Richard Shin
Chief Financial Officer, Jollibee Foods Corporation
Replay available
Jollibee Foods (PSE:JFC) Q3 2024 earnings call, held 2024-11-13. Watch the replay and read the transcript on 6ix.

On 6ix: 6ix.com/event/jollibee-foods-corp-jbfcf-q3-2024-earnings-call
Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
0:00 Call. I'm Hizal Tanyado from AB Capital and I'll be the moderator for the session today. So to give us updates on Jollibee's good results, as well as the company's strategies and plans in the next 12 months, our speakers for today are Mr. Richard Shin, of course, Jollibee Foods Chief Financial Officer, and Ms. Cosette Palomar from Investor Relations. So thank you, Richard. Thank you, Cosette, again. I hope you guys are well. So before we start, a few reminders. As Mr. Shin goes through the presentation, you may type your questions and send it through like some of you have already done so. Secondly, a few disclosures first will be released by Cosette before the presentation proper. So Cosette, the floor is yours.
0:45 Thank you, Hazel. Good afternoon, everyone. Welcome to the Jollibee Group's third quarter 2024 earnings conference call. Okay, so just a few reminders. The earnings call may include forward-looking statements that are based on certain assumptions of management and are subject to risks and opportunities or unforeseen events. Actual results could differ materially from those contemplated in the relevant forward-looking statement and the Jollibee Group gives no assurance such forward-looking statements will prove to be correct or that such intentions will not change. All subsequent written and oral forward-looking statements attributable to the Jollibee Group or persons acting on behalf of the Jollibee Group are expressly qualified in their entirety by the above cautionary statements.
1:35 And now, here's Mr. Shin.
1:38 Thank you very much, Kose. Thank you, Hazel. So I'm quite excited. And first of all, good afternoon and good morning to our dear friends from Europe and America who have dialed in as well. So thank you so much for doing that. It's exciting times for Jollibee as we transition from a single market dependent company to a multi-market opportunity growth company. And so therefore, let me show you now the data to support that excitement. So first and foremost, overall, the quarter delivered another strong quarter and key results led by systemized sales growth were now approaching 100 billion, near 100 billion per quarter business. That represents a 13.2% top line growth. And if you were to look at the full nine month year to date, we're nearly 281 plus billion or 12% growth. That then of course needs to be substantiated by the quality of growth.
2:45 So rolling base or same store sales growth in our case was 5.7% for the quarters. And later I'll show you some comparisons to other companies in our industry. Revenues, of course, the start of the P&O, very important data point, nearly 68 billion or a 10% growth. And for the nine months where just under 200 billion, a similar 10.6% growth. So double digit growth on revenue. On gross profit, middle of our P&O, really robust and strong. Later, I'll show you some rates, margin rates as well to speak to the efficiency of this line. But at the moment, just to share again, 15.2% growth in gross profit, which is in line with the 15.8% that we've delivered so far first nine months.
3:43 Gross profit margin, as mentioned, we are delivering a 19.1% margin rate And this is an increase above the same quarter of last year by nearly 70 bips. So I'll show you the comparables later. And for the nine months, we're holding this rate of 19%. Again, historical high, despite continued pressures in different parts of the world around inflation, whether it's raw materials or labor costs. But nonetheless, we have not taken pricing in the Philippines on major markets. So We're delivering this mainly through efficiencies from procurement, manufacturing, and running our store operations. That leads us now to OI. So our operating income was up 11.6% or 17.3% for the first nine months. And I'll show you a little bit to put context and color to what that percentage means vis-a-vis what we did in 2023 Q3.
4:47 which was a record quarter, which grew 59% from the same quarter in 2022. So I like to show you the comparables so we can have a better understanding of the quality of growth. Net income, 15.3%, bringing us to 24.1% for the full year and well within the range that we had provided in our guidance. Before we continue with the JFC business details, again, I wanted to show you same store sales growth, as well as total system-wide sales growth, what came through as new store contribution versus Yum China, as well as the larger US-based QSRs of McDonald's, Starbucks, Chipotle. We've added Domino's in here as another reference point. And of course, Luckin Coffee is an interesting data point to look at. as we are now 20% of our EBITDA is coming from our beverage category of coffee and tea. So once again, same store sales growth, very robust and ahead of most of our industry peers, except for Chipotle.
6:09 So here's what I'm gonna compare 22 versus 23 and 23 versus 24. So on a revenue basis, let's start with Q3 2024 growth rate. These are all numbers I've just mentioned. So you should be familiar with these numbers. As I repeat, most of them, except for EBITDA, this is a new data point, 12.1% growth on EBITDA. Again, if I was just to take one line to represent profitability, which is the operating profit line here, we grew 59% same quarter, last year versus two years ago of 2022. So off of this very high base, we are still delivering a double-digit growth of 11.6.
6:56 And I will show you a couple of slides later how that unfolds. But before we do that, I just want to quickly come back to our guidance and say that we are on track right across the board on all the metrics that we have indicated. On CapEx, we will, as you can see, nine months we spent under 8 billion. So we'll likely be below this range of CapEx spent. Let's start with top line system-wide sales in the first column. These are growth rates, same store sales. So Philippines, our engine continues to be an engine and the 8.5% is ahead of, market competitors in the Philippines. And the quality of that growth really comes from same store sales growth. So we're very encouraged to see that continue.
