Meadowbrook Insurance Group Inc
Meadowbrook Insurance — Q4 2012 Earnings Presentation
42 slides from Meadowbrook Insurance's earnings presentation, Mar 18, 2013
Slide 1: Investor Supplement Fourth Quarter 2012 Update
Investor Supplement Fourth Quarter 2012 Update
Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements & Non-GAAP Financial Measures
31 Forward-Looking Statements & Non-GAAP Financial Measures Certain statements made by Meadowbrook Insurance Group, Inc. in this release may constitute forward-looking statements including, but not limited to, those statements that include the words “believes,” “expects,” “anticipates,” “estimates,”
Slide 3: Financial Results
32 Financial Results
Slide 4: 4Q 2011 vs. 4Q 2012 Underwriting and Investing Activities
33 4Q 2011 vs. 4Q 2012 Underwriting and Investing Activities •Top line earned premium growth driven primarily by rate increases and maturation of existing business. Net Commissions & Fees •Revenue increase driven primarily by a Michigan agency that was acquired in 4Q 2011. Other Expenses •The 2011 r
Slide 5: 4Q 2011 vs. 4Q 2012 Combined Ratio Analysis
34 4Q 2011 vs. 4Q 2012 Combined Ratio Analysis Loss and LAE Ratio •The 2012 loss and LAE ratio includes 1.8 points of adverse development compared to 3.8 points of adverse development in 2011. •The 2012 accident year loss and LAE ratio increased 6.2 points to 71.6% from 65.4% in 2011; the 2012 accid
Slide 6: Full Year 2011 vs. 2012 Underwriting and Investing Activities
35 Full Year 2011 vs. 2012 Underwriting and Investing Activities •Top line earned premium growth driven primarily by rate increases and maturation of existing business. Net Commissions & Fees •Revenue increase driven primarily by a Michigan agency that was acquired in 4Q 2011. Other Expenses •The 20
Slide 7: Full Year 2011 vs. 2012 Combined Ratio Analysis
36 Full Year 2011 vs. 2012 Combined Ratio Analysis Loss and LAE Ratio •The 2012 loss and LAE ratio includes 10.0 points of adverse development compared to 1.0 point of adverse development in 2011. •The 2012 accident year loss and LAE ratio increased 4.0 points to 69.3% from 65.3% in 2011; the 2012 a
Slide 8: Effective Tax Rate 2011 vs. 2012
37 •Rate on Net Investment Income – 24.6%, tax expense of $13.4 million •Rate on Fee Based and Underwriting Income – 42.1%, tax benefit of $1.8 million •Rate on Capital Gains – 8.6%, tax expense of $0.3 million •Total federal tax rate of 22.3% 2011 ($ in millions) 24.6% 42.1% 8.6% Effective Tax Rate
Slide 9: Reserves Overview
38 Reserves Reserves Overview History of Favorable indications through 2010 •Cumulative favorable loss & LAE development of $76.4 million in calendars years 2008 – 2010. •2008 AY loss & LAE ratio has remained stable since 12/31/2010 estimate Historic claim data pattern changed for accident years 200
Slide 10: Reserves Overview
k MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Reserves Overview History of Favorable indications through 2010 Cumulative favorable loss & LAE development of $76.4 million in calendars years 2008-2010. 2008 AY loss & LAE ratio has remained stable since 12/31/2010 estimate Historic claim data pattern changed for acc
Slide 11: Underwriting Focus: Accident Year Combined Ratio
40 Underwriting Focus Accident Year Combined Ratio (Reported and Re-Evaluated as of 12/31/2012) ^ The Re-Evaluated AY combined ratio reflects reserve adjustments made following the accident year, for example, the 93.6% Re-Evaluated 2008 AY combined ratio reflects new loss development information gat
Slide 12: Underwriting Focus: Accident Year Combined Ratio (Re-Evaluated)
41 Underwriting Focus Accident Year Combined Ratio (Re-Evaluated as of 12/31/2012) 2008 2009 2010 2011 ^ The Re-Evaluated AY combined ratio reflects reserve adjustments made following the accident year, for example, the 93.6% Re-Evaluated 2008 AY combined ratio reflects new loss development informat
Slide 13: Underwriting Focus: GAAP Combined Ratio
42 Underwriting Focus GAAP Combined Ratio 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 * Represents 2009 - 2012 proforma GAAP and Accident Year Combined Ratio excluding terminated programs 2013 Projected** ** Guidance without QS is 98-99%, QS adds 1.2 to 1.5 percentage points to the Combined Ratio
Slide 14: 2012 Reserve Development on Prior Accident Years
43 2012 Reserve Development on Prior Accident Years 10 Year Reserve Development on Prior Accident Years Percent of Prior Year Reserves 1.5% 2.4% (4.5 %) 0.9 % 9.7 % 2.2% (1.0%) (2.3%) (4.9%) (4.6%) 2012 Quarterly Development on Prior Accident Years Reserve Development Adverse / (Favorable) ($m)
Slide 15: 2012 Reserve Development – YTD 12/31/12
44 2012 Reserve Development – YTD 12/31/12* Continued Synergistic Expansion 2012 Reserve Development & Net Reserves at 12/31/2011 ($ in ‘000s) $85.5M Development by Accident Year ($ in ‘000s) The vast majority of the 2012 reserve development relates to the 2009-2011 accident years. Total Development
Slide 16: What Happened?
