Rofin-Sinar Technologies — Proxy Contest (March 2016)
49 slides from Rofin-Sinar Technologies's proxy contest presentation, Mar 4, 2016
Slide 1: Fix Rofin: It's time for change to unlock long-term stockholder value
Fix Rofin: It’s time for change to unlock long - term stockholder value March 4, 2016
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer This presentation contains “forward - looking statements” within the meaning of the safe harbor provisions of the U.S. Private Securiti es Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Forward - looking statements can be identified by words such as: “target,” “future,” “continue,” “anticipate,” “believe
Slide 3: Definitions
Definitions Analysts Includes: Patrick M. Newton, Stifel Nicolaus; Joe Wittine , Longbow Research; Tom Hayes, Northcoast Research; Mark Miller, The Benchmark Company. Excludes: Noble Financial Capital Markets (dropped coverage); Commerzbank Corporates & Markets (outdated report); Deutsche Bank Resea
Slide 4: Fix Rofin: Agenda
Fix Rofin: It’s time for change to unlock long - term stockholder value. I. Rofin at a Glance p. 5 II. Our Proposals and Nominees p. 7 - 8 III. Stockholder Value D estruction p. 10 - 14 IV. Selected O perational L owlights p . 16 - 22 V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies p . 24 - 29 VI. Third P arty
Slide 5: Rofin at a Glance
Rofin is one of the leading companies in the laser industry but with mediocre operational performance. I. Rofin at a Glance Rofin designs , develops, engineers, manufactures and markets laser sources and laser - based system solutions for industrial material processing applications , which include p
Slide 6: Agenda
Fix Rofin: It’s time for change to unlock long - term stockholder value. I. Rofin a t a Glance p. 5 II. Our Proposals and Nominees p. 7 - 8 III. Stockholder Value D estruction p. 10 - 14 IV. Selected O perational L owlights p . 16 - 22 V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies p . 24 - 29 VI. Third P art
Slide 7: Rofin: A company in need of change!
Rofin: A company in need of change! ▪ We believe that Rofin’s leadership has destroyed stockholder value over the long - term and short - term. ▪ We believe that Rofin shows poor operational performance compared to its peer group. ▪ We believe that the Board composition demonstrates an entrenched bo
Slide 8: Vote for our Nominees!
Vote for our Nominees! II. Our Proposals and Nominees Name Reasons why you should Vote For Our Nominees! Mr. Thomas Limberger, 48 A highly experienced corporate restructuring expert, will provide a fresh perspective on the Rofin board. Mr. Thomas Limberger has a deep understanding of the material pr
Slide 9: Agenda
Fix Rofin: It’s time for change to unlock long - term stockholder value. I. Rofin at a Glance p. 5 II. Our Proposals and Nominees p. 7 - 8 III. Stockholder Value D estruction p. 10 - 14 IV. Selected O perational Lowlights p . 16 - 22 V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies p . 24 - 29 VI. Third Party A
Slide 10: Rofin's stock price outperformed by most peers and indices
Rofin’s stock price has been outperformed by most of the peer group companies and indices: ▪ Rofin’s stock price decreased by 17% over 1 year, outperformed by most of its peer group companies and relevant indices; ▪ Rofin’s stock price decreased by 29% over 3 years , outperformed by all of its peer
Slide 11: Stock price performance vs. indices and peers (1 year)
Stock price performance (indexed) vs. relevant indices (1 year; 2 /9/ 15 – 2 /9/ 16 ): ▪ Rofin’s stock price decreased by 17% over 1 year while ▪ S&P 500 / Information Technology index decreased by 7%, ▪ NASDAQ Composite index decreased by 10%, ▪ Russel 3000 index decreased by 12% and ▪ S&P Mid Cap
Slide 12: Stock price performance vs. indices and peers (3 years)
Stock price performance (indexed) vs. relevant indices (3 years; 2/8/ 13 – 2 /9/ 16 ): ▪ Rofin’s stock price decreased by 29% over 3 years while ▪ NASDAQ Composite index increased by 34%, ▪ S&P 500 / Information Technology index increased by 33%, ▪ Russel 3000 index increased by 19% and ▪ S&P Mid Ca
Slide 13: Stock price performance vs. indices and peers (5 years)
