Duke Energy Corporation (Holding Company) · NYSE:DUK
Duke Energy Corporation (Holding Company) — Duke Energy Indiana — Investor Presentation (April 2024)
173 slides from Duke Energy Corporation (Holding Company)'s investor presentation, Apr 29, 2024
Slide 1: 2024 Duke Energy Indiana Integrated Resource Plan
2024 Duke Energy Indiana Integrated Resource Plan Stakeholder Meeting 2 April 29, 2024
Slide 2: Welcome
Welcome
Slide 3: Duke Energy Welcome
Duke Energy Welcome Stan Pinegar State President, Duke Energy Indiana
Slide 4: Safety
Safety
Slide 5: Safety - Eye Wellness
Safety - Eye Wellness To help avoid eye strain, Prevent Blindness recommends the following: Place your screen 20 to 26 inches away and a little bit below eye level. Use a document holder placed next to your screen. It should be close enough, so you don’t have to swing your head back and forth or
Slide 6: Introductions
(= DUKE Se” ENERGY. ‘BUILDING A SMARTER ENERGY FUTURE ® Introductions
Slide 7: Duke Energy Team
Duke Energy Team Integrated Resource Planning Team Matt Kalemba Nate Gagnon Matt Peterson Emma Goodnow Karen Hall Chris Hixson Josh Paragas Tyler Cook Vice President, Managing Director, Resource Market Strategy & Resource Principal Engineer, Engineer, Resource Engineer, Resource Integrated Resource
Slide 8: Agenda
. 7) > § © § xo) ve r= aa SS G%:
Slide 9: Public Stakeholder Meeting #2 Agenda
Public Stakeholder Meeting #2 Agenda Present | Time Duration Discuss Topic Presenter Stan Pinegar, Duke Energy Indiana State President 9:30 5 5|0 Welcome & Safety Karen Hall, Duke Energy Resource Planning Director 9:35 5 5|0 Meeting Guidelines & Agenda Drew Burczyk, Consultant, Resource Planning & M
Slide 10: Meeting Guidelines
Meeting Guidelines
Slide 11: Meeting Ground Rules
Meeting Ground Rules Respect each other: Help us to collectively uphold respect for each other's experiences and opinions, even in difficult conversations. We need everyone’s wisdom to achieve better understanding and develop robust solutions. Focus on today’s topics: Please respect the scope of tod
Slide 12: Participation
Participation There will be several opportunities throughout the presentation for attendees to actively participate by asking questions, making comments and/or otherwise sharing information. Q&A: Please use the “Q&A” feature, on the menu at the bottom of your screen, to submit questions to the pre
Slide 13: Stakeholder Feedback and Incorporation
Stakeholder Feedback and Incorporation
Slide 14: Stakeholder Feedback Received & Incorporated into Meeting #2 Agenda
Stakeholder Feedback Received & Incorporated into Meeting #2 Agenda Feedback, Question, or Requested Information Section of Today’s Meeting How does the IRP account for community impacts related to new resources? IRP Fundamentals, Community Engagement Does the IRP determine where new resources will
Slide 15: Stakeholder Feedback Received & Incorporated into Meeting #2 Agenda
Stakeholder Feedback Received & Incorporated into Meeting #2 Agenda Feedback, Question, or Requested Information Section of Today’s Meeting Include percent CO2 reduction as a scorecard metric Final Scorecard Criteria Review Prefer scorecard metrics are not weighted Final Scorecard Criteria Review Re
Slide 16: Stakeholder Feedback Received & Incorporated into Meeting #2 Agenda
Stakeholder Feedback Received & Incorporated into Meeting #2 Agenda Feedback, Question, or Requested Information Section of Today’s Meeting Current amount of distributed energy resources on DEI system Grid Edge & Customer Programs What is Duke Energy’s plan for distributed energy resources? Grid Edg
Slide 17: Additional Feedback Received and Duke Energy Responses
Additional Feedback Received and Duke Energy Responses Feedback, Question, or Requested Information Response/Update Creating a Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DE&I) This year's IRP will include a discussion of community impact highlighting our and/or environmental justice metric in scorecard. deep
Slide 18: Additional Feedback Received and Duke Energy Responses
Additional Feedback Received and Duke Energy Responses Feedback, Question, or Requested Information Response/Update Will Duke energy provide Scope 3 reporting as part of the IRP? Duke Energy provides information on Scope 3 emissions in its Impact Report. Annual report is available at duke- energy.co
Slide 19: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 20: IRP Fundamentals
(= DUKE Se” ENERGY. ‘BUILDING A SMARTER ENERGY FUTURE ® IRP Fundamentals
Slide 21: What is an Integrated Resource Plan (IRP)?
