PDC Energy Inc

PDC Energy — Proxy Contest (April 2019)

17 slides from PDC Energy's proxy contest presentation, Apr 23, 2019

  1. Slide 1: A Failure of Alignment and Accountability

    A Failure of Alignment and Accountability April 23, 2019

  2. Slide 2: PDC: An Ineffective Board and Underperforming Management

    PDC: An Ineffective Board and Underperforming Management • PDC Energy owns high quality assets that are trapped behind a poorly performing team, with a board that is asleep at the wheel. • Over the last three years shareholders have borne the brunt of this mismanagement with the company delivering a

  3. Slide 3: Pay for Under Performance

    Pay for Under Performance Despite a three-year TSR of -44% (2016-2018), PDC’s top five executives were compensated $16.2M in 2018 and a total of $43.8M over the last three years. 50% $16.2M $18.0 $14.3M 40% $13.2M 36% $12.0 30% Top 5 Executive Compensation $M2 Annual Change in PDC Stock Price1 20% $

  4. Slide 4: Metrics Don't Matter: 2018

    Metrics Don’t Matter: 2018 In 2018, the company awarded its management team cash bonuses of 115% of target despite missing four out of five internally-set targets. Source: PDC’s proxy statement. 4

  5. Slide 5: Metrics Don't Matter: 2016 – 2018

    Metrics Don’t Matter: 2016 – 2018 PDC introduced two new metrics into its 2019 compensation plan: free cash flow margin and debt- adjusted cash flow per share. With little downside risk for missing targets, new metrics won’t matter. Did PDC Exceed Target? Metric: 2016 2017 2018 Production Production

  6. Slide 6: CEO Pay Rising as PDC Stockholder Value is Destroyed

    CEO Pay Rising as PDC Stockholder Value is Destroyed Economic Value Added (Destroyed) = NOPAT – (Invested Capital * WACC)1 $400 $8.0 $7.0 $300 $6.3 $6.1 $6.0 $5.8 $5.4 $4.1 $200 Annual Economic Value Destroyed $M $3.8 $4.0 Annual CEO Compensation $M2 $3.3 Bart Brookman $100 $2.9 appointed CEO $2.0 $

  7. Slide 7: Above Average CEO Pay for Below Average Performance

    Above Average CEO Pay for Below Average Performance In a recent presentation, PDC included a chart from a May 2018 ISS report implying that it is a top performer. This chart was based on performance data through the end of 2017. Accurate and current data paints a different story. ISS Chart in PDC’s

  8. Slide 8: COO: Pay For Underperformance

    COO: Pay For Underperformance The COO Scott Reasoner’s pay has risen despite missing targets. Well costs have risen and capital efficiency has underperformed. The COO also received a special equity grant in 2017. Scott Reasoner Pay Cost Underperformance Total Compensation Production, Exploration and

  9. Slide 9: EVP Corp Dev and Strategy: Pay For Underperformance

    EVP Corp Dev and Strategy: Pay For Underperformance Under Lance Lauck’s watch, PDC has spent $1.9Bn on land, of which $0.74Bn has been impaired, to add 52,000 net acres at an average cost of $35,930/acre. This will rise to $57,840/acre by the end of 2019 based on PDC’s forecasted expirations. Lance

  10. Slide 10: Excuses for Pay

    Excuses for Pay PDC’s Board has provided excuses for why management should not be held accountable for missing targets… “The Committee estimates that without the Wattenberg Field midstream issues, the Company would have been at the high end of production targets for the year.” – 2017 Proxy “DCP and

  11. Slide 11: Material Weaknesses In Internal Control

    Material Weaknesses In Internal Control 2017 10K, Report of Independent Public Accounting Firm (PWC) “Also in our opinion, the Company did not maintain, in all material respects, effective internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2017 based on criteria established in Internal Con

  12. Slide 12: Average Cash Yield for PDC's CEO vs. Outside Shareholders

    Average Cash Yield for PDC’s CEO vs. Outside Shareholders Bart Brookman, PDC’s CEO, has generated an average yield on his personal PDC equity of 27% over the last three years.1 This is the amount of cash Bart receives each year (salary, bonus, and stock sold in the open market) as a percentage of th

  13. Slide 13: Alignment Drives Performance

    Alignment Drives Performance Private equity in the upstream energy sector has materially outperformed the SPDR S&P Oil & Gas Exploration & Production ETF (XOP) over the last ten years despite owning assets in the same basins as public operators. • US oil and gas private equity has generated a $100 I

  14. Slide 14: A Better Model for PDC Compensation and Governance

    A Better Model for PDC Compensation and Governance Kimmeridge believes that more equity and longer hold periods will cause management teams to act like owners. As board members, we would advocate significant change to compensation and governance models. • Compensation − Total cash compensation lower

  15. Slide 15: Summary & Conclusion

    Summary & Conclusion Kimmeridge believes alignment and accountability drive performance and profitability. Putting PDC on a path to profitability will require a strong board that thinks and acts like owners. • Board backgrounds and compensation metrics mean nothing if management teams are not held a

  16. Slide 16: Disclosures

    Disclosures 1. Top five executive compensation defined as the total compensation for the five highest-paid PDC executives in a given year. (Slide 3) 2. Kimmeridge defines NOPAT as earnings before interest after taxes (net operating profit after taxes). Kimmeridge assumes a cost of capital of 10.5%.

  17. Slide 17: Disclosures

    Disclosures Certain data and analysis presented here is based on or derived from filings made by PDC with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or other regulatory agencies or from third party reports or analysis and Kimmeridge is not responsible or liable for any information obtained from

PDC Energy — Proxy Contest (April 2019) on 6ix