Automated transcript · Written by software from the replay's audio. It can mishear names and figures; the replay is the record.
25:01 Now I think overall extractives, we cannot separate that, because in the mindset of Mexico, Mexico has been an extractive industry oriented. It's oil and gas, and mining goes together. And it's part of their history. You cannot separate that. You have regions, like Zacatecas, with more than 500 years mining tradition, non-stopping operations. So it is in the mind. One thing that it is critically important in terms of also talking about mining is that the challenges in agriculture in Mexico makes communities and makes the region appreciate mining because they understand risk. And they understand when an exploration company comes and it could be or could not be. And that is an element that, once again, goes into what is doing business in Mexico is that that piece of risk they understand.
25:48 And not many jurisdictions in Latin America understand risks as Mexicans do. And so that is a key element when you are running an operation in Mexico and they appreciate a healthy mining activity in their time. Yeah, I guess I'll go slightly off on a tangent and say it's quite funny, because right now precious metals seems to be in this battle with crypto, and gold is seen as archaic and everything else. And there is a point to this. But actually I love that history. And I think that history is personified in a country like Mexico. I think the first time I went and visited a project in Mexico was in Durango. And it was never something that a modern public Canadian company could ever have mined and made money on. But the history was there to be seen.
26:43 The old workings, narrow high grade veins And the very town that we stayed in was built around the wealth generated hundreds of years before from these silver veins. So even though it wasn't something that a modern Canadian company could do, you know, the very history and the generations that probably through families, you know, were involved in mining and everything else. There's something really that's wonderful to embrace about that part of operating in a country with such a really a storied history in metals production and I you know it's everywhere you look. Yeah absolutely and Doug before we even came online we were having a bit of a discussion about how Mexico is ranked as a jurisdiction, North America and the world. And I was wondering if you'd be willing to come back around to that conversation again and hear from the panel about how you think Mexico does compare, how it should compare.
27:55 Yeah, I mean, I look at the Fraser Institute rankings somewhat with a bit of a grain of salt, because to me, I think it's less important whether you're a number 123, or 10 spot, or whether you can actually really operate and build in a country in a timely manner because that's what your investors are going to want, that's what the communities are going to want. So you know what Mexico offers is a very good permitting framework which is beneficial for yes all manner of stakeholders from the investor through to the communities. And Mexico does rank high in those Fraser rankings relative to Central and South America.
28:46 However, I still also think that it should be treated like Fraser Institute does Argentina, where because there are certain provinces and states of Argentina which are completely anti-mining, they kind of break Argentina out. And I think Mexico is a diverse country in terms of where 1 operates. The types of mines that we would build in northern Mexico, We couldn't build the same way in southern Mexico. You need a certain scale down there because there's certain additional security impacts that need to be taken into account that I think a smaller scale operation that can grow out of that smaller scale to something larger would struggle with it in the south. So that's why I always say that you know we are very happy in the north of the country but we probably wouldn't operate in the south of the country. We'll leave that to people that are more seasoned in operating down there and understand. And this gets back to having teams and having operational experience and Mexican nationals that know exactly how to operate in these different parts of the country. So, when it comes to the Fraser Institute rankings, I don't care how high up Finland or Sweden is, you know, relative to Mexico, I think it's important for all stakeholders to actually be where you can build
30:18 and add value in the exploitation of a country's natural resources for all. Yeah, I mean, one thing is when you just say that there are 2 Mexicos, I totally agree with you. And the point is that we have, no, we cannot separate Mexico from the reality of Latin America. And that's how the Mexico is basically dealing with the challenges of what is happening in Central America. And the cases of it in a lot of issues around indigenous territories and indigenous peoples and a lot of what is happening with the massive migration coming from the south. And for a mining company is a very center in going for an operation like that. That it is a great deal of social phenomena happening in the South that distract the activities and the efforts that should be happening. And The north of Mexico is a mining town in general. They understand the industry and minerally. I mean, you guys know more than me on this, geologists and mine engineers.
31:28 So I was wondering if maybe while we figure out if Monica can get brought back on, if you could take over from there. Important activity happening. Sorry, we lost you there for a moment. I have 2 points. One is about the comment about the Fraser Institute. It's a valuable piece of statistics to understand what's going on and sentiment of the investment community all over the planet. But in some ways can be biased about who is attending the survey. Sometimes I wonder how many nationals were assessed in that survey, because when you have companies like Grupo Mexico, Penoles, Fresnillo, operating for decades, almost a century in the country, They are the full history of mining in this country. How many of their top executives have been approached, or the diversity of the interviews.