What is an Integrated Resource Plan (IRP)? An Integrated Resource IRPs balance multiple objectives including system reliability, environmental Plan (IRP) explains how responsibility, and cost impacts. an electric utility will meet ► Least-cost planning principles the projected peak demand ► Reliable
Slide 22: The Indiana IRP Process
The Indiana IRP Process IRPs are Plan is created with 20-year look at Modeling and analysis submitted every Stakeholder input how utility can culminate in a Preferred three years cost-effectively Resource Portfolio serve our customers | 22
Slide 23: Fundamentals of Resource Planning
Fundamentals of Resource Planning Planning to Serve Increasing Energy Needs Questions the IRP can help us answer Load forecast changes What is the expected resource need over the planning horizon? Customer Economic development driving growth Demand What are the tradeoffs associated with diff
Slide 24: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 25: Data Sharing
Data Sharing
Slide 26: Data Sharing
Data Sharing Data related to this meeting Technical Stakeholders has been provided to should have received an Technical Stakeholders who email notification with a have signed a non-disclosure registration link for Datasite, agreement. the secure platform Duke Energy is leveraging to share data a
Slide 27: 2024 DEI IRP Stakeholder Meetings (proposed timeline)
2024 DEI IRP Stakeholder Meetings (proposed timeline) Engaging with our stakeholders in multiple sessions throughout the 2024 IRP process Meeting #1 Meeting #2 Meeting #3 Meeting #4 Meeting #5 February 22nd April 29th 1st half June 2nd half July 1st half Sept Review previous IRP Generic Unit Sum
Slide 28: Community Engagement
Community Engagement
Slide 29: History of community impact
History of community impact Duke Energy has a long history of deep-rooted community engagement and partnerships in Indiana. In 2023, Duke Energy employees and retirees contributed about $418,000 to Indiana nonprofit organizations and contributed more than 13,600 hours in the communities where they l
Slide 30: Infrastructure Engagement
Infrastructure Engagement IRP Public Advisory (we are here) Community Engagement Need Siting Construction Operations | 30
Slide 31: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 32: Load Forecasting Methodology
Load Forecasting Methodology
Slide 33: Duke Energy Indiana Retail Customer Mix
Duke Energy Indiana Retail Customer Mix 2023 Customer Breakdown 2023 Sales Breakdown (MWh) Residential customers account Although C&I make up only 11% of the customer base, for 88% of the 900,000 total they account for two thirds of retail sales. customers in Indiana. The largest 15 customers make u
Slide 34: Key Takeaways
Key Takeaways Load forecasting is not just about a number, but about developing a coherent understanding of relationships between drivers like economics, demographics, and behavior, and future customer energy needs. Allows for understanding of a wide range of possible futures. Allows the Company
Slide 35: Load forecasting methodology overview
Load forecasting methodology overview Inputs Energy Forecast Baseline Forecast and Validation Adjustment Econometric Baseline Data Weather Peak Load UEE, BTM, EV, ED Modeling by Energy Gathering Normalization Forecast Adjustments Customer Class Forecast Historical energy consumption Test all eco
Slide 36: Primary Forecast Drivers by Customer Class
Primary Forecast Drivers by Customer Class Retail Load Residential Commercial Industrial Government Population Gross Domestic Product Manufacturing Employment Income Income Employment Rates Rates Rates Industrial Production Weather Weather Weather Indices Appliance Satura
Slide 37: 2024 Load Forecast Drivers
2024 Load Forecast Drivers Current State: Future State: Population growth (natural increase Consistent and net migration) and the impact on population growth residential customers Economic challenges in Feedback cycle between commercial industrial sector success and residential population
Slide 38: Near-Term Sales Growth Drivers
Near-Term Sales Growth Drivers DEI Weather Normal Sales Growth 13,000 1.4% 12,000 11,000 0.1% 1.4% 10,000 -0.1% 2.6% GWh 9,000 -0.4% 8,000 7,000 Average growth Electric Behind-the- Utility Energy Economic Average growth before impacts Vehicles Meter Solar Efficiency Development after impacts 6,000 R
Slide 39: Economic Development
Economic Development Economic Development Pipeline News grows to 300-500 MW by 2030 Headlines IndyStar Manufacturing Dive New solar cell plant Nucor to build $115M will bring 1,200 jobs to utility structure plant southern Indiana in Indiana Oct 2023 June 2023 Kokomo Tribune WLFI.com Stellantis, Sams
Slide 40: Load Scenario Assumptions
Load Scenario Assumptions Electric Behind-the- Economic Economics Electrification Vehicles Meter Solar Development Low Case 90/10 Low Adoption High Adoption Low (25%) Base Base Case 50/50 Base Adoption Base Adoption Base (~60%) Base High Case 10/90 High Adoption Low Adoption Higher (75%) Base Ultra-
Slide 41: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 42: Break
fs DUKE SS” ENERGY. SMARTER ENERGY FUTURE’ Break
Slide 43: EV Forecast
(= DUKE Se” ENERGY. )ING A SMARTER ENERGY FUTURE EV Forecast
Slide 44: Electric Vehicle Modeling – Guidehouse VAST
Electric Vehicle Modeling – Guidehouse Vehicle Analytics and Simulation Tool (“VAST”) | 44
Slide 45: EV Forecast Model Sources
