Marsh Supermarkets Inc

Marsh Supermarkets — Proxy Contest (September 2006)

9 slides from Marsh Supermarkets's proxy contest presentation, Sep 7, 2006

  1. Slide 1: Disclaimer

    Slide 1: Disclaimer

    Disclaimer This presentation includes certain forward-looking statements (statements other than those made solely with respect to historical fact). Actual results could differ materially and adversely from those contemplated by the forward-looking statements due to known and unknown risks and uncert

  2. Slide 2: Extensive Auction Process

    Slide 2: Extensive Auction Process

    Extensive Auction Process Retained Merrill Lynch to assist with sale process (October 2005) Contacted 27 financial and strategic parties (November 2005) 21 potential buyers signed confidentiality agreements, including customary standstills Ten submitted preliminary indications of interest Based on p

  3. Slide 3: Compelling Transaction

    Slide 3: Compelling Transaction

    Compelling Transaction MSH Supermarkets, an affiliate of Sun Capital Partners, to acquire all outstanding shares of both classes of Marsh common stock for $11.125 per share in cash Premium to Marsh's pre-deal stock price and its historical trading prices: 18.0% (Class A) and 21.7% (Class B) above av

  4. Slide 4: Historical Stock Performance

    Slide 4: Historical Stock Performance

    Historical Stock Performance Marsh's Class A and Class B common stock traded as low as $5.56 per share and $5.62 per share, respectively, during calendar year 2006, and the lowest of these values were recorded as recently as six months ago Very limited trading volume in Class A and Class B common st

  5. Slide 5: Challenging Operating Environment

    Slide 5: Challenging Operating Environment

    Challenging Operating Environment Marsh's traditional retail grocery and convenience store markets have come under significantly increasing competitive pressures Expect as many as 17 competitive stores to open or begin development within Marsh's market area in fiscal 2007; 13 of 17 would be Wal-Mart

  6. Slide 6: Sun Capital is the Right and Only Partner for Marsh

    Slide 6: Sun Capital is the Right and Only Partner for Marsh

    Sun Capital is the Right and Only Partner for Marsh Sun Capital is right partner for Marsh and its employees, customers and vendors Leading private investment firm focused on investments in market-leading companies that can benefit from its in-house operating professionals and experience More than $

  7. Slide 7: Post-Auction Developments

    Slide 7: Post-Auction Developments

    Post-Auction Developments Cardinal Paragon, a company primarily engaged in real estate financing transactions such as sale-leasebacks, partnered with Drawbridge Special Opportunities Investors Cardinal/Drawbridge executed confidentiality agreement (which included standstill provisions) and was provi

  8. Slide 8: BML's Flawed Analysis

    Slide 8: BML's Flawed Analysis

    BML's Flawed Analysis Marsh believes that BML's valuation is flawed because it is based solely on a balance sheet basis and on appraised values of Marsh's owned real estate Appraisals are estimates of values based on the stream of rental payments from the supermarket or convenience store operations

  9. Slide 9: Conclusion

    Slide 9: Conclusion

    Conclusion The MSH Supermarkets-Marsh transaction was the result of an extensive and publicly disclosed auction process MSH Supermarkets' all-cash premium offer is and remains the only offer received by Marsh MSH Supermarkets' offer of $11.125 per share represents fair value for Marsh shareholders S

Source: SEC EDGAR · DEFA14A filed Sep 7, 2006