AMERICAN EAGLE ENERGY — Debt Investor Presentation (May 2015)
26 slides from AMERICAN EAGLE ENERGY's debt investor presentation, May 12, 2015

Slide 1: Noteholder Presentation
American Eagle Energy American Eagle Energy Corp. (NYSE MKT: AMZG) Noteholder Presentation March 24, 2015

Slide 2: Table of Contents
ba ener Prepared ot the Deeton of Count Fee Setement Paposes Ory» Scjet 1 FRE 408 TABLE OF CONTENTS A. Introduction 8. Business Overview C. Financial Overview D. Bondholder Requested & Hypothetical Scenarios American Eagle

Slide 3: Statement of Limiting Conditions
happend Prepred ot the Devon of Counse Foe Settlement Paroses On = Sabet to FRE 46 STATEMENT OF LIMITING CONDITIONS ‘he contest and ales cota heen ae property of Amen age Lardy Corporation he “Comoan and mayne be coped ected whut he egress consent fhe Compiny By eur rece and review ofthe mater, You

Slide 4: Forward Looking Information
happend Prepred ot the Devon of Counse Foe Settlement Paroses On = Sabet to FRE 46 FORWARD LOOKING INFORMATION ‘Th resentation contains orear toon statements wen the mea fSction 27Ao the Secures At of 133, a5 amended (th “Series A nd Sction 21E of the Seer xchange AC of 1934, as amended (he “achnge

Slide 5: A. Introduction
“Se AMERICAN EAGLE ENERGY

Slide 6: Highly-Experienced Management Team
HIGHLY-EXPERIENCED MANAGEMENT TEAM hop eer Prepared ot the Deeton of Count Fee SetementParposes Only = Set FRE 408 Management and Technical Team Ss Pp ==_Z— S&S Brad Colby President and Chief Executive Officer 30+ years experience: tote — [Gramnonnes Ss cw | ewe om Kirk Stingley Steve Dilé fi chard

Slide 7: Transformation into a Leading Williston Basin Operator
hoger meer Prepared the Ovecton of Couns TRANSFORMATION INTO A LEADING WILLISTON BASIN OPERATOR ‘August 2014 $175 million senior secured notes issuance: ~ Refinance of Morgan Stanley credit facility ~ Net proceeds after debt refinance, fees, interest and hedge loss of $39.9 million Working capital d

Slide 8: WTI Crude Oil & Peer Share Price Index Pricing Chart
ba ener Prepared ot the Deeton of Count Fee SetementParposes Only = Set FRE 408 WTI CRUDE Olt & PEER SHARE PRICE INDEX PRICING CHART Current ATM High ATM Low $110 - $90 110 4 wo Ss & s 3 5 $60 ne « : $40 = = > cS > cS cS = ° ? ° es ‘2 i rn ar eee SF KK KF KF SK K SK wii crude ol ~~ —= AMZG Peer Grou

Slide 9: Stock & Bond Pricing Chart
hop eer Prepared ot the Deeton of Count Fee Setement Paposes Ory» Scjet 1 FRE 408 STOCK & BOND PRICING CHART 11% Senior Notes 2019 AM2G Share Price $10 $100 $8 $80 re. 2018 ‘arate , £% cagpiwes| 86° 3 $a so & Jar 3.208 Oxcember 1,208 Jones 2013 Rsene Specs 18 Jeaect 358 : coca tg btn $2 fuga, 2041 $

Slide 10: B. Business Overview
B. Business Overview:~ “ae AMERICAN EAGLE ENERGY

Slide 11: Reserve Summary - SEC Pricing
hope ruck Prepared ot te Deeton of Counse Fe SetementParposes Only = Sabet FRE 408 Reserve SUMMARY — SEC PRICING Reserves Overview = Total 1P reserves of 15.5 Mmboe with a PV-10 of $277 million by December 31, 2014 based on SEC pricing Net Proved Reserves as of December 31, 2014 oir Gas Total Pv-10

Slide 12: Reserve Summary - Recent Oil Prices
hee paiinae Prepared ot the Deeton of Course For Setement Purposes Onl = Sabet 1 FRE 408 Reserve SUMMARY — RECENT OIL PRICES Reserves Overview Total 1P reserves of 8.9 Mmboe with a PV-10 of $102 million estimated as of January 31, 2015, based on recent oil pricing of sail Net Proved Reserves as of J

Slide 13: Reconciliation of BOE
hop eer Prepared ot the Deeton of Count Fee SetementParposes Only = Set FRE 408 RECONCILIATION OF BOE Reserves Rollforward (BOE Basis) SEC Pricing a Oil Gas Total (Mbbls) (Mmef) (Mboe) Proved Reserves at 12/31/2013 12,109 8,652 13,550 Revisions (2,430) (1,423) (2,667) Extensions & Discoveries 3,861

