FBL Financial — Proxy Contest (April 2021)
26 slides from FBL Financial's proxy contest presentation, Apr 7, 2021
Slide 1: FBL Financial Group Merger for $56.00 Per Share
FBL Financial Group Merger for $56.00 Per Share April 7, 2021
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer This presentation has been designed to provide general information about FBL Financial Group, Inc. (“FBL” or the “Company”) a nd the proposed acquisition by Farm Bureau Property and Casualty Insurance Company (“ FBPCIC ”) of FBL’s common stock not held by FBPCIC or the Iowa Farm Bureau Fe
Slide 3: Our Independent Directors Ensured an Arm's-Length Negotiation
Our Independent Directors Ensured an Arm’s - Length Negotiation Special Committee of Independent and Unaffiliated Directors with Deep Insurance Industry, M&A and Public Company Transaction Exp ertise Member Bio Paul E. Larson Vice Chairman Served as President of Equitable Life of Iowa and its subsid
Slide 4: $56.00/Share is a Unique and Compelling Opportunity for Unaffiliated Shareholders
$56.00/Share is a Unique and Compelling Opportunity for FBL Financial Group’s Unaffiliated Shareholders Right Price Substantial, 50%+ cash premium to FBL Financial Group’s unaffected stock price Shareholders will continue to receive cash dividends of $0.52 per share per quarter until closing Valuati
Slide 5: Capital Returns Management's Argument is Flawed
Capital Returns Management’s Argument is Flawed Flawed Analyses Ignores important intrinsic value methodologies: Milliman’s independent actuarial appraisal, Barclays’ sum - of - the - parts, dividend discount and comparable companies analyses, and others Overlooks key differences between the propose
Slide 6: Substantial Premium to Unaffected Stock Price
Substantial Premium to Unaffected Stock Price $56.00/share in cash provides immediate, certain and compelling value, representing: Special Committee negotiated a significantly improved offer that is in the best interest of the unaffiliated shareholders Premium to Unaffected Price Premium to Initial
Slide 7: Share Performance Since 9/3/2020
Share Performance Since 9/3/2020 50.3% 34.1% 33.6% FFG Peer Average Peer Median ▪ Even with the run - up in the Life / Annuity sector, the Transaction Price provides a meaningful premium to unaffiliated shareholders ▪ The $56.00 per share deal price plus a dividend from Q1 2021 implies a premium of
Slide 8: Precedent Transaction Book Value Multiple Analysis Supports Transaction Valuation
Precedent Transaction Book Value Multiple Analysis Supports Transaction Valuation ___________________________________ Source: Company filings. Note: multiples measured on the basis of deal value divided most recently disclosed book value excluding AOCI at the time of ann ouncement. 1. Given the long
Slide 9: EPS Multiple Analysis of Peer Companies Also Supports Transaction Valuation
EPS Multiple Analysis of Peer Companies Also Supports Transaction Valuation ___________________________________ Source: FactSet , SNL. Market data as of April 6, 2021. Company Filings. 1. Based on Company Internal Plan provided by FBL’s management on December 23, 2020. 2. Peer average and median app
Slide 10: Independent Actuarial Appraisal Further Supports $56.00/Share Valuation
Independent Actuarial Appraisal Further Supports $56.00 / Share Valuation ___________________________________ Source: All reliances and limitations are subject to the Milliman Report as of December 31, 2020. RIGHT PRICE Per Share Actuarial Value, As Adjusted $52.15 $49.15 $46.53 $44.24 $5.82 $3.47 $
Slide 11: Rigorous Review Process
Rigorous Review Process RIGHT PROCESS Special Committee conducted a detailed review of FBPCIC’s offer Qualified and Engaged Special Committee Special Committee made up of independent and unaffiliated directors, with deep insurance industry and public company transaction expertise Retained Barclays a
Slide 12: Rigorous Review Process (Negotiation)
Rigorous Review Process RIGHT PROCESS Special Committee conducted a detailed review of FBPCIC’s offer 12 Rigorous Negotiation Engaged in multiple rounds of negotiation with FBPCIC, resulting in 19% increase from the initial offer price to deliver a fair and full value for FBL Financial Group unaffil
Slide 13: FBL's Business is Significantly Impacted by Rates
