FBR & — Proxy Contest (April 2016)
74 slides from FBR &'s proxy contest presentation, Apr 5, 2016
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Proxy Statement - FBR & Co.
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a Party other than the Registrant x Check the appropriate box: ¨ Preliminary Proxy
Slide 2: Schedule 14A filing fee information
¨ Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid previously. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or the Form or Schedule and the date of its filing. 1) Amount Previously P
Slide 3: Voce press release and presentation filed; participants notice
On April 5, 2016, Voce Capital Management LLC issued a press release and the attached presentation materials, attached hereto as Exhibits 1 and 2, respectively, which is incorporated by reference herein, regarding FBR & Co. (the “Company”). VOCE CATALYST PARTNERS LP, VOCE CAPITAL MANAGEMENT LLC, VOC
Slide 4: Voce Capital Issues Presentation Detailing Need for Change at FBR & Co.
EXHIBIT 1 VOCE CAPITAL ISSUES PRESENTATION DETAILING NEED FOR CHANGE AT FBR & CO. Makes Comprehensive Case for Strategic, Operational and Governance Reform Believes Current Board and Management are Squandering FBR’s Storied Heritage; New Leadership and Oversight Needed Voce’s Three Highly-Qualified
Slide 5: Voce statement on Board accountability
“Ultimately we believe that FBR’s Board is responsible, and must be held accountable, for these failings. The vast majority of the Directors possess long- standing ties to the Company and management that pre-date their Board tenure and color their objectivity and independence, in our view. One need
Slide 6: Proxy solicitation legal notice
PROXIES FROM THE SHAREHOLDERS OF FBR & CO. (THE “COMPANY”) FOR USE AT THE COMPANY’S 2016 ANNUAL MEETING OF SHAREHOLDERS (THE “PROXY SOLICITATION”). ALL SHAREHOLDERS OF THE COMPANY ARE ADVISED TO READ THE DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT AND OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATED TO THE PROXY SOLICITATION WHEN SUCH DOCUM
Slide 7: Exhibit 2
EXHIBIT 2 A voice vocecapital © Voce Capital for value Management LLC; April 5, 2016
Slide 8: Rekindling the Spirit of Success
Rekindling Materials Discussion vocecapital the Spirit April of Success 5, 2016
Slide 9: Disclaimer
Thefrom Disclaimer (the information for trademarks Unless market This are “anticipate,” events, prove document respect identified differences These may Voce or securities Although communication therein). 2statements vocecapital solicitation the not views “Company”). receive document has reserves cur
Slide 10: Table of Contents
Table 4. A. 1. 2. 3. 35. vocecapital Assessing Value-creation Executive FBR Exit Disband Drive Conclusion Stock Realign ofnon-core overview high Contents performance strategy principal FBR’s summary margin industry opportunities and long-term investing M&A B.business Operating sectors revenue perfor
Slide 11: Voce Capital Management overview
– Average 4?Strategic vocecapital Voce’s Voce 5.3%conducted Has Particular Investor Prior Majority Capital is selectively has hasn’t pursues experience ofprincipals Capital ashares return base led of value-oriented expertise investments sold numerous Management acomprised to Allocation more outstand
Slide 12: Executive summary
Summary Executive 5–?Operating vocecapital ?We FBR Storied Stock Significant FBR’s Current Strategic: Operational: Governance: FBRbelieve see was is remains edge afranchise management Realign worth summary Conclusion multitude founded Realign FBR corporate has Reduce Revitalize less dominant been Bu
Slide 13: FBR stock significantly underperformed peers