7:53 Of course, we're still expanding. In fact, we've raised our target for new stores in the Philippines. So that will be closer to 160 new stores from our original target of 130 stores. So we're seeing momentum. So we'll add to that. China was scaling back on new store growth. Original plan was 150, a combination of franchise and company-owned, but we scaled that back to closer to 100 new stores for the full year, predominantly franchise. And later, I have more slides on China so that we can understand the defense strategy as well as getting ready for regrowth strategy as well in China. North America, Asian brands represented here is mostly Jollibee. Later, I'll show you Jollibee as a P&L, how it's holding up, not just in the Philippines, but also in EMEA and North America.
8:53 Smashburger, we did decline by 4.5% same-store sales growth, and it has been challenging to some extent in the QSR and the fast casual segments in the US. And later again, I'll give a lot more color to this. So we won't brush over it. We'll really get into it. EMEA, it's really Vietnam and other markets that represents EMEA. So Vietnam continues to be strong with a near 31% system-wide sales growth, of which 14% is coming from same stores. And we're rapidly increasing closing in on KFC to be number two in Vietnam, approaching very soon 200 stores.
9:41 And you can see the new store contribution of 16%. Coffee Bean and Tea Leaf continues to perform well. So it's been a few quarters now. So near 18% on System Y and near 11% on same store. Highland Coffee, We continue to build, although we scaled back a little bit, understanding there's some macro challenges that want to just be safe, but we're still running our business with store RIC of around 42% for new stores. So we'll continue to build out our stores, but nonetheless, we're watching that with caution. Milkshake, relatively small, but still continues to contribute.
10:26 And later we can talk about compost. I'm sure there's several, questions around the contribution of the compost business to our third quarter. So I'll say that for a bit later. So net net international 20.5% in system wide and four and a half percent in same store sales growth. So as a portfolio, I believe we are performing ahead of market and global, of course, with Philippines, it's 13.2 and 5.7 for same store. This is nine months. So let's move on. Now let's get into the quality of earnings. So This is a simple bridge that compares operating income of third quarter this year versus operating income of same third quarter a year ago in 2023. Earlier, I referenced that that quarter grew by 59 versus the prior year of 2022. So a couple of things, if you will, the business this third quarter delivered nearly 1.5 billion of real profits. So this is operating income delivered by business growth right across geographies and brands and sectors.
11:38 Our margin expansion, which means our efficiencies on our gross profit margin also continues to contribute nearly 200 million. Where we've invested for continuous growth in people, technology and brand building initiatives, you'll see that this is higher than it was a year ago compared to 2022. And of course, we continue to spend our AMP. So this means that third quarter this year, we've actually spent 200 million more than we did in third quarter last year. And there's a couple of reasons. So there's momentum on a lot of our brands led by Charlie Bee. So we'll continue to invest behind those.
12:23 And there are returns on those investments, of course, because They're very targeted AMP investments. But at the same time, we don't want to have a traffic jam build up in the fourth quarter of catch up as we've gone through that experience in 2022. So here for the third quarter, we're running our business with AMP as a percentage of revenue at 3.5%. Last year, we spent a little bit slower. You can see last year was 2.9. Now I may toggle back and forth in the slides, so stay with me please. So business growth, 1.4. Last year, even with that 59% NOI growth rate, we grew the business, we added an incremental 1 billion.
13:10 So percentages aside, I just want to make sure that we have a true understanding whether the growth is still happening and whether the magnitude of growth is in fact the same, smaller or larger. And the answer is the magnitude of growth, business growth is actually 40% larger. So a billion here versus billion four. In terms of margin efficiencies, last year we had more margin efficiencies. And of course, over time, you keep squeezing out the costs and efficiencies, but you're not going to run a 745 million per quarter efficiency. But nonetheless, we're still delivering margin efficiencies of 167. Investment level last year, again, lower, nearly two-thirds of what we invested this year.
14:02 Again, people, process, technology, brand support. And this is the AMP line that we talked about earlier. EBITDA. So profitability by regions and business units. Philippines continues to be slightly more than half. As you can see here, 59% is now coming from Philippines and 41% is coming from international. This is our highest percentage that we've been able to deliver. Last quarter, I reported, I believe it was about two thirds and one third. China, we did not make money this quarter.
14:47 So we'll dive into that. Year to date, we do have 500 million of profits, but this quarter we missed, and it's for very challenging reasons. North America, so we're near 2.5 billion contribution from Jollibee-led North America, of which almost a billion came through this quarter, so you can see the acceleration of this business growth. Smashburger, we did not... make money this quarter. And again, I'll walk you through, which then brings our nine months down into slight negative. But there are some interesting data points on this one to consider as a predictability measure of whether this is a new trend or whether it's deliberate and purposeful.
