Associated Estates Realty Corp
Associated Estates Realty — Proxy Contest (January 2015)
60 slides from Associated Estates Realty's proxy contest presentation, Jan 28, 2015
Slide 1: Associated Estates (AEC) - Our View: Grossly Undervalued and Undermanaged
| LANDandBUILDINGS Associated Estates (AEC) - Our View: Grossly Undervalued and Undermanaged Please email questions and comments to [email protected]
Slide 2: Table of Contents
Table of Contents | LANDandBUILDINGS |. Introduction Il. Southeast Florida Case Study lll. Grossly Undervalued IV. Destroyed Value, Credibility and Trust - History of Poor Capital Allocation V. Worst of Both Worlds - High G&A and Low Performance Creates Opportunity VI. Real Opportunity to Become Bes
Slide 3: I. Introduction
|—l ae LANDandBUILDINGS |. Introduction TANDinCHUIDINGS,
Slide 4: Land and Buildings Firm Background
LANDand BUILDING + Firm Background cogistored invoslment advise: Sounded in 2008 ond located in Slanstord, » SEC. » Invests in the publicly Wace shares of global REIls and real eslate related companies + Investment Strategy Long-term investment horizon invest primarily in componies with discounted v
Slide 5: Company Overview
Company Overview LANDand BUILDINGS + Associated Estates (NYSE: AEC): Owner and operator of 50 high quality apartment communities containing over 13,000 units acrass 9 states Communities/Units: 50 /13,034 ‘Average Age Ve yenrs Ocaupancy: ah Calfomia, Average Rent 1238 16% [AEC Stock Information Vas P
Slide 6: Associated Estates (AEC): ~50% Upside with Significant Catalysts
Associated Estates (AEC): ~50% Upside will c Significant Catalysts for Future Growth LAND and BUILDINGS .9s believes AEC has significant upside to the private market value of its assets and that this value can be AssociatedEstates Thoocca ough tees congo sine Conny + Grossly Undervalued and Underman
Slide 7: How Did We Get Here?
LANDand BUILDING! How Did We Get Here? «History of operational underperformance and poor capital allocation > Stock below IPO price: AEC shares prior to Investor activism were 33% below the November 1993 IPO price of $22 and lagged proxy peers by over 250% over the trailing 20 years (or 700% includi
Slide 8: Strategic Plan
: Strategic Plan: Cesta LANDandBUILDIN Optimize NO! in-tine with best practices that several Board nominees pioneered! Full operational review, Including taking specific steps to maximize LR? revenue monagement Instil culture of + Reduce bloated G&A Ca fal Allo io + Re-assess all current and future
Slide 9: II. Southeast Florida Case Study
Cl LANDand BUILDINGS Il. Southeast Florida Case Study TaRDaneAUTTDINGS
Slide 10: Southeast Florida Spotlight: Blatant Undermanagement
nT |] Southeast Florida Spotlight: j PSD RSaHEIEING Blatant Undermanagement + AEC’s 14% underperformance in Southeast Florida since 2011 confirms, in our view, that management is well below industry standards + Land and Buildings’ deep-dive into AEC’s Southeast Florida assets revealed significant mi
Slide 11: Smoking Gun: Apartment Lease Mispricing
Smoking Gun: Apartment L : Dramatically Reducing | seisusiaiianaunatianashs ant money on the fable in Southeast Florida + AEC appears to us to be leaving signi due to the organization's mispricing of leases and misuse of LRO > At 4 out 5 of AEC’s Southeast Florida: assets, rents are lowest for 15-mo
Slide 12: The Edge at Flagler Village: Yield Likely Not Being Maximized
The Edge at Flagler Village: Yield Likely Not Being Maximized LANDand BUILDING «The Edge at Flagler Village is an A+ asset in lease-up in a red hot Fort Lauderdale market, but AEC is battlingly offering concessions » One month free Is available—which is highly unusual fer cn operator properly utiliz
Slide 13: AEC Southeast Florida Assets: Filthy and Poorly Maintained
