope you've seen a copy. If not, let me know. I'll send it over. And we've expanded our team. We've hired Dr. Tom Brady. Tom's got a PhD in mineral economics from the Colorado School of Mines, which is lovely, but he was also the chief economist for Newmont for 15 years. He was responsible for all of their forecastings, as well as the cost of capital calculations and the discount rates for operating in different countries. So we're really excited to have Tom join our team. And we are a subscription research business. We don't take ads. We don't sell financings. All we wanna do is be accurate and help everybody else get the price right. If you get the price wrong, lots of other things are hard to correct after that.

33:25 There you go. I'll tell you just for the audience here, our Silver probability weighted, and these are time weighted averages for across the quarter, we're going to call out fourth quarter of 2020 is 26 bucks. And then out to 2022, 1st quarter, 38 bucks. That's our probabilities. And the envelope, the low side is basically 18 and the high side on the bull cases, we get further out to the end is 60. So that's pretty exciting stuff. And all of our, We have no secrets. All of our math is available. We give presentations on this to boards and directors and we're happy to hear from anybody who wants to reach out with a question. You can email me at brian.murenbield.com.

34:15 That's our silver. And then in gold, where we have an even longer brand, you know, our forecast right now, 2021 1st quarter, 2100 bucks. And then by the end of the year, 2021, We think the fourth quarter will average $2,455. One of the things we also do that is we do research on demand. So somebody might call and say, you know, how much geopolitics is in the price right now? We do that kind of work as well. That's what we do. Well, that's interesting. Sean and Keith, I want to get your reaction to, you know, on gold and silver prices. Just obviously you're big in the business and you must get a lot of different perspectives on this and you obviously have a view on it. So it'd be great to share that with the audience.

35:04 Sure. Sean? Oh, Martin, a personal friend. I've known him an awful long time. And Martin, we do believe we shared the stage with him on many occasions. And, you know, In terms of where we see gold price, obviously, the simple answer is it's a fear rating on what's gonna happen to the US dollar, how much inflation will come into that dollar and what the damage will be by the current printing machines in terms of increasing money supply by trillions of dollars in an unprecedented matter. If you're a junior mining company and you double the amount of shares that you have outstanding you can well expect your share price to drop by 50%. Gold and silver are the only currencies that trade that don't have any debt behind them and no government control on them. So I think that, you know, as, as safe haven becomes, more importantly, we saw gold go from 1300 to the current $1,900 level on the back of these, you know, risk, risk on trades.

36:04 It certainly seems like the world is becoming a much more risky place than it was even a month ago. And now Trump getting COVID-19 and sort of the thing in that debate, which I think created somewhat amount of chaos. I think we're in pretty good shape for gold price. We're hoping for north of 2000 but we're planning and engineering for 1250, 1300 and all of our projects. Well, Sean, that's crazy. You know that, right? So anyways, there is a question from Otto that came in from Australia. It's something, Terry, you should probably look at it. Yeah, I was thinking about it. Yeah, yeah. I actually wasn't aware of that, but something maybe the Canadian system should look at it to emulate, because the Canadians are always quite passive in bringing new regulations in, and if there's another country they could point to that is actually doing something maybe a little bit better. Maybe that's an example. I know very little about it except for that text message that came in. So maybe it's worth something to Yeah. Yeah. So anyways, talking about metals, You know, I disagree with Sean to some degree. Gold I don't believe is a fear trade. I think gold is just a currency. It's a granddaddy of all currencies.

37:26 So it's like any investment, right? So you know, whether you carry Euros or Yen or dollars or Canadian dollars in your portfolio, gold is just a part of your currency portfolio. And it's up to the individuals on how much of any of these currencies should be in their portfolio. For me, I like to have a large percentage of my assets, my currency assets, in gold. Silver is a completely different issue. Silver is a strategic metal, and it's way beyond precious. There's more gold on the planet today than has ever existed in human history. So it's not a supply and demand issue.