EV Forecast Model Sources The VAST model is updated biannually by Guidehouse, and the Spring 2024 forecast inputs were gathered end of year 2023 Vehicle Adoption Charging Load Impacts Inputs Description Source Inputs Description Source Vehicle US vehicle registration by make, model Vehicle Adoption
Slide 46: EV Adoption Base Forecast Comparison
EV Adoption Base Forecast Comparison Base EV Projections Reflects impacts of IRA incentives, IIJA, additional EV EV % of New Vehicle Sales 80% models, OEM electrification pledges, internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicle bans in CA and other states to increase 70% vehicle availability Spring 202
Slide 47: EV Alternate Scenarios
EV Alternate Scenarios Multiple EV adoption scenarios were developed to capture a broad range of EV adoption possibilities Low Base High Ultra-High Higher EV Cost Lower EV Cost (~5% increase in MSRP) (~5% decrease in MSRP) EV adoption scaled to meet a Key Assumption Lower EV availability and B
Slide 48: Key Results/Takeaways
Key Results/Takeaways There has been a Currently EVs are a The forecasted substantial increase small portion of total scenarios (Low, in forecasted electric electric usage Base, High, and vehicle adoption since (< 0.2% of total Ultra-High) are the 2021 DEI IRP system energy), designed to capture but
Slide 49: Behind-the-Meter (BTM) Distributed Resource Forecasting
Behind-the-Meter (BTM) Distributed Resource Forecasting
Slide 50: Customer-Owned BTM Solar Capacity
Customer-Owned BTM Solar Capacity DEI BTM Capacity Customers DEI’s current capacity from customer-owned behind-the- meter DERs through the end of February 2024. Solar Only 81.0 MW 3,677 Notes: Does not include large distribution or Solar + Storage 5.8 MW 582 transmission projects Solar paired wi
Slide 51: Forecasting Behind-the-Meter (BTM) Solar
Forecasting Behind-the-Meter (BTM) Solar Forecasted Adoptions Based on the regression Historical Payback equation and the forecasted future payback curve Based on market data Projected Payback Economic view based on: System Size Regression Model System Cost Based on historical connections Develops
Slide 52: DEI Behind-the-Meter Solar History
DEI Behind-the-Meter Solar History BTM adoption counts peaked in 2022 Factors influencing historical trends Recent trends in adoption influence State policy changes Fuel price volatility Investment Tax Credits (ITC) Macroeconomic trends future projections Solar panel prices Maturin
Slide 53: Behind-the-Meter Solar Base Forecast
Behind-the-Meter Solar Base Forecast BTM Solar Adoption & Capacity Forecast 2024 IRP base forecast relative to previous: 2024 IRP MW 2021 IRP MW 2024 IRP Connections 2021 IRP Connections Higher customer adoption, but only 25,000 450 slight increase in BTM generation as percent 400 of total system
Slide 54: Behind-the-Meter Solar Alternate Scenarios
Behind-the-Meter Solar Alternate Scenarios Low Base High Ultra-High Scaled to meet a stakeholder- provided scenario of 25% Payback model adjustments Payback model adjustments Key Assumption adoption by year end 2040 High system costs Base Case Low system costs Differences Removal of ITC cr
Slide 55: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 56: Grid Edge & Customer Programs
Grid Edge & Customer Programs
Slide 57: Integrated System Planning and Operations
Integrated System Planning and Operations Generation: bulk Transmission: bulk Distribution: lines Customer: DERs such as energy production power transmission, that bring power to customer sited solar and facilities typically at or above customers, typically 12 demand response 100 kV to 34 kV Why int
Slide 58: What is the Grid Edge?
What is the Grid Edge? Bulk Electric System Distribution Grid Customer Grid Edge Reliable Affordable Clean ? What is the value to our customers? Engaging with our customers to reduce and manage load at the Grid Edge can be cost-effective | 58
Slide 59: Grid Edge Programs
Grid Edge Programs Technology Energy Examples of Resources and Emerging Opportunities Voltage optimization Integrated Volt Var Control Baseload: Eliminates demand Demand response / Distributed Capacity Residential programs Managed Charging Peaker Plant / Reserves: RESOURCES Functions like a gas CT o
Slide 60: Control Systems
Control Systems Generation Transmission Distribution Customer Customer Energy Control System Business Rules Engine Data Fabric & Integration Layer Forecast Customer / SAP AMI EMS ADMS Customer DERMS System-Wide Control Hyper-Local Control We can only achieve We can achieve system-wide levels Targete
Slide 61: Grid Edge | Demand Response
Grid Edge | Demand Response Current State: Demand Response (kW) Future State: Demand Response (MW) 500 BYOT 33,535 450 400 PM Business 5,327 350 300 PM Water Heating 244 MW 250 200 Power Manager 67,223 150 PowerShare / Savings on 100 Demand 236,519 50 0 Total 342,848 2024 2030 | 61
Slide 62: Grid Edge Opportunity
Grid Edge Opportunity managed circuit load profile Opportunities: Customer Programs: normal circuit load profile Energy Efficiency DR (Residential, C&I) Active Demand Response Bring Your Own Thermostat Distribution Batteries TOUs (EV, Res, etc.) Distribution Renewables Potential Futu
Slide 63: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 64: Market Potential Study
Market Potential Study
Slide 65: Demand-Side Management Market Potential Study
PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Demand-Side | 2024 Management Market © RESOURCE INNOVATIONS Potential Study Duke Energy Indiana | April 2024 HALF MOON BAY, CA. + CHICAGO, IL.. + SALT LAKE CITY, UT. + BOULDER, CO. + TORONTO, ON. + ST. LOUIS, MO . + MADISON, WI. + CHANDLER, AZ.