AEC Southeast Florida Assets: Filthy and Poorly Maintained LANDandBUILDINC + Waterstone at Wellington, a Class A high-end apartment asset in West Palm Beach, is filthy and poorly maintained despite being well-staffed > Mllclew/fungus is evident ceross the property, Including the windows and signage
Slide 14: AEC Southeast Florida Assets: Filthy and Poorly Maintained
AEC Southeast Florida Assets: Filthy and Poorly Maintained ( LAND and BUILDING + Windsor Pines, a Class A asset in Broward County, in mid-January appears fo be a Christmas tree graveyard or supermarket parking lot as much as a high-end apartment community All visible from the leasing office In front
Slide 15: AEC Southeast Florida Assets: Filthy and Poorly Maintained
AEC Southeast Florida Assets: Filthy and Poorly Maintained (« HANTat@ BUILDIN + Doral West, a B+ apartment asset in an A location near Miami, shows that dirty parking lots and ragged signs appear to be an Associated Estates hallmark Appears to be an unkempt & neglected asset ‘Multiple signs with hol
Slide 16: Poor Customer Service Evident Across Southeast Florida
Poor Customer Service Evident Across Southeast Florida LANDand BUILDING + Filthy assets appear symptomatic of greater operational issues and lack of customer focus that Land and Buildings representatives encountered during our on-site due diligence > Long weit times were experienced in leasing offic
Slide 17: Data Supports Contention AEC Is a Poor Operator
Data Supports Contention AEC Is af Operator in Competitive Apariment LANDan< BUILDINGS + AEC has cumulatively underperformed its public peers net operating by 900bps since 2011 in overlapping geographies » Atlanta and Southeest Florida have both been stand-out markets for apartment rental growth sin
Slide 18: III. Grossly Undervalued
.— a LANDandBUILDING Ill. Grossly Undervalued TANDacUUILDINGS
Slide 19: AEC Net Asset Value
AEC Net Asset Value: Significa + $37 Fair Value with L&B Board Nominees > Recovery of cumulative 900ps NOI underperformance of past 4 years relative to proxy peers in same geographies > 10% blue-chip premium inline with high- quality trecitfonel property REITs » 5.7% applied cap rate determined thro
Slide 20: AEC Fair Value of $37 with L&B Board Nominees
AEC Fair Value | LANDand BUILDINGS AEC Fair Value of $37 with L&B Board Nominees se Fair Valve with 128 Nominees $38 37 se _ AEC Achieves curent NAV 107 Blve-chip ss ‘sar remium Recovery of 300 s00bps NOL Undexpertormence 528 5m sae se $20 TaRDancHUTDINGS
Slide 21: AEC Apartment Portfolio Is Class A Quality
LANDand BUILDING + AEC apartment portfolio is Class A qual and warrants a 5.7% cap rate > L&B believes investors currenily rrisunderstand the high quality ond civerse geographic make-up ‘of AEC's porfolio and therefore are not valuing it comectiy in the public markets Portiolio Breakdown Market Unit
Slide 22: CBRE: Class A Apartment Cap Rates Rarely Exceed 6% Range
CBRE: Class A Apartment Cap Rates Rarely Exceed 6% Range ] LANDand BUILDINGS + CBRE private market cap rate transaction data from 1H14 shows a low cap rate ‘environment across all regions, including those seen as “non-core” by public investors Class A sueuroen multifamily assets across Clevelond, Co
Slide 23: AEC Dispositions Highlight Strong Pricing
LANDandBUILDINC AEC Dispositions Highlig! + AEC dispo: 9 > AEC has disclosed a 5.4% weighted average cap rate on 2014 completed cisposttions ns of non-core assets display strong pri > AEC's public market valuation is wholly inconsistent with the low cap rates AEC is able to achieve on the sales of s
Slide 24: AEC Has Historically Traded at an Average 28% Discount to NAV
AEC Has Historically Trade an Average 28% Disco LANDandBUILDINC + AEC has traded at an average 28% discount to NAV over the trail according to Green Street Advisors data analyzed by Land and Bui » Forthe last decade, it appears investors hove voted ageinst management with their feet pe at 40.0% 2008
Slide 25: AEC: Persistent Discount to Proxy Peers
