Equity Commonwealth — CommonWealth REIT — Proxy Contest (March 2014)
62 slides from Equity Commonwealth's proxy contest presentation, Mar 5, 2014
Slide 1: Presentation to Shareholders March 5, 2014
Presentation to Shareholders March 5, 2014 111 East Wacker Drive & 233 North Michigan Avenue Chicago, IL Mellon Bank Center 1735 Market Street Philadelphia, PA Chase Tower 111 Monument Circle Indianapolis, IN CommonWealth REIT
Slide 2: Legal disclaimers
CommonWealth REIT Legal disclaimers. WARNING REGARDING FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS THIS PRESENTATION CONTAINS FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE PRIVATE SECURITIES LITIGATION REFORM ACT OF 1995 AND OTHER SECURITIES LAWS. ALSO, WHENEVER WE USE WORDS SUCH AS "BELIEVE," "EXPECT," "ANTI
Slide 3: Table of contents
CommonWealth REIT Table of contents. Page Executive Summary. 4 18 CWH benefits from being managed by RMR. 24 30 Related/Corvex are attempting to take control of CWH without paying shareholders anything for that control. 36 Removing the entire CWH Board by written consent may destroy shareholder valu
Slide 4: Executive Summary
CommonWealth REIT Executive Summary 4
Slide 5: Board and management have been repositioning CWH's portfolio
CommonWealth REIT portfolio. Since 2008, the Board and management have been aggressively repositioning CWH’s portfolio. Since 2008, CWH has acquired $3.7 billion of properties and most of these acquisitions were high quality office properties in central business district (CBD) locations purchased fr
Slide 6: Over the long term, CWH's stock performance has been strong
Over the long term, CWH’s stock performance has been strong. 6 Source: FactSet and SNL Financial. (1) CWH began to focus its portfolio on office properties at the end of 1999 when it distributed to shareholders healthcare properties in the form of shares of Senior Housing Properties Trust: (NYSE: SN
Slide 7: Many shareholders and analysts are supportive of CWH's business plan
CommonWealth REIT Many shareholders and analysts are supportive of CWH’s business plan. business plan. 7 “The management of CommonWealth has been much maligned recently as the company engages in a takeover battle with Corvex and the Related Companies. In fact, we believe that management at CommonWea
Slide 8: CWH benefits from being managed by RMR
CommonWealth REIT CWH benefits from being managed by RMR. RMR founded CWH in 1986 and has been its manager for the last 28 years; CWH has no employees and its operations are conducted through management agreements with RMR. RMR provides CWH with a nationwide, fully integrated real estate management
Slide 9: Related/Corvex plan is not in shareholders' interests
CommonWealth REIT interests of shareholders. This grade debt ratings, two criteria that REIT investors typically value highly. Related/Corvex base their estimated current net asset value (NAV) of $35 per share and projected 12/31/2015 stock value of approximately $40 per share on faulty financial an
Slide 10: Related/Corvex are attempting to take control of CWH without paying shareholders
CommonWealth REIT Related/Corvex are attempting to take control of CWH without paying shareholders anything for that control. 10 Ever since Related identified CWH as a potential takeover target in 2012, Related/Corvex have engaged in a relentless pursuit to take control of CWH. In February and March
Slide 11: Related/Corvex added two candidates with excessive special compensation
CommonWealth REIT Related/Corvex recently added two candidates to their slate, but had to offer them excessive special compensation arrangements to join their campaign. 11 Sam Zell Related/Corvex are willing to pay $17 million to get Zell and Helfand to join their campaign to take control David Helf
Slide 12: Removing the entire CWH Board by written consent may destroy shareholder value
CommonWealth REIT Removing the entire CWH Board by written consent may destroy shareholder value. The removal of the entire board of a public company by written consent without concurrently electing a replacement board is unprecedented in the history of U.S. publicly traded companies. If Related/Cor
Slide 13: The Board has listened to shareholder suggestions
CommonWealth REIT The Board has listened to shareholder suggestions, as evidenced by the following recent changes: Increased Board independence and size. Strengthened Board leadership. Enhanced Board structure and guidelines. Simplified path for shareholder action. Agreed to terminate shareholder ri
Slide 14: Shareholders and analysts reacted favorably to governance enhancements
CommonWealth REIT governance and management compensation enhancements. 14 external management team of CWH has taken a number of strategic steps that we believe are in the best interests of CWH and which are shareholder friendly. As such, management appears headed in the right direction, and the remo
Slide 15: CWH has made good faith efforts to resolve matters with Related/Corvex
CommonWealth REIT CWH has made good faith and meaningful efforts to resolve matters with Related/Corvex. On and Governance Committee invited Keith Meister of Corvex to join the CWH Board as an Independent Trustee. The only condition to this offer was that Meister enter - activities against CWH and t
Slide 16: CWH Board action on Related/Corvex recommendations
CommonWealth REIT Related/Corvex Recommendation(1) CWH Board Action 1. Appoint three additional Trustees. Added two highly qualified Independent Trustees and offered a third Board seat to Keith Meister of Corvex. 2. Replace Bylaws. Trust. 3. Cease all related party asset sales. Eliminated right of f
Slide 17: Shareholders have a clear path to effect change
CommonWealth REIT The window for making Trustee nominations and shareholder proposals at the June 13, March 24, 2014. Shareholders who have owned a minimum of $2,000 worth of common shares for at least one year may make Trustee nominations and shareholder proposals for consideration at the meeting.