Summary FBR’s 160% 200% 120% Peers: — (40%) Jan-09 FBR Note: FBR: S&P isPeers S&P: 80% 25% (80%) stock Jan-10 worth -4% Realign 500 40% are R2K: has less Jan-11 Russell Company’s significantly today 149% Business Jan-12 2000 than 165% proxy Reduce Proxy Jan-13 when underperformed peers and current J
Slide 14: Management's stated goals versus reality
Summary Business Stock FBR’s Company’s 1? 2? 3? 4? 5? 6? 2015 Reality -2% Compensation Non-comp Delivered –1% 7Corresponding vocecapital $500K Currently Substantially Metric Compensation Highest 2nd Has “One “FBR “An “Ongoing “Consistently “Attractive average revenue revenue lowest Revitalize only S
Slide 15: Return on equity and implied valuation
FBR’s Business its ($mm, Shareholders’ Target Net Taxes Pre-tax Non-Comp 2Variable Comp 3Total cost Income at(at vocecapital Revenue 2. –?3. Even 81. +Return ?All-time Assumes Total Returncurrent per of Income Implied /% Reduce statutory Head Currently $1M+ capital head Opex $25.3 Equity on Benefits
Slide 16: Opportunity 1: Realign business strategy
Summary 9?–Opportunity We Non-core Principal FBR These Lessdon’t Similar Hyper-competitive Long Generate Long-term Unlikely believe than could history We industries disconnects Realign to investment think mainly sectors half believe #1: returns also FBR’s earn ofof Realign FBR complement failing its
Slide 17: Opportunity 2: Reduce expenses
Summary •–?Opportunity FBR’s Operating Exit Compensate Shrink Stop Other High E.g., undifferentiated absorbing public expenses: Executive CEO Officeheadcount national vocecapital 10 eight /Realign expenses #2: CFO company remaining person Reduce abandoned footprint professional Business could are bo
Slide 18: Opportunity 3: Revitalize corporate governance
Summary ?–Opportunity Voce 11 vocecapital We FBR’s AThe Insiders Board Mr. Compensation majority believes believe hold Hendrix tophas awarded Board 5Realign have FBR’s executives been #3: of FBR’s that (CEO) is been the Revitalize scheme Board the not too uncooperative Business the Directors Board n
Slide 19: The Business
The Business vocecapital
Slide 20: FBR institutional overview
?Institutional 13 vocecapital (ATM) Founded Current HQ ? Underwriter in Arlington, issuer Advisory CEO, inBrokerage 1989; 51%? Rick of client Virginia? M&A, IPO Research, Hendrix, in securities, ?restructuring 2007 FBR 303 appointed securities isemployees aincluding leading and other January lending
Slide 21: Financial snapshot and valuation
Summary Business Operating (in FBR Capitalization Share Fully-Diluted Market Less Enterprise Financial Revenue EPS Book % Valuation: TEV P Memo: vocecapital / Book Book EPS millions, $0.27 Unrestricted Investment financial /Value Price Revenue Value Deferred 67.0x Value 0.85x $141 Reduce Metrics Rea
Slide 22: FBR history timeline
Genesis: Acquired $450,000,000 1993 2009 $350,000,000 BROOKLYN 2008 2005 2001 1999 1997 $300,000,000 15 vocecapital 1993 1994 – Rick Second Fallout First Parent Vision MLV 2015 NLC founder major Hendrix PRIME $450,000,000 $350,000,000 $550,000,000 company from founder and subprime energy Execution T
Slide 23: Deep domain expertise in core sectors
Summary Deep Financial ?Energy Publishing 16 vocecapital Banks? Financial domain (4)GSEs? Services Realign analysts: Technology? expertise Life Business (4)11/Real Annuity? in Companies Specialty highly Estate Reduce Commercial attractive (2) REITs under Stock Insurance coverage: Revitalize core ?Fi
Slide 24: 144A market segment overview
Summary Market ?–Segment Historical $125 $75 $50 $$25 This Overview Niche, Economics Attractive These 144A FBR Previous Specialty Upwards — Average $66mm $25mm $100 can segment has leader product deals but overview Realign quarterly limit consistently competitor of distribution for enormously (04-08