32:26 That's the only thing I want to say. But the other point is, Monica Milakon, that's very important because it's part of the social license, the ESG indigenous community. And we need to recognize and we need to respect that Mexico has been in place for thousands of years, even before the Spanish arrived here. There's a history. Even though some states do not have the occupancy of these indigenous, there's some historical traces. This needs to be taken into account. What is very important here about this point about indigenous communities, probably have 3 or 4, I would say 4, clusters of mining in Mexico. Sonora, Chihuahua, let me, Nayarit, not much, Durango, Tinaloa is becoming.
33:17 Most of the indigenous communities where areas that must be protected in some way are more to the south of Mexico. And the geology of Mexico is really well in these 4 clusters. So there's plenty of space for mining companies to invest, explore, develop, and build mines in these clusters without even touching areas that can be occupied by indigenous communities, in my opinion? Absolutely. I think we've been kind of talking about this the entire time. But I think it'd be important for the panel to share their views on what factors they think that make junior mining companies successful in Mexico. Monica, maybe you could share some of your key points, your key thoughts on that. Well, I think that number 1 is a friendly jurisdiction to start exploration.
34:05 As I mentioned before, and I'm sure my colleagues in the panel will agree, that it's doable. It is – the work in there is doable. It's possible for a junior mining company to start their work in Mexico. The permitting process is straight. I know it is complicated as everything in the permitting process is not easy, but it's a straight line somehow. And there is a step by step that has to be followed. So you can jump in that. Concessions are not easy to say and Marcio said beautifully within his introduction, like you are, I mean you really work really hard to get those concessions happening and that and even more in the government like the government that we are living right now, but it is, it is, and somehow it's manageable. And you, as a junior company, you will know what is the next step.
34:56 And this is when you just look at Mexico and the entire picture of Latin America, you compare with other jurisdictions. It will be much more advanced in understanding the industry, much more advanced in understanding the next steps of what is expected from a junior mining company than other countries in Latin America. Communities are familiar with risk and they are familiar with mineral activities. So it is in the engagement process is manageable. And I think that this is a healthy environment. And at the same time, Mexico as a country itself is a stable economy. It has its batches, ups and downs, all the countries in the world are living that. But at least it's a safe jurisdiction without seeing on the private sector, which it just reduces the risk for a junior mining operation starting, and obviously becomes bigger when exploration is successful and can pass the torch to a developer.
35:48 So I think it's a very healthy decision for mining. And on the other hand, in terms of comparing Mexico with the rest of Latin America, the opportunities for Canadian companies in Mexico through the trade agreement and in collaboration with Canada and Mexico is very strong and that helps a lot to work in Mexico for Canadians. Doug, Marcio, do either of you want to share? You didn't leave as much there, I'd say, Monica. Oh, come on. Do you have more experience than me? No, but I mean, it's true. There's a rule of law, there's a structure to permitting. There's an acceptance of mining, a history there. I mean, I think you covered it better than I've ever done when I've listed off everything before and a few other ones on top. I throw in also, I mean, we're a slightly bigger company, so maybe it wouldn't matter, but I love the fact that operating in in Mexico I'm working on the same time zone as my colleagues down there.
36:57 Logistically from that perspective that's less about the country you know itself over over the logistics of operating a company. But I know when I started my career in the UK, I'd work 80 hour weeks purely as a function of time zone difference between me and Vancouver. You know, now everyone's on the same, yeah I know, I don't relish ever doing that again. But so, you know, when running a company efficiently and wanting to have communications, everything, even something as simple as being in a in a nice time zone That that's cooperative is actually important because sometimes problems can arise You know in in Africa that 12 hours later you're hearing about, because just because you've been sleeping through the night or whatever it might be, there's nothing that you're gonna miss that way.
37:55 So I mean, that's literally the only thing I feel that I, as you rattled off everything else, I could add to that. So that was a fantastic response, Monica. Thank you. Thank you. I mean the time zone is good. I mean sounds simple but it's critically important. Even the fact that you can travel right away, no? You can be on site like this, it really becomes amazing. That's a good point. Thank you, Doug. Marcio, do you think that there's anything that we haven't covered? No, pretty much covered, but just to highlight that one thing that I always tell investors and I believe is very important, maybe Monica and Doug mentioned briefly, is Mexico being signatory of the free trade agreement with Canada and US is a major thing.