Slide 18: CWH's business plan increases shareholder value
CommonWealth REIT CWH’s business plan increases shareholder value. 18
Slide 19: The Board and management are successfully repositioning the portfolio
CommonWealth REIT The Board and management are successfully repositioning 19 Purchased in March 2011 (CBD Office in Phoenix, AZ) Purchased in November 2009 (CBD Office in Bellevue, WA) Because CWH maintained a strong balance sheet with low leverage between 2005 and 2007 (when commercial real estate
Slide 20: Repositioning the portfolio to CBD properties
CommonWealth REIT CBD Properties 31% Suburban Properties 69% CWH has been repositioning its portfolio to CBD properties because CBD office markets perform better than suburban office markets. 20 Because of the actions taken by the Board and management during the last several years, CWH is better pos
Slide 21: Execution of the business plan has increased portfolio value
The successful execution of the business plan has increased the value of CWH’s portfolio. 21 Source: Company filings with the SEC. As of 12/31/2013. Based on in-place NOI, including straight line rents, at time of acquisition. Based on management’s estimates. 17th Street Plaza 333 108th Avenue NE 11
Slide 22: CWH raised approximately $2.2 billion from non-core asset sales and IPOs
Between 2008 and 2012, CWH also raised approximately $2.2 billion for the sale of non-core assets and the “spin out” of IPOs of non-core property portfolios. 22 Source: FactSet. Based on 2/28/2014 closing price of $29.15. Total Returns Since IPO: +74% CAGR Since IPO: +12% Total Returns Since IPO: +5
Slide 23: CWH repurchased stock when low and issued stock when higher
CWH has repurchased stock when its share price was low and issued stock when its share price was higher. 23 In 2009, when all of CWH’s peers issued large amounts of equity at record low stock prices in an effort to recapitalize their balance sheets, CWH did not issue equity and, instead, authorized
Slide 24: CWH benefits from being managed by RMR
CommonWealth REIT CWH benefits from being managed by RMR. 24
Slide 25: RMR is a world class real estate operator
RMR is a world class real estate operator that provides superior services to CWH at comparatively low cost. RMR founded CWH in 1986 and has been its manager for the past 28 years. Today, RMR manages one of the largest portfolios of publicly owned real estate in the U.S., including approximately 1,70
Slide 26: RMR provides an integrated platform at below average costs
RMR provides CWH with a nationwide, fully integrated real estate management platform at below average costs. 26 CWH’s G&A is lower than the average G&A for comparable office REITs. Source: Company filings with the SEC. (1) Based on consolidated property related revenue (rental income and operating e
Slide 27: RMR delivers above average leasing metrics
RMR provides superior services to CWH, as evidenced by CWH’s above average leasing metrics. 27 Since the recent recession began in 2007, the office leasing market has been difficult for all office landlords; during this period and while repositioning CWH’s portfolio, RMR has been able to lease offic
Slide 28: Examples of RMR passing through economies of scale
CommonWealth REIT Examples of how RMR passes through its economies of scale to lower operating costs for CWH. 28 operating costs would likely increase substantially. Case Study: Electricity Costs. In 2012, CWH spent approximately $62 million on electricity costs at its properties.(1) By leveraging t
Slide 29: An externally managed structure benefits shareholders
CommonWealth REIT 29 An externally managed structure benefits shareholders at CWH. Rationale for externally managed structure Established manager with an extensive infrastructure and broad geographic reach. Economies of scale in terms of capabilities and costs. Experienced investment team. Superior
Slide 30: Related/Corvex's scheme is NOT in the best interests of shareholders
Related/Corvex’s scheme is NOT in the best interests of shareholders. 30
Slide 31: CWH business plan versus Related/Corvex's scheme
There is a clear difference between the business plan being successfully executed by the CWH Board and management and the scheme proposed by Related/Corvex. Focused on creating long term shareholder value. Maintain and grow recurring cash flows and dividends over the long term. Maintain investment g
Slide 32: Related/Corvex's scheme is reckless and short term oriented
32 We believe that Related/Corvex’s scheme for CWH is reckless and short term oriented. We believe Related/Corvex are focused on short term trading profits at the expense of long term shareholder value. Sell CWH’s best performing, stabilized assets. Increase debt leverage at CWH. Invest in CWH’s mos