FBL’s Business is Significantly Impacted by Rates RIGHT TIME ___________________________________ Source: Company Filings. Company Internal Projections. 1. Based on reserves as of December 31st, 2020. 2. ROAE ex. AOCI defined as net income divided by average shareholder’s equity ex. AOCI. 9.9% 10.6%
Slide 14: CRM's "Comparables" Are Not Relevant
CRM’s “Comparables” Are Not Relevant Dat e Announced Target Acquirer Rationale for Exclusion 2/7/2020 FGL Holdings Fidelity National Much larger acquirer with higher P/E ratio Pre - COVID Acquirer stock price traded down meaningfully post - announcement 8/11/2015 Symetra Sumitomo Life Transaction an
Slide 15: CRM's Comparables Index is Not Appropriate
CRM's Comparables Index is Not Appropriate 15 ___________________________________ Source: Bloomberg, FactSet. SNL. 1. Index weighting based on Bloomberg as of 4/6/21. 2. Per FactSet as of 4/6/21. 3. Per SNL. Financial Data as of 12/31/21. Price Data as of 4/6/21. Company Weighting 1 Market Cap 2 ($m
Slide 16: CRM's Inclusion of AOCI is Fundamentally Misleading
CRM’s Inclusion of AOCI is Fundamentally Misleading Under GAAP accounting, low interest rates cause a positive mark - to - market in fixed income investments, but do not provide for a similar mark - to - market of interest - bearing liabilities ▪ AOCI fluctuates as assets are marked up in a declinin
Slide 17: $56.00/Share is a Unique and Compelling Opportunity: Right Price, Time, Process
$56.00/Share is a Unique and Compelling Opportunity for FBL Financial Group’s Unaffiliated Shareholders P Right Price P Right Time P Right Process 17 Special Committee negotiated a compelling offer that is in the best interest of the unaffiliated shareholders Special Committee recommends shareholder
Slide 18: Path to Closing and Certain, Substantial Cash Value
Path to Closing and Certain, Substantial Cash Value January 11 Transaction Announcement March 11 Record Date for Voting at Special Meeting March 17 Filed and Mailed Definitive Proxy Statement March 31 Payment of $0.52 Quarterly Cash Dividend to Shareholders of Record as of March 15, 2021 April 29 Sh
Slide 19: Appendix
Appendix 19
Slide 20: Understanding the Negotiated Premium and "Bump"
Understanding the Negotiated Premium and “Bump” ___________________________________ Source: Company filings, Factset and Dealogic . 1. Premium measured from $56.00 per share transaction value to implied FBL price for the relevant row. 2. Buy - in precedent referenced by CRM. ▪ The Special Committee
Slide 21: FBL Financial / CRM Timeline
FBL Financial CRM files its preliminary proxy statement against the transaction (3/5/2021) CRM files its definitive proxy statement with the SEC (3/17/2021) CRM writes a letter to the Special Committee indicating they believed the offer was inadequate (12/1/2020) CRM issues press release, including
Slide 22: CRM's FBL Trading History / Activity
CRM’s FBL Trading History / Activity ___________________________________ Sources: Capital Returns Management, LLC Form DEFC14A filed on March 18, 2021. Factset for VWAP data. Note: Trades may have been made post this disclosure that are not reflected on this page. Note: Activity above does not inclu
Slide 23: Initial Post-Announcement Share Price Movement Did Not Reflect the Market's View
Initial Post - Announcement Share Price Movement Did Not Reflect the Market’s View of Transaction and the Stock Has Returned to Expected Levels Dividend Payments Shareholders of record as of March 15, 2021 have received a $0.52 per share dividend in addition to the $56.00 per share deal consideratio
Slide 24: Management Financial Projections Reviewed by Special Committee
Management Financial Projections Reviewed by Special Committee ___________________________________ Sources: Company filings, FBL Financial Group’s internal estimates for 2020, and GAAP plan for 2021. 1. Realized losses on investments are presented net of income taxes at a rate of 21% for 2021 and th
Slide 25: Significant Shift in Yield Curve Over the Last Years
Significant Shift in Yield Curve Over the Last 3 Years ___________________________________ Source: Bloomberg. Market Data as of 4/6/2021. 25 0.02% 0.02% 0.04% 0.06% 0.16% 0.35% 0.88% 1.34% 1.67% 2.24% 2.32% 1.28% 1.39% 1.53% 1.76% 1.89% 1.98% 2.20% 2.33% 2.40% 2.58% 2.74% 1 Mo 3 Mo 6 Mo 1 Yr 2 Yr 3
Slide 26: FBL Financial Group, Inc.
FBL Financial Group, Inc. www.fblfinancial.com www.fbfs.com 26