ODP — Office Depot — Proxy Contest (August 2013)
63 slides from ODP's proxy contest presentation, Aug 2, 2013
Slide 1: Investor Presentation Office Depot, Inc.
Investor Presentation Office Depot, Inc. August 2, 2013
Slide 2: Overview of Starboard Value LP
Overview of Starboard Value LP Starboard Value LP is a deep value oriented investment firm that specializes in investing in underperforming companies and analyzing alternative strategies to unlock value for the benefit of all shareholders. − Our approach to investment research begins with a deep f
Slide 3: Why We Are Involved with Office Depot
Why We Are Involved with Office Depot We first invested in Office Depot (“ODP” or the “Company”) in July 2012 because our research indicated that an opportunity existed to create significant value for Office Depot shareholders based on actions within the control of management and the Board of Dire
Slide 4: It Is a Critical Time for the Future of Office Depot
It Is a Critical Time for the Future of Office Depot While we have continued to push for, and be supportive of, the OfficeMax Merger, we believe the transaction puts Office Depot at a critical juncture. Now more than ever, Office Depot NEEDS a well-qualified, committed Board to protect the interes
Slide 5: It Is a Critical Time for the Future of Office Depot
It Is a Critical Time for the Future of Office Depot If the OfficeMax Merger closes, the new Board will be tasked with transforming the Company for the future. If the OfficeMax Merger closes, the pro forma Board will be tasked with developing the long-term plan of the combined company, including:
Slide 6: Change is Necessary at This Critical Time for Office Depot
Change is Necessary at This Critical Time for Office Depot Now more than ever, shareholders require and deserve well-qualified and committed representation in the boardroom for the following reasons: To substantially improve the disastrous operating performance that has persisted under the watch o
Slide 7: Our Nominees Are Vastly More Qualified Than the Four Incumbent Directors
Our Nominees Are Vastly More Qualified Than the Four Incumbent Directors We Are Seeking to Replace Through an exhaustive search process, we identified and nominated a slate of four candidates with exceptional and relevant credentials, including: Cynthia Jamison – Lead director of Tractor Supply Co
Slide 8: Our Nominees Have a Superior Plan to Successfully Transform Office Depot
Our Nominees Have a Superior Plan to Successfully Transform Office Depot and Enhance Value Either as a Stand-Alone or Merged Company Over the past nine months, Starboard and our Nominees have been working closely with one of the world’s leading restructuring firms that we engaged to assist us in d
Slide 9: Starboard’s Involvement Has Yielded Positive Results for Shareholders
Starboard’s Involvement Has Yielded Positive Results for Shareholders Our involvement in Office Depot over the past 11 months since we filed our initial Schedule 13D in September 2012 has been constructive and has yielded positive benefits for all shareholders. Through five public letters and nu
Slide 10: Starboard’s Involvement Has Yielded Positive Results for Shareholders
Starboard’s Involvement Has Yielded Positive Results for Shareholders We do not believe that Office Depot’s recent actions to enhance value for shareholders is a coincidence. For years, Office Depot failed to create value for shareholders and only since our involvement has the Board begun to tak
Slide 11: Real Change Is Necessary Now
Real Change Is Necessary Now 11
Slide 12: Dramatic Stock Price Underperformance
Dramatic Stock Price Underperformance Prior to Starboard filing a Schedule 13D on September 17, 2012, Office Depot’s stock price had materially underperformed both the broader equity markets, its Peer Group, and its direct office supply superstore (“OSS”) competitors – Staples and OfficeMax – over a
Slide 13: Weak Historical Financial Performance
Weak Historical Financial Performance Despite a massive revenue decline of $4.8 billion from 2007 to 2012, total G&A expense has actually increased, causing G&A expense as a percentage of revenue to increase from 4.2% to 6.3% and Adjusted EBITDA margins to decline from 5.3% to 3.1% over the same tim
Slide 14: Weak Historical Financial Performance
Weak Historical Financial Performance Since 2007, Office Depot’s retail comp sales and sales per square foot have declined dramatically. North American Retail Comp Sales % Change North American Retail Sales $ per Sq. Ft. (1) ($ in millions) 0% $280 $254 ($79) Decline -1% $250 -2% $220 -3% $190 $175