Slide 33: Related/Corvex's valuation is based on faulty analysis
Related/Corvex’s valuation is based on faulty financial analysis and unrealistic projections. 33 Related/Corvex do not disclose the assumptions underlying their financial analysis and projections, which they admit are “subject to significant risk and contingencies.” Related/Corvex Claim: The Facts:
Slide 34: Related's track record with public companies
Centerline Holding Company – DELISTED FROM NYSE Stephen Ross (Chairman of The Related Companies) and Jeff Blau (CEO of The Related Companies) both served on the Board of Centerline Holding Company (f/k/a Charter Municipal Mortgage Acceptance Co., or “CharterMac”) until 2009. Centerline is a real est
Slide 35: Meister and Corvex at ADT
Meister and Corvex have only been in business for about two years, but they appear to have already destroyed long term shareholder value at ADT Corporation (NYSE: ADT): ADT was spun out of Tyco in late 2012. Corvex and Soros Fund Management soon thereafter amassed a greater than 5% position at an av
Slide 36: Related/Corvex are attempting to take control without paying shareholders
Related/Corvex are attempting to take control of CWH without paying shareholders anything for that control. 36
Slide 37: Related identified CWH as a takeover target in 2012
Related identified CWH as a possible takeover target in 2012 and solicited the support of Keith Meister of Corvex to take control of CWH. Related’s investment in CWH is held in the Related Real Estate Recovery Fund, a distressed real estate private equity fund. Related is principally known as a comm
Slide 38: Replacement trustees have strong ties or questionable track records
The majority of Related/Corvex’s handpicked slate of replacement trustees have strong ties to Related/Corvex or questionable track records. 38 (1) Source: Wall Street Journal, “Goldman Real-Estate Play Skirts Ban In Volcker”, by Craig Karmin and Justin Baer, December 23, 2013. (2) Source: PERE, “Sig
Slide 39: Replacement trustee track record: Edward Glickman
CommonWealth REIT governance, this is not the slate of replacement trustees they would have chosen. 39 Edward Glickman is a Related/Corvex designated replacement trustee for CWH. Between June 2004 and August 2012, Glickman simultaneously served as President and a management board member of Pennsylva
Slide 40: Zell and Helfand options as replacement trustees
In return for agreeing to serve as Related/Corvex replacement trustees, Zell and his long serving lieutenant Helfand received options to purchase more than 4 million CWH common shares from Related/Corvex that were approximately $17 million “in the money” on the day the options were granted.(1) Relat
Slide 41: Removing the entire CWH Board by written consent may destroy shareholder value
Removing the entire CWH Board by written consent may destroy shareholder value. 41
Slide 42: Removing the entire Board is unprecedented
Removing the entire CWH Board as proposed is unprecedented; CWH would be in limbo without a Board for an extended period of time. 42 If successful, the consent solicitation would result in the entire CWH Board being removed immediately. Upon the removal of the entire CWH Board by written consent and
Slide 43: Consent solicitation would be disruptive and harmful to shareholders
A successful consent solicitation to remove the entire CWH Board without cause would be disruptive to CWH and harmful to shareholders. 43 “Change of control” gives lenders the right to declare default and accelerate debts. The removal of all Trustees as a result of the Related/Corvex consent solicit
Slide 44: Preferred conversion rights and rating downgrades risk
CommonWealth REIT 44 gives preferred shareholders dilutive conversion rights. The removal of the entire CWH Board Convertible Preferred Shares, triggering the right of holders to convert their preferred shares into common shares at a favorable conversion rate that would dilute existing common shareh
Slide 45: Governance and management compensation enhancements
CommonWealth REIT governance and management compensation in response to suggestions from shareholders. 46 Board Composition Recently added two highly qualified new Independent Trustees that were identified by the search firm Nominating and Governance Committee continues to work with Korn / Ferry to
Slide 46: Board committed to additional governance enhancements
CommonWealth REIT The Board is committed to implementing additional governance enhancements. 47 Board Leadership The Independent Trustees are committed to designating a Lead Independent Trustee with clear and robust responsibilities. The selection of this individual and the specific responsibilities