45 What Happened? In Q2 2012, case incurred loss & ALAE (excluding IBNR) increased $23.9 million from $114.7 million in Q1 to $138.6 million in Q2 •21% higher than first quarter In Q2 2012, reserve review we identified average case reserve acceleration driven primarily by three major factors (1) Cla
Slide 17: “Top Ten Exposure” Program: Overview
46 * Excludes Public Entity Excess, 63.5% with Public Entity Excess “Top Ten Exposure” Program: Overview Cause: •Claims department program was announced to the claim adjusters in November 2011 •Goal of program was to identify (but not necessarily change reserves on) high exposure claims earlier in t
Slide 18: “Top Ten Exposure” Program: Observations
47 “Top Ten Exposure” Program: Observations Verification of “Top Ten Exposure” acceleration impact •In Q2, the actuarial team learned of the “Top Ten Exposure” project •In Q2, they gave some credit to the “Top Ten Exposure” acceleration in our ultimate loss selections, but not full weight •Throughou
Slide 19: “Top Ten Exposure” Program: Reserve Position
48 “Top Ten Exposure” Program: Reserve Position Given that we have : a) Verified a real acceleration from the “Top Ten Exposure” program b) Utilized an appropriately-adjusted development method and c) Selected ultimate losses above this method for the affected lines We are confident that we have a s
Slide 20: California Workers’ Compensation Reserve Development
49 We have confidence in our reserves. California Workers’ Compensation Reserve Development •As planned, we hired new claim adjusters to manage increased claim volume due to the growth of our California workers’ compensation business in recent years. As we hired new adjusters, the case load per adju
Slide 21: Positioned to Manage Insurance Cycles – CA WC Low Hazard Mix of Business
50 Positioned to Manage Insurance Cycles – CA WC Low Hazard Mix of Business
Slide 22: CA WC Business Mix Compared to Industry
51 How does our business mix compare to California workers’ compensation industry? •Low hazard group mix •We write 71% of our premium in hazard groups 1 & 2 vs. 55% for the industry •Almost no premium in hazard groups 6 & 7 vs. 5% for the industry •Industry group mix favorable •We write 67% of our p
Slide 23: CA WC Low Hazard Mix of Business (Continued)
52 6 & 7 1 & 2 3, 4 & 5 3, 4 & 5 1 & 2 6 & 7 Positioned to Manage Insurance Cycles – CA WC Low Hazard Mix of Business (Continued) We write our premium in less hazardous groups and more favorable CA WC industries Meadowbrook Industry Industry Group Distribution
Slide 24: Excess Lines
53 Manufacturing Goods and Services Goods and Services Manufacturing Office & Clerical Office & Clerical Construction Construction Other Other Excess Lines •Excess Lines had $15.3 million of adverse development YTD on prior accident years, with $14.9 million related to Public Entity Excess •Public E
Slide 25: Excess Lines
= MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Excess Lines Excess Lines had $15.3 million of adverse development YTD on prior accident years, with $14.9 million related to Public Entity Excess Public Entity Excess IBNR selected above most methods including paid and incurred BF and paid development Aggressive claim
Slide 26: SEC Line of Business Detail: California WC Experience and Projections
55 SEC Line of Business Detail: Experience and Projections Experience by SEC LOB – California WC •Significant growth in California beginning in 2009 with rollover books of business •Midwest – MIG owns 28.5% of production source •FSIM – food service industry – single source expert •Achieved cumulativ
Slide 27: Experience by SEC LOB – Auto
56 * MIG Statutory CA WC Expense & ULAE ratio typically ranges from 35% - 36% Experience by SEC LOB – Auto •We terminated underperforming classes of Auto and transportation •Transportation book was one of the primary causes of the poor Auto performance in 2009 - 2012 –It added 4.8 of the 10.3 point
Slide 28: Experience by SEC LOB – CMP / GL
57 * MIG Statutory Auto Expense & ULAE ratio typically ranges from 34% - 36% Experience by SEC LOB – CMP / GL (excluding Public Entity Excess) •Historically a very profitable line of business for Meadowbrook •There was a spike in incurred loss activity in 2011 •Continued area to target for profitabl
Slide 29: Experience by SEC LOB – Property: 2012 - 2013
58 * MIG Statutory CMP/GL Expense & ULAE ratio typically ranges from 35% - 36% Experience by SEC LOB – Property: 2012 - 2013 •We have historically had limited exposure to property risks •The Property segment of Meadowbrook and its subsidiaries made up 12% of the 2012 NEP •We generally structure our
Slide 30: Experience by SEC LOB — Property: 2012 - 2013
MEADOWBROO! INSURANCE GROUP Experience by SEC LOB — Property: 2012 - 2013 We have historically had limited exposure to property risks = The Property segment of Meadowbrook and its subsidiaries made up 12% of the 2012 NEP We generally structure our insurance programs to avoid geographic concentration
Slide 31: Rates, Loss Ratio Trends & Loss Ratios
60 Rates, Loss RatioTrends & Loss Ratios Rates, Loss Ratio Trends, and Loss Ratios
Slide 32: Rates, Loss Ratio Trends, and Loss Ratios (cont.)