Slide 15: Substantial Market Share Losses
Substantial Market Share Losses Office Depot continues to lose significant market share to Staples. Historical North American Retail Market Share (1) 40% SPLS: Gained 6% Market Share 30% ODP: Lost 4% Market Share Market Share 20% OMX: Lost 3% Market Share 10% 0% 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Office
Slide 16: Office Depot’s Margins Have Significantly Underperformed Compared to Peers
Office Depot’s Margins Have Significantly Underperformed Compared to Peers Despite substantial revenue and an attractive asset base, Office Depot has struggled to run its business effectively, resulting in the lowest margins of all of its peers. 2012 Peer Group Financials ($ in millions) 2012 Adj. O
Slide 17: Unfortunately, Office Depot’s Recent Results Continue to be Alarming
Unfortunately, Office Depot’s Recent Results Continue to be Alarming Recent revenue, same store sales, and operating margins continue to be the worst among OSS peers. Avg. 4Q12/1Q13 Revenue % Change Avg. 4Q12/1Q13 SG&A as % Revenue 0% 30% -0.1% 23% 24% -2% 25% 20% 20% -4% 15% -6% 10% -6.5% -8% 5% -8
Slide 18: Management and Board Lack Essential Retail Experience
Management and Board Lack Essential Retail Experience and Have Not Been Held Accountable for Office Depot’s Poor Performance Management Board • CEO’s operating experience outside of Office Depot • Only 2 out of the Company’s 10 current directors have consists of the National Football League (NFL) an
Slide 19: Only Two of Office Depot’s Ten Current Board Members Have Any Substantial Retail Operating Experience
Only Two of Office Depot’s Ten Current Board Members Have Any Substantial Retail Operating Experience Apart from Nigel Travis and Kathleen Mason, the rest of the Board lacks substantial retail operating experience (1) Name Relevant Prior Operating Experience (1) Experience(1) Thomas Colligan Forme
Slide 20: Office Depot’s Replacement of One Director Was Reactionary
Office Depot’s Replacement of One Director Was Reactionary and Falls Far Short of the Meaningful Improvement the Board Needs ■ On July 5, 2013, Office Depot announced that Michael Massey will be nominated for election to the Board to replace Brenda Gaines. ■ While adding a new independent director w
Slide 21: Office Depot Is at a Critical Juncture and Change Is Necessary Now
Office Depot Is at a Critical Juncture and Change Is Necessary Now to Improve Performance at the Company ■ In summary, under the watch of the current Board, Office Depot’s financial performance has continued to deteriorate and substantial value has been destroyed: ■ Prior to our involvement, the Com
Slide 22: The Current Board Has Sought to Entrench Itself and Has Overseen Troubling Corporate Governance Practices
The Current Board Has Sought to Entrench Itself and Has Overseen Troubling Corporate Governance Practices 22
Slide 23: The Current Board has Sought to Entrench Itself by Instituting a Poison Pill
The Current Board has Sought to Entrench Itself by Instituting a Poison Pill with a 15% Ownership Threshold On October 24, 2012, only days after Starboard had amended its 13D filing disclosing a 14.8% ownership position in Office Depot, the Company unilaterally instituted a Poison Pill with a 15%
Slide 24: The Current Board has Sought to Entrench Itself by Instituting a Poison Pill
The Current Board has Sought to Entrench Itself by Instituting a Poison Pill with a 15% Ownership Threshold As shown in the table below, at the time Office Depot instituted the Poison Pill, the Board was in position to increase its effective voting authority to above 30% within three years, while
Slide 25: The Current Board Sought to Disenfranchise Shareholders by Manipulating the Annual Meeting Timing
The Current Board Sought to Disenfranchise Shareholders by Manipulating the Timing of the Annual Meeting The current Board played games in delaying the date of the 2013 Annual Meeting. For at least the last six years, Office Depot has consistently held its Annual Meeting in the latter half of Ap
Slide 26: The Current Board Has a Long History of Self-Interested Behavior
The Current Board Has a Long History of Self-Interested Behavior and Disregard for Shareholders’ Interests Self-Interested Arrangement with BC Partners : In 2009, Office Depot negotiated an arrangement with BC Partners which contemplated that BC Partners would invest $350 million in Office Depot,