38:13 Silver can completely be the opposite. There's less silver today on the surface of the earth than there ever has been in known history. So, and we're using it at rates that are not sustainable at current silver prices. And I think there's a disconnect between that rationale and the current price of the metal. And if you just, this call itself, and many of your listeners may hear me rant about this, because I feel like I'm a broken record sometimes, but this call would not be possible without silver. Virtually everything we do on a daily basis would not be possible without silver. We as a human race expect to achieve the goals that we want to achieve over the next 10, 20, 30 years to electrify this planet in sustainable long-term ways, we're going to need way more silver.

39:11 And at current prices, there's just simply not enough metal. We've had 4 years of declining production and sustainable consumption rates. You've got a perfect storm in my view. At some point, of course, the big consumers like the Samsungs and the Apples and the Teslas and the Panasonics and the Toyotas and the BMWs that require vast quantities of silver are absolutely paranoid that any of us are actually going to figure it out. Because every investor on the planet is going to front run them all and drive it like Cobalt was driven, or Uranium, or Platinum, you name it. So they try to keep the tightest information out there to try to always water it down if it's not an important metal. But it is actually, if you think about it, silver and copper are really the future of the human race.

40:21 So from an investment perspective, in my opinion anyways, and maybe Tom will prove me wrong, but in my opinion, those 2 metals have to be in your portfolio. I agree. I agree. Before you move on, I'd love to add something. Go ahead. You just said real metal in the sense that it moves up and down with GDP and there's lots of industrial buyers. And once it gets into that use, he's quite right. It doesn't come back into the market in the way that jewelry on the neck will come back into the market later on in life in the same format as pure gold. There's something else I just want to add, and this is now that it's press released, I can say it. I'm involved with a company, Zen, ZEN, and we've just finished testing with the University of Western Ontario, silver doped graphene that kills the coronavirus.

41:15 And so what I want to point it to Keith and everyone else is there's going to be a growing market for silver based on its antivirus idle properties. I mean, silverware, we call every utensil in the drawer at our house silverware. But the reason We call it silverware is because for hundreds of years people have been using it for its antiviral Properties and seeing as kovat is not going away anytime as quick as we all hoped That's going to be an ongoing additional use case for silver. Yeah, interesting interesting This that's that's all good You can see this Interesting, interesting. This, that's all good. One of the things- You can see this, Brian, this is a silver spray, right here, you see that silver spray? I spray this on my masks.

42:03 So actually, you know, I have a cloth mask or actually summer cloth masks. And every morning I spray this on my masks. So actually, you know, I have a cloth mask or actually summer cloth masks and every morning I spray this on my masks. Cool. Fantastic. Yeah. You know, I was surprised. I went to, you know, review the, you know, your presentation on the 1st majestic site, Katie, this week, just to refresh my memory of things. And I, you know, obviously a lot of time and discussion about the industrial applications for silver and I always knew there was, but I didn't really recognize that it was such a big growth in the electrification side of things and now obviously maybe antivirals will be another thing. So let's take a few questions from the audience. Keith mentioned there was a few in the post there and I just want to hit upon those. So one of the 1st, Otto, Otto O'snell, Thank you for your comment. He points out that in Australia, I guess, only the top 100 companies can be shorter and excludes all junior exploration place. Well, that would be a wonderful rule.

43:11 As he said, we can introduce that. I was unaware of that. And if that's indeed the case, then that's a good point. And there have been periods of time where Australian companies would leave Canada to go list in Australia for higher valuation and easier access to capital. And then it's not just a mining thing, this is a little off topic, but I'll point out, there are 2 publicly traded fishing companies in Canada and they're trading at half the EBITDA of the Nordic countries. And there's probably a shorting reason related to that. Interesting. Paul mentions about, shouldn't the mainstream press be picking up on this and advocating for you? And what has your success been with the mainstream press?

