Transatlantic — Merger or Acquisition (September 2011)
51 slides from Transatlantic's merger presentation, Sep 12, 2011

Slide 1: Investor Presentation September 2011
Investor Presentation September 2011

Slide 2: Cautionary Note Regarding Forward-Looking Statements
Cautionary Note Regarding Forward-Looking Statements This presentation contains forward-looking statements that involve a number of risks and uncertainties. Statements that are not historical facts, including statements about our beliefs and expectations, are forward-looking statements. Such stateme

Slide 3: Key Discussion Issues / Questions
Key Discussion Issues / Questions Our assessment of current industry dynamics and their impact on Transatlantic How did we assess our strategic alternatives? Why did we pursue the Allied World merger? How did we assess other proposals? Validus proposal National Indemnity proposal Why we believe the

Slide 4: I: Current Industry Dynamics and Their Impact on Transatlantic
I: Current Industry Dynamics and Their Impact on Transatlantic

Slide 5: Who We Are
Who We Are 3 Global pure play property and casualty reinsurer A 30-year track record of performance, profitability and shareholder returns An unparalleled global franchise with a unique local presence with significant scale 24 locations with local underwriters Customized products for many markets Al

Slide 6: Competitive Landscape
Competitive Landscape 4 Industry Dynamics: Primary insurance writers are buying less reinsurance due to higher retained capital, better information, and stronger underwriting results Soft pricing environment Low interest rate environment Recent regulatory requirements have increased the need for loc

Slide 7: Competitive Landscape in the Global P&C Reinsurance Industry
Competitive Landscape in the Global P&C Reinsurance Industry 5 EXCEL SOURCE range $E$5:$H$15 copied at 30- Aug-11 10:38:27: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\Reinsurance Back-up 01.xlsx (Sheet1) EXCEL SOURCE range $E$5:$I$16 copied at 30- Aug-11 07:01:48: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Exce

Slide 8: Summary of P&C Industry Performance
Summary of P&C Industry Performance 6 Historical Industry Price / Book Multiples EXCEL SOURCE copied at 30-Aug-11 03:41:48: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\PB Chart v2.xlsx (Quarterly) EXCEL SOURCE copied at 31-Aug-11 09:39:52: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\PB Chart v4.xlsx (Quarte

Slide 9: Third Party Assessment of Transatlantic
Third Party Assessment of Transatlantic 7 "Management is debating the merits of building out a primary insurance business and knows it will require capital and potential M&A to achieve critical scale in a timely fashion." Morgan Stanley, 30-Nov-2010 "We've argued (since AIG sold its majority ownersh

Slide 10: II: How Did We Assess Our Strategic Alternatives?
II: How Did We Assess Our Strategic Alternatives?

Slide 11: How Transatlantic Evaluated Potential Merger Candidates
Opportunity for meaningful shareholder value creation Ability to reallocate capital globally with minimal costs U.S. tax treaties and regulatory regime Established primary insurance operations with minimal conflicts with Transatlantic's reinsurance business Established EU operations with European pa

Slide 12: Summary of Selected Companies
10 Summary of Selected Companies EXCEL SOURCE range $B$2:$Q$25 copied at 23- Aug-11 09:49:57: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\Summary of (Re)insurers with Lloyd's syndicates v14.xlsx (Summary Info) EXCEL SOURCE range $B$2:$N$25 copied at 31- Aug-11 08:49:46: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS

Slide 13: Timeline of Key Events
Timeline of Key Events 1990-2009: AIG owned a majority stake in Transatlantic 10-Jun-2009: AIG disposed of 29.9mm of its shares in Transatlantic through a secondary public offering reducing its stake from 59% to ~14% From time to time since the secondary sale, Transatlantic engaged in preliminary di

Slide 14: Combination with Allied World Creates Industry Leader and Generates Significant Shareholder Value
Combination with Allied World Creates Industry Leader and Generates Significant Shareholder Value Maintains strategic optionality for future Merger creates significant value upside to Transatlantic stockholders Modest initial reduction to book value per share resulting from Allied World Transaction1

Slide 15: Strategic Objectives
Strategic Objectives 13 #7 among peers on capital1 Current Path Allied World Merger #3 among peers based on capital1 ~59% Transatlantic ownership Near-term benefits of re-domestication are not feasible Swiss domicile (tax treaty) with Bermuda operations Strong financial strength of Transatlantic (A+

Slide 16: How We Expect the Merger to Create Value for Transatlantic Stockholders
How We Expect the Merger to Create Value for Transatlantic Stockholders 14 Strategic Strengths Shareholder Value Creation Strengthened industry leadership supports future growth and enhances revenue growth opportunities $80mm+ of after-tax run-rate annual synergies and structural benefits (including

Slide 17: Attractive Financial Implications For Transatlantic Stockholders
Mid single-digit EPS accretion in the first full year 80-100 bps ROE enhancement in the first full year 50% dividend increase 16% premium to undisturbed Transatlantic share price 15 Attractive Financial Implications For Transatlantic Stockholders