Slide 25: Assessing FBR's long-term performance
Assessing FBR’s long-term performance vocecapital
Slide 26: A. Stock performance
A. Stock performance vocecapital
Slide 27: Voce's history with the Company
Summary Voce’s 8/4/15: $capital Apr-15 From to 2030.00 29.00 28.00 27.00 26.00 25.00 24.00 23.00 22.00 21.00 20.00 19.00 18.00 17.00 16.00 15.00 understand May history allocation Company May-15 Allison meeting same 9/16/15: declared7/15/15:itsFBR 5/5/15: meetingSVPwithofCFOIR 10/6/15: 2/10/16: the 7
Slide 28: Total shareholder return bridge since 2009
Summary Business Stock Returns 10.0% 20.0% Book (60.0%) (50.0%) 21 vocecapital Under Value Revitalize —bridge current Reduce Realign Book since management, Value 2009 Multiple Operating shareholder Share Conclusion repurchases return is negative. / Total Shareholder The only offset Return hasDividen
Slide 29: Capital return reliance
Summary Business Stock Capital -7% $250 $100 $59 $$23 2009 Cash Management’s Note: 22 vocecapital —$21 $66 $236 $73 2010 & Company’s Revitalize return Investments $51 $16 Reduce Realign 2011 $50 isreliance finite 2012 2015 Cash 2013 Operating 10-K on Returned capital 2014 filing Conclusion 2015 retu
Slide 30: Capitalization, liquidity and research coverage
Summary FBR $500 $450 Capitalization Market YE2008 ADTV The 23 vocecapital ongoing has -45% $446 (000’s $100 YE2009 marooned Realign mm) plunge share $50 Shares) $200 $400 YE2010 $Business in repurchases — itself $196 equity 51 Operating 82 $178 YE2011 Reduce value! 45 $150 have 26 61 YE2012 Conclus
Slide 31: B. Operating performance
B. Operating performance vocecapital
Slide 32: Revenue per head versus peers
Summary 1Business vocecapital /Revenue $$500 $800 Head $200 MC 25 FBR been — GHL Performance –$100 $399 $733 $600Reduce 2011Realign a2015 significant per LAZ $?$564 $550 –revenue Stifel — head 2015 EVR FBR $545 Stock Operating and /Revitalize Commentary disappointment per JMP Average: $536 Oppenheim
Slide 33: Revenue CAGR versus peers
2Summary (2%) EVR Performance vocecapital 2011 15% CAGR Revenue (10% — 5% ?investors 26 1%) 14% –(3%) MC Realign 2015 11% 7% SF 12% it(5%) Business expected Stock Commentary 6% PJC LAZ toJMP Reduce Revitalize grow OPY revenues FBRC Revenue asGHL CAGR a result COWNof newOperating Peer revenues Conclu
Slide 34: Compensation per head
3Summary 27 $500 $519 $600 Head $300 Compensation $100 2011 FBR’s peers $?/Peer COWN Stifel FBR $391 — —MC GroupPerformance 2012 Peer $251 $400 and Realign Average: 50.0% strategy FBRC badly Business Oppenheimer Average: 2013 $257 $345 Average LAZ $400 Per $200 Peer is$334 lags 2014 EVR Stock forcin
Slide 35: Non-comp expense ratio
Summary 4Business 28 Non-Comp FBR 70% 60% Ratio 33% FBR’s59% Performance Reduce Realign –Commentary Expense MC Professional Business Occupancy Communications Other JMP FBR49% 30% 2011 40% percentage opex 22% 15% LAZ –development Expenses 2015 and 10% servicesStock Average: EVR equipment of5% GHL Rev
Slide 36: Operating margin versus peers
5Summary GHL FBR 22% 30% 10% 23% 14% 2011 LAZPerformance Management 25% 15% 11% Margin 5% Operating 2% 11% 20% 3% Realign —(10%) 10% 10% 10% 20% 14% —–PJC 2015 8% has Peer 17% EVRBusiness Stock SFReduce repeatedly Commentary Average: MC Revitalize told 10% OPYOperating JMPinvestors FBRC – its FBR’s
Slide 37: Return on equity versus peers
Summary 6Business vocecapital FBR 25.0% 20.0% Equity 15.0% 6.3% 5.0% P (20.0%) ?2011 Commentary Peer 50% 25% 24% Return -19% Pre 4% (5%) COWN 30 re 5% ROE –5% Performance (10.0%) For Reduce aRealign Average: Group 21% 2011 2012 (1%) on 1.7% 21.6% 10.0% is on —tax 20% 1% Peer (17.6%) comparability, E
Slide 38: Value-creation opportunities for FBR shareholders