15:40 Middle East and the rest of Asia, near 400 million brings us to near 1.2. for nine months. The coffee and tea category, coffee, bean, and tea continues to be our biggest contributor in that category. So grew by 60% in the quarter. That's great. Highland coffee is flattish at minus 4.8%, but nonetheless still delivering 569. And then for nine months, you can see we're slightly up versus the previous year by 2.9% at 1.7 billion. Compost comes in. So the magnitude of impact of compost is here. It's 483 million.
16:25 And that represents a month and a half because we took over the business August 16th. So Q4 should be even a stronger performance. Let's go into our challenges. So China, so what we're seeing, and before I go through what we're seeing, I just want to share again, So a quarter ago, China was profitable at 233 million EBITDA. So I want to keep that in context. That represented a 40% growth. What we've seen is we've seen an acceleration of asset-like distribution model in both beverage and food. And so I think...
17:10 The future growth within China, really, we need to consider franchising. We need to consider asset-light distribution model with a lot of off-premise percentage of total sales. We're also seeing heightened nationalism. And if I was to look at a couple of brands like Starbucks versus Luckin, Luckin is now over 20,000 locations. Starbucks is just over 70. but in the quarter, I think they're now heading strides of putting up or building a couple of thousand new points of sales per quarter. So the accelerated growth happening there, Luckin as a brand is also attracting quite a bit of youthful consumer base as well because of product innovation, the constant new flavors, localized flavors, We're also seeing that in Taystian, which is the fastest growing value food play in China.
18:13 So Chinese burgers, as they're known. And of course, the marketing is really geared towards the younger generation. And the final thing that we're seeing, we've talked about this in the past as well, is the price and value positioning is incredibly sensitive at the moment. So there are certain price points for breakfast and price points for lunch. where Yong Ha King is now pivoting towards. So as we do that, we will see the P&O reflect that going forward. But that's a major work to pivot through, manage your cost of goods, manage your margin, manage your supply chain. So it's quite a bit of work to transition into that value segment, but it's necessary because the only brands and businesses in our category that's growing are really due to a reprice or value positioning.
19:11 Now let's talk about the other challenge, which is Smashburger. Industry first. What's interesting is although it's a smaller category than QSR, the fast casual space CAGR rate is decent. We've seen from 2024 out, we see a projected CAGR rate of 15%. So there's still quite a bit of optimism in this space that sits above QSR. And of course, the key value or sort of key growth drivers like to say is really understanding the strong preference, strong experience preference, as well as quality of food preference from the millennials and Gen Z.
20:00 It's also, of course, recognizing that there's a certain fresh tasty health conscience element to the products that we offer. And of course, we've seen this, and if you add drive-through in as well, the off-premise channels continue to grow rapidly. So now let's start bringing this to Smashburger. So fast cash flow in the US, however, there's also some challenges. So there are value wars that's happening. In the consumer's mind, they don't categorize between QSRs and fast casuals per se. So we have to consider having QSR price points in our fast casual dining experience. So having different tiers of burger prices for Smashburger is something that seems to fit right into the trends that we're seeing.
20:57 And that means you can go to QSR. or you can go to a better burger place and get similar price point now for entry-level burgers. But of course the quality will be significantly different as we use fresh Angus beef. Growth in traffic and frequency will therefore depend on success of how we support our ad support campaigns, whether they be promos or LTOs. And this was a quote from Shake Shack's third quarter earnings call, but Flattish, TC is now seen as a win in this very sort of price sensitive environment that we're seeing in the U.S. And just below here are data points. So these data points are not two, three data points per se, but these are data points starting from September 17th.
21:49 So that's week one all the way to the most recent week seven. And this is to really show you what has happened since our new menu launch. what has happened in terms of daily traffic. And that's represented by the number of entrees we sold, which is a proxy of how many guests we are having coming into the stores. Traffic. So, sorry, the same store sales growth on that traffic number that I just mentioned, you can see it's starting to pick up to, you know, to high singles and now to even double digits. So we're getting now guests into the store, which is great. And this is just our company-owned stores.
22:36 And the reason is because we're testing the menu here and then we'll roll it up to our franchise stores. The average daily transactions you can also see are picking up. So this is what we're more familiar with, our TC, as we say, transaction count. And you can see similar to what Shake Shack is seeing and experience, flattish, to slight positive, 1.2 here, seems to be not a bad thing given the environment. Continuing with Smashburger, so just very quickly, some of this you've seen before, but this is actually a new logo. It's rebranded. The whole concept around the future growth of Smashburger is really leaning into going back to our basics, which is we're a great burger player.
23:26 And so therefore we've menu relaunched as I've shown you. And I'll show in a second how we're tracking against our target of 4,000 ADS, which is a store level breakeven. We've also worked quite a bit on our digital app and website development to make sure we're capturing those off premise trends that I spoke of earlier. And of course we have a very clear ADS glide path to profitability. So, The numbers are what you saw earlier that I showed you. Now, I do want to say there's a couple of pivots. And earlier I used the word deliberate. So we've been testing and trying. So Smashberg has made a deliberate pivot away from the classic funnel marketing approach, which is create awareness, spend a lot of AMP to do that, spend AMP to get that to consideration and even trial. and then eventually to repeat order. And then of course, with loyalty plans, programs, sorry, to get them into higher frequency customers.
