ALTERRA CAPITAL HOLDINGS Ltd

ALTERRA CAPITAL — Max Capital Group — Investor Presentation (November 2009)

24 slides from ALTERRA CAPITAL's investor presentation, Nov 6, 2009

  1. Slide 1: A World Class Specialty Insurer and Reinsurer

    Exhibit 99.1 A World Class Specialty Insurer and Reinsurer Investor Presentation Third Quarter 2009 BERMUDA IRELAND UNITED STATES LLOYD’S

  2. Slide 2: Information Concerning Forward Looking Statements

    INFORMATION CONCERNING FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS CAUTIONARY NOTE REGARDING FORWARD-LOOKING INFORMATION This presentation includes statements about future economic performance, finances, expectations, plans and prospects of the Company that constitute forward-looking statements for purposes of the s

  3. Slide 3: Max Capital – Core Operations

    Max Capital – Core Operations Global underwriter of specialty insurance and reinsurance Multiple operating platforms - Bermuda, Dublin, United States, and Lloyd’s Short-Tail 38% Diversified business profile across specialty classes of business 62% Highly experienced management with proven track reco

  4. Slide 4: Strong YTD Results

    Strong YTD Results Profitable Growth in Gross Premiums Written… Reflects continued build-out of our global platform P&C GPW Max Specialty - $219 million GPW (34% increase) $1,054.9 Reflects first year of Max at Lloyd’s - $110 million GPW $787.9 Combined ratio reflects higher casualty mix Market cond

  5. Slide 5: Opportunistic Expansion Across our Business

    Opportunistic Expansion Across our Business Opportunistic approach to growing our business Underserved market niches which allow for technical underwriting orientation Disciplined approach in building teams Identify sound underwriters with multiple years of experience Create sophisticated pricing mo

  6. Slide 6: Identifying & Recruiting “Franchise Players” Has Been Instrumental In Our Success

    Identifying & Recruiting “Franchise Players” Has Been Instrumental In Our Success 2006 2005 Insurance 2007 Reinsurance Aviation U.S. E&S Insurance Property / Property Cat Property Inland Marine U.S. Casualty Reinsurance 2004 Multi Peril Crop Insurance Property Experienced & highly quantitative 2008

  7. Slide 7: Global Reach Through Established Platforms

    Global Reach Through Established Platforms Bermuda / Dublin Bermuda / Dublin Lloyd’s U.S Specialty Insurance Reinsurance Insurance Agriculture Aviation Personal accident General liability Aviation Excess liability Financial institutions Marine Excess liability Professional liability Professional lia

  8. Slide 8: Diversified Platforms Generate More Consistent Margins

    Diversified Platforms Generate More Consistent Margins Max has performed well within its diversified peer group with less volatility than property focused reinsurers Diversified Reinsurers Property Focused Reinsurers 300% 300% 252% 150% 150% 124% 140% 125% 125% 110% 101% 104% 96% 96% 97% 100% 100% 9

  9. Slide 9: Max is less exposed to swings in the cat market than peers

    Max is less exposed to swings in the cat market than peers Max had the lowest losses from Ike/Gustav as a % of equity Ike/Gustav Ultimate Net Losses as a % of 6/30/08 Common Equity ($ in millions) 14.0% 12.4% 12.0% 11.0% PMLs (% of capital) 10.1% 10.0% 1:100 yr 1:250 yr 8.9% Target 8%-12% 15% - 20%

  10. Slide 10: Max Investment Portfolio Highlights

    Max Investment Portfolio Highlights As of September 30, 2009 Cash High quality, defensively postured portfolio 19.5% Low OTTI during volatile periods in 2008-09 73% of fixed income portfolio rated Aa or better; Hedge funds 7.2% diversification by sector and issuer Fixed income 73.3% Less than 7% rat

  11. Slide 11: Favorable Earnings Growth Prospects

    Favorable Earnings Growth Prospects Selected growth in premiums Max Full Year P&C GPW Opportunistic expansion in specialty areas 26% Growth $1,275 Full year impact of Lloyd’s platform $1,012 Generate combined ratios of 90% +/- Diversified portfolio will result in less volatility Max Specialty & Lloy

  12. Slide 12: Max’s Diversification and Growth are Attractive

    Max’s Diversification and Growth are Attractive June 30, 2009 YTD 2008 (1) 2008 2008 GPW Distribution GPW % Combined Combined Price / (2) GPW Reinsurance Insurance Property Casualty Change Ratio Ratio Tang. BV Diversified Transatlantic $4,423.2 100% 0% 30% 70% 0.2% 94.3% 98.5% 0.91x PartnerRe 4,028.