Value-creation opportunities for FBR shareholders vocecapital
Slide 39: Opportunity 1: Exit non-core sectors
Opportunity 1. 2. 3. vocecapital Exit non-core Disband Drive high principal #1: margin Realign industry investing M&Astrategy sectors within effort and core business industries
Slide 40: FBR's historical strategy and requirements
–FBR’s vocecapital requirements FBR“FBR’s historical Predecessor strategy ofsuccess itsIPO clients since Prospectus wasfor inception built sophisticated upon (1997) hasitsbeen relentless and tooffer non-traditional target focus: FBR’s specific fullindustry investment range ofsectors investment advic
Slide 41: FBR has abandoned its historical focus
Summary The consumer, from –?insurance, mergers 34 vocecapital FBR FBR’s “Hendrix, “In “We “FBR new aitsfocus reiterated has is boutique & adds and brief dedicated corporate spreading Realign real energy, Co. abandoned 43, acquisitions, our value history, is estate, said investment capital its a hea
Slide 42: Headcount grows while revenues fall
Summary Headcount Employees Net 35 vocecapital Revenue Realign continues ($mm)Business $151 to grow $260 Reduce while $182revenues Stock $120Revitalize Revenue fall Operating / Head ($000’s) Conclusion 305 $550 302$931 301 $605 300 295 $399 290 285 280 279 276 275 270 265 260 2012 2013 2014 2015
Slide 43: Resource and revenue mismatch
Summary Business Stock Significant Core Industry Research Companies Estimated Est. Contribution (Banking/Brokerage) Recognition Track Equity vocecapital Revenue Areas Revitalize Record Financials,Energy Reduce Analysts Realign Revenue mismatch Non-Core Covered 36 / Mix Very Brand ~80% 11 Strong 75%
Slide 44: Research coverage is misaligned
Summary Research Industrials—54 Non-Core: 5% Core 37 vocecapital industry coverage Coverage Realign 205research Insurance—23 Business isbymisaligned… Industry is now Reduce less than Operating Stock halfRevitalize ofConclusion the coverage universe 11% Financials—70 RealEnergy—70 Estate—51 Core: 11%
Slide 45: Diminished analyst capabilities versus competitors
Summary …resulting Analysts 50 45 600 40 35 30 47 Coverage Realign 630 500 400 700 in diminished Business capabilities Reduce Stock vs. competitors Revitalize Operating Conclusion 25 21 20 15 11 10 329 300 200 214 5KBWnow 100 FBR vocecapital 38 Sandler has coverage significantly FBR KBW than Sandler
Slide 46: Revenue by sector and type
Sector Annual 100% 80% Healthcare 90% Industrials Real 30% Insurance 40% 50% Energy 60% 70% 10% 20% 2011 0% FIG Despite most trading 39 vocecapital Real TMT Estate FIG likely 2012 Consumer revenues rather Banking repeated Estate 2013 because than overstate Insurance 2014 and requests, banking the Tr
Slide 47: Corporate events skewed to non-core areas
Summary Corporate ?September 40 vocecapital FBR Third Healthcare Realign events 9,Annual 2015are Series Business (Boston, Housing skewed NewReduce MA)? toward Financing Prescriptions: FBR Stock non-core Digital Conference, Revitalize Innovation areas Media Operating June Thought in 4, the2015 Treatm
Slide 48: Healthcare acquisition and aftermath
Acquisition Business ?–…time 41 vocecapital At Voce In FBR Management’s Almost Bought Included No 124Only Incremental publishing to October the material 3has 2estimated low to sales institutional time, Reduce all in acknowledge very compensation margin of aof 2013, traders management liquidation ban
Slide 49: Management healthcare expansion promises
Management’s Business Stock “I’m are going compensation Objective healthcare business banking ?Markets “Our more –energy vocecapital Almost Want Trying Time Revenue All Byalready FBR not pleased 2014…then of expanding broadly, Revitalize to CEO and credible sensitive tothe –occur to –Reduce all ramp