Slide 14: Operated Well Results
OPERATED WELL RESULTS 22 Wells Average 7 Wells Average 12 Wells Average” 3 Wells Average ” Three Forks Avg. Daly Rates (BOE) 1Year 30 6090 Sori Critone (eel) S-1 Geerge wep ome wet rope oe _wet get Se Teo Shey yon wero tnen ‘ales emaina Compton [28 Nov bree) Tee foe mr SS TO. Ovon(Pwalipn)_ tlten Da

Slide 15: Three Forks and Bakken Well Economics Overview (Ryder Scott)
Coren Prepared he Direction of Course fer Setdement Purposes Only ~ Sabet 1 FRE 40 THREE FORKS AND BAKKEN WELL ECONOMICS Overview (RYDER SCOTT) Ryder Scott Assumption Implications“ Long Lateral Ryder Scott Type Curve a = 30% IRR = 23% IRR = 32month payback = 38 month payback = $2.8MM per well PV-10

Slide 16: Three Forks Well Economics Sensitivity (Management Estimates)
ape-eceer Prepored at he Orecton of Coons For Setement Parnes Only ~ Sect 1 FRE 40 THREE FORKS WELL ECONOMICS SENSITIVITY (MANAGEMENT ESTIMATES) Three Forks Well IRR Sensitivity Three Forks Well Economics) SS9NMONC | $50MMCWC | $8.5 MMCWC American Eagle Hanmeowe 2% com" meme _ 88 65 7s 385 so uno Th

Slide 17: C. Financial Overview
C=Financial Overview "SpE AMERICAN EAGLE

Slide 18: Cost Reduction Initiatives
dopa Prepared ot the Dvection of Couns For Setdement Parpones On ~ Subject 10 FRE 40 Cost REDUCTION INITIATIVES Well Development and Infrastructure Improvements Hypothetical Cost Structure 2015 Well Development Plan = Modest CopEx for growing production with reduced well costs = No material CapEx is

Slide 19: Cash Flow Reconciliation
Cash FLOW RECONCILIATION Conpientian Prepared at the Direction of Counte For Setement Purposes Only ~ Subject to FRE 408 Revenue Production Expenses (LOE) Production Taxes (Severance Tax) {GBA Expense -Excusing Share-based Comp, Realized Gain (Los) on Derivatives es1ToA Capital Expenditure - Operate

Slide 20: Working Capital Overview
Cont Prepared ot the Deeton of Count Fee SetementParposes Only = Set FRE 408 WORKING CAPITAL OVERVIEW 6/30/2014] 12/31/2014 2/28/2015} $22.2 $25.9 $19.0 Accounts Receivable $21.2 $95 SuL7 Total Current Assets $43.4 $35.5 $31.0 Vendor Payables & Accruals $53.6 $32.5 $24.0 Royalties & Revenues Payable

Slide 21: D. Bondholder Requested & Hypothetical Scenarios
“Se AMERICAN EAGLE ENERGY

Slide 22: Liquidity Summary - Status Quo
LiquiDiTy SUMMARY — STATUS QUO ba ener Prepared ot the Deeton of Count Fee SetementParposes Only = Set FRE 408 = Assumptions: No new capital; no CapEx; interest payment made in March Accounts Receivable ‘Changes in Vendor Payables & Accruals (1.9) (2.3) (0.8) Changes in Royalties & Revenues Payable

Slide 23: Operating Summary - Illustrative Hypothetical Scenario 1
ba ener Prepared ot the Deeton of Count OPERATING SUMMARY — ILLUSTRATIVE HYPOTHETICAL SCENARIO 1 = ~S5.MM Capéx in 2015 for the Shelley Lynn and Byron well completions; no drilling CapEx in 2016 & beyond [Operating Metrics Summary Fens xcept pe poston ct) Spralas- Operated - Gross Wells riled Sprala

Slide 24: Operating Summary - Illustrative Hypothetical Scenario 2
ba ener Prepared ot the Deeton of Count OPERATING SUMMARY — ILLUSTRATIVE HYPOTHETICAL SCENARIO 2 = Minimal CopEx to maintain flat production [Operating Metrics Summary 20138 20148 2015¢ 2016€ Foon xcept er aston ke St) Spralass- Operated - Gross Wels riled Spyglass - Operated - Net Wells Celle ‘Aver

Slide 25: Operating Summary - Illustrative Hypothetical Scenario 3
ba ener Prepared ot the Deeton of Count OPERATING SUMMARY — ILLUSTRATIVE HYPOTHETICAL SCENARIO 3 = Modest CapEx for growing production with reduced welll costs and enhanced production [Operating Metrics Summary 2013A 20188 2015€ 2016€ 20176 Fomor except per natn ee 3), Spralass - Operated - Gross We

Slide 26: Spyglass Project Operating Area
SPYGLASS PROJECT OPERATING AREA = A majority of the Company's wells target the Bakken and Three Forks formations By 2 S a <= = S Zz 163N 103W = er air American Eagle @ Bakken Wells @ Three Forks Wells
Source: SEC EDGAR · 8-K filed May 12, 2015