Stock price performance (indexed) vs. relevant indices (5 years; 2 /9/11 – 2 /9/ 16 ): ▪ Rofin’s stock price decreased by 48% over 5 years while ▪ NASDAQ Composite index increased by 53%, ▪ S&P 500 / Information Technology index increased by 45%, ▪ Russel 3000 index increased by 37% and ▪ S&P Mid Ca
Slide 14: Stock price performance vs. peer group and buy back programs
Stock price performance (indexed) vs. peer group ( 11/5/07 – 2/9/16 ): ▪ Rofin’s stock price and decreased by 54% while ▪ IPG’s stock price increased by 315%, ▪ Coherent’s stock price increased by 169%, ▪ II - IV ’s stock price increased by 19%, ▪ Newport ’s stock price increased by 12% and ▪ GS ’s
Slide 15: Agenda
Fix Rofin: It’s time for change to unlock long - term stockholder value. I. Rofin at a Glance p. 5 II. Our Proposals and Nominees p. 7 - 8 III. Stockholder Value D estruction p. 10 - 14 IV. Selected O perational L owlights p . 16 - 22 V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies p . 24 - 29 VI. Third Party
Slide 16: Rofin's sales and market share keep losing ground to peers
Rofin’s sales and market share keeps losing ground compared to its peers: ▪ Sales grew by only 2.4% CAGR while total relative market 1 grew with a CAGR of 7.0% ( 2006 – 2015 ); ▪ Rofin’s sales relative to it’s peer group decreased by 35% from 20% down to 13% from 2006 to 2015. N umerous A nalysts ex
Slide 17: Sales and market share vs. peer group
16% 18% 19% 19% 19% 16% 16% 15% 15% 14% 10% 10% 9% 10% 9% 19% 21% 23% 24% 26% 23% 21% 20% 20% 20% 16% 14% 13% 12% 12% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 2013 2014 2015 2016E* 2017E* Rofin Coherent IPG GSI Newport II-VI 11% 11% 13% 16% 14% 15% 16% 16% 18% 19% 21% 19% 18% 19% 19% 17% 18% 16%
Slide 18: Gross margin vs. peer group
38.8% 36.4% 35.1% 35.6% 37.8% 38.9% 35.2% 35.2% 36.0% 36.2% 33.0% 35.0% 37.0% 39.0% 41.0% 43.0% 45.0% 47.0% 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Rofin (as reported) Rofin (at constant currency rates) Gross margin as reported: Gross margin as reported vs. gross margins at constant currency rates: Observations: ▪
Slide 19: R&D and EBIT margin vs. peer group
38 43 43 46 40 40 41 45 52 57 35 40 45 50 55 60 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Rofin Peer Average Figures in $ million 14.0% 9.3% 8.8% 6.4% 10.8% 14.1% 8.6% 8.9% 6.8% 8.8% 5.0% 6.0% 7.0% 8.0% 9.0% 10.0% 11.0% 12.0% 13.0% 14.0% 15.0% 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Rofin (as reported) Rofin (at constant currency)
Slide 20: Key financial ratios below peer group averages
Rofin’s key financial ratios 1 are all below peer group averages. IV. Selected Operational L owlights : Below peer group average : B etter than peer group average Sources: FactSet , Peer Group Filings, Rofin Filings, SilverArrow Analysis; Note: 2015 Figures for IPG, GSI and Newport are based on last
Slide 21: Rofin statements on gross profit improvement
In 2015 Rofin has stated that their gross profit increased mainly as a result higher efficiencies and reduced manufacturing cost: ▪ “ We delivered very strong third quarter results that demonstrate that our measures to increase efficiency and profitability are gaining momentum” (press r elease, Q3 r
Slide 22: Surprise history: guidance vs. analyst consensus
Sources: FactSet , Rofin Filings, SilverArrow Analysis . Surprise history quarterly sales: Rofin’s guidance vs. analysts consensus and actual sales per quarter: Surprise history quarterly EPS: Rofin’s guidance vs. analysts consensus and actual sales per quarter: Observations ▪ Rofin quarterly sales
Slide 23: Agenda
Fix Rofin: It’s time for change to unlock long - term stockholder value. I. Rofin at a Glance p. 5 II. Our Proposals and Nominees p. 7 - 8 III. Stockholder Value D estruction p. 10 - 14 IV. Selected O perational L owlights p . 16 - 22 V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies p . 24 - 29 VI. Third Party
Slide 24: Don't be fooled by this Board's lip service on governance
Don’t be f ooled by this Board and their lip service on corporate governance. We believe that the board composition demonstrates an entrenched board without proper governance: ▪ Lengthy Tenure, ▪ Lack of Independence, ▪ Questionable “ Known” Related Party Transactions, ▪ Violation of their own r eti
