NorthWestern Energy Group, Inc. · NASDAQ:NWE
NorthWestern Energy — Technical Presentation (April 2022)
41 slides from NorthWestern Energy's technical presentation, Apr 20, 2022
Slide 1: ETAC Meeting Agenda
ETAC Meeting Agenda April 20, 2022 Item Lead Start Time End Time Kickoff and Introductions S. Schmitt, NorthWestern 9:30 9:40 S. Schmitt Project Status Update 9:40 9:50 NorthWestern D. Millar, B. Mauch Deep Dive on Scenarios and Modeling Process 9:50 11:00 Ascend Analytics Break 11:00 11:10 B. Nelso
Slide 2: Project Schedule
Project Schedule Item Status Timing February ETAC Complete Feb 22, 2022 Ongoing, preliminary ELCC Studies for solar, wind, and storage March – April results shown today April ETAC Today April 20, 2022 Capacity Expansion and Production Cost Runs Not Started May – June June ETAC Not Started June 22, 2
Slide 3: Agenda: Project Status Update
Agenda Project Status Update Scenarios Technology Project Status Mid-C Price and Cost TOC Review Update Forecast Modeling Forecast 3
Slide 4: The Analytical Planning Process
Define ELCC Curves, Technology Objectives, Costs Curves, Constraints Assumptions, and Inputs Using PowerSimm’s ARS least-cost least risk capacity expansion tool Capacity Expansion Runs Test if portfolio meets 0.1 LOLE Metric. Adjust portfolio if needed. The Analytical Check Reliability Planning Proc
Slide 5: Scenario Approach – Core Cases
Scenario Approach – Core Cases • Four capacity expansion runs with various Colstrip retirement dates 1. 12/31/2042 (base case) 2. 12/31/2035 3. 12/31/2030 4. 12/31/2025 • Sensitivity Runs • Add social cost of carbon $50/ton with 5% annual growth rate) • Test SMR replacement of Colstrip at 2030 and 2
Slide 6: Developing an IRP with ARS Process
Developing an IRP with ARS Process Define market • Market Yearly Buildout Schedule assumptions and Prices 700 New Contracts (MW, Nameplate candidate resources • ELCC 600 • PPA costs 500 Capacity) 400 300 Define • GHG constraints • RPS 200 • Reserve 100 Iterate Margin - 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027
Slide 7: Candidate resource list
Candidate resource list Technology/Fuel Resource Size Wind 50 MW Solar 50 MW Renewable Solar Storage hybrid 50 MW Wind Storage hybrid 50 MW Stand Alone Storage 25 MW (4- hour) Stand Alone Storage Storage 25 MW (8-hour) Pumped Hydro 100 MW (9 - hour storage) Aeroderivative gas turbine 50 MW Natural G
Slide 8: What is production cost modeling?
What is production cost modeling? • Production cost modeling is used to project the Q: Why do we dispatch to market prices? physical and economic dynamics of a utility serving customer load in the future A: Because NorthWestern exists within a broader wholesale energy • The core elements are custome
Slide 9: The final analysis: a balancing act
The final analysis: a balancing act $25 Billions $20 We use production cost NPV of Total Portfolio Cost ($) simulation results plus $15 capital expenditures to calculate net present value $10 of candidate portfolios for $5 economic comparison. $- We want to identify the Budg 1A 1B 1C 1D 2 3 4 portfo
Slide 10: Ascend Analytics PowerSIMM for Client Portfolio Simulation
Ascend Analytics PowerSIMM for Client Portfolio Simulation Portfolio Configuration Renewable Dispatchable Hedge Load Generation Assets Instruments Fundamentals Outputs 100s of variables & metrics Long-run on/off-peak Volatility Portfolio Distributions forwards Positions & Payoffs Price RT Price Mean
Slide 11: Example: Simulated Temperature, Load, Gas and Power Prices
Example: Simulated Temperature, Load, Gas and Power Prices SIMULATED WEATHER SIMULATED GAS Iterations SIMULATED LOAD SIMULATED POWER 11
Slide 12: Simulating supply uncertainty in renewable generation
Simulating supply uncertainty in renewable generation Historic Solar Output Historic Wind Output Simulated Solar Output Simulated Wind Output
Slide 13: PowerSimm Reliability Planning
PowerSimm Reliability Planning Simulated renewables Forced outages and Weather drives load and renewable generation & load energy limitations generation Renewables Battery Charge level Loss of Load + = Expectation Simulated Weather Hydro PowerSimm™ captures the Generation interactions of weather→ re
Slide 14: Diagram of LOLE Analysis
Diagram of LOLE Analysis Typically, we plan for the Additional MW Need and Cost by Percentile mean value of the 5,000 $450 MW Needed to reach 2.4 LOLH Average Monthly Customer Bill A more conservative approach simulations to stay below $400 4,000 $350 would be planning to 95th the standard 1 day in
Slide 15: LOLE Example for Capacity Planning
LOLE Example for Capacity Planning Case 1a requires the addition of ~700MW to Firm Up the Portfolio Coal 1&2 retire, replacement resources begin 1A LOLH by Added Capacity 50 45 Average Market Exposure Hours (h) 40 LOLH rises with 35 increasing peak 30 load Addition of 700MW brings 25 Additional NGCC
Slide 16: Resource Adequacy Analysis in Today's Systems
Resource Adequacy Analysis in Today’s Systems Weather is becoming the primary “fuel” o Weather drives uncertainty in load AND generation o In addition to unforeseen outages, there is uncertainty in generation output o Load and generation are no longer independent variables Load Probability Generatio
Slide 17: Resource Adequacy is More Than Peak Load Hours
Resource Adequacy is More Than Peak Load Hours Risk of Capacity Shortfalls Follow Seasonal and Daily Patterns of Load and Renewables o Winter load can be high with electric heat o Spring and fall months generally have lower load and higher wind generation o Summer months see significant risk after s
Slide 18: Why we worry about depth and duration of shortfalls
Why we worry about depth and duration of shortfalls NWE was short resources when the wind died down in February for three days, by on average 500 MW. NWE was forced to rely on the market to fill the energy need.
