Anchor Bancorp

Anchor Bancorp — Proxy Contest (October 2015)

26 slides from Anchor Bancorp's proxy contest presentation, Oct 6, 2015

  1. Slide 1: Anchor Bancorp Needs a Direct Shareholder Representative

    Joel S. Lawson IV Anchor Bancorp Needs a Direct Shareholder Representative October 2015 3421322-1

  2. Slide 2: Disclaimer

    Disclaimer • THIS PRESENTATION IS FOR DISCUSSION AND GENERAL INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. IT DOES NOT HAVE REGARD TO THE SPECIFIC INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE, FINANCIAL SITUATION, SUITABILITY, OR THE PARTICULAR NEED OF ANY SPECIFIC PERSON WHO MAY RECEIVE THIS PRESENTATION, AND SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN AS ADVICE

  3. Slide 3: Executive Summary

    Executive Summary • Anchor Bancorp (“Anchor” or the “Company”) is deeply undervalued • The Company has a history of operational underperformance • Anchor consistently trails its peers in relevant metrics including loan growth, Return on Average Assets (ROAA) and Return on Equity (ROE) • Anchor has n

  4. Slide 4: Why I Invested in Anchor Bancorp

    Why I Invested in Anchor Bancorp • I believe Anchor is undervalued and opportunities exist to unlock value • Anchor priced its IPO offering in January 2011 at a large discount to its Tangible Book Value (TBV) at the minimum of proposed total equity raise • According to the prospectus for the offerin

  5. Slide 5: History of Operational Underperformance

    History of Operational Underperformance 3421322-1

  6. Slide 6: Anchor has Significantly Trailed its Peers in Terms of Loan Growth

    Anchor has Significantly Trailed its Peers in Terms of Loan Growth Loan Growth June '14 June '15 Yoy change Timberland Bancorp 591.4 668.4 13.0% Pacific Financial Corp 547.3 603.6 10.3% FS Bancorp 331.0 442.5 33.7% Riverview Bancorp 547.0 570.2 4.2% First Financial Northwest 688.4 669.9 -2.7% Peer A

  7. Slide 7: Anchor's Return on Average Assets (ROAA) Consistently Lags its Peers

    Anchor’s Return on Average Assets (ROAA) Consistently Lags its Peers Peers - LTM ROAA Sept '14 Dec '14 March '15 June '15 Average Timberland Bancorp 0.88% 0.92% 0.75% 1.11% 0.92% Pacific Financial Corp 0.74% 0.59% 0.59% 0.82% 0.69% FS Bancorp 0.99% 1.22% 1.60% 1.99% 1.45% Riverview Bancorp 0.52% 0.5

  8. Slide 8: Anchor's Core ROAA is Only Estimated to be 30-40 bps

    Anchor’s Core ROAA is Only Estimated to be 30-40 bps 3Q '14 4Q '14 1Q '15 2Q '15 Net interest income 3.428 3.453 3.438 3.491 Provision - - - - NIM after provision 3.428 3.453 3.438 3.491 Non-interest income 0.983 1.025 0.839 1.655 Gain on sales of investments 0.047 - - 0.162 Gain on sale of loans (0

  9. Slide 9: Anchor's Return on Equity (ROE) Consistently Trails its Peers

    Anchor’s Return on Equity (ROE) Consistently Trails its Peers Peers - LTM ROE Sept '14 Dec '14 March '15 June '15 Average Timberland Bancorp 8.04% 8.29% 6.86% 10.03% 8.31% Pacific Financial Corp 7.55% 5.98% 6.05% 8.44% 7.01% FS Bancorp 7.24% 9.46% 12.68% 16.35% 11.43% Riverview Bancorp 4.26% 4.45% 5

  10. Slide 10: Anchor is Significantly Under-Earning its Cost of Capital

    Anchor is Significantly Under-Earning its Cost of Capital • Based on my analysis, Anchor’s cost of capital is approximately 10% and it has a Tangible Common Equity (TCE) to Tangible Assets (TA) ratio of 16.8% • On a LTM basis, Anchor’s ROE was approximately 2.63% (excluding the non-recurring reversa

  11. Slide 11: Anchor has no Realistic Path to Earn its Cost of Capital

    Anchor has no Realistic Path to Earn its Cost of Capital 3421322-1

  12. Slide 12: Anchor has no Realistic Path to Earn its Cost of Capital

    Anchor has no Realistic Path to Earn its Cost of Capital • To achieve the necessary 10% ROE to earn its cost of capital, the Company would need to deploy its $30mm of excess capital in a prudent and timely manner • Unfortunately, the Company’s options on a stand-alone basis appear to be limited to:

  13. Slide 13: Unrealistic Option 1: Loan Growth

    Unrealistic Option 1: Loan Growth • To utilize its excess capital, Anchor would need additional net loan production of $300mm (assuming leverage of 10x) • This would require a staggering 105% increase in gross loans versus the current loan portfolio of $287mm • Unfortunately, Anchor has been unable