Slide 25: Entrenched board without proper governance
We believe that the B oard composition demonstrates an entrenched board without proper governance. V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies No new directors added in 12+ years before SilverArrow asked for representation; 6 of the 8 directors have served on the board for 12+ years; 4 of the 8 directors h
Slide 26: Board has taken unacceptable actions
We believe that the Board has taken unacceptable actions. V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies Why this is Unacceptable? While the Company is being criticized for operational deficiencies, the Board determined that they should hire the then current COO (with over 15 years at the Company), who we bel
Slide 27: Board has taken more unacceptable actions
We believe that the Board has taken more unacceptable actions. V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies Why this is Unacceptable? While we agree that there are extenuating circumstances where exceptions can be made for a mandatory retirement age, in theory, such provisions are designed to ensure an appr
Slide 28: Board has taken even more unacceptable actions
We believe that the Board has taken even more unacceptable actions. V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies Why this is Unacceptable? - Rather than focusing their campaign on their own performance, corporate governance and the strength of their nominees, they have chosen to engage in a negative, shrill
Slide 29: Rofin's Nominees – continue to entrust these individuals?
Rofin’s Nominees – Do you want to continue to entrust these individuals ? V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies Name Age Note Mr. Daniel J. Smoke Board Tenure – 13 years 66 Mr. Smoke was fired with cause and accused of serious violations related to his previous employment at JAC Products, where he se
Slide 30: Agenda
Fix Rofin: It’s time for change to unlock long - term stockholder value. I. Rofin at a Glance p. 5 II. Our Proposals and Nominees p. 7 - 8 III. Stockholder Value D estruction p. 10 - 14 IV. Selected O perational L owlights p . 16 - 22 V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies p . 24 - 29 VI. Third P arty
Slide 31: Third parties' unfavorable opinions of Rofin (1/2)
Third parties’ unfavorable opinions of Rofin illustrate that many share our beliefs (1/2). ▪ ISS Proxy Paper (02/19/2015) Board: ISS QuickScore of 7 with a red flag for “Board Composition” Shareholder rights: QuickScore of 8 with red flags for “ T akeover Defenses” and “Meeting and voting related is
Slide 32: Third parties' unfavorable opinions of Rofin (2/2)
Third parties’ unfavorable opinions on Rofin illustrate that many share our beliefs (2/2). ▪ activiststocks.com (10/13/15): “Rofin is battling the likes of IPG Photonics, Lumentum , Coherent and nLight . Rofin would be able to compete more effectively if a number of changes were made , including the
Slide 33: Agenda
Fix Rofin: It’s time for change to unlock long - term stockholder value. I. Rofin at a Glance p. 5 II. Our Proposals and Nominees p. 7 - 8 III. Stockholder Value D estruction p. 10 - 14 IV. Selected O perational L owlights p . 16 - 22 V. Corporate Governance Deficiencies p . 24 - 29 VI. Third party
Slide 34: Dedicated SilverArrow program for cost and market leadership
Dedicated SilverArrow program to achieve c ost and market leadership. VII. SilverArrow’s A ction P lan Long Term > 3 years Mid Term 1 - 2 years ▪ Remove unnecessary dual listing in Germany ($500 - 800k )and dual HQ; ▪ Eliminate large consulting spending by the Board and Management ($3 - 5m ); ▪ Cons
Slide 35: Strong operational upside potential for stockholders
VII. SilverArrow’s Action Plan Strong operational u pside potential to the benefit of stockholders. ▪ Streamline technology / product portfolio; focus on high - margin business with substantial growth potential ( i.e. fiber laser in new applications (2.5KW ;>3.0KW; < 2.0KW), USPL and new Ablation, 3
Slide 36: Rofin: A company in need of change!