44:00 And we've reached out, and generally speaking, had fairly little uptick from these guys, no pun intended there. But I was on BNN early days, and you know, it was funny, it was supposed to be sort of a puff piece, but you know, in terms of supporting the cause, but then turned out to be they started to flag about about the, you know, the, the, you know, the some, some, some of the old historic problems in junior mind promotion and, you know, a shady mine promotion or stuff like that. He asked me a couple of specific companies I had no idea about. And I said, you know, anybody who's actually a really serious mining investor and builder developer wants the crooks to go to jail because they make it bad for everyone. I think now with the internet era and everything being so much more sophisticated, it's harder and harder for, you know, you know, mining promoters of the old classic ways to sort of pump and dump stocks, though, the way they used to. And that's a good thing. And we're all sort of inside for that. But generally speaking, the press has not picked up this advocacy.

45:10 There's a few theories on that. Some view that there's so much money on the short side of this game. Like these guys have made billions and indeed trillions globally on this thing. And you know they they influence the press. They have a lot of cash to work with. So you know the individual small companies or the individual enterprises you know like like When I started this out of the basement, just to try and before I left mining, I thought, Jesus, I should try and change something. I've got 1% of my wealth in mining at the time. And I thought before I leave it on my watch, I should try and change this rule. And, but I mean, that's just a small individual. And luckily, you know, Eric picked up on it. He came in, Eric Sprott, and became a big help. And then you guys joined, you know, we were trying to make a grassroots campaign of this, but, you know, we're up against some big press machines that the banks own and, you know, that's the tough part. So we have to get individuals to be passionate and push the things out. And we have to get our mining companies to be passionate, support, push the thing out and hopefully make a difference on this.

46:21 Going back to the questions, Phillip asks, are there many players ultimately just creating a perfect situation where the miners will eventually soar in price when they're no longer able to suppress the price of precious metals or the miners? Sean, what do you think about that? Yeah, I think that, you know, it's there's always the quid quo pro. I mean nothing you like to be see better than a short sell. If there's a commodity down tick of 100 bucks an ounce in gold or, you know, 10, but 5 bucks an ounce in silver, you're always happy to see that short cover come in as a bottom of the market issue. But, you know, I think the thing that we all need here is we just need to create a marketplace where investors are happy to be there, where there's no social mediation for the regulators and the supporters.

47:08 And we need to have a group of people that take this seriously as you and Eric, and hopefully we have here and we move forward. If I understood the question correctly, I'm not sure that I did. Yeah, no, I think that's a good point. We'll take one more question here. There's a question for Keith. Keith, this is from Paul. He talks about the short position being high and it's quite for some time relative to other silver gold positions, silver gold producers. Can you comment? And thanks for your great work with 1st Majestic and lots of positive things happening. Yeah, thanks, sir. I did see that. Yeah, the short position on 1st Majestic is quite high. It could be related to just the silver short position because there is quite a high silver short.

47:55 And then because 1st Majestic is really the purest of the majors in the space, I think we sometimes get picked on. You know, there's this talk is very, very liquid and you know, it's a great trading vehicle for big institutions. It's kind of, you know, over the last decade has been kind of like the go-to silver name, whether you're a kind of long opinion or a short opinion. So I think it's just, you know, become a huge training vehicle for them, you know. I don't think there's any particular one, you know, group. I think it's just, It's just the way it is, right? It's just, you know, but there is another question here. It's from Todd. I'm not sure if you saw that one. He actually works for 1st Chesnok.

48:43 So I'm somewhat biased with this question. But he actually points out a pretty good thing. This came up in the IROC letter, where it actually said in that IROC letter yesterday, whereby they're suggesting that the hedge funds actually report short positions because currently they do not. I didn't know that. That's interesting. That would be very helpful. Yeah, because it doesn't seem very fair if they just report longs and they don't report shorts it sounds. It's like yours or Sean's comment that the perspective is sort of look after the hedge funds as opposed to the perspective should be look after individual investors, look after individual companies. That's what exchanges were invented for. Well, there's a huge push from regulators on transparency, transparency for issuers.