24:36 We're now pivoting away from that as we're going more towards a focused digital marketing effect, which is really about performance marketing. So we're turning on that faucet. So that AMP that we spend is very deliberate and direct. and we're starting to measure what that means in terms of ADS. Long story short, ADS started to pick up by 15% with that new pivot on the AMP investment strategy. So some deliberate, all those investments of course are part of this EBITDA numbers that you're seeing. So again, I didn't want to show you data to the point that it would cover that.
25:23 shows you what's been happening post menu launch, because I think that's the more interesting part to look at. So if you were to sort of look at snapshots of week one, week three, week five, so every two weeks, if you will, to week seven, this is what we've been seeing post our pivot and also post the new menu launch. So we're nearing that 4,000 that we spoke of, and we're still targeting the 4,000 by the end of this year. What does all that mean? That means we get to store level NOI positive level. For a company NOI, including the investments in our leadership team, et cetera, we need to get to 4,500. So the glide path is there for that. And somewhere between four or five and 6,000 is when we're starting to get to net income after tax positive levels.
26:19 So first stage 4,000, We're currently at 37 and change. I know it's quite a bit of slides on Smash, but I wanted to make sure that I just share with you in a bit more detail some concerns our investors may have. Looking at the domestic versus international, so no new news in that domestic continues to be the bigger contributor, significantly larger contributor, but the growth rate, you can see similar to in Q2 when I show this chart, 8.5% growth rate in Philippines is an excellent number. International and smaller base were growing at 25. And on a NEAT basis Q3, we're now international NEAT positive.
27:11 So that's great. And you can see the growth rate there. Let's talk about Jollibee, which is really our flagship brand. So let me start with store count. So we're 1,700 stores globally, of which nearly 1,300 is in the Philippines, and just over 400-ish is outside, of which Vietnam, as mentioned earlier, we're getting very close to our 200 stores. What has that delivered? Well, that has delivered a same-store sales growth of high singles and double-digit, with North America being a high double-digit growth, Vietnam being, in terms of number of stores and in terms of growth rate, being very significant.
28:00 And the reason why we're over-indexed here in the system-wide sales is because, mentioned earlier, Vietnam's opening up new stores quite rapidly as our paybacks come considerably down. We started outside Ho Chi Minh and Hanoi because these are higher rental areas, but now the brand is strong. So it's starting to really accelerate its store openings in Ho Chi Minh. We are also taking locations where KFC has vacated because they have not performed as well. So we're getting into some prime locations that way as well. EMEA also very strong performance. So overall Jollibee 12.6% system-wide sales growth. and you can see the various same store sales growth.
28:48 At Hong Kong, if you recall last year, we took the strategy of investing 60% into the franchisee. So we're now at the majority. We've test piloted two locations with the new store model called Jollibee 2.0. And in one of the two locations, I was there actually on Sunday to check it out. And we were running that day at around 13,000 USD ADS. Incredible shift from where Jollibee was in Hong Kong a year ago. So I wanted to give that one a call out as well. We now have 24 stores. The other accolades that we received, that is Southeast Asia's number one food brand. So this is right across all markets in Southeast Asia.
29:36 So we received that very recently. We've also a couple of months back received the employer of the year award. in the Philippines. So that was an honor. And our chief HR officer, Archie Sabato, who's right here next to the Jollibee mascot. He got the second award as well as the People Leader Award. So good momentum following our CEO of the Year Award in 2023 by Sir October here last year. Coffee, bean and tea leaf. So the brand, not the category. So before we get into that, let me just show you what that segment looks like. Again, system-wide sales growth, you know, pretty robust for the big brands of CBT and Highland.
30:26 And now our P&L, our revenue growth and our EBITDA growth, quite significant growth rates of 18% on revenue, producing 60% on EBITDA as we continue to go more and more into the franchise model. So many of our markets are performing well. US, Malaysia, other parts of Southeast Asia, and of course, Middle East has been performing very well. Operational efficiency. So let's just start to wind this down. So earlier I mentioned that our gross profit margin rate of 19.1 is higher than it's ever been. You can see last year was 18.3. are operating profit margin 10 basis point, but on a larger pie.
31:13 So that's producing significant earnings for our shareholders. And of course, NEON also grew by 10 basis point. Free cash flow. I wanted to focus on our cash generated from operations at 9.1% or 6.2 billion. And of course, our CapEx management. Earlier I told you, that we were just under 8 billion for the year. For the quarter, we were 2.6 million spent on CapEx. So that continues to give us opportunities to work on our RIC, improve our RIC, but also work on our free cashflow margins. Very simply, we have lots of headrooms, all the financial covenants that we are tied to.