Slide 19: Effective Load Carrying Capability (ELCC)
Effective Load Carrying Capability (ELCC) Standard ELCC Calculation Process Step 1: Calibrate the base portfolio to 0.1 LOLE target • ELCC analysis determines the capacity contribution for variable resources Add or Remove Firm Loss of Load and energy storage Base Model Capacity for “Adequate Hours =
Slide 20: NWE Load Annual Peaks
NWE Load Annual Peaks Year Peak Load (MW) Season Date Day Hour 2002 958 Summer 7/12/2002 Fri 14 2003 1,078 Summer 7/23/2003 Wed 15 Summer months and 2004 1,096 Winter 1/5/2004 Mon 18 winter months have 2005 1,096 Winter 1/14/2005 Fri 18 2006 1122 Summer 7/28/2006 Fri 14 similar peaks 2007 1,177 Summ
Slide 21: Resource Adequacy Contribution of Solar
Resource Adequacy Contribution of Solar Loss of load hours by month and hour – Base Model 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Jan 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.01 0.02 0.02 0.03 0.02 0 0 0.02 0.01 0.05 0.07 0.04 0.01 0.01 0 0 0 Feb 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.03 0.02 0.02 0.01 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.03 0.06 0
Slide 22: Declining value of ELCC
Declining value of ELCC Solar ELCC Wind ELCC 60% 20% 15% 15% 40% 39% 13% 10% 10% 20% 25% 7% 7% 7% 6% 5% 6% 4% 2% 0% 4% 1% 1% 0% 1% 1% 200 MW 400 MW 600 MW 200 MW 400 MW 600 MW Added Capacity Added Capacity Annual Summer Winter Annual Summer Winter Battery (4hr) ELCC 100% 100% 100% 100% 72% 50% 63% V
Slide 23: Potential QF impact on ELCC
Potential QF impact on ELCC Resource ELCC (200 MW Capacity) The current queue for QF 100% projects in development 8hr Battery 100% 100% 90% includes 80% 72% • 350 MW of solar 70% 4hr Battery 65% 60% • 415 MW of wind 50% • 250 MW of battery 40% (charged from wind or 30% solar) 20% Wind 13% 3% 10% 0%
Slide 24: NWE Base Portfolio with all QFs
NWE Base Portfolio with all QFs Qualifying facilities Capacity by Year double wind and solar in 3000 the next 4 years. 2500 Nameplate Capacity (MW) Accredited Capacity by Year 2000 1600 1500 1400 Accredited Capacity (MW) 1000 1200 1000 500 800 0 600 2021 2023 2025 2027 2029 2031 2033 2035 2037 2039
Slide 25: Agenda: Mid-C Price Forecast
Agenda Project Status Update Scenarios Technology Project Status Mid-C Price and Cost TOC Review Update Forecast Modeling Forecast 25
Slide 26: Ascend Analytics Fundamental Forecasting Framework
Ascend Analytics Fundamental Forecasting Framework Policy and Buildout Price Formation Outputs Macro Assumptions Long-run Supply Stack on/off-peak Volatility Load forwards Climate & Load RPS Policy Growth Ramps Power Flows Market Interconnection RT Price Queue Renewable Price Shapes Spikes Forwards
Slide 27: Forecasting in a bilateral market
Forecasting in a bilateral market Mid-C Supply Stack Average share of demand in Mid-C Capacity Additions Retirements Generation Demand Accreditation EIA – EIA – Hourly demand Regional studies Technology- announced announced from 12 local retirements specific profiles additions utilities Local experi
Slide 28: Clean Energy Growing Across the West
Clean Energy Growing Across the West • California — 60% RPS by 2030, 100% GHG free retail sales by 2045 • Oregon — 100% GHG free by 2040 • Washington — 100% clean energy by 2045, Legislation to achieve 25% below 1990 levels by 2035, phase out coal by 2025 • Idaho — Idaho Power goal of 100% clean by
Slide 29: PNW Supply Evolution: Capacity almost doubles over the forecast period
PNW Supply Evolution: Capacity almost doubles over the forecast period Installed capacity (MW) Share of Share ofgeneration generation(%)(%) Installed Capacity (MW) 120,000 100% 90% 100,000 80% 70% 80,000 60% 60,000 50% 40% 40,000 30% 20% 20,000 10% - 0% 2019 2021 2023 2025 2027 2029 2031 2033 2035 2
