Transatlantic — Merger or Acquisition (September 2011)
31 slides from Transatlantic's merger presentation, Sep 8, 2011

Slide 1: Investor presentation September 2011
Investor presentation September 2011

Slide 2: Forward-looking statements
This presentation contains forward-looking statements that involve a number of risks and uncertainties. Statements that are not historical facts, including statements about our beliefs and expectations, are forward-looking statements. Any forward-looking statements made in this presentation reflect

Slide 3: Strategic rationale: TransAllied merger delivers superior intrinsic and long-term value
Strategic rationale: TransAllied merger delivers superior "intrinsic" and long-term value Section 1 Strategic rationale: TransAllied merger delivers superior "intrinsic" and long-term value Berkshire's offer cements discount for TRH shareholders AWH offers superior currency versus Validus Process co

Slide 4: The TransAllied merger is the superior combination
The TransAllied merger is the superior combination Industry leading management team Industry leading management team Superb specialty franchise with direct insurance distribution Well-respected property catastrophe / short-tail lines and long-tail reinsurance capabilities Ratings: A / A / A2(1) Rati

Slide 5: The TransAllied merger is the superior combination (continued)
The TransAllied merger is the superior combination (continued) Validus unsolicited conditional takeover proposal High personnel flight risk and loss of talent Inefficient overlap in property cat books Increase in risk profile, limiting growth opportunities and potentially leading to lower ratings Ri

Slide 6: Stronger credit profile and risk management potentially leading to higher pro forma ratings
Stronger credit profile and risk management potentially leading to higher pro forma ratings TransAllied will be more diversified and considerably less exposed to catastrophe losses (1) Based on ending Total Shareholders' Equity for the period prior to occurrence. Source: SNL Financial, Company filin

Slide 7: Stronger credit profile and risk management (continued)
Stronger credit profile and risk management potentially leading to higher pro forma ratings (continued) Note: Combination of AWH or VR wind occurrence, respectively, and TRH Florida wind 1:250 PMLs, as a percentage of equity, without accounting for overlap. After-tax rates for TransAllied, VR and TR

Slide 8: Stronger credit profile and risk management (continued)
Stronger credit profile and risk management potentially leading to higher pro forma ratings (continued) Financial Strength Ratings Financial Strength Ratings Financial Strength Ratings Financial Strength Ratings Financial Strength Ratings Agency reactions Agency reactions Agency reactions TRH AWH VR

Slide 9: Street recognizes TransAllied transaction merits
Street recognizes TransAllied transaction merits vs. questionable logic and deal certainty "This deal makes sense in our view... The deal provides a platform and better balance by product, geography and long- and short-tail lines. While neither player was large in property-CAT, the combined entity s

Slide 10: TransAllied merger terms are fair to both AWH and TRH shareholders
TransAllied merger terms are fair to both AWH and TRH shareholders User XP ID(login name): darojas File Path: NOT SAVED File name: NOT SAVED XL Sheet name: NOT SAVED Time Stamp: 8/21/2011 4:53:39 PM User XP ID(login name): darojas File Path: NOT SAVED File name: NOT SAVED XL Sheet name: NOT SAVED Ti

Slide 11: Allied World shareholders are more supportive
Allied World shareholders are more supportive AWH Note: Market data as of 9/2/2011. Percentages represent share price performance. Source: Capital IQ VR In our opinion, trading in AWH shares upon announcement of the TransAllied merger, as compared to trading in VR shares upon announcement of VR's ac

Slide 12: Shrinking VR premium over TransAllied terms
Shrinking VR premium over TransAllied terms Note: Based on current stock price which does not include full value of synergies and earnings to close. Source: Capital IQ

Slide 13: TransAllied's definitive merger agreement vs. unsolicited takeover proposals
TransAllied's definitive merger agreement vs. unsolicited takeover proposals Unsolicited conditional takeover proposals Fair economics with exchange ratio based on premium to book-for-book exchange ratio, which is industry standard Opportunistic attempt to acquire TRH at a double-digit discount to b

Slide 14: Allied World terms are fair to all shareholders
Allied World terms are fair to all shareholders, while VR and Berkshire are trying to acquire TRH opportunistically at a discount AWH VR Berkshire Offer terms 0.8800x AWH shares 1.5564x VR shares + $8.00 cash $52.00 in cash vs Q1 book-for-book value(a) 0.8610x 2.2% premium to TRH 1.7915x(b) (13.1%)

Slide 15: TransAllied delivers superior intrinsic value (basic shares)
TransAllied delivers superior "intrinsic value" to unsolicited takeover proposals (based on basic shares) TransAllied announced synergy value exclusive of any revenue synergies and incremental excess capital upside (a) Q2 basic pro forma book value per share as per respective S-4 filings. (b) Based

Slide 16: TransAllied delivers superior intrinsic value (fully diluted shares)
TransAllied delivers superior "intrinsic value" to unsolicited takeover proposals (based on fully diluted shares) TransAllied announced synergy value exclusive of any revenue synergies and incremental excess capital upside (a) Q2 fully diluted pro forma book value per share based on Treasury Stock M

Slide 17: Conservative synergies worth $3.78 to $6.81 per share
Conservative synergies worth $3.78 to $6.81(a) per share excluding any revenue synergies and incremental excess capital upside Validus Expanded global network and infrastructure creates additional future growth opportunities and enhanced earnings potential Minimal business overlap and meaningful bus