Slide 27: We Have Serious Questions About the 2010 CEO Search Process
We Have Serious Questions About the 2010 CEO Search Process On October 25, 2010, Office Depot announced that its then-CEO, Steve Odland, would be stepping down and that Neil Austrian would assume the role of interim CEO and Chairman. A CEO search committee was formed consisting of four directors
Slide 28: We Have Serious Questions About the 2010 CEO Search Process
We Have Serious Questions About the 2010 CEO Search Process Neil Austrian claimed that the Company was looking for the following in a new CEO: “We want a Hall of Fame guy. I think the specs are pretty obvious…you want someone who’s an absolute proven leader, somebody who’s run a major business,
Slide 29: We Have Serious Questions About the 2010 CEO Search Process
We Have Serious Questions About the 2010 CEO Search Process Further, through our public involvement in Office Depot over the last year, a number of highly qualified former CEO’s and high level executives with substantial retail experience have reached out to us stating that at the time of the sear
Slide 30: Leading Proxy Advisory Firms Have Raised Serious Concerns Regarding ODP’s Compensation Practices
Leading Proxy Advisory Firms Have Raised Serious Concerns Regarding ODP’s Compensation Practices and Board Structure Glass Lewis recommended that shareholders vote AGAINST four of ODP’s nominees last year, including two of the ODP nominees we oppose -- Marsha Evans who has served as Chair of ODP’s
Slide 31: Leading Proxy Governance Firms Have Raised Serious Concerns with Regard to ODP’s Compensation Practices
Leading Proxy Governance Firms Have Raised Serious Concerns with Regard to ODP’s Compensation Practices Marsha Evans has served as Chair of ODP’s compensation committee since 2009 and Hedrick has served as a member since at least 1994, serving as Chair from 1996 through 2004. Over the last three
Slide 32: Leading Proxy Governance Firms Have Raised Serious Concerns with Regard to ODP’s Compensation Practices
Leading Proxy Governance Firms Have Raised Serious Concerns with Regard to ODP’s Compensation Practices In last year’s proxy paper, Glass Lewis noted the following concerns regarding ODP’s compensation practices, many of which they have been highlighting for years: No Performance Based Long-Term I
Slide 33: Compensation Committee Continues to Ignore Glass Lewis Concerns
Office Depot’s Compensation Committee Continues to Ignore the Concerns Highlighted by Glass Lewis Glass Lewis Concern #1 – No Performance-Based Long-Term Incentive Awards Glass Lewis Concern: The Long Term Incentive compensation program consisted entirely of time based vesting with only a minimal
Slide 34: Compensation Committee Continues to Ignore Glass Lewis Concerns
Office Depot’s Compensation Committee Continues to Ignore the Concerns Highlighted by Glass Lewis Glass Lewis Concern #2 – Incentive Limits Glass Lewis Concern: The Compensation committee allows executives to receive unlimited compensation through the STI plan which Glass Lewis states in its proxy
Slide 35: Compensation Committee Continues to Ignore Glass Lewis Concerns
Office Depot’s Compensation Committee Continues to Ignore the Concerns Highlighted by Glass Lewis Glass Lewis Concern #3 – Guaranteed Bonuses Glass Lewis Concern: The Compensation committee has granted Mr. Newman and Ms. Garcia large annual guaranteed bonuses, regardless of the performance of the
Slide 36: Compensation Committee Continues to Ignore Glass Lewis Concerns
Office Depot’s Compensation Committee Continues to Ignore the Concerns Highlighted by Glass Lewis Glass Lewis Concern #4 – Peer Group Concerns Glass Lewis Concern: A choice of a peer group can have a significant impact on the size and structure of compensation. Many times, the management at larger
Slide 37: Glass Lewis Recommended Shareholders Vote AGAINST Compensation Committee Leadership
Glass Lewis Recommended Shareholders Vote AGAINST Compensation Committee Leadership Each of the Last 4 Years Glass Lewis’ concerns regarding Office Depot’s compensation practices is not a new problem Glass Lewis has given Office Depot a grade of “F” for four out of the last five years with the onl
Slide 38: Shareholders Have Also Demonstrated Their Concern with Compensation Practices and Board Structure
Shareholders Have Also Demonstrated Their Concern with Compensation Practices and Board Structure at Office Depot At the 2011 Annual Meeting, the Company had on the ballot, for the first time, a non-binding resolution for shareholders to approve management compensation. Approximately 33% of vote