38:43 Most of the countries which can be ranked even above Mexico in attractiveness for mine investors do not have this special treatment. Yeah, the rule of law, there's a hard and strong document there that people derives. So that's something that gives me as investor, as a mine builder developer, very comfortable to really be here as well. Fair enough. Thanks for that, everyone. And as we kind of wrap up this conversation before we enter the Q&A, I'm wondering what the panel thinks investors should be most excited about for Mexico going forwards in the future. Marcio, I'm going to go right back to you. What's exciting? What's coming up? Okay, I'll make sure I leave a little bit for all the other panelists here.
39:34 That's sweet. That's sweet. Just as a background, I'm Brazilian. Some people think I'm Mexican. I'm not Mexican. And I'm Canadian, living in Vancouver, geology engineer. But why Mexico drove my attention when the first time I came here in 2003, how the geology is so prospective is a wealth geology. Although there's a history of mining, there's still plenty of areas to be explored, to be developed, to discover deposits, different sizes, different economics, and how the society, the mining society in the country is vibrant, is very integrated, and because mine has been part of the history of the country. That gave me always such a level of comfort to be an investor, to be operating here. And language is not a barrier, but helps.
40:21 No, but thinking about a country, the proximity with the capital markets, very couple of hours to Toronto and Vancouver, that helps. And how the system has worked for the last 20 years, 30 years, mining, coal, environmental legislation, everything makes very important for me as investor and shareholder as well to be in Mexico, comparing with other countries, particularly in Latin America. That's great, thank you. Monica, what's exciting coming up in Mexico, in your opinion? Well, Marcio, you did very well here and just leave little things. And, Doc, I hope I leave room for that. So I think that I think as an investor, if I'm an investor, I would like stability in a country that we can continue and kind of knowing that the operation is moving.
41:12 And I think that the rule of law is there, as we saw before, the permitting process is stable in terms of it is a step by step process. So I can understand what the companies are going through and when the reports come and the press releases come about the process, I can kind of rely That the government is already organizing their approach and sadly in Latin America not many countries are organizing their approach. From the concessions to the permanent and monitoring how the operation is going. I think that is critical for investors to be aware of what is happening out of what operation it is. The other piece that I will see as an investor, Marcio is saying very, very well, is that when you go for a drilling campaign in Mexico and you have a very good team of geologists working with you, it is a big chance that you can develop an opportunity in Mexico.
42:03 The other piece that is important is that Mexico understand extractive industry. And the dynamic of extractives is very different than any other industry. And that's what probably makes investors that are not familiar with mining a little bit conscious about why I'm going for a junior exploration company that obviously is not profits at any time versus a manufacturing process. So it is important because Mexico understands that. And it's not easy for a country to understand that. If you compare to countries that have great potential in terms of geology like Colombia, and well, forget Venezuela with all the political issues, but they have it, it is very difficult for a junior company to be successful in the short term and show results. And it's not because of lack of capacity of the technical team. It's because the political environment and the conditions in the countries are making it very difficult to complete permitting and to complete the process in an organized, a step-by-step way.
43:00 The other thing that I will say is that yes, there's this content like any country in the world with the government and people might disagree or agree, but you don't see a stop of operations in a country or you don't see a massive revolution or you don't see things happening like that. And somehow Mexicans are also aware that they want to protect the industries that are providing for their families. And we are an industry providing for their families. So they will take care of that too. These agreements, yes, anti-mining groups all around the world. But when you just go to what is the daily operations you see, you see that communities are backing up that. And the best part is that they're backing up Canadian operations. Canadian operations are very welcome by communities and the investor should be aware that a Canadian operation going to Mexico, it is a good combination and a good match and I will put my money on that.
43:52 Well I've got one thing that you didn't cover. Oh great! I think what Mexico actually allows, if there's the desire for companies to do so. I'm not going to get on my soapbox, but I think we have an industry that focuses so much on the front peak of the Lasonga. And Mexico can provide great discovery potential there because it's geologically, whilst it's got a storied history, there are plenty of discoveries to be made or in in the case of discovery often is come you know assets that go through multi generations of ownership each each generation providing more data to help the next one. But everything about Mexico as a jurisdiction actually gives those those companies working on the front end of the Lusanka, the opportunity and the environment and the jurisdiction and the regulatory environment and the workforce and the hospitality towards Canadian mining companies to actually make that journey to being a producer, which I think from an investor's point of perspective and trying to galvanize interest in a story, there's no better differentiator.
