9 slides from Nymex's proxy contest presentation, Jun 19, 2008
Slide 1: NYMEX Class A Member Meeting June 19, 2008
NYMEX Class A Member Meeting June 19, 2008 Exhibit 99.1
Slide 2: Bylaw Section 311(G)
1 Bylaw Section 311(G) If the Exchange determines, which determination must be consistent with all related protections and safeguards included in this Section 311, to terminate permanently all open outcry floor trading for a particular listed product on the NYMEX Division and instead to list such NY
Slide 3: Two Revenue Triggers
2 Two Revenue Triggers Permanent termination of open outcry trading or "Shift" to at least 90% of contract volume from electronic trading (Note: This is a product-by-product determination)
Slide 4: "Shift" To At Least 90% Electronic Trading
3 “Shift” To At Least 90% Electronic Trading Notice to Members No. 08-217 (April 23, 2008) "Shift" occurs at the end of… Two consecutive fiscal quarters During each quarter, average quarterly electronic trading volume has equaled or exceeded 90% of the total contract volume in such product
Slide 5: A 311(G) "Shift" Is Not Temporary
4 A 311(G) “Shift” Is Not Temporary Once triggered for a particular product, a 311(G) shift requires the revenue stream to continue in perpetuity or until NYMEX no longer lists such product for electronic trading Thus, a “shift” sufficient to justify permanent 311(G) payments cannot be temporary Sho
Slide 6: The Definition Of "Shift" Takes Into Account Historical Data
5 The Definition Of “Shift” Takes Into Account Historical Data Electronic Trading Volume as a Percentage of Total Contract Volume 74.83% 80.60% 81.33% 88.47% 89.02% 86.57% 61 Jan - Mar 2008 77.02% 86.44% 83.00% 64 Oct - Dec 2007 74.81% 79.17% 87.21% 86.38% 82.71% 63 July - Sept 2007 71.54% 68.92% 74
Slide 7: "Shift" Formula
6 “Shift” Formula As provided in Bylaw Section 311(G), a “shift” occurs when “at least 90% of contract volume of such applicable NYMEX Division product is from electronic trading … . ” Thus, to determine if a “shift” has taken place, it is necessary to divide “electronic trading” volume by “contract
Slide 8: "Contract Volume"
7 “Contract Volume” What is meant by “contract volume”? Section 311(G) says “at least 90% of contract volume” Section 311(G) does not say “at least 90% of trading volume” As regularly reported by NYMEX Holdings, Inc., contract volume includes transactions submitted for clearing via NYMEX ClearPort®
Slide 9: When 311(G) Payments Begin To Accrue
8 When 311(G) Payments Begin To Accrue Bylaw Section 311(G): “If ... at least 90% of contract volume of such applicable NYMEX Division product is from electronic trading, then in such case the owners of Class A memberships shall, at the time of termination or shift to electronic trading, thereafter