Slide 39: Board Continues to Ignore Shareholder Concerns Regarding Compensation and Board Structure
Office Depot’s Board Continues to Also Ignore the Concerns of Its Shareholders Regarding Compensation and Board Structure Shareholder Concern #1: The desire that long-term compensation be linked to long-term performance of the FAILED Company While Office Depot made some cosmetic changes to its 201
Slide 40: Board Continues to Ignore Shareholder Concerns: Combined Chairman and CEO Role
Office Depot’s Board Continues to Also Ignore the Concerns of Its Shareholders Regarding Compensation and Board Structure Shareholder Concern #2: The combined role of the Chairman and CEO FAILED After the resignation of the former CEO, Steve Odland, and Mr. Austrian becoming interim CEO and Chairm
Slide 41: Board Continues to Ignore Shareholder Concerns: Compensation Committee Membership
Office Depot’s Board Continues to Also Ignore the Concerns of Its Shareholders Regarding Compensation and Board Structure Shareholder Concern #3: The membership on the compensation committee of Raymond Svider, a representative FAILED of BC Partners Given BC Partners’ preferred ownership interest i
Slide 42: Serious Questions About the Lack of Ownership and Long Tenure of the Current Board
We Have Serious Questions About the Lack of Ownership and Long Tenure of the Current Board ■ The current Board has an average tenure of 7 years. (1) ■ Despite having collectively received millions in Board fees, we note that the current Board members appear to have only personally purchased in aggre
Slide 43: Serious Questions Regarding the Track Records of Incumbent Board Members
We Have Serious Questions Regarding the Track Records of Office Depot’s Incumbent Board Members Marsha Evans: As Chair of the Compensation committee for each of the last 3 years, Glass Lewis has recommended that shareholders vote AGAINST Ms. Evans’ continued service on the Board of Office Depot an
Slide 44: Serious Questions Regarding the Track Records of Incumbent Board Members
We Have Serious Questions Regarding the Track Records of Office Depot’s Incumbent Board Members W. Scott Hedrick: Mr. Hedrick has served on the Board for 22 years, since 1991. Over his lengthy tenure on the Board, Office Depot deteriorated from one of the leading Office Supply Companies to the w
Slide 45: Serious Questions Regarding the Track Records of Incumbent Board Members
We Have Serious Questions Regarding the Track Records of Office Depot’s Incumbent Board Members Tom Colligan: Mr. Colligan serves as the chair of the audit committee of the Board. Glass Lewis recommended a vote AGAINST his continued service on the Board in 2011 when he was a member of the audit co
Slide 46: Serious Questions Regarding the Track Records of Incumbent Board Members
We Have Serious Questions Regarding the Track Records of Office Depot’s Incumbent Board Members Eugene Fife: Eugene Fife joined the Board on July 24, 2012, pursuant to the terms of the Investor Rights Agreement between Office Depot and BC Partners which provides BC Partners with a contractual righ
Slide 47: The Directors We Are Seeking to Replace Lack Operational Retail Experience
The Directors We Are Seeking to Replace Lack Operational Retail Experience All four directors we are seeking to replace lack the necessary operational experience to transform Office Depot. Relevant Name Operating Prior Operating Experience (1) Experience(1) Formerly Vice Dean of the Wharton School
Slide 48: Our Independent Nominees are More Qualified and Have a Better Plan
Our Independent Nominees are More Qualified and Have a Better Plan to Oversee Office Depot for the Benefit of All Shareholders 48
Slide 49: Office Depot Is at a Critical Juncture and an Improved Board Is Desperately Needed
Office Depot Is at a Critical Juncture and an Improved Board Is Desperately Needed Now to Improve Performance at the Company ■ Under the watch of the current Board, Office Depot’s financial performance has deteriorated and significant value has been destroyed: ■ Prior to our involvement, the Company
Slide 50: Starboard’s Nominees Have Strong Relevant Experience
Starboard’s Nominees Have Strong Relevant Experience Cynthia T. Jamison: ■ Ms. Jamison is a seasoned, high energy Board member and CFO with over 25 years of experience, providing her with a variety of internal and external strategic perspectives in the retail, consumer products, food, and other indu
