Chiquita Brands International Inc

Chiquita Brands International — Merger or Acquisition (September 2014)

24 slides from Chiquita Brands International's merger presentation, Sep 2, 2014

  1. Slide 1: Setting the Record Straight on Cutrale / Safra's Presentation

    Slide 1: Setting the Record Straight on Cutrale / Safra's Presentation

    1 1 O Setting the Record Straight on Cutrale / Safra’s Presentation September 2014

  2. Slide 2: Forward-looking statements

    Slide 2: Forward-looking statements

    2 This presentation contains certain statements that are “forward - looking statements.” These statements are subject to a number of assumptions, risks and uncertainties, many of which are beyond the control of Chiquita and Fyffes plc (“Fyffes”), including: the customary risks experienced by global

  3. Slide 3: Cutrale/Safra's Presentation to Chiquita Shareholders is Flawed and Misleading

    Slide 3: Cutrale/Safra's Presentation to Chiquita Shareholders is Flawed and Misleading

    3 Cutrale/Safra’s Presentation to Chiquita Shareholders is Flawed and Misleading 1 Cutrale/Safra Grossly Misrepresents Fyffes Business and Performance Track - Record 2 Cutrale/Safra Grossly Misrepresents Synergies in the ChiquitaFyffes Transaction 3 Cutrale/Safra Grossly Overstates the Multiple Offe

  4. Slide 4: Misrepresents Fyffes Business and Performance Track Record

    Slide 4: Misrepresents Fyffes Business and Performance Track Record

    4 Cutrale / Safra Grossly Misrepresents Fyffes Business and Performance Track - Record 1 Cutrale / Safra Reality • “Fyffes is a middleman: its relative lack of land ownership is reflected in its lower multiple versus peers” • Fyffes has a deep understanding of production • Fyffes’ significant assets

  5. Slide 5: Fyffes Has Grown Much Faster Than Peers

    Slide 5: Fyffes Has Grown Much Faster Than Peers

    Fyffes Has Grown Much Faster Than Peers Cutrale / Safra Grossly Misrepresents Fyffes Business and Performance Track - Record 1 Standard Deviation of Annual EBITDA Growth (2010 – 2014E) Chiquita 47% Fyffes 14 Fresh Del Monte 17 Industry Average 26% 5 Fyffes Has Been Much Less Volatile Than Peers Sour

  6. Slide 6: ChiquitaFyffes Produces Large Amounts of Fruit on Controlled Land

    Slide 6: ChiquitaFyffes Produces Large Amounts of Fruit on Controlled Land

    ChiquitaFyffes Produces Large Amounts of Fruit on Controlled Land Chiquita Fyffes ChiquitaFyffes Cutrale / Safra Grossly Misrepresents Fyffes Business and Performance Track - Record 1 ~16,000 ~26,000 ~10,000 Hectares Controlled 6 Source: Management figures 37 % 63% 100% Bananas Pineapples 30% 30% 10

  7. Slide 7: Misrepresents Synergies in the ChiquitaFyffes Transaction

    Slide 7: Misrepresents Synergies in the ChiquitaFyffes Transaction

    7 Cutrale / Safra Grossly Misrepresents Synergies in the ChiquitaFyffes Transaction 2 Cutrale / Safra Reality • “Chiquita and Fyffes have suddenly discovered an additional $20 million of alleged synergies for the proposed Fyffes combination” • Irish Takeover Rules require synergy estimates to be doc

  8. Slide 8: Combined EBITDA and synergies illustrative figures

    Slide 8: Combined EBITDA and synergies illustrative figures

    8 Source: Public filings Note : Combined figures are not projections of how the Combined Group will trade ; EUR converted to USD at an exchange rate of $1.3242 to € 1.000. (1) For illustrative purposes, 2014 Fyffes initial estimated EBITDA is stated as $52 million being the mid - point of Fyffes pro