AEC: Persistent Discount fo Prox LANDand BUILDING + AEC has consistently traded at a discount fo NAV while its proxy peers have traded very close fo NAV, according to Green Street Advisors data L&B analyzed » AEC is 0 clear outlier, trading ot the largest discount to NAV among its proxy peers acrass
Slide 26: AEC Apartment Markets: Good Growth with Less Volatility
AEC Apartment Markets: Good Growth with Less Volatili LANDandBUILDINt + low cap rates in AEC markets justified by attractive risk-adjusted growth profile > AEC’s morkets, on a weighted overage basis, have achieved similar cnnual rental growth [42.2%] as the national average (+2.4%] over ‘the last 10
Slide 27: AEC Apartments Are Class A and Amongst the Best
AEC Apartments Are Cla: Rent and Amongst the Best LANDandBUILDINGS It's a Submarket Story eign
Slide 28: AEC Apartment Markets Projected to See Accelerating Rental Growth
AEC Apartment Markets Proje to See Accelerating Rental Gro wth. LANDandBUILDINGS + Axiometrics forecasts AEC's apartment markets will see accelerating rental growth, averaging 3.1% annual growth from 2015 - 2017, well above the trailing 10 year average of 2.2% Projected Market Rent Growth af Portaio
Slide 29: National Apartment Rent Growth Likely Causing Growth
National Apartment Ret i LANDandBUILDINGS Likely Causing Growth + National annual effective rent growth in December 2014 reached 4.9%, the strongest of 2014 and the highest since August 2011 - 41 months ago - when the rate was 5.0% > Bucking normal seasonality: December wos a 21 bps Increase from No
Slide 30: Markets Below National Average Supply Growth
Markets Below National Avera J LANDandBUILDINGS Aparimentsupply growth in acc sonal hirer markets meaningfully below United District of Coumbio 07% O7% 07% O7% 247% States average Detroit 01% 0.2% 046% 08% 134% 5 AEC rerkatsan terecenteat6 ee te ane Be experience 10% less annul multifamily emt giee
Slide 31: "Renter Nation" to Benefit
“Renter Nation" to Benefit LANDandBUILDINGS + Low homeownership rates appear structural as well as cyclical as renter lifestyle is preferred by younger generations > Renting can allow for greater freedom of movernent andi the ability to live in locations with better amenities and social/cultural opp
Slide 32: Housing Shortage
Housing Shortage of rose amuaty LANDandBUILDINC + Harvard estimates demand for 1.6 - 1.9 million homes annually between 2015-2025! + Shortfall of ~750,000 homes annually at current pace of housing starts + Apartment shortfall: multifamily starts at ~350,000 annually are 30% below necessary 500,000?
Slide 33: IV. Destroyed Value, Credibility and Trust - History of Poor Capital Allocation
| LANDandBUILDINGS IV. Destroyed Value, Credibility and Trust - History of Poor Capital Allocation TaNDewe HUTTDINGS
Slide 34: AEC: Years of Material Share Underperformance
AEC: 20 Years of Material Share Underperformance LANDand BUILDING + AEC's share returns are significantly below proxy peers > Over the post 20 years AEC’s fotal retum including dividends hos lagged proxy peers by necrly 700% ond its shore price return has logged proxy peers by over 250% > AEC shores
Slide 35: Negative "Management Value Added" Score Highlights Poor Capital Allocation
Negative “Management Val Score Highlights Poor Capital LANDandBUILDINGS + AEC is the lowest scoring apartment REIT in Green Street Advisors’ “Management Value Added” metric over the last 7 years! > From June 2006 through June 2013, AEC’s NAV growth underperformed the levered appreciation of the comp
Slide 36: Destroying Value and Credibility: Five Equity Offerings at Large Discounts to NAV
Destroying Value and Credibility: Five Equity . Offerings at Large Discounts to NAV. Reni eneeE DOI + AEC has issued large blocks of new common equity five times since January 2010 > AEC issued over $450 millon of equity ot o 22% average discount to Green Street's AEC NAV > These issuances were high
Slide 37: Destroying Trust: May 2013 Issuance Raises Serious Questions