  13. Slide 13: Max Has a Strong Market Position in Specialty Classes …

    Max Has a Strong Market Position in Specialty Classes … Bermuda / Dublin Insurance Bermuda / Dublin Reinsurance 2008 GPW - $389 million 2008 GPW - $420 million General Marine &Liability Property Whole Energy Other Account 14% 3% Excess Aviation 3% Property Liability 8% 25% 32% Prof. 14% Aviation Lia

  14. Slide 14: … With an Attractive Position in the U.S. Market and Lloyd’s

    … With an Attractive Position in the U.S. Market and Lloyd’s U.S. Insurance Max at Lloyd’s 2008 GPW - $194 million 2008 GPW - £65 million (1) Accident & Health Marine 17% 20% Property 45% Treaty Fin. 18% Property 49% Institutions 31% General 19% 1% Casualty Prof. Employers' Indemnity / Public Liabil

  15. Slide 15: Overview of Life Reinsurance

    Overview of Life Reinsurance Spread management business, comparable to basic full Loss Portfolio Transfer Purchase blocks of existing policy or claim reserves (reserve buy outs) All originated transactions – winner takes all 2008 GPW Max at Lloyd's (1) Known data files – no unreported exposures, min

  16. Slide 16: Max is Strongly Positioned For Profitable Growth

    Max is Strongly Positioned For Profitable Growth Max Bermuda and Dublin (Insurance/Reinsurance) 2009E GPW Rates favorable in short-tail property cat and energy Bermuda / Dublin Insurance / Long-tail lines have stabilized and stopped declining Reinsurance 63% Max Max at Lloyd’s 11% at Lloyd's Provide

  17. Slide 17: Max Offers a Compelling Story

    Max Offers a Compelling Story We believe we can generate an average ROE of 13% to 16% across the cycle Well established operating platforms provide full access to business Diversified portfolio of business across casualty and property lines Specialty orientation with a balance of insurance vs. reins

  18. Slide 18: Appendix

    APPENDIX 18

  19. Slide 19: Strong Balance Sheet

    Strong Balance Sheet September 30, December 31, ($ in millions) 2009 2008 Cash & Fixed Maturities $5,029 $4,603 Other Investments 390 754 Premium Receivables 546 555 Losses Recoverable 986 847 Other Assets 478 493 Total Assets $7,429 $7,252 Property & Casualty Losses $3,159 $2,938 Life & Annuity Ben

  20. Slide 20: Nine-Month Results Comparison

    Nine-Month Results Comparison Nine months ended September 30, ($ in millions) 2009 2008 Gross Premiums Written $1,097 $882 Net Premiums Earned 627 512 Net Investment Income 125 137 Net Gains on Other Investments 63 (145) Net Realized Losses on Fixed Maturities - (18) Other Income 3 1 Total Revenues

  21. Slide 21: Diversified Operating Platform

    Diversified Operating Platform Nine months ended September 30, 2009 Life & Property & Casualty Annuity Corporate Consolidated ($ in millions) Bermuda / Dublin Max at Insurance Reinsurance U.S. Specialty Lloyd's Total Reinsurance Gross premiums written $302.7 $422.3 $219.3 $110.6 $1,054.9 $41.7 $0.0

  22. Slide 22: Profitable Underwriting Trends

    Profitable Underwriting Trends Gross Premiums Written ($ in millions) Operating EPS $1,500 $6.00 $4.81 $1,246 $1,254 $1,200 $1,078 $4.00 $3.52 $1,044 $2.70 $865 $900 $2.00 $0.19 $600 $0.00 $300 ($2.00) $212 $275 $45 $302 $242 ($2.59) $0 ($4.00) 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Life

  23. Slide 23: A Growing, Global Insurance / Reinsurance Company

    A Growing, Global Insurance / Reinsurance Company Invested Assets ($ in millions) Operating Cash Flow ($ in millions) Investment Leverage $6,000 5.0x $1,000 3.9x 3.9x $799 $5,000 3.6x 3.3x 4.0x $800 3.2x $4,000 3.0x $600 $508 $3,000 $447 $5,123 $5,357 $4,536 2.0x $400 $2,000 $4,223 $273 $252 $3,515

  24. Slide 24: Reinsurance / Bermuda – Investment Portfolio Peer Review

    Reinsurance / Bermuda – Investment Portfolio Peer Review As of June 30, 2009 % of Total Cash & Investments Equity / Other Cash & Cash Fixed Income Equity / Other Total Cash & Investment as a % of (1) Equivalents Securities Securities Investments Leverage Equity Everest Re 11.1% 83.4% 5.5% $14,207.3

Max Capital Group — Investor Presentation (November 2009) on 6ix