32:03 So I'm moving in the right direction. So key summer again, we are growing ahead of industry in many markets across several brands. We continue to have very strong Jollibee brand growth, but also store network expansion. We continue to have sustainable growth in the Philippines and Philippines as a market, we did not see it saturated anytime soon. It continues to be a consumer market for us and we're ahead of competition. Compost Coffee's first quarter post-acquisition results are ahead actually of the targets that we had when we purchased this business. But nonetheless, Q4 will be a full quarter to look at. We believe it's going to be a very strong quarter for us, not just for compost, but overall for JFC.
33:02 And we're managing through the two key challenges, which I've have gone through, which is China value repositioning. So we will continue to see some losses in the business. But again, I've shown you that the business comes from a place where we're still self-funded and in the past that we have had positive EBITDA. So it's hard work here, but we also know that the swings are large. So the repositioning and the rebound could also be a very large contribution for us. Smashburger ABS Improvement, which is what we had promised. And we also promised that we will turn CVTL around and now start scaling through towards greater profitability.
33:48 So I'll wrap up again as a reminder, we're on track to triple in five years if 2024 is an indication of year one. And we're working very hard to continue to get to this target of 20%. and acquisitions such as compost is really helping us accelerate that achievement target as well. We continue to stay with our five core strategies as I've shown before, and we continue to incite a lot of interest in the franchisee arena in large markets like the US. So with that, apologies a little bit more than my usual 20 minutes, I wanted to deeper dive on some of the challenges.
34:37 So I'll take questions now and whatever we can answer on this call, we will certainly follow up through other calls or through emails. Thank you, Richard. Congratulations on the results. So we're opening the floor now to questions. For those who have questions, please use the raise hand function. Otherwise, as some of you have done so, you can use the chat feature. via Zoom as well as email. Whatever medium you'd like, just send it over to me. So again, use the raise hand function or email me your question. Our first question comes from John Teh. John, you may unmute and ask your question.
35:14 Hey, thanks, Hazel. And hey, Richard. Three questions for me. First is maybe touch on the domestic business a little. Because we've seen that revenues actually sequentially fell. So any particular reason and... on the operating margin side, we also saw that it was flat year-on-year and there was quite of a dip quarter-in-quarter, but you alluded to some investments and glad if you could just focus the discussion on the domestic business.
35:46 That's first. Hey, John. Thanks for the question. What was the first one? What had fallen, you said, in domestic?
35:53 Sales, quarter-in-quarter.
35:56 Quarter-on-quarter. Okay. Okay. Quarter and quarter. To be honest, I'll have to go back and look at the reasons for quarter and quarter because the seasonality, that's the easy answer because Q2 is usually stronger than Q3, but I want to give you a better answer than seasonality, but that has something to do with it. I'm not sure if domestic is slowing down the way we're seeing it actually, although our average check has slightly come down through our various value plays. the mix and match programs, et cetera. What we're most, I guess, focused on is transaction count and volume. And we continue to see high single digits on that. But let me get back to you on Q2 versus Q3.
36:42 But certainly Q3 versus last year Q3, we're quite happy with the high single digit growth rates. And the margin percentage, let me get back to you as well on if there are any specific factors raw material cost impact or any reason why that would have softened. But as far as we know, we didn't take pricing in the Philippines and we kept our GP margin up. So I'll have to come back on the OPM question if that's okay.
37:16 All right. No problem, Richard. Thanks for that. Second is on Smashburger, you alluded to the new menu and achieving 3,700 ABS. Congratulations on that. The question is, how many stores have the new menu and how many stores have the 3,700 ADS? Is it all company-owned or across the board, including franchisees?
37:40 Yeah, great question. So we're testing and rolling out in pockets. So the company-owned stores is about 110 out of the 230, sorry, 120 out of the 230 stores. And the idea is to roll them out across the different geographies of the company. So in terms of coverage, we're less than half with the new menu. So the other thing I'll say is franchise stores typically have higher ADS than company owned stores because they have non-traditional locations as well, which is all blended in. And we have not rolled out the new menus there. And the plan is to do so in December and January. So the test seems to be working. The pivot to the type of marketing seems to be working. So now we're going to roll that out for balance of this year and first month of next year.
38:34 All right. And the 3,700, just to be perfectly clear, only applies to half of the 120 company-owned stores.
38:43 Yes. So the 3,700 would be the blended ADS for all the stores, but the new menu have not hit half of those stores.
38:57 Thanks, Richard. And if you don't mind, a quick follow-up. Anything specific that has happened to the three-fourths that has lifted ADS to 3.7 at least in the past four weeks after? Thank you.
39:09 Sorry, the question one more time, John?
39:12 If the blended number is indeed 3.7, anything specific that has happened to, I guess, the three-fourths of the stores that do not have the menu that seem to have also improved?
39:22 Yeah, so the stores without the new menu, we saw a slight decline in ADS. The stores with the new menu, we saw an increase in ADS. So that gives us confidence that there is a differential between the menus. So we'll roll it out into the rest of the stores as well.
39:41 I see. Okay. Thanks, Richard. Last question on equitized income. There was a big bump in 3Q. Anything specific?
39:49 Equitized income.
39:51 Equity income from associates.