Slide 47: Two new Independent Trustees appointed in January 2014
CommonWealth REIT Ann Logan business (1998-2000) and Chief Credit Officer (1993-1998). Ms. Logan left Served on Board of PHH Corporation (NYSE: PHH), a leading provider of Finance and Risk Committee and as a member of the Audit and Compensation committees. Previously held positions with Standard and
Slide 48: Further alignment of management compensation with shareholders' returns
Further alignment of management compensation with shareholders’ returns. 49 The base business management fee paid by CWH to RMR was calculated on the basis of the gross historical cost of CWH's real estate assets. Calculation and Payment of Incentive Fee The fee is now calculated on the basis of the
Slide 49: Restructured compensation may lower already low G&A
CommonWealth REIT 5.2% 4.2% 6.7% CWH (Actual) CWH (Pro Forma) Office REIT Peers Average 0.62% 0.50% 0.84% CWH (Actual) CWH (Pro Forma) Office REIT Peers Average 9.4% 7.6% 10.6% CWH (Actual) CWH (Pro Forma) Office REIT Peers Average Restructured management compensation may result in already low G&A e
Slide 50: CWH moved to best in class governance among REIT peers
CWH Office REIT Peers Large Cap Office REITs CWH(1) BDN CLI LPT PDM HIW DRE PKY VNO SLG BXP Annual Election of All Trustees X X X Majority of Votes Cast Required to Elect Trustees X X X X X X X Non-Executive Chairman or Designated Lead Director X X No Active "Poison Pill" X Ratio of Independent Trus
Slide 51: Request for your support
Request for your support. CommonWealth REIT 52
Slide 52: Consent solicitation is NOT in shareholders' best interests
The Related/Corvex consent solicitation to remove the entire CWH Board without cause is NOT in shareholders’ best interests. For the last several years, the Board and management have been executing a strategy to improve CWH’s portfolio by shifting the focus to high quality CBD office properties. Thi
Slide 53: Protect the future of CWH
Protect the future of CWH. We request you continue to support CWH’s Board and management. Submit your WHITE revocation card and discard Related/Corvex’s gold card. CommonWealth REIT 54
Slide 54: Appendix
APPENDIX. CommonWealth REIT 55
Slide 55: Review of CWH's Q4 2013 Results
Review of CWH’s Q4 2013 Results. CommonWealth REIT 56
Slide 56: CWH announced fourth quarter and year end 2013 results
On February 27, 2014, CWH announced fourth quarter and year end 2013 results which prove the business plan is working. $0.63 per share of normalized funds from operations, or Normalized FFO, for the fourth quarter, versus consensus estimate of $0.54 per share.(1) 81.4% ratio of dividends paid to cas
Slide 57: Operating outperformance compared to CWH's peers
The successful execution of the business plan has resulted in operating outperformance compared to CWH’s peers. Q4 2013 Same Property Results Q4 2013 Leasing Activity CWH Peers % Change in GAAP NOI % Change in Cash NOI % Change in GAAP Rental Rates Avg. Cap. Ex. Commitment Per Sq. Ft. Per Lease Yr.
Slide 58: Portfolio repositioning is nearly complete
The portfolio repositioning that began several years ago is nearly complete. In 2013, CWH sold 43 non-core suburban office and industrial properties with a combined 8.4 million square feet for an aggregate gross sale price of $249.1 million. In early 2013, CWH listed for sale 40 properties with a co
Slide 59: Shareholders and analysts reacted favorably to Q4 2013 results
Many shareholders and analysts have reacted favorably to CWH’s Q4 2013 results. “The quality of the core portfolio has improved, as a substantial number of assets have either been sold or moved to discontinued operations ahead of a sale. Leasing metrics improved, with positive cash spreads… Overall,
Slide 60: Meister/Corvex's investment in ADT: A case study
Meister/Corvex’s investment in ADT: A case study in shareholder value destruction. CommonWealth REIT 61
Slide 61: Summary of Meister/Corvex's recent investment in ADT
A summary of Meister/Corvex’s recent investment in ADT. Company Overview ADT provides electronic security, and interactive home and business alarm monitoring services. ADT has a market capitalization of ~$6 billion and an enterprise value of ~$10 billion. Trades under ticker “ADT” on the NYSE Member
Slide 62: Lessons learned from Meister/Corvex's involvement in ADT
Lessons learned from Meister/Corvex’s involvement in ADT. Over-promising and underperformance create destruction of shareholder value. Meister/Corvex enticed others to invest in ADT by making a presentation projecting share prices considerably above market. From the day prior to Meister/Corvex filin