Slide 18: Implied offer value comparison
Implied offer value comparison Implied by current peer multiples (9/2)(a) Implied current market valuation (9/2) Implied by 1 year average P/B(b) Implied by average P/B since respective IPOs(c) Note: Q4E'11 book values per share calculated based on 2Q'11 actuals and earnings and dividends per share

Slide 19: Implied offer value comparison (continued)
Implied offer value comparison (continued) Implied by current tangible peer multiples (9/2)(a) Implied by average P/TB since respective IPOs(c) Implied by 1 year average P/TB(b) Implied current market valuation (9/2) Note: Q4E'11 book values per share calculated based on 2Q'11 actuals and earnings a

Slide 20: Berkshire's offer cements discount for TRH shareholders
Berkshire's offer cements discount FOR Trh SHAREHOLDERS Section 2 Strategic rationale: TransAllied merger delivers superior ''intrinsic'' and long-term value Berkshire's offer cements discount for TRH shareholders AWH offers superior currency versus Validus Process considerations ?

Slide 21: Lower Berkshire cash premium relative to market norm
Lower Berkshire cash premium relative to market norm Median 52-week premia over time (annual) Median 52-week premia over time (quarterly) Note: Includes all-cash consideration M&A transactions with US targets over $500mm. Excludes transactions involving real estate and governments. Excludes share bu

Slide 22: Berkshire offer is significantly below comparable acquisition multiples
Berkshire offer is significantly below comparable acquisition multiples Note: Price-to-book calculated as of announcement date. Shown on a fully diluted basis. (a) IPC shareholders received .9727 Validus shares and $7.50 in cash for every IPC share they owned. ParisRe shareholders received 0.3 Partn

Slide 23: Berkshire offer is below dividend discount value
Note: Calculated using a discount rate of 9.3% to 10.3% for Transatlantic. Source: Moelis fairness opinion to Transatlantic Board delivered on June 12, 2011 and as disclosed in S-4 proxy filed on August 17, 2011 Value differential: $7.00 Value differential: $18.75 Berkshire offer is below dividend d

Slide 24: AWH offers superior currency vs. Validus proposal
AWH offers superior currency VS. validus proposal Section 3 Strategic rationale: TransAllied merger delivers superior ''intrinsic'' and long-term value Berkshire's offer cements discount for TRH shareholders AWH offers superior currency versus Validus Process considerations ?

Slide 25: Allied World delivers superior currency and demonstrated record of value creation
Allied World delivers SUPERIOR currency and demonstrated record of value creation (1) Growth in book value per share calculated by taking change in basic book value per share from September 2006 through June 2011, adjusted for dividends paid. (2) Bloomberg annualized total shareholder returns based

Slide 26: Allied World delivers superior currency (continued)
Allied World delivers SUPERIOR currency and demonstrated record of value creation (continued) "In the end, the bet by TRH shareholders is who will compound Tangible BV/share at a faster clip over time. In the last 5 years, VR has compounded value creation (Tangible BV/share + cumulative dividend) by

Slide 27: Allied World delivers superior currency: operating ROE
Allied World delivers SUPERIOR currency and demonstrated record of value creation Average operating ROE: 2006 - 2010 2010 operating ROE Note: Period from 2006 through Q1 2011. Allied World's investment returns have outperformed Validus' through a volatile market environment...(a) ....with lower vola

Slide 28: TransAllied merger creates superior long-term shareholder value
TransAllied merger creates SUPERIOR long-term shareholder value 100% stock-for-stock transaction allows TRH shareholders to preserve significant upside value $8.00 cash consideration per share and increased leverage that limits future equity upside AWH has more valuable specialty insurance mix, impl

Slide 29: Process considerations
process considerations Section 4 Strategic rationale: TransAllied merger delivers superior ''intrinsic'' and long-term value Berkshire's offer cements discount for TRH shareholders AWH offers superior currency versus Validus Process considerations ?

Slide 30: Speed and certainty of potential upside vs. execution risk of other proposals
Speed and certainty of potential upside vs. significant uncertainty and execution risk of other proposals Signed definitive merger agreement with shareholder votes scheduled on Sept. 20, 2011 In our view, desperate attempt to disrupt transaction Uncertainty related to Hurricane season, which may cha

Slide 31: TransAllied clear and fast road to completion
TransAllied clear and fast road to completion August 2011 August 2011 August 2011 August 2011 August 2011 August 2011 August 2011 September 2011 September 2011 September 2011 September 2011 September 2011 September 2011 September 2011 October 2011 October 2011 October 2011 October 2011 October 2011
Source: SEC EDGAR · 425 filed Sep 8, 2011
More decks from Transatlantic Holdings Inc
Q3 2012 Earnings Presentation10 slides · Nov 2, 2012
Merger or Acquisition (December 2011)40 slides · Dec 1, 2011
Merger or Acquisition (December 2011)39 slides · Dec 1, 2011
Merger or Acquisition (November 2011)11 slides · Nov 29, 2011
Merger or Acquisition (November 2011)28 slides · Nov 10, 2011
Merger or Acquisition (November 2011)41 slides · Nov 4, 2011