Slide 66: Agenda
Agenda PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL 1 Introduction to Resource Innovations 5 Summary 2 DSM Market Potential and the IRP Process | 2024 3 Overview of MPS Concepts © RESOURCE INNOVATIONS 4 Key MPS Components 66
Slide 67: RI Services and Software
RI Services and Software Providing Innovative Technology-Enabled PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Advisory Services Software, Services, and Consulting. Research & Measurement Planning & Design Analytics & Strategic Consulting Grid Modernization Utility DSM Residential & Income Qualified Commercial, Indust
Slide 68: Broad geographic reach combined with deep client relationships
Broad geographic reach combined PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL with deep client relationships Advisory Services • 25+ US and Canada customers • Highly skilled team of experts • End-to-end utility services Utility DSM • 90+ Utility Customers | • Geographically diversified customer base • 99% Customer ret
Slide 69: DSM Market Potential and the IRP Process
© RESOURCE INNOVATIONS 2024 | PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL DSM Market Potential and the IRP Process 69
Slide 70: DSM Market Potential Analysis
DSM Market Potential PROPRIATARY & CONFIDENTIAL Analysis Our analysis identifies opportunities for energy efficiency, demand response, and distributed energy resources. We examine all customer types and electricity end uses to find ways that utility programs can engage with customers to support ener
Slide 71: Project Goals
Project Goals PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Technical, Economic, and Achievable Potential over a 25-year Study Period, with Estimates of 5-year, 10-year, and 25-year Energy and Demand Savings | 2024 Achievable Potential Estimates for Cost-effective Program Offers: © RESOURCE INNOVATIONS • Energy Effici
Slide 72: Market Potential Studies & IRPs
Market Potential Studies & IRPs PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL WE ARE HERE IN THIS PROCESS 2021-2023 CREATE DUKE ENERGY PREFERRED DSM DUKE ENERGY IRP INPUTS IRP PORTFOLIO FILING DSM PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION | MODELING 2024 © RESOURCE INNOVATIONS File Portfolio of Realistic Achievable IRP Resource Programs
Slide 73: Market Potential Follows a Stepwise Workflow
Market Potential Follows a Stepwise Workflow PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL The framework for analyzing market potential was established in 2007 under the National Action Plan for Energy Efficiency. The stages of market potential are designed to ensure broad consideration of measure opportunities, and f
Slide 74: Study Workflow
Study Workflow PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Kickoff /Data Collection Baseline Measures Modeling Reporting | 2024 Vision of study Characterize Conduct research on Model technical, © RESOURCE INNOVATIONS parameters Deliver reports and local market, residential, economic, data Key items to consider exist
Slide 75: Description of MPS Concepts
© RESOURCE INNOVATIONS 2024 | PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Description of MPS Concepts 75
Slide 76: Overall Process
© RESOURCE INNOVATIONS 2024 | PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Overall Process 76
Slide 77: Forecast Disaggregation and DSM Potential
Forecast Disaggregation and DSM Potential PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL 1 2 3 Customer Saturations End Use, Fuel Type, Customer Classes Base Forecast Remove Planned 4 Consumption Sector, Segment Equipment Economic Sector, DSM Segment | 7 6 5 2024 © RESOURCE INNOVATIONS Calibration Forecast End Use Veri
Slide 78: Electricity Sales Forecast Decomposition
© RESOURCE INNOVATIONS 2024 | PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Electricity Sales Forecast Decomposition 78
Slide 79: Seasonal Load Disaggregation (Residential, SMB)
Seasonal Load Disaggregation (Residential, SMB) PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Analysis Based on Sample or Census AMI Data for Residential and Small/Medium Businesses Regression Analysis to Quantify Weather Responsive Load at Peak Actual Usage Predicted Baseline 3 • Cooling Degree Days, Heating Degree D
Slide 80: Seasonal Load Reduction Capacity, Large Commercial
Seasonal Load Reduction Capacity, Large Commercial PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Analysis Based on Census AMI Data Key Assumptions of Total, Short-term Load Shed for a Suitable Price/Incentive • Customer Loads at System Peak • Large C&I Customers More Flexible in Scheduling, Contracting | • Individual,
Slide 81: Technology Research
Technology Research PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL We develop a robust set of all commercially-available Define the Features of the Measure technologies to consider in the study. Our model applies the 1 What is the baseline technology? How much energy can efficient tech. save? technologies to the market
Slide 82: Measure Characterization
Measure Characterization Measure data required: Measure sources: • Efficient and baseline technology characteristics • Indiana TRM • Equipment and labor costs • Nexant measure library platform • Equipment useful life • Input from OSB • Energy and demand savings • Custom measures and new technologies
Slide 83: Measure Library
Measure Library resource Home — Apu 00Cs HELP RESETPASSWoRD Loc QUT innovations getgtomeron wth NEXT ody Collection-level Variables + Add Collection-level Equation Variable ceneraL | messuaes | components | vaRiaates on a Info Files Name Value ‘Short Desc. @ Name: Duke Energy MPS Indiana Duke_Energy
Slide 84: Key MPS Components
© RESOURCE INNOVATIONS 2024 | PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Key MPS Components 84
Slide 85: The Model
The Model PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Stock-and-Flow • Current customers, sales, efficiency (stock). • Changes in sales, customers, efficiency levels, equipment turnover, codes & standards (flow). • Apply technologies to customers, end uses; retrofit and/or replace with efficient technology. • Total
Slide 86: Technical Potential (EE)
Technical Potential (EE) Technical Base Case Potential Total Equipment Saturation Percent Feasibility Savings of Number of Energy Use Shares Incomplete Factor Factor Efficient Households Intensity Measures (kWh/unit) • Measures ranked by savings % • Applied to baseline “equipment forecast” • Dealing
Slide 87: Economic Potential
Economic Potential PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Duke Energy and OSB Stakeholders Use the Utility Cost Test Features of the UCT Test • Compares Utility Cost of a Program Offer to Avoided Energy, Capacity, and T&D • Incorporates All Utility Costs: Incentive and Administrative • Consistent with DSM Progr
Slide 88: Achievable Potential
Achievable Potential PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL 80% 70% 60% Acceptance Rate 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 0 5 10 15 | Simple Payback Years 2024 © RESOURCE INNOVATIONS Incorporates Expected Market Response to Cost-Effective Offers • Customer Payback Acceptance is Long-run Market Share • Competing Measures a
Slide 89: High-Resolution Output
High-Resolution Output PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL • Expected Utility Costs and Benefits from Program Offerings • Energy and Load Impacts by Economic Sector, Customer Segment, Electricity End Use, and Construction Vintage • Anticipated Energy and Load Impacts for Each Year of the Planning Period • Ro
Slide 90: Thank you!