Slide 50: Opportunity 2: Disband principal investing
Opportunity 1. 2. 3. vocecapital Exit non-core Disband Drive high principal #1: margin Realign industry investing M&Astrategy sectors within effort and core business industries
Slide 51: 2014 Investor Presentation quote on business model
–“AFBR vocecapital transaction 2014 Investor driven Presentation business model focused on ideas and execution that make money for our clients – not relying on revenue generated from our capital”
Slide 52: Principal investing is inefficient
Principal A Inefficient ?FBR Redemptions –Reduced Summary Business Stock Operating Funds Fixed Multi-strat PE Investment Warrants Marketable Convertible Internally Liquidation Segment Within Expiring Total Currently 45FBR Consumes Management flawed Funds –57.9 value Revitalize Income allocations int
Slide 53: Anemic historical returns on principal investing
Summary Anemic Historical 30.0% 35.0% 10. 20.0% 25.0% 5.0% ((10.0%) — voc1. 46 historical 29.7% Return of Realign pre-tax 15. 4.8% 5.0%)(4.5%) FBR Average Deployed Management disclosures layer 0% 2012 0% for adjusted returns Adjustedcapitfor taxes Capital ($mm) indicate on has mean Business 4% (0.8%
Slide 54: Beware management's additional strategies
Summary –?Beware Management’s 47 vocecapital Management Acquisition Launching Entering Retail Niche ? FBR’s additional credit products Realign the poor new of strategies high reluctance has additional principal and principal Business misallocations floated yield / or origination distribution to inve
Slide 55: Opportunity 3: Drive M&A effort
Opportunity 1. 2. 3. vocecapital Exit non-core Disband Drive high principal #1: margin Realign industry investing M&Astrategy sectors within effort and core business industries
Slide 56: 2014 Investor Presentation quote on advisory growth
– FBR 2014 Investor vocecapital “FocusedPresentation growth in advisory business with several dedicated M&A bankers embedded across industry verticals – healthy pipeline reflecting new expanded capabilities in high volume market”
Slide 57: Then and now peer comparisons
Summary Business Stock In high-performing FBR Then Revenue Compensation Operating Return Price Now to Source:ecapiInvestor 50 measuring September badly EVR that Now /Revitalize Book Earnings on/Reduce those Realign Equity Margin Head GHL Then lags 1.0x itself 2014, Ratio comparisons in $931 12.9x LA
Slide 58: Perennially missed M&A opportunities
Summary Perennially –?“Within $20 $25 Revenues Advisory 2009 FBR 51 vocecapital Advisory FBR They M&A Management should 2010 has CEO are revenues banking, $5 $11 Realign failed 2011 arevenues missed prioritize Rick logical $—has 2012 to have our Hendrix, Business acknowledged opportunities leverage
Slide 59: Opportunity #2: Reduce expenses
Opportunity #2: Reduce expenses vocecapital
Slide 60: Historical expenses and efficiency
Summary Historical 2012 Capital Brokerage Advisory Net Operating % Clearing Business Professional Other Average Revenue Compensation CEO, reimbursement markets ?Headcount 53 Company-stated Margin of Revenue Revenue 2013 CFO 8.4 Opex Raising and Headcount and /Development 6.5 9.9 Realign FBR Profit 2
Slide 61: Accelerated and excessive overhead
–?Accelerated 54 vocecapital FBR’s Despite Excessive Announces Marchanother February September CEO, E.g., SVP CFO response 2016 carrying 2016 of overhead expense 2015 the and –“Investor SVP Announces –Election CIO to –Announces excessive of Announces its growth and average “Corporate disastrous Rela
Slide 62: Opportunity #3: Revitalize corporate governance and accountability
Opportunity #3: Revitalize corporate governance and accountability vocecapital
Slide 63: FBR's Board is not truly independent