45:09 And everything we're talking about with ESG, the best way to really make an impact is to be in a jurisdiction where you can actually go the whole path of the Lassonde curve, because it's that back end of the Lassonde curve where you can really add value to your stakeholders. And that, I think that we have a fantastic opportunity when running companies to absolutely make a difference in our shareholders' lives, but equally importantly, make a difference in so many people's lives that will never own a share in their life in anything, but in many ways have become a direct stakeholder, shareholder in a collective operation that you can do in Mexico. And I think that to me is something which has made my experiences of operating down in Mexico something where I really feel there's that ability to enrich so many people at different layers of society and yeah Mexico offers that so I think Mexico can have a very bright future you know because it is fortunately endowed with so many things which make it a perfect country to operate in. And yes, as Monica mentioned, it absolutely has its issues.
46:39 Every country does. You know, I've been asked recently, it's like, well, are they going to play with the royalty rates there again. It's like I think every country, Canada, the US, you know, like in the past, you know, it would be West Africa and Latin America that in rising metals prices, the governments would want a little bit of a take, extra take, and you'd see those changes made. I think coming out of COVID, coming out of this pandemic, every single jurisdiction, so it's an even playing field in that regard. Would Mexico change their lottery rates? Conceivably. We're already seeing it at the state level in Nevada. It's being voiced at the federal level in the states. I'm sure that the mining sector in booming commodity times in Canada will be equally susceptible to just a little bit more of a tax grab.
47:32 You know that's that's no bad thing. And in a time of rising metal prices there should be more than enough to go around. You know. So. So yeah Mexico has its has its issues but there are many many ways to to deal with those in a responsible manner. I think it offers far more benefits than any of the kind of Bloomberg headlines that you click bait into that are often thrown up on Twitter or whatever. There's so much undiscovered benefits of operating in Mexico. Thank you for that, Doug. With the time we have remaining, I think we're going to start addressing some of the questions that have been coming in live from the audience. And very neatly, dovetailing out of what you were just speaking about, Doug Keenan, the audience asks this, some critics of mining investment in Mexico claim that taxation environment has become unwieldy and unpredictable.
48:31 And what are your thoughts, what are the panel's thoughts, if anyone wants to leap in? Well I mean there have been changes to it and I'm sure there are going to be future changes to it. But I don't think it's going to be any different. Maybe if it was just a time of rising metal prices it would be, but I think post-pandemic we're going to see lots of tax changes at all levels of industry and provincial, state, governments in whichever country you want to throw a dart at. So, you know, is it important to have a stable environment in that regard for planning purposes? Absolutely. I think we're into a very strange time in the world right now where, you know, I hate to say it, but in the last 18 months, I've hated using this word fluid in my vocabulary as much as I have, because we live in very fluid times, And that doesn't necessarily make it easy for planning.
49:34 But is Mexico going to be any different than most other countries out there? I don't think so. That's my take on it. I would like just to add one comment to Doug. I completely agree the environment is changing, but it's changing all over the planet. To address all the money that was deployed to address all the shortages and issues, something we need to help happen in every country in the planet, not only Mexico. And I find that's important for us as executives, as investors, as managers, to have that in mind when you go and explore, discover, delineate that in modern nature you need to provide something a little bit better to cope with the potential additional taxes to provide better return to the communities and the government to overcome the issues.
50:26 The SDA is going to be part of the role. The feasibility of future deposits might or might not need to take that into account. And I think 1 point that we cannot discard is that worldwide after COVID, the developing world, and Mexico is part of the developing world, not in the extreme but in other countries, it just creates a crisis in terms of the countries managing their capacity to meet the needs of others. And obviously, taxation to the private sector is the shortcut for them to find the imbalances. So it's not a reality only in Mexico. We're going to see that worldwide as that was being pointed and right now even more and even more when we are dealing with a government that is going on the social angle is that cost and that is expected.
51:15 Is it going to be forever? I don't think so, because they need investment as much as the communities need the opportunities and employment that is happening. So that will be the opportunity also to balance that. But it is expected worldwide. I won't say it's only Mexico, just to be fair. Right. This next question from Howard in the audience was asked of you specifically, Doug, but I think that we can kind of go around the horn going over it, but Doug, could you describe the status of your ramp-up of production? And what's next for you in 2022? Yeah, well, RAMPUP is going well. There'll be news out shortly, so for full disclosure and proper dissemination I won't talk too much about it, except to say that a typical open pit heat leap that our team have built in the past, you look at about 6 months before it starts kicking off net cash at the operations level. If we can achieve that by, you know, within that 6 months, then I will consider it a very successful ramp up of operations, especially during the current environment. And then we certainly seem on track for that. So as far as 2022, well, this wonderful permitting environment that we've talked about, we will be engaging in that again with what will be our second mine we plan to build.