Destroying Trust: May 2013 LANDandBUILDINCS Issuance Raises Serious Que + AEC lowered growth and earnings guidance less than 2 months after issuing forward equity > On May 29, 2013, AEC issued over 7 milion shares of fonward commen. eculty ino secandary offering and raised over $120 milion that woul
Slide 38: AEC: Five Equity Raises and No Earnings Growth
AEC: Five Equity and No Earnings Grow LANDandBUILDINGS + AEC's share count growth has far outpaced its earnings per share growth > Since 2008, AEC’s weighted average cilluted share count has grown 257% while the company’s FFO (funds from operations} per shore growth Is 4%, a stork contrast —curuistv
Slide 39: AEC: NOI Growth NOT Translating to Cash Flow Growth
AEC: NOI Growth NOT Trans! to Cash Flow Growth LANDandBUILDINC + Poor capital allocation decisions have deprived shareholders of cash flow growth > Despite comparable same-store NOI growth as peers since 2008, cilutive equity raises, cisproportionally high G&A costs ang, in our view, other managemen
Slide 40: Paying Full Price in the Private Market When AEC's Own Portfolio Is Cheap
Paying Full Price in the Private b When AEC’s Own Portfolio Is EAS Dab BOLDIN + Poor capital allocation: Why was AEC buying 5.5% cap rate apartment assets in the private market when AEC stock was trading at an 8%+ implied cap rate? > On September 23, 2013, AEC announced it had entered into a definit
Slide 41: AEC: Large Development Pipeline Weighing on Shares
AEC: Large Development Pipeline Weighing on Shares: + Investors likely skeptical of AEC development value creation > AEC currently camies a development pipeline requiting ~$400 million of spend or ~20% of enterprise value, the lorgest of cea AEC’s proxy peer group ae > Over 50% of the development pi
Slide 42: V. Worst of Both Worlds - High G&A and Low Performance Creates Opportunity
| LANDandBUILDINGS V. Worst of Both Worlds — High G&A and Low Performance Creates Opportunity TAN nlUIDINGS
Slide 43: AEC: Outsized G&A and Excessive Compensation Relative to Peers
AEC: Outsized G&A and exce essi Compensation Relative to | Pe EAD and BUILDING + AEC's general and administrative expenses (G&A), including executive compensation, are outsized relative to peers on a variety of measures > AEC's G&A as a percent of revenue Isneaitly 1166s. the pioxy peer average of 4
Slide 44: AEC G&A Has Grown Significantly
AEC G&A Has Grown Signi LANDandBUILDINGS + G&A expenses continue to grow, potentially benefiting management at the expense of shareholders despite statements by management that AEC will become more efficient > “Well, as it relates 10 G&A, we believe we operate very thin In thal G&A as a percentage o
Slide 45: AEC G&A Expense Ratios Continue to Grow While Peer Ratios Fall
AEC G&A Expense Ratios to Grow While Peer Ratios I LANDandBUILDIN + AEC G&A expense as a percent of revenue has kept growing while peers have become more efficient . wore orm 0 eam : He 5 8 ¥ an ® 45% aoe Bax = o% nec roxy Peers TaND ee HUTDINGS tanren
Slide 46: AEC Management Consistently Missing Own Expectations
AEC Management Consistently B Missing Own Expectations: LANDand BUILDING + As apartment fundamentals soared since 2009, AEC still frequently lowered guidance and missed expectations > The past six years, AEC actual annual FFO/share has missed initial guidance by -0.9% on average > Annuol FFO per sha
Slide 47: AEC Mismanaged LRO - Management Implementation
AEC Mismanaged LRO- Management Impleme LANDandBUILDINGS + AEC saw no visible “pop” from LRO revenue management rollout Rainma ke 6 > According te Rainmaker, owner of LRO, apartment operators typically experience 400 - 700bps of ‘edaitional revenue growth in the initicl 24 months following a complete
Slide 48: AEC: On Pace to Deliver the Worst Revenue Growth of Peers in 2014