Slide 30: Battery buildout compensates for declining effective VRE capacity
Battery buildout compensates for declining effective VRE capacity in late 2020s Capacity Additions (MW) ELCC projections 15,000 100% Capacity Additions (MW) 10,000 80% 60% 5,000 40% 20% - 2022-2025 2026-2030 2031-2035 2036-2040 2041-2045 2046-2050 Wind Offshore wind Solar Biomass Hydro Petroleum Nuc
Slide 31: PNW Demand Evolution: Feeling the heat
PNW Demand Evolution: Feeling the heat 30,000 February – Average Monthly Demand (2015-2021) 30,000 August – Average Monthly Demand (2015-2021) Average Month-hour Demand (MW) Average Month-hour Demand (MW) 25,000 25,000 20,000 20,000 15,000 15,000 10,000 10,000 5,000 5,000 - - 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Slide 32: Supply stacks, prices and empirical relationships drive DA price formation
Supply stacks, prices and empirical relationships drive DA price formation Supply stack & regional fundamentals Forwards & Price History Mid-C Supply Stack AECO Forwards Utility generation profiles Day-Ahead Mid-C On & Off-Peak Forwards Price Formation Utility load profiles Mid-C Price History Renew
Slide 33: The Narrowing On/Off-Peak Gap
The Narrowing On/Off-Peak Gap Gas Forecast Average annual power prices $6.00 $100 Average Power Price ($/MWh) AECO NG Price ($/MMBTU) $5.00 $80 $4.00 $60 $3.00 $2.00 $40 $1.00 $20 $0.00 2027 2043 2021 2023 2025 2029 2031 2033 2035 2037 2039 2041 2045 $- 2019 2024 2029 2034 2039 2044 Hub Forward Pric
Slide 34: Price Depression with Increasing Renewables Occurs Across Markets
Price Depression with Increasing Renewables Occurs Across Markets CAISO ERCOT SPP • Across all markets with substantial renewable penetrations, prices are negatively correlated with renewable generation in both the DA and RT markets • With large amounts of incoming renewables, these price dynamics a
Slide 35: Solar Penetration vs. Price: CAISO Duck Curve Coming to PNW
Solar Penetration vs. Price: CAISO Duck Curve Coming to PNW Solar will have pronounced impacts on net load and prices, as CAISO has already shown: Average net load Average diurnal prices • Implied heat rates decline over time due to renewable entry. As solar penetration increases, mid-day heat rates
Slide 36: Volatility and “ducky” shapes are coming
Volatility and “ducky” shapes are coming DA Price Volatility Month-hour average price shapes 2.5 $70 March $50 May Power Price ($nom/MWh) Power Price ($nom/MWh) $60 2 $40 $50 Forecasted Spot Price Volatility (Residual) $40 $30 $30 $20 1.5 $20 $10 $10 $0 $0 1 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 0 2 4 6 8
Slide 37: Agenda: Technology Cost Forecast
Agenda Project Status Update Scenarios Technology Project Status Mid-C Price and Cost TOC Review Update Forecast Modeling Forecast 37
Slide 38: Technology Cost Forecasts
Technology Cost Forecasts • The modeling team is currently working on long-term cost forecasts for technology costs • Renewables • Thermal gen • Storage • We leverage projections from several data sources • NREL’s Annual Technology Baseline (ATB) -> Waiting for 2022 update in April • Lazard • BNEF •
Slide 39: Agenda: TOC Review
Agenda Project Status Update Scenarios Technology Project Status Mid-C Price and Cost TOC Review Update Forecast Modeling Forecast 39
Slide 40: New Website
New Website • Supply Planning Website: • https://www.northwesternenergy.com/about-us/gas-electric/electric-supply- resource-procurement-plan • Please sign up for the email distribution list: • https://lp.constantcontactpages.com/su/XE0SdNG • Submit portfolio requests and other feedback via the new f
Slide 41: NorthWestern Energy – ETAC Meeting
NorthWestern Energy – ETAC Meeting August 4, 2021 Thank you. 41
NorthWestern Energy Group — Technical Presentation (April 2022) on 6ix