  14. Slide 14: Unrealistic Option 2: Share Repurchase Program

    Unrealistic Option 2: Share Repurchase Program • If the Company were to utilize its excess capital in a share repurchase program, the Company would have to retire approximately 53% of its outstanding shares (assuming an average cost of $22 per share) • Assuming Anchor earns 40 bps ROAA and completes

  15. Slide 15: Board Change is Needed NOW – Shareholders Deserve Direct Representation

    Board Change is Needed NOW – Shareholders Deserve Direct Representation 3421322-1

  16. Slide 16: Anchor Needs Truly Independent Directors who will Evaluate ALL Options

    Anchor Needs Truly Independent Directors who will Evaluate ALL Options to Maximize Shareholder Value • Anchor currently trades at approximately $22 per share • My analysis indicates that Anchor could be worth between $27 and $30 per share in an M&A transaction (see Annex 2) • This represents a consi

  17. Slide 17: Comparable Trading Valuations

    Comparable Trading Valuations • While Anchor’s peers trade at an average Price-Earnings (P/E) ratio of 12.2x, Anchor is trading at an unsustainable 39.5x Peers - Valuation Ticker LQA EPS Last Price P / E Ratio Timberland Bancorp TSBK $ 1.24 $ 10.57 8.5x Pacific Financial Corp PFLC $ 0.60 $ 6.60 11.0

  18. Slide 18: Anchor's Outperformance is Solely Due to Discounted Demutualization Pricing

    Anchor’s “Outperformance” is solely due to its extremely discounted demutualization pricing IPO Date Today 1/26/2010 10/6/2015 Price Change TSR w/ dividends SPDR S&P Regional Banking ETF (KRE) $ 24.13 $ 41.47 72% 89% Anchor Bancorp $ 10.00 $ 22.00 120% 120% TBV as of June 2010 $ 26.51 31% Discount t

  19. Slide 19: Anchor's Valuation as Stand-alone Company v. its M&A Value

    Anchor’s Valuation as stand-alone Company v. its M&A Value • If Anchor were to trade at a P/E ratio similar to its peers on a stand-alone valuation, I believe the share price would fall significantly; however, at the same time, the Company trades at a material discount to its M&A value Anchor Bancor

  20. Slide 20: The Board Has Consistently Resisted Shareholder Input

    The Board Has Consistently Resisted Shareholder Input • In 2013, the Board wasted shareholder capital fighting my non-binding proposal seeking to allow shareholders to voice their opinions as to whether the Company should consider hiring an investment banking firm to evaluate potential strategic alt

  21. Slide 21: The Board Lacks Proper Focus on Delivering Shareholder Value

    The Board Lacks Proper Focus on Delivering Shareholder Value • The Board is stale • The average tenure of the incumbents is nearly 19 years • The Board has seen only two new additions since 1998 • The long tenure of the incumbents raises questions as to whether such directors are truly independent •

  22. Slide 22: Direct Shareholder Representation is Needed on the Board NOW

    Direct Shareholder Representation is Needed on the Board NOW • Unlocking shareholder value at Anchor requires: • Open-minded evaluation of all viable alternatives • Fresh perspective in the boardroom • True director independence • Direct representation of shareholders’ best interests in Board decisi

  23. Slide 23: Joel S. Lawson IV

    Joel S. Lawson IV • With ownership of approximately 8.9% of Anchor’s outstanding shares, I am a significant and long-standing shareholder who will bring an owner’s perspective to the boardroom • As the managing member of an investment firm specializing in the financial sector and as a director of tw

  24. Slide 24: Joel S. Lawson IV

    Joel S. Lawson IV • Managing member of Cloister Capital LLC, a firm which invests primarily in orphaned and undervalued securities in the financial sector, since August 2011 • Director of: • Biscayne Bancshares, Inc., a privately-held bank holding company based in Miami, since November 2013 • Regent

  25. Slide 25: Annex 1

    Annex 1 3421322-1 Anchor Banc f June 2016) ‘Accume 10% buyback completed at $22 per share Acoumethecampany isableto cam 40bpsROAA over thefiscal year 2016 Ascts 3790 3790 3790 Estimated standalone ROAA 030% 025% 040% Estimated stand alonenet income uw 13 15 UMrearingneintestopase 160 160 160 Cost sa

  26. Slide 26: Annex 2

    Anchor Bancorp - M&A Value (end of June 2015) Assets 379.0 379.0 379.0 0.30% Annex 2 Estimated stand-alone ROAA 0.35% 0.40% Estimated stand-alone net income 1.1 1.3 1.5 LTM recurring non-interest expense 16.0 16.0 16.0 Cost savings 30% 30% 30% Pre-tax cost savings 4.8 4.8 4.8 Taxes 40% 40% 40% After

Anchor Bancorp — Proxy Contest (October 2015) on 6ix