  9. Slide 9: Overstates the Transaction Multiple Offered to Shareholders

    Slide 9: Overstates the Transaction Multiple Offered to Shareholders

    9 Cutrale / Safra Grossly Overstates the Transaction Multiple Offered to Shareholders 3 Cutrale / Safra Reality • “Cutrale / Safra Proposal : A record - high multiple ” • “At a 11.8x multiple of Chiquita’s reported adjusted EBITDA for the last 12 months ended June 30, 2014 the Cutrale/Safra proposal

  10. Slide 10: Underlying EBITDA: Overstates the Transaction Multiple

    Slide 10: Underlying EBITDA: Overstates the Transaction Multiple

    10 June 30, 2014 Standalone Cutrale / Safra Buying in December 2014 Chiquita Shareholders Selling ChiquitaFyffes Run - Rate EBITDA Underlying EBITDA: Cutrale / Safra Grossly Overstates the Transaction Multiple Offered to Shareholders 3 June 30, 2014 Standalone Adjusted for 1x Costs Source: Public fi

  11. Slide 11: Chiquita shareholders are asked to abandon merger for low multiple

    Slide 11: Chiquita shareholders are asked to abandon merger for low multiple

    11 Cutrale / Safra is trying to hide the real value creation opportunity that C hiquita shareholders are selling Chiquita shareholders are asked to abandon merger for low multiple 11.8x 10.4x 10.2x 9.8x 9.5x 9.4x 9.4x 9.0x 8.6x 8.6x 8.2x 8.0x 7.3x 7.2x 6.9x 6.7x 6.0x Cutrale / Safra Offer On Dated L

  12. Slide 12: Overstates the Premium Offered to Chiquita Shareholders

    Slide 12: Overstates the Premium Offered to Chiquita Shareholders

    12 Cutrale / Safra Grossly Overstates the “Premium” Offered to Chiquita Shareholders 4 Cutrale / Safra Reality • “Our proposal values Chiquita at $13 per share and represents an attractive premium of 29.2% to the $10.06 per share price” • Cutrale / Safra offer is a (4.2)% discount to Chiquita’s 52 -

  13. Slide 13: A look at the real premium offered by Cutrale / Safra

    Slide 13: A look at the real premium offered by Cutrale / Safra

    13 Cutrale / Safra Grossly Overstates the “Premium” Offered to Chiquita Shareholders 4 A look at the real premium offered by Cutrale / Safra $ 13.00 $ 13.57 $ 12.64 $ 10.85 Cutrale / Safra Offer 52-Week High High Since Announcement of Fyffes Transaction Chiquita on June 30, 2014 (4.2)% (Discount) /

  14. Slide 14: The 5/10/15% EBITDA growth is not founded

    Slide 14: The 5/10/15% EBITDA growth is not founded

    14 Cutrale / Safra Grossly Overstates the “Premium” Offered to Chiquita Shareholders 4 Cutrale / Safra Reality • “The 5 / 10 / 15% EBITDA growth in the Investor Presentation is not founded” • “Must believe in the “new” incremental $20 million in synergies and high - end EV / LTM EBITDA multiple and

  15. Slide 15: Analysis incorrectly discounts future values to today

    Slide 15: Analysis incorrectly discounts future values to today

    15 Cutrale / Safra Grossly Overstates the “Premium” Offered to Chiquita Shareholders 4 Cutrale / Safra analysis incorrectly discounts future values to today instead of December 2014 closing date Cutrale / Safra Analysis - Implied FYE 2015 Future Share Price Discounted to Dec. 2014 None of these valu

  16. Slide 16: Cutrale / Safra Assumes 0.3% EBITDA Growth for Chiquita

    Slide 16: Cutrale / Safra Assumes 0.3% EBITDA Growth for Chiquita

    16 Cutrale / Safra Grossly Overstates the “Premium” Offered to Chiquita Shareholders 4 Cutrale / Safra Assumes 0.3% EBITDA Growth for Chiquita Cutrale / Safra Assumes Blended 6.3x - 7.3x LTM EBITDA 2 Chiquita Growth Since Turnaround Chiquita EBITDA Margins Current LTM EBITDA 10 - Year Average LTM EB