39:54 Ah, okay. Yeah, I think of a couple. So our Cargill JV called SeaJoy, that's actually doing really well. So we got some upside from there. Plus our Middle East and other JVs that we have in Jollibee that comes through that line that's also doing well. And of course, we took a gain. We reported a gain from Titan Revaluation and we got several brands in Titan, Timo One Plus and other brands like Common Man, etc. So those were the main reasons why that popped.
40:32 Okay. No, thanks, Richard. And congrats again.
40:34 Okay. Thanks, John. Appreciate it. Thanks, John. So I'll read a few questions, Richard, if you don't mind, from the chat. A few questions on compost coffee. First was in the 17Q, it was noted that compost coffee's net income contribution in the third quarter was at 360 million, but it would have been 2.5 billion had compost been consolidated as of January. So the question is, this seems to suggest a slight slowdown in 3Q compared to the first half. is there seasonality on the quarter on quarter basis for compost? That's the first question.
41:12 Okay, it's really hard for me to say whether it is slow down or in fact, it's over delivering to what we had anticipated because we only have a month and a half. But what I can share with you in that month and a half, when we bought the business, the business was running at around 42% EBITDA margin rate. And at an NOI margin rate, it was... at a PBT margin rate, it was running around at 40%. Today, that PBT margin rate is running at 56%, based again on a month and a half. And our EBIT margin rate is running at 55%. So from that data set, we think that actually it's ahead of what we had anticipated.
42:00 The forecasting back to January, et cetera, I'm not sure. We haven't done that work. in that sense, because there are seasonalities, but also simply because we don't have enough data points to really make that statement concrete. So a net net, I'll say compost actually is over delivering to what we had anticipated. So the impact, for example, on revenue compost, again, one and a half months out of the three months in the quarter on revenue line, it's delivering 1.3% of total JFC revenue as a contribution. On OI level, it delivered 9.8%. So again, shows you the model of, you know, 100% franchised out and there's no royalty program in Korea, as mentioned earlier. It's really the sale of the beans.
42:49 So we're extremely happy on that gearing of 9.8% contribution, which is quite significant from one brand for JFC. So yeah, that's Composite. Yeah, and then next, being a value player in Korea, is there building pressure on compost from historically high prices of coffee at present?
43:16 Yeah, so it's a volume play and we're lucky in that our quality of beans, which we, of course, for buy and lock in, yes, is priced for tomorrow as much as we can. We are very cognizant of the Arabica as well as the Robusta, in our case, Robusta Son in Vietnam. But we are very aware of the coffee price increases and movements. We're also very aware that as a value player, we need to make sure our retail price doesn't reflect coffee bean price increases. So what we're seeing at the moment with these kind of margin rates is that a lot of the, I guess, the volume drive volume place that we're doing is actually making up. We have very low overheads as a business as well.
44:09 And that's why we're seeing very high net operating income margins as well as EBITDA margins. So yeah, I'm not sure if we're going to take price to our franchises next year, but we'll continue to work with different sourcing of beans to make sure that our blend is as good, but make sure we get the best price blend mix that we can. And Richard, lastly on compost, future plans and targets.
44:39 Oh, future plans and targets. So what we've announced, I think at the time we acquired it, it was running around 25 to 2,600 stores. We said that in the next few years, we want to get up to 4,000 stores with focus on Greater Seoul because we're under-indexed there compared to our competitor, Mega, as we are a Busan business type. We are very strong in Busan. So I think that still remains the target. If there's opportunities to go outside of Korea, that's probably going to be a little bit later. The other KPI that I've asked the team to really hone in on is to close the gap between us and Mega. Mega, on a unit basis, that's about 25% higher in ADS than us. And the reason, again, is they do less Americano, which is a lower-priced product, and more of those sweet blends.
45:33 and so we are working on menu architecture to close that gap. So I think next full year 2025 will be a better year than this year, full year 2024, which will end up being a better year than 2023. And so therefore I think our valuation multiple still remains at seven and yeah, we're very focused about new stores, Closing the gap on ADS, making sure our menu has the right product mix. Beyond that, we don't have a, I guess, a long-term numeric plan to share at this stage of the business as we just bought it a couple of months ago.
46:19 Thanks, Richard. And probably the same as other coffee markets, right? There's usually a seasonality. I'm not sure if it's the same in Korea, but there's usually summer and winter peaks, right? Where 1Q and 2Q are the strongest because it's the coldest. One of the reasons why 3Q would seasonally be weak as well.
46:39 Yeah, I'm laughing because the Korean office worker, if I may call it that, coffee drinking habits, Whether it's winter or summer, Ice Americano still seems to be the number one variant. And they drink it three times a day. But we are working on Q4 or winter seasonality drinks. But yeah, we're not seeing too much seasonality at the moment. But then again, it's still a very new business for us. So I don't want to overanalyze it until we get a bit more data points. Okay, so enough about compost. Divya, you cannot ask any compost questions. You can ask your question.
