Mac-Gray — Proxy Contest (May 2013)
34 slides from Mac-Gray's proxy contest presentation, May 10, 2013
Slide 1: It's time for change at Mac-Gray
It's time for change at 9 May 2013
Slide 2: Proxy solicitation legend
MOAB CAPITAL PARTNERS, LLC ("MOAB CAPITAL") WILL FILE A PROXY STATEMENT REGARDING THE ELECTION OF DIRECTORS OF MAC-GRAY CORPORATION (THE "COMPANY") AT THE COMPANY'S 2013 ANNUAL MEETING OF STOCKHOLDERS. SECURITY HOLDERS ARE ADVISED TO READ THIS PROXY STATEMENT AND OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATED TO THE SOLIC
Slide 3: Moab disclosures and disclaimer
Moab Capital Partners, LLC ("Moab") is an investment adviser to funds that are in the business of buying and selling securities and other financial instruments. Moab currently has a long position in Mac-Gray Corporation ("Mac-Gray" or the "Company") common stock. We do not own any options on Mac-Gra
Slide 4: Summary of concerns: subpar performance, missed fundamentals, earnings deterioration
Subpar share price performance: Mac-Gray's share price has underperformed the Russell 2000 Index over 1-year and 3-year periods, which corresponds to the post-recession period. The stock is trading 24% below the rejected KP Capital's offer two years later. Failure to benefit from improved end-market
Slide 5: Share Performance and Operating Metrics
Share Performance and Operating Metrics
Slide 6: Shareholder value has suffered
Mac-Gray's share price has underperformed the Russell 2000 Index over 1-year and 3-year periods, which corresponds to the post-recession period. In its FY2010 earnings announcement, Mac-Gray noted: "The multi- housing market transitioned from a period of stabilization in the first half of 2010 to wh
Slide 7: Mac-Gray's shifting statements on apartment vacancy rates
Mac-Gray has previously argued that apartment vacancy rates had significant impact on revenue and profitability. Despite acknowledging that "occupancy" rates are now the "highest they have been in more than a decade", Mac- Gray is now saying that "occupancy is not the sole driver of our business". W
Slide 8: Vacancy rates are better than pre-recession levels
According to a report by Reis Inc., the national apartment vacancy rate fell to 4.3% in the first quarter of 2013, the lowest it has been since the fourth quarter of 2001*. 7 Vacancy rates are better than pre-recession levels Source: * http://www.reuters.com/assets/print?aid=USBRE93204820130403
Slide 9: Despite improved end-market dynamics, Mac-Gray has stagnated
In March 2009, Mac-Gray estimated the impact of high vacancy rates on revenue to be at least $5 million annually. Given current vacancy rates are now lower than that in 2008, Mac-Gray's revenue should be even higher than. $332 million (FY08 revenue of $327mn +$5mn of lost revenue) - without accounti
Slide 10: Competitors have performed much better than Mac-Gray
Whereas Mac-Gray has stagnated, its direct peers -Coinmach and WASH Multifamily Laundry Systems ("WASH") - have successfully capitalized on improved end-market fundamentals as reflected in their much stronger revenue and EBITDA growth rates. Apartment REITs who are exposed to the same end-market hav
Slide 11: Competitors have significantly higher profit margins
As noted earlier, Coinmach and WASH Multifamily have not only outperformed Mac-Gray in terms of revenue and Adj. EBITDA growth rate since the beginning of recovery in 2010, but are also operating more efficiently as indicated by their superior EBITDA margin. 10 Competitors have significantly higher
Slide 12: Inability to grow revenue has resulted in failure to benefit from cost leverage
Not only has Mac-Gray failed to benefit from improved apartment vacancy rates, but its profit margins have deteriorated to levels that are even below what the Company achieved during the recession period. Shareholders should remember that during its proxy contest in 2011, Mac-Gray laid out a strateg
Slide 13: Deterioration in core business continued in 1Q2013
In 1Q2013 revenue declined by 3.1% and gross profit by 6.7% over the same quarter last year. After excluding litigation expense from 1Q2012 SG&A, Adjusted EBITDA declined by 5.9% sequentially in the first quarter. While, 1Q2013 gross margin is slightly higher than for FY2012, it is worth noting that
Slide 14: Deteriorating Cash ROIC and Cash ROE
Mac-Gray is suffering from deteriorating Cash ROIC and Cash ROE 13
Slide 15: The two incumbent nominees have approved a failed acquisition strategy
During 2004-2012, Mac-Gray spent $316 million on acquisitions for approx. $200 million in annualized revenue. The amount spent on acquisitions is 1.5x the current market capitalization of $194.4 million. Net revenue acquired (after MicroFridge divestiture) over this period is exactly equal to the co
Slide 16: Incumbent nominees showed questionable understanding about acquisition valuations
Board approved transactions at multiples that were higher than Mac-Gray's at the time of each acquisition. Board's failure in creating value through acquisition is evidenced by the fact that Mac-Gray is currently trading at a significant discount to the multiples it paid at the time of acquisition.