© RESOURCE INNOVATIONS 2024 | PROPRIETARY & CONFIDENTIAL Thank you! 90
Slide 91: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 92: Break
fs DUKE SS” ENERGY. SMARTER ENERGY FUTURE’ Break
Slide 93: Supply-Side Resources
Supply-Side Resources Generic Unit Summary & Resource Availability
Slide 94: Generic Unit Summary "GUS" Development
Generic Unit Summary “GUS” Development Resource Sources Internal Review: Final Output: GUS Technology Specific Review and Comparison Resource specific costs Overnight cost estimates by: RFP also informs Configuration Renewables & Storage renewables, storage, gas Region Fixed Charge Rate for Inte
Slide 95: Overnight Capital Costs | Thermal
Overnight Capital Costs | Thermal 1200 Gas CT Gas CC 1400 2023 CPCN 2024 IRP 2023 CPCN 2024 IRP 1000 1200 $/kW (real$ 2024) 1000 $/kW (real$ 2024) 800 800 600 600 400 400 200 200 0 0 Project Start Year Project Start Year Gas CC w/CCS Nuclear SMR 4000 12000 2023 CPCN 2024 IRP 2023 CPCN 2024 IRP 3500
Slide 96: Overnight Capital Costs | Renewables & Storage
Overnight Capital Costs | Renewables & Storage Solar Tracking Wind 2000 2500 2023 CPCN 2024 IRP 2023 CPCN 2024 IRP 2000 1500 $/kW (real$2024) $/kW (real$ 2024) 1500 1000 1000 500 500 0 0 Project Start Year Project Start Year Battery Storage 2500 2023 CPCN 2024 IRP 2000 $/kW (real$ 2024) 1500 1000 50
Slide 97: Low Renewables & Storage Cost in Aggressive Policy & Rapid Innovation Scenario
Low Renewables & Storage Cost in Aggressive Policy & Rapid Innovation Scenario The Aggressive Policy & Rapid Innovation “worldview" includes lower renewable and storage costs than the Reference Case Propose to use the NREL ATB 2023 Advanced case cost decline curves for future solar costs DEI’s
Slide 98: Annual Resource Availability | Thermal
Annual Resource Availability (Interconnection Timing, BOY) | Thermal Resource Aggressive Policy & Minimum Policy & Reference Case Basis for Assumption Type Rapid Innovation Lagging Innovation 2031+: Two HA.03 (851 MW) Assessment of resource availability and CT 2031+: Two HA.03 (851 MW) Reference H2
Slide 99: Annual Resource Availability | Renewables & Storage
Annual Resource Availability (Interconnection Timing, BOY) | Renewables & Storage Resource Aggressive Policy & Minimum Policy & Reference Case Basis for Assumption Type Rapid Innovation Lagging Innovation 2026: 199 MW 2026: 199 MW 2027: 300 MW 2027: 300 MW Added capacity to 2023 & 2024 queues, Solar
Slide 100: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 101: Fuels
(= DUKE Se” ENERGY. ‘BUILDING A SMARTER ENERGY FUTURE ® Fuels
Slide 102: Fuel Prices – Overview
Fuel Prices – Overview The fuel price curves are constructed from three components: Years 1-5 Years 6-8 Years 9 and beyond (2025-2029) (2030-2032) (2033 and beyond) Forward Long-term Market Blend Fundamentals Gas – Interpolate between Composite of outlook NYMEX Henry Hub (March 20, 2024) forwards an
Slide 103: Fuel Prices – Natural Gas and Coal
Fuel Fuel Prices Prices – Natural – Natural Gas Gas and Coal Gas Price by Case - Henry Hub Natural Gas Price - Local Hub 12.0 8.0 10.0 7.0 $/MMBtu (Nominal $) $/MMBtu (Nominal $) 6.0 8.0 5.0 6.0 4.0 3.0 4.0 2.0 2.0 1.0 0.0 0.0 Reference Low High Henry Hub REX Z3 Coal Price by Case - Illinois Basin 9
Slide 104: Commodity Price Trends
Commodity Commodity Price Prices Trends – 2021 vs 2022 GAS COAL Short term pricing across the region Short term pricing for Illinois Basin has has decreased considerably due to decreased considerably after the robust supply coupled with delays in record highs seen in 2022 due to low new LNG expo
Slide 105: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 106: Accreditation/Reserve Margin
Accreditation/ Reserve Margin
Slide 107: Planning Reserve Margin
Planning Reserve Margin Would require To help ensure future system reliability in the face of Winter Day reserve of forecast uncertainty, utilities carry a certain amount of 5,000 1,224 MW capacity above projected peak load. 4,500 Total capacity requirement = peak load + Planning Reserve 4,000 I
Slide 108: Resource Accreditation
Resource Accreditation Is the calculation of how much capacity a PY23-24 Summer Fall Winter Spring specific resource is accredited compared Resource to the installed capacity. Class Current Proposed Current Proposed Current Proposed Current Proposed MISO (along with its stakeholders and Gas 90%
Slide 109: New Unit Accreditation in Modeling Overview
New Unit Accreditation in Modeling Overview Plan to monitor MISO For MISO Market runs For IRP runs updates (D-LOL) Non-dispatchable resources Non-dispatchable Propose using D-LOL as Start with proposed MISO For each scenario, look at base case assumption in seasonal D-LOL values installed
Slide 110: Reliability Verification: Motivation and Modeling
Reliability Verification: Motivation and Modeling Integration into the MISO market is a fundamental component of reliability for DEI, and DEI supports MISO through reliably operating generating resources and ultimately supporting its firm load obligations to customers. The PRMR is influenced by
Slide 111: Reliability Verification: Measurement