49:35 But then we have the predators that have no transparency requirements. Thousand percent. Thousand percent. Well, listen, before we go, I promised the viewers that we'd go around the table and we've got some of the more experienced mining minds in the country, and we get a pick, you know, it's pick'em season. So Brian, we're gonna start with you. What do you, you gotta pick somebody in the mining space and say, hey, this is my, I've got, If I'm putting money down, I like these guys, I'm gonna buy this stock. Who are you buying? Well, I'll tell you, they're our customer base, so I'm not gonna choose amongst my children. I will tell you some of what I do own is the GoAU ETF, which is run by Frank down in San Antonio. The reason why I own it is because it's recognizing the fact that a lot of these companies are in a better cashflow position than they've ever been in years.

50:28 And you're starting to see dividend hikes, you're starting to see capital allocation decisions that make a lot of sense compared to the decisions that got made a decade ago. And that's the way at Mirren Build, we're going to do it. Sounds good. Keith, what are your thoughts? Who do you like these days? You want me to pick some stocks? Yeah. Yeah. Well, of course, my 2 favorites, of course, first, I'm Jessica, I'm the founder, CEO. Been there for a long time. First mining gold, I put that company together back in 2015, got a huge portfolio of Eastern Canadian, Ontario, Quebec gold assets. Pretty exciting company as far as I'm concerned.

51:13 I'm the chairman and founder and I don't run it, but there's a pretty good management team involved with running the day to day and suggest people look at it. Some of my side investments, I'm a big investor, big shareholder in Silver 1, have been for over 5 years. My more recent investments have become a reasonably large or older Newfound Gold. They've gone public and they've got some pretty exciting stuff going on in Newfoundland and then and Solaris. You know you got Dan Earl, XTD analyst who left the banking career to take over as CEO of this new startup with Ross and a couple of other pretty key people behind the scenes. I think Rob's there, Ross the robber, there behind the scenes.

52:09 And I'm a shareholder of that as well. I think it's got a huge upside. So those are good. John, what about you? One of the new ones that we've got that's got some pretty exciting stuff on the go would be Talisker Resources with the Braylorn deposit in BC. Kind of an unknown story trading around a $30-$40 million market cap. It's an old high-grade mine that was mining at 15 to 20 gram high-grade vein system. It's been redrilled a lot like what we did at Bargerville. And then the big one that's in our portfolio is Falco Resources, 6.1 million ounce gold equivalent reserves and over 9 million ounces in the overall resource but trading at $100 million while they sort through their permitting issue with the dewatering of the mine. But if they get that permit, I think that that's a serious outcome.

53:00 It's the old horn mine that produced 11 million ounces of gold from the first 600 meters and 3 billion pounds of copper. So it's got some legs on it. And it's mostly just a permitting issue. The technical issues, the full feasibility and reserve status are already there. So not too reliant on the drill bit to get success. It's more of a time-driven portfolio play. That sounds interesting, I'm going to check that out. Last time I was asked, I picked a lithium play, CRE, but it's up 80% in the last 3 weeks. So that was a timely call. I didn't know anything. It just so happened that it was a good run. I like a couple that I've got a speculation on. I got Quebec Precious Metals. They're up in the James Bay in Quebec and Gold Explorer got some interesting stuff happening there. I think they're underpriced and got good upside. And I like Scotty Resources in the Golden Triangle. They're a Golden Triangle sort of, I like that area a lot. And I think they're gonna have some good results here shortly.