52:41 So maybe we check back in a year's time and I'll tell you how that went relative to what I said the permitting environment was like in Mexico, but we've had 2 permits that have been awarded, 2 final EIAs that have come from the AMLO government. So a lot of things you hear about on Reuters or Bloomberg don't necessarily portray an accurate picture of the permitting environment in Mexico. We've permitted 2 with sign off from the current government. So, very happy to continue working with them in that regard. Thanks for that, Doug. Monica, what's coming up for Monarca in 2022? Well, we are juniors, so we are not like these 2 big guys here. So we are going for drilling and exploration in the north in San Jose. It looks very promising, I must say.
53:30 The results are starting kind of something when geology gets excited, everybody in the team gets excited. So that is what is happening at the Interior of Monarca. We hope that we can go further with the results from San Jose. Things goes well. We have Tejamen as one of our jewels that has been sleeping, it's sleeping beautifully for a long time. So we hope that we can restart the dialogue around what could be Tehamen. But right now, San Jose is offering quite promising future for Monarch. Thank you. That sounds great. And Marcio, what's 2022 hold? For sure. It's going to be continuation of the 2021 post consolidation, successful consolidation of the district. Now we have access to these 24 veins and with all the 7 drill rigs we continue to drill more and expansion of the resources.
54:25 Because our vision is to create a large deposit of eventual ounces in the company, 100% controlled by the company. Okay, great. Well, listen, I want to first and foremost, thank you, Doug, Monica, Marcio for coming on today. But I also of course, wish to extend my gratitude to everyone in the audience for coming on today. If you didn't get a chance to have your question answered or if you think of 1 after the summit, we're going to be sending out short surveys where you can leave your contact information and you can get into direct contact with any of the companies represented here. With that, though, I'd like to go around the room 1 last time and hear some closing remarks from each of our panelists before we close up shop for the day. Marcio, could you start us off? Sure. Of course, again, thank you for the opportunity and thank you for the panelists to a very intensive discussion and presentation here today.
55:19 My final remark is Mexico, mining country, like any Latin American country, we have cycles of instability, political instability, has been the history of these countries for 200 years or more, And that might create some anxiety and nervousness in the audience, in the public, investors. But it's a very stable country from a mining perspective and a wealthy country from a geological exploration perspective as well. Thank you. Monica? Well, thank you very much for the opportunity. This is even fantastic to be with Doc and Marcio with big operations and successful in Mexico. As a junior mining company, we are very, very excited about what is coming in the future. We strongly believe that the North of Mexico it is a great place for mining and exploration and we really hope that investors start taking this opportunities that all of us we're pulling together as an opportunity to build a solid portfolio.
56:21 Again, what Doug says about cryptocurrencies, I think it's still in the world we need to have gold and silver in the back, just for whatever comes around. So thank you for that. Absolutely, and Doug, you want to finish this off? Yeah, I want to thank, yeah, a really fascinating conversation with Monica and Marcio. And also thank the audience for attending because in many ways you know whether you're attending because you follow our companies or you you have an interest in Mexico well you know good I think it's a country that's worth being interested in. I hope what we've discussed today has helped you with kind of framing the country and the opportunities it presents. And it's incumbent on people such as us to now follow through on demonstrating that through what we do at the company level.
57:21 I can honestly say, and I've been involved with projects in all manner of countries over my 26 year career. The last 3 years of working with our team, with what we're doing in Mexico, and it's largely to do with the benefits of operating in this jurisdiction have been absolutely hands down the best 3 years of my career and long may that continue. So yeah I mean thank you for really entertaining for me at least and hopefully the audience conversation today and Yeah, that's that's about it Great. Well again, I want to thank you all for coming on today. But with that, we are going to unfortunately wrap this conversation up and I hope you all each have a good rest of your day.
58:08 This panel will be recorded and will be available as an on-demand video in the coming days, so you have a lot to look forward to. Thanks again everyone and Cheers. Thank you. Thank you guys. Thank you, Ken. Thank you, Marcio and Doug. Really nice. Yeah. Bye.