Reliability Verification: Measurement Reliability verification process measures how well the DEI portfolio performs in serving DEI customer loads relative to a near-future benchmark. Not targeting 0.1 event-days/year LOLE for DEI in isolation – this reliability threshold is a property of the inter
Slide 112: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 113: Power Price Development
Power Price Development
Slide 114: Power Price Development
Power Price Development Use EnCompass to simulate Horizon Energy developed National Database. Make updates to align with IRP assumptions Natural gas forecast Coal forecast CO2 tax New resource costs Unique simulation performed for each IRP Scenario Hourly LMPs from MISO wide analysis
Slide 115: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 116: Scenarios & Generation Strategies Review
Scenarios & Generation Strategies Review
Slide 117: Modeling Scenarios | "Worldviews"
Modeling Scenarios | “Worldviews” Goal: Develop scenarios that (A) reflect vastly different future outcomes than the reference case and (B) where the fundamental drivers of those divergent futures could plausibly impact many resource plan modeling inputs. | 117
Slide 118: Considerations
Considerations Scenarios and sensitivities should not be construed as policy goals. The Aggressive Policy & Rapid Innovation and Minimum Policy & Lagging Innovation scenarios are not predictions of the future. Instead, they are vastly varying futures developed to intentionally push the boundarie
Slide 119: Proposed Scenarios | Variables Across Worldviews
Proposed Scenarios | Variables Across Worldviews Resource Distributed Renewables & Emerging CAA 111 Coal Price Gas Price IRA Availability CO2 Tax Resources Storage Cost Technology (interconnection timing) (incl. net metering) Extend + High Renew. Avail. Aggressive Policy & Phases LDES & High High Do
Slide 120: Scenario Narrative | Aggressive Policy & Rapid Innovation
Scenario Narrative | Aggressive Policy & Rapid Innovation Resource Distributed Renewables & Emerging CAA 111 Coal Price Gas Price IRA Availability CO2 Tax Resources Storage Cost Technology (interconnection timing) (incl. net metering) Extend + High Renew. Avail. Aggressive Policy & Phases LDES & Hig
Slide 121: Scenario Narrative | Minimum Policy & Lagging Innovation
Scenario Narrative | Minimum Policy & Lagging Innovation Resource Distributed Renewables & Emerging CAA 111 Coal Price Gas Price IRA Availability CO2 Tax Resources Storage Cost Technology (interconnection timing) (incl. net metering) Advanced Minimum Policy & Repeal Low Low Repeal Base None Base Low
Slide 122: Generation Strategies Summary
Generation Strategies Summary 2024 IRP Generation Strategies Stakeholder Strategies Predefined Retirements Optimized Retirements Optimized Ret. Predefined Ret. Tech Agnostic Tech Agnostic Coal Retirement Coal Retirement No New Tech Agnostic Out of Coal Aggressive Policy & Minimum Policy & Carbon Cap
Slide 123: Coal Retirements (EOY) by Generation Strategy
Coal Retirements (EOY) by Generation Strategy 2024 IRP Generation Strategies Predefined Optimized Stakeholder Strategies Retirements Retirements Optimized Ret. Predefined Ret. Tech Agnostic Tech Agnostic 2023 IRP CPCN Coal Ret. Coal Ret. No New Tech Agnostic Out of Coal Unit 2021 IRP Aggressive Poli
Slide 124: Risk Analysis | Sensitivities
Risk Analysis | Sensitivities Proposed Sensitivities for 2024 IRP Modeling: Sensitivity: Single Variable LOW Sensitivity analysis stresses a single LOW variable while holding all else constant to Resource Load HIGH Technology isolate the impact of that variable. Capital Costs This provides insight i
Slide 125: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 126: Break
fs DUKE SS” ENERGY. SMARTER ENERGY FUTURE’ Break
Slide 127: Scorecard Metrics
(= DUKE Se” ENERGY. ‘BUILDING A SMARTER ENERGY FUTURE ® Scorecard Metrics
Slide 128: House Enrolled Act (HEA) 1007 Requirements | 5 Pillars
House Enrolled Act (HEA) 1007 Requirements | 5 Pillars Reliability Resiliency Stability Environmental Affordability Sustainability Adequacy of Ability of system Ability of an (A) Impact of Retail electric electric service: to: (A) adapt to electric system to environmental utility service that (A) th
Slide 129: Planning Objectives will guide selection of Preferred Portfolio
Planning Objectives will guide selection of Preferred Portfolio “Preferred resource portfolio Affordability means the utility’s selected long term supply-side and demand- Reliability side resource mix that safely, Environmental Sustainability reliably, efficiently, and cost- effectively meets the el
Slide 130: Additional Scorecard Feedback Considered/Incorporated
Additional Scorecard Feedback Considered/Incorporated Feedback Response Recommend examining both the near-term and total for each measure: • “Near-Term” - reflect how portfolio performs over first decade of the IRP Partially incorporated Overall analysis period to assess near-term impacts Will inclu
Slide 131: Additional Scorecard Feedback Considered/Incorporated
Additional Scorecard Feedback Considered/Incorporated Feedback Response The peak availability of on-system resources does not necessarily align with the Incorporated hours in which there is a risk of resource inadequacy since Duke a small piece of Shifted assessment from Duke Energy peak to Reliabil
Slide 132: Additional Scorecard Feedback Considered/Incorporated