Slide 18: How Did We Arrive at the Exchange Ratio?
How Did We Arrive at the Exchange Ratio? 16 EXCEL SOURCE range $E$3:$G$16 copied at 01- Sep-11 12:15:39: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\6-30-2011 BVPS Impact_12.xlsx (Exch Ratio)

Slide 19: Participation in Synergies Provides Potential Upside to Public Market Values
Participation in Synergies Provides Potential Upside to Public Market Values 17 "... We believe one also needs to account for the $80 million, or $1.26 per share, of expected run-rate cost and tax benefits (based on management estimates). Applying an 8X EPS multiple (TRH's current multiple) implies

Slide 20: Transatlantic Stockholder Value Based on Analysis Presented to Board of Directors
18 Transatlantic Stockholder Value Based on Analysis Presented to Board of Directors 12-Jun-2011 EXCEL SOURCE range $D$4:$K$18 copied at 30- Aug-11 04:57:50: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\intrinsic valuation.xlsx (Sheet1)

Slide 21: Third Party Observations Regarding the Transatlantic / Allied World Deal
Third Party Observations Regarding the Transatlantic / Allied World Deal 19 "Looks like a great strategic/operational fit; TransAllied to be a dominant off-shore casualty Global Reinsurer. AWH is smaller than TRH but fits on key levels:1) each is 70%+ casualty lines, 2) AWH offers tax- advantages gi

Slide 22: III: How Did We Assess Other Proposals?
III: How Did We Assess Other Proposals?

Slide 23: A: Validus Proposal
A: Validus Proposal

Slide 24: Summary of Validus Proposal
Summary of Validus Proposal 22 1.5564 Validus shares per each Transatlantic share $8.00 cash per Transatlantic share Approximately 48% Transatlantic board found that Validus proposal is reasonably likely to lead to a superior proposal and provided Validus opportunity to conduct diligence Need to sig

Slide 25: Validus Proposal - Key Events
Validus Proposal - Key Events 3-Jun-2011: Received unsolicited call from Ed Noonan, Chairman and CEO of Validus 7-Jun-2011: Received a letter from Validus - Without economic or other specific terms - Validus mentioned need for confidentiality agreement and expressed desire to conduct due diligence 1

Slide 26: Why Did We Not Consider Validus Proposal a Superior Proposal?
Why Did We Not Consider Validus Proposal a "Superior Proposal"? 24 Validus Proposal delivers less book value per share Why Validus' Proposal is Inferior The Facts As a result of certain significant tax advantages with the Allied World merger, we believe the potential synergies with Allied World are

Slide 27: EXCEL SOURCE range $F$13:$H$29 copied at 01- Sep-11 12:20:40: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\Book for Book
25 EXCEL SOURCE range $F$13:$H$29 copied at 01- Sep-11 12:20:40: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\Book for Book v10.xlsx (B4B 6-30) EXCEL SOURCE range $E$13:$H$33 copied at 02- Sep-11 12:05:57: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\Book for Book v11.xlsx (B4B 6-30)

Slide 28: Validus Exchange Offer Provides Lower Book Value per Share
Validus Exchange Offer Provides Lower Book Value per Share 26 EXCEL SOURCE copied at 26-Jul-11 10:37:30: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\7g 14D9\proforma book value per basic transatlantic share.xlsx (Sheet1 Chart 1) Pro Forma 30-Jun-2011 Book Value per Transatlantic Basic Share EXCEL SOURCE copied at 23

Slide 29: In Validus' Own Words: Growth in Book Value per Share
27 In Validus' Own Words: "The Compensation Committee [of Validus' Board] determined that growth in diluted book value per share plus dividends was the most appropriate measure of increase in long-term shareholder value." Validus Holdings Schedule 14A, 23-Mar-2011 Annualized Growth in Book Value per

Slide 30: ....and Lower Volatility in Earnings...
....and Lower Volatility in Earnings... 28 Historical Quarterly Operating Income1

Slide 31: ....Which Have Led to Superior Returns for Allied World Shareholders
....Which Have Led to Superior Returns for Allied World Shareholders 29

Slide 32: Illustrative Adjusted Value per Transatlantic Share
Illustrative Adjusted Value per Transatlantic Share ($ in millions; except per share amounts) 30

Slide 33: Pro forma PMLs under Validus proposal change the risk profile
31 Pro forma PMLs under Validus proposal change the risk profile for Transatlantic stockholders Transatlantic has not been able to diligence Validus' risk management capabilities Higher PML tolerances can generate significant additional premiums in addition to materially increasing volatility of ear

Slide 34: Significant Uncertainty in Ratings Outcome in Validus Proposal
Significant Uncertainty in Ratings Outcome in Validus Proposal 32 Credit Ratings Reaction Estimated June 30, 2011 Pro Forma Total Debt / Total Capitalization1 S&P TransAllied: Expected to raise ratings on Allied World by one notch (from current A FSR) and reduce OpCo / HoldCo notching to two for Tra