Rofin: A company in need of change! ▪ We believe that Rofin’s leadership has destroyed stockholder value over the long - term and short - term. ▪ We believe that Rofin shows poor operational performance compared to its peer group. ▪ We believe that the Board composition demonstrates an entrenched bo
Slide 37: Further Information and Supporting Material
VIII. Further Information and Supporting M aterial 37 I For further information please visit www.fixrofin.com .
Slide 38: Current Board of Directors
Current Board of Directors V. Corporate Governance Sources: Rofin definitive proxy statement as of 2016/02/17 Name Affiliation Shares Stock Gen - Age Key Commitees Term Term Tenure 2 Board Member owned 1 options der Audit Comp Nom start end Carl F. Baasel Director 0.41% M 74 1996 2016 20 Up for elec
Slide 39: Key Observations on Rofin's Presentation
Key Observations on Rofin’s Presentation ▪ We believe Rofin uses selective data points and generalities to mask weak historical financial performance . We believe reality shows a different picture: poor company performance compared to its peer group over years and the destruction of stockholder valu
Slide 40: Observations on Rofin's Presentation
40 I Confidential I © SilverArrow Capital LLP Observations on Rofin’s Presentation VIII. Further information and supporting material Rofin Says … Our observation Rofin has a Clearly Defined Strategy to Drive Continued Growth Rofin’s sales and market share keeps losing ground compared to its peers: ▪
Slide 41: Observations on Rofin's Presentation
41 I Confidential I © SilverArrow Capital LLP Observations on Rofin’s Presentation VIII. Further information and supporting material Rofin says … Our observation Results for Seasonally Low Q1 Generally in Line with Management Expectations The Company’s stock price decreased dramatically after the co
Slide 42: Observations on Rofin's Presentation
42 I Confidential I © SilverArrow Capital LLP Observations on Rofin’s Presentation VIII. Further information and supporting material Rofin says … Our observation Mr. Limberger Has a Track Record of Long - Term Value Destruction Mr. Thomas Limberger is a highly experienced corporate restructuring exp
Slide 43: Mr. Daniel Smoke's Lawsuit
Mr. Daniel Smoke’s Lawsuit Mr . Smoke was a defendant in a suit instigated by his former employer, JAC Holding Enterprises, Inc . et al (“JAC”) . The case was being litigated in the U . S . District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan (Detroit), JAC Holding Enterprises, Inc . et al v . Atrium
Slide 44: Mr. Willis and Mr. Fantone's shared board history
Mr. Gary Willis … and Mr. Stephen Fantone … have a past history of serving on numerous boards together, … ▪ In addition to serving together on the board of directors of Rofin, Messrs. Willis and Fantone have also served together on the boards of directors of Zygo Corporation (“ Zygo ”) and Benthos I
Slide 45: Mr. Fantone and the Nominating Committee
We believe Mr. Fantone Demonstrated Another Reason Why This Board Should Not Be Entrusted Mr. Fantone, Head of the Nominating Committee, interviewed one of the Company’s two Chief Operating Officers, Mr. Martin Seifert, in 2013 and it was shocking to us what was said. Mr. Seifert is also the Preside
Slide 46: Letter to Stockholders: Vote the green proxy card
SilverArrow Capital Advisors LLP Ι 3 More London Riverside, 1st Floor Ι London SE1 2RE Ι United Kingdom T: + 44 (0) 20 3637 2185 Ι F: + 44 (0) 20 3014 8671 Ι www.silverarrowcapital.com VOTE THE GREEN PROXY CARD FOR THREE HIGHLY QUALIFIED NEW DIRECTORS AND STOCKHOLDER PROPOSALS TO FIX ROFIN-SINAR TEC
Slide 47: Company's stock performance over the past year
In addition, the Company’s stock performance over the past year has been particularly abysmal. The chart below depicts the total return over the past 12 months, through February 19, 2016, assuming a $100 investment.
Slide 48: Current board has overseen deterioration of sales and margins
*as reported on Rofin’s Form 4 filings with the Securities & Exchange Commission. THE CURRENT BOARD HAS OVERSEEN THE DETERIORATION OF SALES AND POOR MARGINS FOR TOO LONG Deterioration of Relative Sales and Market Share. While the global laser market and Rofin’s peer group average has grown from 2011
Slide 49: Your vote is very important
Your vote is very important, regardless of how many or how few shares you own. If you have any questions, or need assistance in voting your shares, please call our proxy solicitors D.F. King & Co., Inc., which is assisting us, toll-free at (866) 796-7186, call collect at (212) 269-5550 or email fixr
Rofin Sinar Technologies — Proxy Contest (March 2016) on 6ix