Additional Scorecard Feedback Considered/Incorporated Feedback Response HHI metrics for resource diversity and fuel diversity do not get at the meaning of Partially incorporated resilience. Removed fuel diversity metric Resiliency Performance in a 95th percentile extreme weather event, paired with a
Slide 133: Additional Scorecard Feedback Considered/Incorporated
Additional Scorecard Feedback Considered/Incorporated Feedback Response Market exposure metric is similar to the proposed reliability metric (market Incorporated Market Exposure reliance), which means if both are used, the metric is effectively double counted. Market exposure included only as risk m
Slide 134: Measures of Environmental Sustainability & Affordability
Measures of Environmental Sustainability & Affordability Planning Measure Description Purpose Objective CO2 Emissions Percent CO2 reduction from 2005 baseline at Allows comparison of pace of emissions Environmental Reduction specified years (2035, 2044) reduction Sustainability Cumulative CO2 Cumula
Slide 135: Measures of Reliability & Resiliency
Measures of Reliability & Resiliency Planning Measure Description Purpose Objective Availability of On- On-demand MW as percentage of peak load Ability of the portfolio to provide energy ‘on- System Resources in during MISO high-risk resource adequacy demand’ during high-risk hours High-Risk Hours h
Slide 136: Measures of Risk & Uncertainty
Measures of Risk & Uncertainty Planning Measure Description Purpose Objective Maximum PVRR and the range between Min Cost Risk & Certainty Indicates risk of cost variance and high-cost Cost Risk ($B) & Max PVRRs across scenario and risk outcomes across different potential futures analysis Total PVRR
Slide 137: Q&A
Q&A
Slide 138: Open Q&A
Open Q&A
Slide 139: Thank you
Thank you
Slide 140: Next Steps
Next Steps Additional questions, comments, and feedback can be sent to [email protected] The third technical meeting will occur in early June. The next public stakeholder meeting will occur in first half of June. Meeting registration will be sent out 4-6 weeks in advance. | 140
Slide 141: Appendix
Appendix
Slide 142: Appendix: DEI Emissions, Energy, & Capacity Mix
Appendix: DEI Emissions, Energy, & Capacity Mix
Slide 143: Duke Energy Indiana Carbon Emissions
Duke Energy Indiana Carbon Emissions Note: Scope 1 | 143
Slide 144: Energy & Capacity Mix Over Time
Energy & Capacity Mix Over Time | 144
Slide 145: Appendix: DEI Customer Programs
Appendix: DEI Customer Programs
Slide 146: Special Assistance Programs
Special Assistance Programs Duke Energy offers several programs and resources to assist customers in times of uncertainty, including Installment Plans Due Date Extensions Financial Assistance Energy Assistance Program Share the Light Fund 211.org For more information about Duke Energy’s
Slide 147: Energy Efficiency Programs
Energy Efficiency Programs | 147
Slide 148: Appendix: Domestic Content Bonus Assumptions
Appendix: Domestic Content Bonus Assumptions
Slide 149: Domestic Content Bonus Considerations
Domestic Content Bonus Considerations The IRA has added a bonus of +10% ITC or a 1.1x PTC for new carbon free generation built with domestic materials There will be a cost premium for domestic content which will offset most of the PTC bonus Domestic content qualification is very complicated as
Slide 150: Aggressive Policy & Rapid Innovation Scenario assumes additional capture of IRA Domestic Content Bonus
Aggressive Policy & Rapid Innovation Scenario assumes additional capture of IRA Domestic Content Bonus for Renewables Base Base Reference Aggressive Policy & Rapid Innovation (PTC->45Y) (ITC-> 48) Domestic Content Bonus Domestic Content Bonus Solar Pre-2030 Yes No No No Solar 2030-2034 Yes No No 100
Slide 151: Appendix: Load Forecasting Results
Appendix: Load Forecasting Results
Slide 152: Forecasting Process
Forecasting Process EXTERNAL DATA INTERNAL DATA Initial Forecast: Customer Growth Efficiency trends Large Account trends Load Shapes MWh Sales MW Peaks Multiple Itron SAE modeling runs Strategic Issues Appliance saturations Appliance status Rate Design IVVC EV Load Forecast Other Weather
Slide 153: Historical Customer and Energy Usage Trends: 2014-2023
Historical Customer and Energy Usage Trends: 2014-2023 Total Customers Total Retail Sales Monthly Peak Trends 1,000,000 30,000,000 6,000.00 29,000,000 900,000 28,000,000 5,000.00 27,000,000 800,000 MWh 26,000,000 4,000.00 Customers MW 700,000 25,000,000 24,000,000 Years CAGR (%) 3,000.00 600,000 23,
Slide 154: Historical Residential Trends: 2014-2023
Historical Residential Trends: 2014-2023 Residential Customers Residential Sales 900000 10,000,000 9,500,000 800000 9,000,000 700000 8,500,000 Customers MWh 8,000,000 600000 7,500,000 COVID 500000 7,000,000 Years CAGR (%) 2014-2023 -0.11 Years CAGR (%) 6,500,000 400000 2019-2023 0.06 2014-2023 1.21
Slide 155: Historical Commercial Trends: 2014-2023
Historical Commercial Trends: 2014-2023 Commercial Customers Commercial Sales 120,000 7,000,000 110,000 6,500,000 6,000,000 100,000 Customers MWh 5,500,000 90,000 5,000,000 COVID 80,000 Years CAGR (%) 4,500,000 2014-2023 0.04 Years CAGR (%) 70,000 2019-2023 0.30 2014-2023 0.68 4,000,000 2019-2023 0.
