Ecology & Environment — Proxy Contest (March 2017)
24 slides from Ecology & Environment's proxy contest presentation, Mar 24, 2017
Slide 1: Presentation to Class A Shareholders by Mill Road Capital II, L.P.
Presentation to Class A Shareholders by Mill Road Capital II, L.P. 2017 Annual Meeting of Shareholders of Ecology & Environment, Inc. April 20, 2017 Exhibit 1
Slide 2: Summary of Contents
Summary of Contents Background Mill Road Capital (“Mill Road”) Situation Summary Timeline Class A Shareholders Key Factors in Board of Directors Vote History of Weak Performance of EEI Operating Performance Stock Price Unsustainable Dividend Governance Deficiencies EEI and Mill Road Nominees Propose
Slide 3: Mill Road Capital
Mill Road Capital Mill Road Capital Founded in 2004 with offices in Greenwich, CT and San Francisco, CA Investment firm with approximately $670 million of aggregate equity commitments Background Core group of former Blackstone professionals Successful track record of public and private investing Lon
Slide 4: Situation Summary
Situation Summary Annual Meeting of Shareholders: April 20, 2017 EEI Board of Directors Board seats: 7 (5 Class B, 2 Class A) (8 seats authorized) Dual Class Structure To elect Directors, each class votes separately for A and B Directors For a combined vote, Class B shares have 10x voting power of C
Slide 5: Timeline of Key Events
Timeline of Key Events 2013 Mill Road buys initial shares in EEI Aug 2014 Mill Road sends letter to Chairman of BoD proposing a take-private No formal response received July 2015 Mill Road purchases block of shares from estate and family of former Chairman, one of the original Founders July 2015 Mil
Slide 6: EEI Class A Shareholders
EEI Class A Shareholders Notes: As of 3/17/17. Source: SEC Filings, Lionshares. The company’s filings are misleading as to the true owners of the Class A Shares. The table below accurately reflects the largest disclosed Class A Shareholders.
Slide 7: Declining Operational Performance
Declining Operational Performance EEI’s operating performance has declined materially over the last 5+ years Notes: All $ in millions. "Gross Profit" equals "Revenue, net" less "Subcontract Costs and Cost of Professional Services" as reported per EEI's SEC filings. Source: SEC Filings.
Slide 8: Substantially Underperforms Peers
Substantially Underperforms Peers EEI underperforms its peers in key operational metrics Notes: All data is as of latest available. Net Revenue is equivalent to “Revenue, net” less “Subcontract Costs”. Peer Group Median defined as “Environmental Consulting” Median on the Zweig Group 2016 Financial P
Slide 9: Material Share Price Decline
-38% Decline Material Share Price Decline Due to EEI’s weak operating performance, the company’s share price has declined 38% over the last five years Source: S&P Capital IQ.
Slide 10: Significantly Below Index and Peers
Significantly Below Index and Peers Total return (share price plus dividends) materially lags the NASDAQ and Peer Group over the past 5 years Notes: Peer Group is per Environmental Financial Consulting Group, a leading industry consultant. Peer Group includes ENXTAM:ARCA, ACM, BWXT, CBI, ENG, EXPO,
Slide 11: Unsustainable Dividend
Unsustainable Dividend Over the past 5+ years, EEI has paid $11 million in total dividends yet only has $2 million in total Net Income Attributable to EEI Shareholders In July 2016, the company cut its dividend by 17% If operating results do not materially improve, future reduction in the dividend i
Slide 12: Disenfranchised Class A Shareholders
Disenfranchised Class A Shareholders Class A shareholders have almost no voice despite holding 70% of the economic ownership of the company The Nominating Committee has ceded authority to the full Board The 5 Class B Directors, through their majority on the Board, therefore control the nomination of
Slide 13: Governance Deficiencies
Governance Deficiencies Long Tenured Board EEI’s current Board has an average tenure of 26 years and an average age of 71 Limited Spectrum of Experience Each member of the current Board either has the same background (working for the Company) or has completely irrelevant experience Board Composition
Slide 14: Governance Deficiencies (cont.)
Governance Deficiencies (cont.) Weak Governance EEI has a set of governance practices that are weak, even for a “controlled company” Nominating, Governance, and Compensation Committees Only formed in Nov 2016, reacting to Mill Road nominations in Oct 2016 As of March 1, 2017 in Company’s definitive
Slide 15: EEI's Weak Nominees for Class A Directors
EEI’s Weak Nominees for Class A Directors EEI has put forth two nominees who lack the background and expertise to represent Class A shareholders Nominee #1: Mike Betrus Background: Auditor/Accountant Junior Accountant: 1976-1981 Divisional Controller: 1985-1994 Contracts & Accounting Manager at EEI:
Slide 16: EEI's Weak Nominees for Class A Directors
EEI’s Weak Nominees for Class A Directors Nominee #2: Robert Untracht Background: Auditor/Professor Auditor: 1974-1981 Auditor: 1981-1998 Accounting Professor: 1989-1994 Accounting Professor: 1999-2003 Financial Reporting Consultant: 2007-2012 The Company states: “…He has personally conducted due di
Slide 17: Mill Road Nominees
Mill Road Nominees Mill Road’s nominees have extensive experience in the following critical areas: Strategic Planning and Value Creation Operational Turnaround Public and Private Company Boards Acquisitions Founder-Led Companies in Transition The Nominees: Justin Jacobs Michael El-Hillow Relationshi
Slide 18: Nominee: Justin Jacobs
Nominee: Justin Jacobs Summary Biography: Managing Director of Mill Road Capital Vice President of LiveWire Capital Part of a team focused on operationally-intensive buyouts of small companies The Blackstone Group Investment professional in the private equity group Relevant Board of Directors Experi
Slide 19: Nominee: Michael El-Hillow
Nominee: Michael El-Hillow Summary Biography: CFO of National Technical Systems, Inc. (Public / Private) CEO, CFO / COO of Evergreen Solar, Inc. (Public) CFO of Advanced Energy Industries, Inc. (Public) CFO of Helix Technology Corp. (Public) CFO of A.T. Cross Company (ATX) (Public / Controlled Compa
Slide 20: Case Study: National Technical Systems (NTSC)
Case Study: National Technical Systems (NTSC) NTSC is a leading engineering and test laboratory business serving large government, defense and aerospace customers Situation: Mill Road started following NTSC in 2008 and acquired an approximately 5% ownership stake from 2008 to 2010 NTSC’s Chairman ap
Slide 21: Case Study: National Technical Systems (NTSC)
Case Study: National Technical Systems (NTSC) Michael El-Hillow appointed CFO NTSC announces sale to 3rd party buyer
Slide 22: Comparison of Nominees
Comparison of Nominees Key Experience Justin Jacobs Michael El-Hillow Michael Betrus Robert Untracht Strategic Planning ✔ ✔ Operational Turnaround ✔ ✔ Public and Private Company Board ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Successful Transition of Founder-Led Companies ✔ ✔ Acquisition Experience ✔ ✔
Slide 23: Mill Road Capital – Proposed Plan for EEI
Mill Road Capital – Proposed Plan for EEI Our nominees are committed to working collaboratively with the existing Board Improve Corporate Governance Implement basic corporate governance best practices Establish formal committees with proper independence Align management and company performance throu
Slide 24: Conclusion
Conclusion EEI’s Current Situation Performance is Poor Operational performance is weak and declining Total shareholder return significantly lags comparable companies and indices Board Oversight is Weak The Board is ineffective Directors lack experience in key areas to effectuate change Recommendatio