AEC: On Pace to Deliver th Revenue Growth of Peers in ‘ LANDand BUILDINGS + Not only has management consistently missed own growth expectations, AEC is now ‘on pace fo deliver the worst same-store revenue growth of their proxy peers ‘Associated Estates 2014 Same-store Revenve Guidance or Worst Among
Slide 49: AEC: Already Lowered Expectations for 2015
LANDandBUILDINGS AEC: Already Lowered Expe: + AEC appears to be laying the groundwork for an underwhelming 2015 > 2014 initicl same-store revenue growth guidance was 3.25% at the midpoint » 2Q14 earnings Conference Call: “...we would expect 2015 revenue particularly to be better than 2014" Chie! Exe
Slide 50: VI. Real Opportunity to Become Best in Class REIT
LANDandBUILDINGS VI. Real Opportunity to Become Best in Class REIT TARDncHUILDINGS
Slide 51: REITs Particularly Well Suited for Change
LANDandBUILDING! REITs Particularly Well Suited for ¢ + REITs generally own a collection of homogeneous and “hard” assets, allowing for a unique set of circumstances > Significant recurring revenue means little t¢ no operotionel disruption should occur when board or management tumover occurs > All o
Slide 52: Land and Buildings AEC Board Nominees
Land and Buildings AEC Board N LANDandBUILDINGS + Land and Buildings proposes to make AEC’s Board stronger > Land and Buildings has nominated seven independent, highly-exeerienced, high integrity individuals whe want to take a fresh look at the best ways to create value for stockholders at AEC > The
Slide 53: Land and Buildings AEC Board Nominees
Land and Buildings AEC Boar LANDand BUILDINGS + Land and Buildings AEC Board Nominees > Marcus E. Bromley ~ Former public multifamily REIT CEO and Cheirman at Gables Residential Tust > Michael J. DeMarco — Fermer investment banker and public office REIT executive at Vornado Realty Trust (NYSE: VNO}
Slide 54: Analyst Research Notes on Nominees
LANDandBUILDINC + Green Street Advisors Research Note (11/17/14) > ".,.9even highly-reputable independent directors...Scot Sellers’ presence Is noteworthy as he Is regarded os one of the top apartment executives in the country.” + Citigroup Research Note (11/17/14) > "...we do believe L&B's slate wo
Slide 55: Land and Buildings AEC Board Nominee Biographies
Land and Buildings AEC Board Non LANDand BUILDINGS ‘Mateus , Bromley ~ Former public mullianly RET CEO and Chakman at Gobes Resident Hust ar tri nrc 2a of ceranon re eee ora en Ne are nd Endman rk! cSnarhteng nie ee Laser) Hearne aie ears ras acs tra opin Cp Hel aman suseaneca gy try her ara Roget h
Slide 56: Land and Buildings AEC Board Nominee Biographies
Land and Buildings AEC Board | LANDandBUILDINGS ‘ChatlesM.Ekon ~Fotessor and leading authomy on cemporate governance for Corte Corson ole Unvetyo Dslovore ia ko Or Gael lolactas tat elena & esi Fedral siperivenekite cosparoters somntosregation and cereal eoveranc lea grate of baer Ces ‘2nd hater ot
Slide 57: Board Nominee Biographies
LANDandBUILDING! S ‘Gregory F. Hughes ~ Former puble RET CFO cl SL Green with experiance across numerous realestate vectors ‘egos Huanes, tom Never 201010 eraser, nas svecas a Hinge or escomman CoptalLintea Fammesh.o Frtsnctaoxeae, onl imetn fr i hag ono ers ech Grovaing eer of Cena fly Car A SGrem
Slide 58: Scot Sellers Biography
Land and Buildings AEC LANDand BUILDINGS 7 Scot Seles ~ Forme! pubic multtanuly RET CEO and CIO at Archslone-Srah Ts TO Sele est er Ul eerie Tre ace ee cca ee er et SESS Pa Se faa See anes eee oe stoae ater ects arneereree amen amet tees ccee nod rae ac Seer sn ene rca fated enc asta mesma nantes at
Slide 59: Stay Tuned
Stay Tuned LANDandBUILDINGS + Land and Buildings looks forward to having further opportunities to communicate with shareholders > In the coming weeks Lend and Buildings anticipates publicly releasing our detalled strategic plan nd c robust case why our Bocrd nominees are best suited to lead AEC’s tr
Slide 60: Disclosures
DISCLOSURES LANDand BUILDINGS TaRDancRUTDINGS
Associated Estates Realty — Proxy Contest (January 2015) on 6ix