Summary Business Stock FBR’s FBR Allison Employment Arthur Tilley(2016) Sachs Mark Reena (2006 Richard Kraemer (Since Thomas (1996 William (2001 Director All Rick Pre-2001 Nearly pre-date 56 vocecapital Hendrix Insider Patterson Revitalize –Crestview Aggarwal 2013) Board Reimers all Leopold 2014)(Si
Slide 64: FBR insider share purchases and sales
Summary FBR Purchases Most Shares Management Brad Jim Adam Michael Kenneth Non-Executive Arthur Allison Mark Reena Richard Thomas William ?Total Note: 57 All Recent NetNeuhauser insiders purchases Wright Non-Executive Executives Most sales Patterson Excludes Agarwal Fishman Reimers Recent Leopold He
Slide 65: Excessive, misaligned CEO compensation
Business Excessive, $6,000,000 $7,000,000 $8,000,000 $5,000,000 $4,000,000 $2,000,000 $$3,000,000 $1,000,000 Return Cumulative -4% -45% Mr. 58 vocecapital —Hendrix TSR 2009 lower Annual Reduce 2010 and ?(’09 market (CEO) has Shareholder misaligned, 2011 made –Stock Present) cap Annual 2012 over Revi
Slide 66: Flawed compensation structure
…extends •–FlawedFunding No –?$20.0 Profitability Summarydirect Mix Historical Compensation Growth Restricted to atincentive “Performance” Tied Solely Based Board-approved to4.0%Cap equity 7.0% based least the (prior tangible Realign Top Stock other 5$on $share cost based for: yearexecutives… Struct
Slide 67: Top executive compensation allocation
Summary …and 9.0% 7.0% 3.0% 5.0% 1.0% Top 12.0% 14.0% 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% OPY -- ?FBR Greedy 60 vocecapital FBR 5is SF 8.3% 5.5% 4.0% 0.8% 6.6% 3.9% 2.7% 1.2% Compensation is 12.0% 9.0% ispaying compensation MC LAZ grossly allocating Realign 2.7% 1.3% 4.2% 1.8% LAZ MC more unfair 3.1% 1.7% 4.5
Slide 68: Conclusion
vocecapital Conclusion
Slide 69: Summary and conclusion
?Summary at operational and 62 vocecapital Voce FBR capital believes hasRealign allocation been and FBR’s governance disastrous, Business expertise current changes Reduce theBoard to potential drive Stock outlined andthe to management Revitalize change restore in ourneeded its plan Conclusion succes
Slide 70: Voce's nominees
Summary Voce’s ?J. 63 vocecapital ?Held Current Daniel since ?Private Senior anominees investment March number Plants Board Realign investor Director, 2006; (Nasdaq:DEST) member of will Business and banker positions Head also usher Chairman Acquisitions atserved at ofCutera, in Reduce Kidder Corpora
Slide 71: Sources
?Sources 64 vocecapital ?Page Page23: 9: 10: 14: 15: 20: 21: 4:Company Activist ProxyCapital Form Forms S&P 10-K, statements, 10-K, campaign website Wall IQ IQ, S-1,Bloomberg, Form Street duration Company Formstatements, 10-K? estimates 10-K? and website, Form Page returns Page 2014 22: 10-K? 11: Co
Slide 72: Sources (continued)
Sources research, 51: ?Page 65 vocecapital Page Form 57: 35:Form 36: 46: 59: 60:Meetings 10-K, Voce Form4? Proxyearnings research, 10-K 10-K, statements statements, Page withVoce 58: management? transcripts? Meetings Proxy research, Formstatements, 10-K with Page Meetings Page management? 53: 42: S&
Slide 73: Voce Disclaimer
VOCE Disclaimer “PARTICIPANTS”) SHAREHOLDERS ALL DOCUMENTS DEFINITIVE INFORMATION http://www.sec.gov/. THE 66 vocecapital SHAREHOLDERS PARTICIPANTS CATALYST PROXY BECOME ABOUT PARTNERS OF INTEND WITH STATEMENT THE OF THE AVAILABLE, THE COMPANY THE TO PARTICIPANTS LP, FILE COMPANY SEC VOCE AND WITH O
Slide 74: Exhibit 3 Participants
EXHIBIT 3 PARTICIPANTS: The participants in this solicitation of proxies from the shareholders of FBR & Co. are anticipated to be: (i) Voce Catalyst Partners LP (“Voce Catalyst Partners”); (ii) Voce Capital Management LLC (“Voce Capital Management”); (iii) Voce Capital LLC (“Voce Capital LLC”); (iv)