47:25 Thanks, thanks. Yeah, just a couple of questions from me. The first one is on your ROIC target of 20%. Just wanted to hear your thoughts on, you know, I know you said that on M&A, you'll be just more opportunistic and it's not part of your strategy as of now. but how about divestment? So especially when you look at some of these businesses like smash burger, or you've pointed out at some structural issues in China as well, at what point in time do we start thinking about whether we rather scale down some of these businesses that have not been fixed for many years, rather than, you know, putting more money behind it, um, to get to that 20% ROIC target.
48:02 Yeah. It's a great question, Divya. And, uh, probably only a lot more than a couple of minutes, but in short, you're right. In short, that has to be part of the thinking. In reality, we seem to have some hurdles around if we diversify, what's the impact in terms of do our competitors get stronger because of those brands? What's the impact in terms of geographies that we're not as big and strong in that we leave vacated, etc.? ? What I will say is that the question and the topic of diversifying the tail is an ongoing discussion. And so I don't have a concrete, we will sell this by this date yet, but it is a very important topic that we discuss quite frequently.
48:56 In particular, in China, where we have really two Chinese brands outside of Timohan, because we're going to manage as a global brand. The question is, do we need both or can we just go with Young Art King? I think Smash might be a difficult one to divest out of now because we just feel that our investments are starting to show signs with the new management team in there as well. Okay, fair enough. And my second and last question is just on the outlook for 2025. I'm particularly interested on Philippines because there, you know, we've taken a bit of a pause on store openings, but in your opening remarks, you did mention that you're increasing that. How are you thinking about sales growth going into the next year?
49:44 And in terms of store openings, if you can give us some color.
49:48 We are looking at... Let's say high mid to high single for same-store sales growth. Jollibee will continue to lead the way, but we're also seeing very good high single-digit same-store sale growth rate with our two other champion brands, which is Magnacell and Chowking. They're much smaller brands than Jollibee, but the momentum's really good. And in terms of store counts, we will build more stores next year than we did this year in the Philippines. but thank you very much.
50:23 Okay, thank you, Divya. Thanks, Divya. One question from the chat. CBTL EBITDA grew far faster than revenue. Can you break down how much is coming from operating leverage of corporate stores versus mixed shift towards franchise stores?
50:43 So because we are two-thirds franchise, roughly, What happens there is when we take price increase, we're seeing in the company-owned stores, we're seeing that pretty much come straight down to the EBITDA line. In terms of royalty rates and the rest, we haven't adjusted. So I would say the EBITDA growth really is coming from the mix of, you know, the Malaysia stores are doing really well. Singapore stores are solid. The US company-owned stores, are starting to show double-digit same-store sales growth as well. I guess that gearing is happening because our company-owned stores are growing at a good rate.
51:33 Operational leverage, I can't think of anything, Hazel, to say that we've done some major operational leverage piece, but we've taken price and held volume. I know that's not operational leverage per se, but that was also another big contributor to our profit growth. How about Richard franchising for the US? That was something you mentioned in the past.
51:56 Yeah, so we looked at how to scale faster and bigger. And one thought was if we were to convert our company-owned stores into a franchise, so we're still analyzing that, but we're now starting to see that with highest double single digit growth, I think we did about 18% of the quarter, We don't want to rush in and sell, not sell, but we don't want to rush in and convert too quickly. So we've taken a pause on that. Yeah, but the main thing for the U.S. is we're looking to scale through franchising. So it may not be through sale of the company own stores, but it'll be through new territories and with new franchises. And I guess sticking to North America, we saw that SSSG accelerated to 19% in 3Q versus 8.7% in 3Q year-to-date.
52:52 So can you give some color on why it was very strong in the third quarter? Any reason for that?
52:59 SG&A, if you take the SPs out, I would say it's two-thirds people cost, so I think it's having better quality capabilities that will be leading. We're also spending quite a bit on digital, as I've spoken of in several quarterly reports. So let me just give you an eight-week-based data point. So I know it's not a long-term data point, but as we were able to now launch our Jollibee North America loyalty app, what we've seen in the last eight weeks is a 30% uplift on average check. That is huge. So we're excited about that. We're equally excited about going national now with our better burgers in Jollibee. So that's Jollibee price pointing, but all the learnings we got from Smash, we are using Angus as well.
53:57 That's starting to really be very interesting in terms of additional ADS coming from second pillar of, burgers and not just chicken. And then the last piece that we've been seeing consistently now is our investment in Batrista. We're now doing about 400 USC and ADS, which added 20% uplift to our drinks category. So these investments that we've been making, whether it's SG&A or CapEx or direct capital investments, we're starting to see the synergies coming through. And so one last bit on North America. What kind of 80s are you doing in North America Jollibee stores now?
