Equity Commonwealth — CommonWealth REIT — Proxy Contest (April 2013)
23 slides from Equity Commonwealth's proxy contest presentation, Apr 22, 2013
Slide 1: Investor Presentation April 2013
Investor Presentation April 2013 111 East Wacker Drive & 233 North Michigan Avenue Chicago, IL Mellon Bank Center 1735 Market Street Philadelphia, PA Chase Tower 111 Monument Circle Indianapolis, IN CommonWealth REIT
Slide 2: Participants in solicitation and important information
CommonWealth REIT CWH, its Trustees and certain of its executive officers and Reit Management & Research LLC and certain of its directors, officers and employees may be deemed to be participants in the solicitation of consent revocations from shareholders in connection with the consent solicitation
Slide 3: Since 2008, CWH has improved the quality and composition of its portfolio
CommonWealth REIT 34.7% 9.5% CBD Office 55.8% Now (4Q 2012)(1) Company strategy. • CWH owns a portfolio that offers a balance between stability and growth: . Stability: . Large portfolio of properties with diversity by geography and tenancies. . Growth: . Large number of properties with long term gr
Slide 4: Successfully implementing strategic plan
CommonWealth REIT Successfully implementing strategic plan. • Portfolio repositioning started in 2008. . Since 1/1/2008, CWH has acquired $3.7 billion of properties with approximately 24.1 million square feet (excluding properties acquired by SIR since its IPO in March 2012). . Primarily Class A CBD
Slide 5: Disciplined acquisition/disposition strategy
CommonWealth REIT Disciplined acquisition/disposition strategy. 6 Source: Company filings. (1) Based on in-place NOI, including straight line rents, at time of acquisition. Since 2008 CWH has taken advantage of market dislocation to acquire high quality properties at attractive cap rates and to sell
Slide 6: Track record of successful high quality acquisitions
CommonWealth REIT Track record of successful high quality acquisitions. 7 Source: Company filings. (1) Occupancy as of 12/31/2012. (2) Based on in-place NOI, including straight line rents, at time of acquisition. (3) Based on management’s estimates. 17th Street Plaza 333 108th Avenue NE 111 River St
Slide 7: Successful GOV and SIR IPOs
CommonWealth REIT Successful GOV and SIR IPOs. 8 Source: FactSet. (1) Based on 4/19/13 closing price of $28.06. Total Returns Since IPO: +70% CAGR Since IPO: 15% Total Returns Since IPO: +38% CAGR Since IPO: 34% • In March 2012, Select Income REIT (NYSE: SIR) completed its IPO. CWH received $400 mil
Slide 8: Strong, well managed balance sheet
CommonWealth REIT Strong, well managed balance sheet. • Conservative balance sheet strategy. . CWH is currently rated investment grade by Moody’s (Baa3) and S&P (BBB-). . CWH was one of the first REITs to be investment grade rated by Moody’s and S&P (1994). . CWH has historically maintained a strong
Slide 9: CWH is managed by Reit Management & Research LLC (RMR)
CommonWealth REIT • CWH is managed by Reit Management & Research LLC (RMR). • RMR was founded in 1986 to manage publicly owned real estate investments. • Today, RMR manages five publicly traded REITs, two publicly traded operating companies, a publicly traded mutual fund that invests in unaffiliated
Slide 10: The RMR management agreements
CommonWealth REIT 11 The RMR management agreements. Source: Company filings. (1) The business management fee is 0.70% for the first $250 million of gross historical real estate asset value, 0.50% of gross historical real estate value over $250 million, and 1.00% of the gross historical real estate a
Slide 11: Response to Corvex/Related claims on RMR fees
CommonWealth REIT • Corvex/Related have stated that CWH paid $77.3 million to RMR in 2012 and implied that these fees represent excessive G&A costs which can be eliminated if RMR’s management agreements were terminated.(1) . The amount stated by Corvex/Related appears to include RMR fees paid by CWH