61 Rates, Loss Ratio Trends, and Loss Ratios (cont.)
Slide 33: Rates, Loss Ratio Trends, and Loss Ratios (cont.)
62 Rates, Loss Ratio Trends, and Loss Ratios (cont.)
Slide 34: Rates, Loss Ratio Trends, and Loss Ratios (cont.)
MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Rates, Loss Ratio Trends, and Loss Ratios (cont.) Meadowbrook Insurance Group - Statutory Rate Change & Net Loss & ALAE Ratio History 3) Rates are now firming. The Bro forma loss ratios exeliing terminated business and ‘Unutual storms: to decrease in 2013 and Beyond wen
Slide 35: Investments
64 Investments
Slide 36: Investment Portfolio Review
Investment Portfolio Review We continue to maintain a high-quality, low-risk investment portfolio. Portfolio Allocation and Quality Low equity risk exposure •98% fixed income •2% equity High credit quality •99% of bonds are investment grade •Average Moody’s rating of Aa3 / S&P rating of AA- Duration
Slide 37: Gain Harvesting Program Results
66 Gain Harvesting Program Results Gross Realized Gains of $55.3 million, $40.2 million net of taxes Net proceeds in excess of $500 million: •The overall portfolio mix remains consistent with 99% investment grade •Minor change to security sectors with inclusion of a $50 million high dividend equity
Slide 38: Government and Agency – December 31, 2012 Profile
67 Government and Agency – December 31, 2012 Profile Summary Profile •$27.7 M market value; approximately 2% of the managed portfolio •Rated Aaa by Moody’s and AA+ by S&P •December 31, 2012 net unrealized gain was $0.9M •Average investment yield: 1.46% Government & Agency vs. Entire Portfolio 2% 98%
Slide 39: Corporate Fixed Income – December 31, 2012 Profile
68 Corporate Fixed Income – December 31, 2012 Profile Summary Profile •$507.0M market value; 39% of the investment portfolio •December 31, 2012 net unrealized gain was $24.7M. •Average investment yield: 3.15% Quality Indicators Corporate vs. Entire Portfolio Corporate Profile Corporates Average Qual
Slide 40: Municipal Bonds – December 31, 2012 Profile
69 Municipal Bonds – December 31, 2012 Profile Summary Profile •$629.0M market value; 48% of the investment portfolio •December 31, 2012 net unrealized gain was $41.7M •Tax exempt unrealized gain $37.6M •Taxable unrealized gain $ 4.1M •Average tax equivalent yield: 4.93% Quality Indicators & Geograp
Slide 41: Structured Securities – December 31, 2012 Profile
70 Structured Securities – December 31, 2012 Profile Summary Profile •$121.0M market value; 9% of the investment portfolio •December 31, 2012 Net unrealized gain was $7.3M •RMBS unrealized gain $ 4.4M •CMBS unrealized loss $ 1.8M •ABS unrealized loss $ 1.1M •Average investment yield: 4.08% Quality I
Slide 42: Equities – December 31, 2012 Profile
71 Equities – December 31, 2012 Profile Summary Profile •$22.7 million market value; 2% of the managed portfolio •December 31, 2012 net unrealized gain was $2.3M •Preferred stock unrealized gain $1.6M •Bond mutual fund unrealized gain $0.7M •Average tax equivalent yield: 7.1% Equities vs. Entire Por
Meadowbrook Insurance Group — Q4 2012 Earnings Presentation on 6ix