Slide 51: Starboard’s Nominees Have Strong Relevant Experience
Starboard’s Nominees Have Strong Relevant Experience Robert L. Nardelli: Mr. Nardelli is widely recognized as one of the best operating executives in the United States, having grown sales and profits of several businesses for nearly 30 years at General Electric Co., doubling the size of The Home D
Slide 52: Starboard’s Nominees Have Strong Relevant Experience
Starboard’s Nominees Have Strong Relevant Experience Jeffrey C. Smith Managing Member, Chief Executive Officer and Chief Investment Officer of Starboard Value, the largest shareholder of Office Depot. As Chief Investment Officer of Starboard Value, Mr. Smith has significant experience evaluating c
Slide 53: Starboard’s Nominees Have Strong Relevant Experience
Starboard’s Nominees Have Strong Relevant Experience Joseph S. Vassalluzzo: ■ Mr. Vassalluzzo has substantial operating experience in high-profile retail and real estate executive positions, providing him with the skill set, acumen and professional management to facilitate and enable an organization
Slide 54: Our Nominees Are More Qualified than the Incumbent Board to Maximize Value
Our Nominees Are More Qualified than the Incumbent Board to Maximize Value for Shareholders Name Experience Name Experience Joe Vassalluzzo Former Vice Chairman of Staples, the largest Office Marsha Evans Majority of operating experience consists of roles at non- Supply Company in the world prof
Slide 55: Our Nominees Have a Better Plan to Create Value
Our Nominees Have a Better Plan to Create Value As stated earlier in the presentation, we have been working with one of the world’s leading and most successful restructuring firms for the past nine months to develop a comprehensive plan to successfully transform Office Depot. We separately filed
Slide 56: Our Nominees Have a Better Plan to Create Value
Our Nominees Have a Better Plan to Create Value In total, we believe our plan for Office Depot will improve operating margins from 0.9% to 7.3%, while providing Office Depot with a plan to successfully transform the future of the Company. Annual EBIT Run Rate After Full Implementation Efficiency & E
Slide 57: Our Nominees Can Help Drive an Even Greater Upside in a Merger with OfficeMax
Our Nominees Can Help Drive an Even Greater Upside in a Merger with OfficeMax Office Depot and OfficeMax have publicly stated they project synergies of $400 million to $600 million over three years, excluding any synergies related to store closures. However, we believe that the synergies from th
Slide 58: Appendix
Appendix Director Nominees − Cynthia T. Jamison − Robert L. Nardelli − Jeffrey C. Smith − Joseph S. Vassalluzzo 58
Slide 59: Cynthia T. Jamison
Cynthia T. Jamison Ms. Jamison currently serves on the board of directors of Tractor Supply Company, where she is currently lead director and has served as the chair of several committees since joining the board in 2002. Ms. Jamison has also served as a director of B&G Foods, Inc., since 2004. Pre
Slide 60: Robert L. Nardelli
Robert L. Nardelli Mr. Nardelli is the founder and Chief Executive Officer of XLR- 8, LLC, Investment & Advisory Co., an investment and consulting company, he established in 2012. Commencing in 2007, Mr. Nardelli has served in several capacities at Cerberus Capital Management, L.P., a private inve
Slide 61: Jeffrey C. Smith
Jeffrey C. Smith Mr. Smith is co- Founder, Chief Executive Officer and Chief Investment Officer of Starboard Value LP, a New York- based investment firm that is the largest stockholder of Office Depot. Mr. Smith has extensive public company board experience. Currently, he serves on the board of di
Slide 62: Joseph S. Vassalluzzo
Joseph S. Vassalluzzo Mr. Vassalluzzo currently serves as a director on a number of public company boards, including Federal Realty Investment Trust, where he is Non- Executive Chairman of the Board, and Life Time Fitness, where he is Lead Director and Chairman of the Compensation Committee. Mr. V
Slide 63: This Presentation Is for Discussion and General Informational Purposes Only
THIS PRESENTATION IS FOR DISCUSSION AND GENERAL INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. IT DOES NOT HAVE REGARD TO THE SPECIFIC INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE, FINANCIAL SITUATION, SUITABILITY, OR THE PARTICULAR NEED OF ANY SPECIFIC PERSON WHO MAY RECEIVE THIS PRESENTATION, AND SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN AS ADVICE ON THE MERIT