Select Income REIT — Proxy Contest (January 2015)
31 slides from Select Income REIT's proxy contest presentation, Jan 14, 2015
Slide 1: Lakewood Capital's Presentation to the Board of Trustees
Select Income REIT Lakewood Capital’s Presentation to the Board of Trustees January 13, 2015
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer THIS PRESENTATION IS FOR DISCUSSION AND GENERAL INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. IT DOES NOT HAVE REGARD TO THE SPECIFIC INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE, FINANCIAL SITUATION, SUITABILITY, OR THE PARTICULAR NEED OF ANY SPECIFIC PERSON WHO MAY RECEIVE THIS PRESENTATION, AND SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN AS ADVICE O
Slide 3: Table of Contents
Table of Contents Who is Lakewood Capital? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 How Did We Get Here? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Grav
Slide 4: Who is Lakewood Capital?
Who is Lakewood Capital? Firm Overview Founded in 2007, Lakewood Capital Management, LP ("Lakewood") is an SEC-registered investment adviser based in New York, NY Over $3 billion in assets under management Value-oriented investment partnership dedicated to providing attractive long-term return
Slide 5: How Did We Get Here?
How Did We Get Here? Lakewood’s Position in SIR Lakewood holds a 6.8% economic interest in Select Income REIT (“SIR” or the “Company”) through ownership of common stock and cash-settled total return swaps We believe we are the second-largest independent shareholder of SIR We are a long-term sh
Slide 6: Grave Corporate Governance Concerns
Grave Corporate Governance Concerns SIR suffers from a misalignment of interests due to its external management structure in which the manager, Reit Management & Research LLC (“RMR”), receives fees almost entirely based off the size of the assets of the Company, not SIR’s share price performance.
Slide 7: Grave Corporate Governance Concerns
Grave Corporate Governance Concerns The Board has a fiduciary duty to act in the best interest of shareholders and protect shareholders from the inherent misalignment of interests from the external management structure. Instead, recent actions taken by the Board have (1) only further entrenched RM
Slide 8: Recent Board Actions Are Concerning
Recent Board Actions Are Concerning On March 25, 2014, the shareholders of CommonWealth REIT (“CWH”), an RMR-managed public company that owned 44% of SIR at the time, voted to remove its entire Board of Trustees (including SIR Trustees Barry Portnoy, Adam Portnoy and William Lamkin, who together hol
Slide 9: Concerns Raised in Our June 2014 Letter
Concerns Raised in Our June 2014 Letter Concern##1: Concern 1: Using Bad Faith Tactics to Ensure the Board De-staggering Amendment Did Not Pass In September 2013, SIR announced that it would propose an amendment to SIR’s Declaration of Trust that would eliminate the current three-year staggered te
Slide 10: Concerns Raised in Our June 2014 Letter
Concerns Raised in Our June 2014 Letter Concern##2: Concern 1: Obligating SIR to Pay RMR a Termination Fee in the Event of a Termination In May 2014 (just two months after the CWH Board was removed), the SIR Board amended its management agreements with RMR to obligate the Company to pay a terminat
Slide 11: Concerns Raised in Our June 2014 Letter
Concerns Raised in Our June 2014 Letter Concern##3: Concern 1: Conducting a Large and Unnecessary Dilutive Equity Offering In May 2014, the Company announced a public offering of nine million shares, which amounted to an astounding 18% of the outstanding common shares and 32% of the freely-tradabl
Slide 12: New Concerns Have Arisen Since Our Letter
New Concerns Have Arisen Since Our Letter # 1: #1: An RMR-Related Entity purchased CWH’s 37% SIR stake New Concern Concern In July 2014, RMR and Government Properties Income Trust (“GOV”), an RMR-managed entity, purchased CWH’s 37% stake in SIR at a premium to the market price GOV’s substantial
Slide 13: SIR's Stock Price Performance Reflects Concerns
SIR’s Stock Price Performance Reflects Concerns May 2014 Equity Offering GOV Purchases SIR Stake from CWH Announces Expensive and Dilutive CCIT Acquisition Source: Bloomberg 13
Slide 14: Governance Concerns Are Widely Held
Governance Concerns Are Widely Held Third Party Statements Morgan Stanley Research Analyst “We are lowering our base case for SIR to $26 from $29 and converting our base (December 1, 2014 Report) case to a price target. We arrive at this PT using a ~10x multiple on our updated 2015 FFO of $2.69 (dow
Slide 15: Governance Concerns Are Widely Held
Governance Concerns Are Widely Held Publication / Author Statements Re: RMR and CWH New York Times / Gretchen Morgenson • “The annals of business history abound with stories of entrenched corporate (“Management, to the Barricades!,” May 4, executives building fortifications to maintain their plush s
Slide 16: Proxy Advisory Firms Note RMR-Related Concerns
Proxy Advisory Firms Note RMR-Related Concerns Proxy Advisory Service Statements Re: RMR and CWH Institutional Shareholder Services, • ISS gave CWH, an RMR-managed entity at the time, a score of 10 (the worst possible Inc. (“ISS”) score), for Shareholder Rights (1 indicates lower governance risk, 10