Slide 35: B: National Indemnity Proposal
B: National Indemnity Proposal

Slide 36: Summary of National Indemnity Offer
Summary of National Indemnity Offer 34 All Cash Proposal Transatlantic pro forma ownership of 0% No participation in upside Signed confidentiality agreement

Slide 37: National Indemnity Delivered its Opportunistic Offer During Market Decline
National Indemnity Delivered its Opportunistic Offer During Market Decline 35 EXCEL SOURCE copied at 30-Aug-11 06:00:15: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\PB Chart v4.xlsx (P-BV) EXCEL SOURCE copied at 30-Aug-11 07:51:11: NAUTILUS2011\Presentatio n\8h ISS\Excel\PB Chart v4.xlsx (P-BV) "The bat

Slide 38: National Indemnity Proposal is Below Levels of Selected Precedent Cash Transactions
National Indemnity Proposal is Below Levels of Selected Precedent Cash Transactions in Insurance 36 Premium to: Multiple of: National Indemnity Offer 25th Percentile Median 75th Percentile EXCEL SOURCE copied at 29-Aug-11 07:06:13: nautilus2011\Presentation\8 h ISS\Excel\Deal Comp as Values_v5.xlsx

Slide 39: IV: Summary and Conclusion
IV: Summary and Conclusion

Slide 40: Why We Believe the Allied World Transaction Delivers Superior Value
Why We Believe the Allied World Transaction Delivers Superior Value to Transatlantic Stockholders 38 Maintains strategic optionality for future Merger creates significant value upside to Transatlantic stockholders A leading diversified insurance and reinsurance company with a specialty focus Scale a

Slide 41: Appendix A: Reconciliation of Non-GAAP Measures
Appendix A: Reconciliation of Non-GAAP Measures!

Slide 42: Allied World Operating Income Reconciliation
40 EXCEL SOURCE range $D$8:$N$26 copied at 23- Aug-11 11:27:09: nautilus2011\Presentation\8 h ISS\Excel\AWH Op INc Net Inc Reconc v5.xlsx (AWH)

Slide 43: Validus Quarterly Operating Income Reconciliation
Validus Quarterly Operating Income Reconciliation 41 EXCEL SOURCE range $D$8:$N$31 copied at 23- Aug-11 11:30:08: nautilus2011\Presentation\8 h ISS\Excel\AWH Op INc Net Inc Reconc v5.xlsx (VR)

Slide 44: Appendix B: Other Materials
Appendix B: Other Materials

Slide 45: Notes to Summary of Selected Companies
Notes to Summary of Selected Companies (1) Primary insurance as percent of total premiums based on GPW. (2) Excludes life insurance business segments of XL. (3) Cumulative catastrophe losses for 2008 through Q2 2011 as a percentage of cumulative NPE for 2008 through Q2 2011. (4) Validus Re Europe Li

Slide 46: Comparison of Selected Companies
Comparison of Selected Companies ($ in millions) 44

Slide 47: Notes to Slides
Notes to Slides Slide 3 (1) Source: Transatlantic Investor Presentation from 11-Mar-2010 and Q2 2011 financial supplement. Slide 5 Source: Company filings Note: Includes only results from non-life segments. (1) Reinsurance premiums include results for Berkshire Hathaway Reinsurance Group and General

Slide 48: Notes to Slides
Notes to Slides Slide 12 Note: Premium relative to Transatlantic undisturbed stock price of $44.01 as of 10-Jun-2011. Initial book value per basic share dilution of 2.5% versus Transatlantic 30-Jun-2011 book value per basic share of $67.76. based on pro forma book value per basic share as of 30-Jun-

Slide 49: Notes to Slides
Notes to Slides Slide 18 Per Transatlantic management projections. Based on dividend discount model using 10.3% discount rate and 0.75 terminal multiple for the low case and 9.3% discount rate and 0.95x terminal multiple for the high case. Discount rates and terminal multiples per disclosure in Alli

Slide 50: Notes to Slides
Notes to Slides Slide 28 Source: Allied World and Validus financial supplements (included in the Appendix) Note: Data updated through 30-Jun-2011. (1) Net operating income as defined by Allied World and Validus in their respective public filings. Slide 29 Source: Bloomberg Notes: Total return define

Slide 51: Notes to Slides
Notes to Slides Slide 32 Source: Public filings and rating agency research reports (1) Pro forma capitalization for TransAllied based on information provided in S-4 filed by Allied World on 17-Aug-2011, excludes $80.3mm fair value write-up of debt . Pro forma capitalization for Validus proposal base
Source: SEC EDGAR · 425 filed Sep 12, 2011
More decks from Transatlantic Holdings Inc
Q3 2012 Earnings Presentation10 slides · Nov 2, 2012
Merger or Acquisition (December 2011)40 slides · Dec 1, 2011
Merger or Acquisition (December 2011)39 slides · Dec 1, 2011
Merger or Acquisition (November 2011)11 slides · Nov 29, 2011
Merger or Acquisition (November 2011)28 slides · Nov 10, 2011
Merger or Acquisition (November 2011)41 slides · Nov 4, 2011