Slide 156: Residential and Commercial Usage Per Customer: 2014-2023
Residential and Commercial Usage Per Customer: 2014-2023 Residential Usage per Customer (UPC) Commercial Usage per Customer (UPC) 16 75 14 70 12 65 10 60 MWh 8 55 MWh 6 50 Years CAGR (%) 4 45 2014-2023 -1.31 2 Years CAGR (%) 2019-2023 -0.98 40 0 2014-2023 -0.62 35 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Slide 157: End-Use Trends: History and Forecast
End-Use Trends: History and Forecast Residential end-use energy intensity forecast is produced by Itron. Residential End-Use Shares Residential End-Use Intensities 140% 4000 Cooling 3500 Misc. 120% kWh per household 3000 100% Misc. & Lighting 2500 80% 2000 60% 1500 Heating 40% Heating 1000 Cooling &
Slide 158: Historical Industrial Trends: 2014-2023
Historical Industrial Trends: 2014-2023 Industrial Customers Industrial Sales 2900 12,000,000 2700 11,000,000 2023 Weakness 2500 10,000,000 Customers MWh 2300 9,000,000 2100 8,000,000 COVID Years CAGR (%) 1900 7,000,000 2014-2023 -1.79 Years CAGR (%) 2019-2023 -2.83 1700 2014-2023 -0.22 6,000,000 20
Slide 159: Current Industrial Landscape
Current Industrial Landscape Indiana Top Industrial Sectors | 159
Slide 160: Residential Sales Forecast
Residential Sales Forecast Residential MWh Sales Residential Customers Avg. Growth Spring 2024 Avg. Growth Spring 2024 14,000,000 2025-2034 1.37% 2025-2034 1.08% 2035-2044 1.19% 2035-2044 0.48% 13,000,000 950,000 2025-2044 1.27% 2025-2044 0.76% 12,000,000 900,000 11,000,000 850,000 Customers MWh 10,
Slide 161: Commercial Sales Forecast
Commercial Sales Forecast Commercial MWh Sales Commercial Customers Avg. Growth Spring 2024 Avg. Growth Spring 2024 10,000,000 108,000 2025-2034 1.53% 2025-2034 0.57% 9,500,000 2035-2044 1.78% 106,000 2035-2044 0.26% 2025-2044 1.66% 2025-2044 0.41% 9,000,000 104,000 102,000 8,500,000 100,000 8,000,0
Slide 162: Industrial Sales Forecast
Industrial Sales Forecast Industrial MWh Sales Avg. Growth Spring 2024 14,000,000 2025-2034 1.58% 13,000,000 2035-2044 0.50% 2025-2044 1.01% 12,000,000 11,000,000 10,000,000 MWh 9,000,000 Growth in industrial sales driven by increases in industry output of the current DEI mix of industrial sectors
Slide 163: Total Retail Sales Forecast
Total Retail Sales Forecast Total Retail MWh Sales Avg. Growth Spring 2024 40,000,000 2025-2034 1.42% 38,000,000 2035-2044 1.00% 2025-2044 1.20% 36,000,000 34,000,000 32,000,000 MWh 30,000,000 28,000,000 26,000,000 24,000,000 22,000,000 20,000,000 2021 IRP 2023 IRP Refresh 2023 Fall Modeling 2024 IR
Slide 164: Retail Sales by Class - Spring 2024 Forecast
Retail Sales by Class - Spring 2024 Forecast Retail MWh Sales by Large Customer Segments 14,000,000 12,000,000 10,000,000 8,000,000 MWh 6,000,000 4,000,000 2,000,000 0 Residential Commercial Industrial Government | 164
Slide 165: DEI Annual Retail Gen IRP Peak Load Factor Components
DEI Annual Retail Gen IRP Peak Load Factor Components Total System Peak MW - 2024 IRP 6,600 6,400 6,200 MW 6,000 5,800 5,600 5,400 | 165
Slide 166: Appendix: D-LOL Accreditation
Appendix: D-LOL Accreditation
Slide 167: D-LOL Accreditation
D-LOL Accreditation Direct-LOL results using latest Planning Year (PY), results from the non-thermal evaluation and the 2022 Regional Resource Assessment (RRA) portfolios PY: Planning year | F1: Future 1 | RRA: Regional Resource Assessment | ICAP: Installed Capacity | D-LOL: Direct Loss of Load Sour
Slide 168: Appendix: EV Forecast
Appendix: EV Forecast
Slide 169: Vehicle Analysis and Simulation Tool (VAST) EV adoption model
Vehicle Analysis and Simulation Tool (“VAST”) EV adoption model Key Outputs Output Description EV Sales Number of units per year Total units in operation in a EV given year, accounting for Population cumulative sales and scrappage Year 2021-2030 US States, plus Targeted Location Cities, at the Censu
Slide 170: Vehicle Analysis and Simulation Tool (VAST) Load Impacts Model
Vehicle Analysis and Simulation Tool (“VAST”) Load Impacts Model Key Outputs Output Description System State-Territory level Geography Charging use case, examples Use Case include Public Market and Private Depot Duty Light, Medium, Heavy Technology L1, L2, DC Year 2021-2040 Day of Week/ Hourly, Week
Slide 171: Appendix: Acronyms
(= DUKE Se” ENERGY. ILDING A SMARTER ENERGY FUTURE’ Appendix: Acronyms
Slide 172: Acronyms
Acronyms ADMS Advanced Distribution Management System ED Economic Development ADP Advanced Distribution Planning EDG Excess Distributed Generation AMI Advanced Metering Infrastructure EE Energy Efficiency ATB Annual Technology Baseline EMS Energy Management System BEV Battery Electric Vehicle EOY En
Slide 173: Acronyms
Acronyms IURC Indiana Utility regulatory Commission PPA Power Purchase Agreement IVVC Integrated Volt/VAR Control PRMR Planning Reserve Margin Requirement kV Kilovolt PTC Production Tax Credit kW Kilowatt PV Photovoltaic LD Light Duty PVRR Present Value Revenue Requirement LDES Long Duration Energy
Duke Energy Indiana — Investor Presentation (April 2024) on 6ix