Slide 17: SIR's Stock Has Dramatically Lagged Peers
SIR’s Stock Has Dramatically Lagged Peers From the IPO to the time of our 13D filing, SIR’s stock has underperformed its peers by 28% cumulatively, despite the Company’s discounted IPO price. Total Shareholder Return Since SIR IPO(1) 119% 120% 100% 80% 76% 67% 69% Peer Median: +61% 63% 59% 60% Under
Slide 18: SIR's Stock Has Dramatically Lagged Peers
SIR’s Stock Has Dramatically Lagged Peers In the twelve months preceding our 13D filing, SIR’s stock has underperformed its peers by 29% cumulatively, which we believe reflects growing governance concerns. Total Shareholder Return (Past Twelve Months)(1) 40% 31% 30% 28% 26% Peer Median: +21% 21% 21%
Slide 19: No Growth in Funds from Operations Per Share
No Growth in Funds from Operations Per Share Despite growing assets by over 4x since the IPO, Funds From Operations (“FFO”) per share has remained stagnant. This is particularly disappointing in light of the significant tailwind the Company had from rental resets in the Hawaii portfolio. SIR Normali
Slide 20: SIR's Stock is Dramatically Undervalued
SIR’s Stock is Dramatically Undervalued Based on a conservative multiple of Projected 2015 FFO per share, we believe shares of SIR are worth around $35 to $45 per share, approximately 40% to 70% above recent trading levels. Target FFO Scenarios Low Middle High (A) 2015 Projected SIR FFO ($/share) (1
Slide 21: SIR's Stock is Dramatically Undervalued
SIR’s Stock is Dramatically Undervalued Based on a 5.25% cap rate for the Hawaii portfolio (reflecting its high quality and embedded growth) and 6.5% cap rate for the mainland portfolio, we believe shares of SIR are worth $35 to $40 per share, approximately 30% to 50% above recent trading levels. NO
Slide 22: SIR's Stock Trades at a Large Discount to Peers
SIR’s Stock Trades at a Large Discount to Peers The shares of SIR trade at a discount of over 40% to the peers based on Price / 2015 FFO and nearly 30% based on capitalization rates despite the Company’s premium Hawaii asset portfolio. We believe the discount in the stock is the result of the widely
Slide 23: SIR's Stock Trades at a Large Discount to Peers
SIR’s Stock Trades at a Large Discount to Peers On all key valuation metrics, SIR trades at discounts of 30% to 40% vs its peers. Dividend Yield(1) Cash Cap Rate(1) P / 2015 FFO(1) 8% 9% 18x 17.0x 7.4% 8.4% 7% 8% SIR 16x discount SIR of 29% 7% 14x SIR 6% discount discount of 41% 6.0% of 43% 6% 12x 5
Slide 24: Misalignment: RMR is Incented to Grow Assets
Misalignment: RMR is Incented to Grow Assets SIR has grown its assets and share count significantly more than its peers… Total Assets vs. Q1’12(1) Growth in Diluted Shares Since Q1 2012(1) 5.0x 4.6x 200% 183% 4.0x 150% 3.0x 100% 2.0x 1.3x 50% 36% 1.0x 0.0x 0% SIR Peer Median SIR Peer Median … leadin
Slide 25: Misalignment: RMR Wins, Shareholders Lose
Misalignment: RMR Wins, Shareholders Lose While RMR Fees have grown by 319%, shareholder returns have underperformed peers by 28%. Fees to RMR Over Time ($ millions)(1) Shareholder Return Since SIR IPO(2) $40 70% $34.5 61% $35 60% SIR underperformed peers by 28% $30 RMR fees +319% 50% since Q2 2012
Slide 26: Our Highly Qualified Nominee: William H. Lenehan
Our Highly Qualified Nominee: William H. Lenehan SIR shareholders need a true independent voice on the Board. We have nominated William H. Lenehan, a highly qualified real estate executive with significant public company experience to the Board, to give shareholders a voice and seek to improve the C
Slide 27: Appendix A: Our Highly Qualified Nominee
Appendix A OUR HIGHLY QUALIFIED NOMINEE 27
Slide 28: William H. Lenehan Biography
William H. Lenehan Biography William H. Lenehan is an independent real estate industry professional with significant experience in net leased properties and public company corporate governance matters Formerly Interim Chief Executive Officer of MI Developments, Inc. (NYSE: MIM), a real estate op
Slide 29: Track Record: MI Developments (MIM)
Track Record: MI Developments (MIM) Mr. Lenehan served as interim CEO of MI Developments in late 2011 • During Mr. Lenehan’s tenure as CEO, MIM (now called Granite Real Estate Investments), generated a total shareholder return of +7.9%, significantly outperforming the RMZ Index, which declined -10
Slide 30: Track Record: Gramercy Property Trust (GPT)
Track Record: Gramercy Property Trust (GPT) Mr. Lenehan was elected to GPT’s Board on January 17, 2012 Since that time, GPT has generated total shareholder returns of +123.0%(1) • This represents total returns of more than double the RMZ Index, which is up +52.1% and significantly better than th
Slide 31: Track Record: Stratus Properties (STRS)
Track Record: Stratus Properties (STRS) Mr. Lenehan was elected to STRS’s Board on May 24, 2012 Since that time, STRS has generated total shareholder returns of +84.2%(1) • This represents total returns significantly above the RMZ Index, which is up +41.1% and significantly better than the overa