Slide 17: Management and Board failed to expand addressable market
Management and the Board have failed in their efforts to expand Mac-Gray's addressable market MicroFridge (Intirion Corporation) "sells a proprietary line of appliances for small space living environments, primarily combination refrigerators/freezers/microwave ovens utilizing its Safe Plug(r) circui
Slide 18: FY2013 guidance reiterated
On May 2, 2013, Mac-Gray reiterated FY2013 guidance of $328-332 million for revenue and $68-71 million for Adjusted EBITDA. The weak first quarter revenue and profitability suggest that this guidance may be aggressive. Interestingly, FY2013 guidance is around the same level as the guidance for FY201
Slide 19: Corporate Governance
bs MOAB Corporate Governance
Slide 20: Results of Voting on Stockholder Proposals
19 Results of Voting on Stockholder Proposals Source: Company 8-Ks dated 5/26/2010, 5/18/2011, and 6/13/2012 Date Stockholder Proposal % Needed for Approval For Against Abstain % For Result Implemented 5/6/2010 Declassify the Board of Directors 50.1% 7,088,802 6,009,404 39,716 53.8% Approved No 5/18
Slide 21: Incumbent Directors have shown utter disregard for shareholder rights
Incumbent Directors have shown utter disregard for shareholder rights 20 "At last year's annual meeting, a shareholder proposal to declassify the Board received affirmative votes from a majority of the Company's shares outstanding. The Board has failed to act on this proposal; it does not discuss th
Slide 22: Incumbent directors are trying to take away shareholders' right to vote
Incumbent directors are trying to take away shareholders right to vote on Board members 21 In stark contrast to past elections, the Board has elected to implement a heretofore ignored age limit in its nominations. This year, the Board has decided to retire Class I Director Edward F. McCauley, citing
Slide 23: Incumbent Directors voted to reject two premium offers
Incumbent Directors voted to reject two premium offers December 2006: Board unanimously rejects $13.00-$13.75 per share offer from Coinmach Services Corporation to acquire the Company Coinmach's offer represents a 21% to 28% premium to Mac-Gray's trading price at the time of the proposal Over six ye
Slide 24: Share repurchase and proxy contest costs
After Moab proposed a slate of directors for election at the 2012 annual meeting, representatives of the Company used the Company's entire $2.0 million share repurchase authorization to negotiate a private purchase of stock from a stockholder who had indicated support for Moab's slate at approximate
Slide 25: Mac-Gray should return more cash to shareholders
Mac-Gray should return more cash to shareholders The February 25th announced dividend increase represents an increase of just $1.6 million per year, which is just 5% of the 2013 adjusted after-tax free cash flow of the business based on Company guidance. Moab estimates the dividend going forward is
Slide 26: Compensation Committee must be held accountable
The Compensation Committee must be held accountable for setting low levels of performance targets. Moreover, the performance metrics seem to lack rigor and have been set low enough to almost guarantee some payout. Same performance metrics (EBITDA and revenue) are used in both the short and long-term
Slide 27: Is the CEO's compensation aligned with stockholder value?
Is the CEO's compensation really aligned with creating stockholder value? See Exhibit D 26 (CHART)
Slide 28: Board Nominees: Background and Plan
Board Nominees: Background and Plan
Slide 29: Proposed nominee background: James E. Hyman
Proposed nominee background 28 James E. Hyman (age 53) is the President and CEO of TestAmerica Inc., the nation's largest provider of environmental testing services, a role he has held since 2011. In addition to his role at TestAmerica, Mr. Hyman has served as a Board Member of Grosvenor Americas, a
Slide 30: Proposed nominee background (continued): Michael M. Rothenberg
Proposed nominee background (continued) Michael M. Rothenberg (age 39) has spent the past 15 years in the investment management industry. In 2006, he co-founded Moab Capital Partners, LLC, a value-oriented event-driven money management firm. From 2003 to 2005, Mr. Rothenberg was a senior investment
Slide 31: Our Plan
Our Plan Business review Review market density across the country and address weakest markets with buy/divest/harvest mindset. Aggressively pursue accretive deals. Moab believes due to the utter failure of the company's past acquisitions that this board is stunted from evaluating the next deal. In a
Slide 32: Summary: reasons for change
Mac-Gray's share price has underperformed the Russell 2000 Index over 1-year and 3-year periods, which corresponds to the post-recession period. The stock is trading 24% below the rejected KP Capital's offer two years later. Both incumbent nominees are long serving Board members and must be held acc
Slide 33: Appendix
bs MOAB APPENDIX
Slide 34: Discourse of Moab Nominees to ISS
33 Discourse of Moab Nominees to ISS Thank you for your attention today. This is a very important meeting for us and we truly appreciate your time. Michael Rothenberg: My name is Michael Rothenberg. I founded Moab Capital Partners 7 years ago and our business has grown to manage $300 million in asse