Slide 12: CWH's G&A is lower than the average for comparable office REITs
CommonWealth REIT 0.66% 0.67% 0.76% 0.69% CWH CWH (Excl. SIR) Primary Peers Secondary Peers 5.1% 4.9% 6.3% 7.3% CWH CWH (Excl. SIR) Primary Peers Secondary Contrary to the assertions made by Corvex/Related, RMR provides CWH with a nationwide, fully integrated management platform at below industry av
Slide 13: Corvex/Related proposal to remove the Board may cause material losses
CommonWealth REIT The Corvex/Related proposal to remove the entire CWH Board and terminate RMR’s management of CWH may cause material losses to CWH and CWH shareholders. • Corvex/Related seem oblivious to the adverse consequences which will likely result from removal of the entire CWH Board and the
Slide 14: Related Companies track record: AMAC and Centerline
CommonWealth REIT American Mortgage Acceptance Company (AMAC): • Jeff Blau (CEO of the Related Companies) previously simultaneously served as an officer of the Related Companies and as Chairman, CEO and Trustee of AMAC, a publicly owned REIT that made mortgage loans. AMAC funded loans to properties
Slide 15: Corvex track record: WCI Communities
CommonWealth REIT WCI Communities, Inc. (WCI): • Keith Meister (Managing Partner of Corvex) and his former employer acquired a 14.6% ownership position in WCI in January 2007. WCI was a publicly owned real estate development company. In public filings, Keith Meister and his associates criticized WCI
Slide 16: Corvex/Related offers and financial analysis
CommonWealth REIT • Corvex/Related originally “offered” $25.00 per share to acquire CWH, then increased their “offer” to $27.00 per share, and later lowered their “offer” to $24.50 per share. . These amounts are significantly below their own initial value for the company of $40.00 to $55.00 per shar
Slide 17: Continued repositioning is the best way to improve shareholder value
CommonWealth REIT 18 The continued repositioning of CWH into high quality, high growth CBD office properties is the best way to improve shareholder value. • What we have accomplished: . Repositioned the majority of CWH’s portfolio into high quality CBD office properties. . Used financial strength to
Slide 18: Appendix
CommonWealth REIT Appendix 19
Slide 19: Calculation of EBITDA and fixed charge coverage and debt / EBITDA ratios
CommonWealth REIT Calculation of EBITDA and fixed charge coverage and debt / EBITDA ratios. 20 (1) Pro forma adjusted for: (a) $627.6 million raised from the issuance of common shares in March 2013, (b) $240.1 million raised from the sale of GOV shares in March 2013; and (c) the application of the n
Slide 20: Calculation of CWH annualized Q4 2012 stand alone NOI
CommonWealth REIT Calculation of CWH annualized Q4 2012 stand alone NOI. 21 Three Months Ended December 31, 2012 CWH consolidated operating income $ 69,937 Plus: depreciation and amortization 66,950 Plus: general and administrative 13,738 Plus: acquisition related costs 646 CWH consolidated property
Slide 21: CommonWealth Trustees
CommonWealth REIT 22 CommonWealth Trustees. Source: Company filings. Trustee Age Affiliation Tenure Background William A. Lamkin 53 Independent Trustee 6 years Mr. Lamkin has been a partner at Ackrell Capital LLC, a San Francisco based investment bank, since 2003. Joseph L. Morea 57 Independent Trus
Slide 22: Forward looking statements
CommonWealth REIT THIS PRESENTATION CONTAINS FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE PRIVATE SECURITIES LITIGATION REFORM ACT OF 1995 AND OTHER SECURITIES LAWS. THESE FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS ARE BASED UPON CWH’S CURRENT EXPECTATIONS BUT THEY ARE NOT GUARANTEED TO OCCUR AND MAY NOT OC
Slide 23: CommonWealth REIT
Investor Presentation April 2013 111 East Wacker Drive & 233 North Michigan Avenue Chicago, IL Mellon Bank Center 1735 Market Street Philadelphia, PA Chase Tower 111 Monument Circle Indianapolis, IN CommonWealth REIT