54:00 So from a speculative perspective, I like those guys. So that's it. So, Brian, so we got one more? Well, because we finished the first round, I'm going to give you a non-silver and gold name. Zen Graphene Solutions. I'm the CFO and a director. Myself and some friends took it over through a hostile proxy fight in May 2018 because at a globally unique graphite which makes the world's best graphene and graphene is going to be huge. So ZEN is the ticker. Okay we got we got some good good calls here today. Well listen I want to thank everyone for listening and being on the call with us. I wanna thank our guests for taking the time out of their very busy day. These are very busy people and doing some great work and I really appreciate you guys for coming on and helping us out here. And I would say to the audience, if you like what you're hearing, if you wanna help the Canadian capital markets, then please come to Save Canadian Mining and join, tweak this video replay that'll be posted that you'll get and push it out as much as you can to as big an audience as you can because it's only through exposure to getting individuals on site and collect the power of the people will we get government to listen to us and make the changes they should make in our enlightened self-interest. So again, thanks very much for the gasp. We appreciate it, guys. And I hope you guys all have a great day and a wonderful weekend. And we'll look forward to catching up to you soon, hopefully

55:31 once again in the real world at some mining conference and catch up. All right guys, thanks again. Thanks Terry. Thanks for organizing this. In the mining world for listening. Okay. You

Follow Save Canadian Mining into a list and get an email when it puts out news.

Follow Murenbeeld & Co. into a list and get an email when it puts out news.

Follow First Majestic Silver Corp. into a list and get an email when it puts out news.

Latest news releases

Companies on this call

Speakers

Speaker profile Terry Lynch

Terry Lynch

CEO, President & Director at Power Nickel

Terry is the CEO of Power Nickel Inc. and the Founder of Save Canadian Mining. Power Nickel is advancing the NISK project in James Bay Quebec. NISK has a historical resource of approximately 3-over-3 million-tonne 2 percent NiEq. Power completed an initial 3D modelling of the project and is drilling 4,000 metres in Q4 with a view to having a new technical report published in Q1 2022.

Speaker profile Keith Neumeyer

Keith Neumeyer

Chairman at First Mining Gold

Keith Neumeyer founded First Majestic Silver in 2002 and First Mining Gold in 2015. First Majestic grew from a start-up company to one of the world’s largest silver producers with a market cap of US$4BN+. Mr. Neumeyer has worked in the investment community since 1984. He began his career at a number of Canadian national brokerage firms. Mr. Neumeyer moved on to work with several publicly traded companies in the resource and high technology sectors. His roles have included senior management positions and directorships responsible in areas of finance, business development, strategic planning and corporate restructuring. Mr. Keith Neumeyer who has an unparalleled track record which includes creating two world-class mining companies: First Quantum Minerals Ltd. which has now grown into one of the worlds largest copper producers, and First Majestic Silver Corp. which is one of the largest silver producers in the world. Mr. Neumeyer has also listed a number of companies on the Toronto Stock Exchange and as such has extensive experience dealing with the financial, regulatory, legal and accounting issues that are relevant in the investment community.

Speaker profile Sean Roosen

Sean Roosen

Chair of the Board of Directors and Chief Executive Officer at Osisko Gold Royalties

Sean Roosen is Chair of the Board of Directors and Chief Executive Officer of Osisko since June 2014. Prior to this, Mr. Roosen was the President and CEO of Old Osisko. He has led the transition of Old Osisko from a junior exploration company to a leading intermediate gold producer. He was responsible for leading the strategic development of Old Osisko and was instrumental in securing the necessary financing to fund the development of the $1 billion Canadian Malartic Mine. Among other awards, Mr. Roosen was a co-winner of the Prospectors and Developers Association of Canada’s “Prospector of the Year Award” for 2007, and was named, together with John Burzynski and Robert Wares as “Mining Men of the Year” for 2009 by the Northern Miner. Mr. Roosen is a Supervisory Board member of EurAsia Resource Holdings AG – a European based venture capital fund – and a director of EurAsia Resource Value SE. Mr. Roosen also sits on the Board of Directors of the following publicly listed companies: Astur Gold Corporation, Bowmore Exploration Ltd., Condor Petroleum Inc., Dalradian Resources Inc., Falco Resources Ltd. and NioGold Mining Corporation. Mr. Roosen is a graduate of the Haileybury School of Mines and has had various progressive positions in the mining industry both domestically and internationally.

More from First Majestic Silver Corp.