  17. Slide 17: Illustrative FYE 2015 Future Share Price

    Slide 17: Illustrative FYE 2015 Future Share Price

    17 Illustrative FYE 2015 Future Share Price Illustrative 2014 Pro Forma EBITDA (Run - Rate Synergies) Illustrative Present Value of Future Share Price Cutrale / Safra Grossly Overstates the “Premium” Offered to Chiquita Shareholders 4 Cutrale / Safra criticizes analysis for showing 2015 Future Value

  18. Slide 18: Understates the Value of the ChiquitaFyffes Transaction

    Slide 18: Understates the Value of the ChiquitaFyffes Transaction

    18 Cutrale / Safra Grossly Understates the Value of the ChiquitaFyffes Transaction 5 Cutrale / Safra Reality • “$13 per share proposal implies an attractive premium vs. proposed Fyffes combination” • “This proposal is unquestionably superior to the proposed transaction with Fyffes and provides compe

  19. Slide 19: Correct Math and Updated Facts

    Slide 19: Correct Math and Updated Facts

    19 Cutrale / Safra Presentation Correct Math and Updated Facts Cutrale / Safra Grossly Understates the Value of the ChiquitaFyffes Transaction 5 Values Discounted to February 28, 2014 12/31/14 $13.00 $9.96 $11.42 $11.27 $13.92 Cutrale / Safra Offer Low High Low High Present Value of ChiquitaFyffes F

  20. Slide 20: Proposal of $13 Per Share is Inadequate

    Slide 20: Proposal of $13 Per Share is Inadequate

    20 Cutrale / Safra Reality • “Chiquita shareholders should want the Chiquita Board to engage in discussions with Cutrale/Safra about its $13 / Share All Cash Proposal” • The Board of Chiquita is aware of its fiduciary duties • The Board of Chiquita unanimously determined that $13 represented an inad

  21. Slide 21: Cutrale / Safra Riskless Option Has No Value

    Slide 21: Cutrale / Safra Riskless Option Has No Value

    21 Cutrale / Safra “Riskless Option” Has No Value For Weeks, Cutrale / Safra Has Dug in At An Inadequate Proposal of $13 / Share Cutrale / Safra Reality • The Chiquita Board has determined that the Cutrale / Safra offer of $13 / share does not constitute a Chiquita Superior Proposa l • “There is abs

  22. Slide 22: The Choice for Chiquita Shareholders

    Slide 22: The Choice for Chiquita Shareholders

    22 The Choice for Chiquita Shareholders Cutrale / Safra Reality • “In order to preserve your optionality, you must vote “FOR” the Cutrale - Safra negotiation proposal at the Special Meeting” • The Chiquita Board believes that Cutrale / Safra that $ 13 per share is not a superior proposal • The Chiqu

  23. Slide 23: Responsibility statement and No Offer and Solicitation

    Slide 23: Responsibility statement and No Offer and Solicitation

    23 The directors of Chiquita accept responsibility for the information contained in this presentation. To the best of the knowle dge and belief of the directors of Chiquita (who have taken all reasonable care to ensure that such is the case), the information contained in this pr esentation for which

  24. Slide 24: No Profit Forecast / Asset Valuations / Basis of Synergies / Non-GAAP Information

    Slide 24: No Profit Forecast / Asset Valuations / Basis of Synergies / Non-GAAP Information

    24 No Profit Forecast / Asset Valuations / Basis of Synergies / Non - GAAP Information The foregoing presentation should be read in conjunction with the definitive Proxy Statement/Prospectus/Scheme Circular dated Au gust 6, 2014 mailed to shareholders of Chiquita and Fyffes and those announcements i

Source: SEC EDGAR · 425 filed Sep 2, 2014

More decks from Chiquita Brands International Inc