54:40 80s? Yes. Yeah. So if we don't add the Batrusta piece, it's around 13,000. But I think adding the Batrusta piece and seeing where we go with the burgers, there's plenty of upside to the 13,000. Okay, thanks for that. We have a question from the floor. Jeanette, you can ask your question. Yeah, thanks so much. Good afternoon. Hi, Richard. Just two questions. First is on Tim Ho Wan. Could you share any details of the company's financials, top line EBIT, net income, et cetera, or even operational details? Just want to understand also the implied, I think, if I'm not mistaken, 250 SING, valuation for the company just want to ask what's the valuation basis is this enterprise value or equity value you know any caller or insights on the company would be helpful and also when do you expect this to be consolidated into Jollibee okay this is a great question so we've always said we had four strategic pillars of which Chinese Cuisine was one and we've also said without only Tim O'Wan direct because we're
55:58 owning it as an LP through a fund. We said that Timo one is the one where we believe that there's real brand value. So this deal effectively, what it allows is as an investor into a fund, we do not consolidate the P&L and it's a positive P&L. So it'll be profit accretive P&L. Starting from January, we're able to now take the TMO on P&O and start consolidating that. So that's the first bit. In terms of cash, we're able to have that cash as well because there's been no cash or dividends or any other kind of payments in that sense.
56:43 So from both P&O and cash, I think that it's a very good creative move. In terms of valuation, how we got to 250, it really got through the classic models and we used third parties, Deloitte, and they're the ones who came up with a range and 250 is actually within that range. But yeah, it would be the classic enterprise value model. In terms of the synergies, what's interesting is- Any multiples? Sorry to interrupt you. Any multiples of the-
57:19 I would have to get back to you on the EBITDA multiple on that deal. In terms of, I guess, operational capability of running this business, this is the first business, and it's not a full acquisition because we've owned it in a different vehicle for a while. We're just buying out the 8% and then extracting the entire 100% out as a subsidiary. But this is the first business or project, if you want to call it, where a team has been built and is ready to go. And it's a nice mix between the Timo One team existing and also some resources from JFC. So I think that's the other key point to mention that.
58:06 Operationally, we have a lot of faith in the leader. Sheng Li is his name. And he'll then start to work with the China Tema One team as well so that we have one Tema One group. But this is profitable. This is bottom line.
58:23 Yes, it's a creep. Yes. And the last thing I'll say is this is the beginning of the journey of value growth because once we bring it in-house and we start to run it and build business and expand and scale, you'll see that The value creation is significantly higher than the 250 sink that we bought it at. Okay. Last question is actually on balance sheet. What are your plans on your senior perpetual securities as well as senior bonds, which will have a step up as well as increase in rates?
59:03 So we've been working on this for a long time. so now the plan is concrete we have selected the institutions that we're going to work with so in January 2025 we'll have 396 million USD perpetual bonds maturing so we're going to roll the 300 as a senior bond with a relatively shorter tenure because the rates are coming down so we don't want to lock into a long and then the 96 we're going to turn that into a term a pay so long So we also reduce our exposure on dollars by 96 million. So that's the plan for that. Then in January 2026, so one year out from coming January, 300 million USD of the senior bonds are coming. And that one, likely the rates will be much better. And so that one, we could consider a longer tenure of, let's say, a seven.
1:00:05 So we also have banks lined up for... Still in US dollar. We'll keep that one in USD as well. The reason for the three is because anything for those in fixed income, anything less than three is very difficult to market and get traded. And it doesn't come onto any indices. So we have to keep that 300 minimum level and it'll be in USD. Now, by the time we're done in 2023, So in 2030, with the final 300 coming, that final 300 coming in 2030, we will be repaying that off fully. So our exposure goes from 996 today down to 600. So that's the glide path. We don't want to go to zero debt because we actually get a very good return on this capital.
1:00:57 All right. Thanks. Thanks, Richard. Thanks, Hazel. That's all for me. Thank you. Maybe just to wrap it up, Richard, since we're running out of time, last question via email. What challenges do you foresee in the coming quarter? What's the biggest cost challenge for Jollibee? You came up with very good results. For the next quarter, is there anything that keeps you awake at night?
1:01:22 There's a lot of stuff that keeps me awake at night. I guess if I step back, I go back to that NOI bridge chart where I spend a little bit of time walking through. We created 1.4 billion of NOI from our existing business in one quarter, incremental, versus a billion in the year before. So I guess what I need to make sure that the investment community understands is that is there a sustainable growth business? Are we growing? And not just be, I guess, stuck at looking at percentages. The word flat gets me a little bit uneasy because I don't feel we have a flat business. In addition, we've also taken on quite a bit of a hit in China. As you saw, the EBITDA in Q2 versus the EBITDA, negative EBITDA in Q3, that swing is almost half a billion pesos.
1:02:21 So we've taken on, you know, not making money, but also losing money. We've taken that hit on. So if you add all that up, actually our normalized growth instead of 15% will be something like 37% if you adjust for getting China right. So I think that's what we're going to focus. As always, we always focus on a growth engine, Jollibee, and we always focus on those that sort of pulling things down a little bit, which at the moment is a China business. thank you very much Richard so with that we end this session on Jollibee Foods and we thank you Richard we thank you Cosette for sharing your views and thoughts today and for answering all of our difficult questions so to all the participants thank you also for joining us so if you have further questions please do send us an email or Richard or Cosette they'll answer it for you so take care and you may now disconnect thank you very much everyone thank you bye
Follow Jollibee Foods Corp. into a list and get an email when it puts out news.
Chief Financial Officer, Jollibee Foods Corporation
Analyst
Investor Relations, Jollibee Foods Corporation