Penn Millers — Investor Presentation (May 2010)
15 slides from Penn Millers's investor presentation, May 17, 2010

Slide 1: Penn Millers Holding Corporation
NASDAQ Symbol: PMIC May 17, 2010 PENN MILLERS HOLDING CORPORATION Exhibit 99.1

Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements
2 Forward-Looking Statements This presentation may include forward-looking statements. These forward-looking statements include comments with respect to our objectives and strategies, and the results of our operations and business. By their nature, however, these forward-looking statements involve n

Slide 3: Business Overview
Business Overview a

Slide 4: Penn Millers Leadership
4 Penn Millers Leadership Douglas A. Gaudet - President and Chief Executive Officer President and CEO since December 2005. Over 30 years of industry experience. Experience with other insurance companies includes the development and introduction of new insurance products for those companies. Michael

Slide 5: Overview of Agribusiness
5 Overview of Agribusiness Experience writing agribusiness insurance for over 120 years Specialty/niche market Excellent industry reputation 3rd largest writer of commercial agribusiness Specialized underwriting, loss control and claims personnel Service businesses in 33 states throughout the countr

Slide 6: Agribusiness States, Brokers and Target Customers
Agribusiness 6 States 33 Brokers/State 6 Number of Brokers >200 Average Size $44,000 Target customers:

Slide 7: Agribusiness Long-Term Strategy
7 Agribusiness Long-Term Strategy Increase broker and agent network Looking to grow in upper Midwest and West Increase penetration in low volume states Add production underwriters in select territories Broaden underwriting appetite Higher property limits Long haul vehicle exposures Capitalize on com

Slide 8: Commercial Business Solutions (Businessowners Policy)
8 Commercial Business Solutions(r) (Businessowners Policy) Provides enhanced coverage intended for select agents and preferred small business owners. Target markets include retail and service, "Main Street" businesses Has not performed consistently well its design serves a relatively small populatio

Slide 9: Commercial Business 2009 States, Agents and Target Customers
9 Commercial Business 2009 States 8 Agents per State 31 Number of Agents 250 Average Size $6,300 Retailers, including beverage stores, floor covering stores, florists, grocery stores, office equipment and supplies stores, dry cleaners, printers, and shopping centers; Artisan contractor businesses, s

Slide 10: Penn Millers - Expansion Product
10 Penn Millers - Expansion Product Introduced PennEdge product in January 2009 Focused on those industry segments we understand, and in which we can differentiate ourselves from other insurance companies: Select Middle Market Niches - target markets include wholesalers, manufacturers, printers, and

Slide 11: Commercial Business - Long Term Plan
11 Commercial Business - Long Term Plan Transition from being a generalist insurer of small business to being a specialist focused on select industries for small and middle market customers. Penn Edge - the middle market product Develop niche markets out of our existing commercial business target ma

Slide 12: Financial Overview
Financial Overview Michael O. Banks, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Slide 13: Penn Millers Income Statement
13 13 Penn Millers Income Statement Earned premiums down due to Commercial Business profitability initiatives: terminating relationships with underperforming producers and discontinued writing certain unprofitable classes of business Significant weather losses in Q1 2010

Slide 14: Long-Term Strategy
14 Long-Term Strategy Long -Term Return on Equity Goal of 10% Agribusiness growth in Midwest and West Penetrate States with low volume Add new States where opportunities exist Commercial Business Improve small business customer profitability Grow higher margin PennEdge book Improve productivity of u

Slide 15: 2010 Risks and Opportunities
15 2010 Risks and Opportunities Soft market Underwriting discipline will limit top line growth Pricing pressures will put stress on bottom line General economic pressures will lower exposures and premiums on new and renewal business 2010 Stock Repurchase Plan will add shareholder value On May 12th B
Source: SEC EDGAR · 8-K filed May 17, 2010
