Essendant — Proxy Contest (September 2018)
28 slides from Essendant's proxy contest presentation, Sep 4, 2018
Slide 1: Essendant's Proposed Merger with S.P. Richards is Inferior and Less Certain than Staples' All-Cash Proposal
Essendant’s Proposed Merger with S.P. Richards is Inferior and Less Certain than Staples’ All-Cash Proposal September 4, 2018 Exhibit 2
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer STAPLES, INC. (“STAPLES”) INTENDS TO FILE WITH THE SEC A DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT AND AN ACCOMPANYING GOLD PROXY CARD TO BE USED TO SOLICIT PROXIES IN CONNECTION WITH THE UPCOMING SPECIAL MEETING OF STOCKHOLDERS OF ESSENDANT INC. (THE “COMPANY”), INCLUDING ANY ADJOURNMENTS OR POSTPONEME
Slide 3: Vote NO on S.P. Richards Merger
Vote NO on S.P. Richards Merger We urge ESND shareholders to vote NO on the proposed merger with S.P. Richards The S.P Richards (“SPR”) merger presents multiple risks that could destroy value for ESND shareholders: Substantial risk that antitrust approval is not received Secular industry headwinds f
Slide 4: Key Risks the SPR / ESND Merger Creates for ESND Shareholders
Key Risks the SPR / ESND Merger Creates for ESND Shareholders This presentation addresses a number of key risks of the proposed SPR merger that ESND shareholders should be concerned about: Risk #1: SPR Merger Has Significant Risk of Not Closing Due to Antitrust Issues Risk #2: ESND Shares Are Curren
Slide 5: Risk #1: SPR Merger Has Significant Risk of Not Closing Due to Antitrust Issues
Risk #1 SPR Merger Has Significant Risk of Not Closing Due to Antitrust Issues
Slide 6: ESND / SPR Unlikely to Obtain Antitrust Clearance
ESND / SPR Unlikely to Obtain Antitrust Clearance ESND / SPR is a “merger to monopoly” Challenges levied by the FTC will not be remedied by synergy arguments ESND / SPR will be subject to a very long review process Staples’ proposal offers the clearest path to completion Staples’ proposal also offer
Slide 7: ESND's Stock Price Would Plunge if Shareholders Approve the SPR Deal and it is Then Blocked
ESND’s Stock Price Would Plunge if Shareholders Approve the SPR Deal and it is Then Blocked… 10 days prior to announcing the SPR deal, ESND hit its YTD low closing price of $7.44(1) ___________________________ Represents closing price on 4/2/2018. As of the unaffected share price of $8.47 on 4/11/20
Slide 8: Continuing an Established Trend of Dismal Performance
...Continuing an Established Trend of Dismal Performance… ___________________________ Source: Factset. ESND (77%) S&P 500 +66% ESND shares fell 77% in the 5 years leading up to the SPR merger announcement Declining industry trends will continue to pressure ESND regardless of whether the SPR merger i
Slide 9: With Potential Downside to ~$4 per Share Based on Recent Performance
…With Potential Downside to ~$4 per Share Based on Recent Performance If the SPR deal is blocked and ESND trades at its pre-announcement EV/EBITDA multiple of 6.9x, the implied price would be $4.22 ___________________________ Represents closing price 1 day prior to announcement of SPR transaction on
Slide 10: Risk #2: ESND Shares Are Currently Inflated Due to Speculation About Staples' Proposal
Risk #2 ESND Shares Are Currently Inflated Due to Speculation About Staples’ Proposal
Slide 11: Investors Valued Pro Forma Combination at Below $10 per Share
Investors Valued Pro Forma Combination at Below $10 per Share ESND’s Current Trading Levels Are Based on Takeover Speculation ESND never traded above $10 post announcement of transaction and pre-Staples investment 4/12/18 Announcement of S.P. Richards Deal 4/25/18 Reported disappointing Q1 EPS ($0.1
Slide 12: ESND's Stock Price is Inflated by Staples' Actions
ESND’s Stock Price is Inflated by Staples’ Actions Over 81% of the gains in ESND stock price can be attributed to (1) Staples’ / Sycamore’s purchases of ESND shares and (2) the public announcement of Staples’ acquisition interest ___________________________ Source: Company Filings, S&P Capital IQ. I
Slide 13: Risk #3: The SPR Merger Requires Faith in Unrealistic Assumptions About the Go-Forward Company
Risk #3 The SPR Merger Requires Faith in Unrealistic Assumptions About the Go-Forward Company… …Staples’ All-Cash Offer Provides Certainty of Value
Slide 14: Key Considerations for ESND Shareholders
ESND Management’s Poor Track Record Meeting Guidance / Expectations ESND and SPR Both Face Long-Term Secular Industry Headwinds ~35% of the Target Pro Forma 2020 EBITDA is Comprised of Synergies / Cost Cutting The SPR Merger Offers Unjustifiable and Less Certain Value vs. Staples’ All-Cash Offer Key
Slide 15: ESND Management Has a Poor Track Record of Forecasting Future Performance
ESND Management Has a Poor Track Record of Forecasting Future Performance… 1 ___________________________ Implied growth based on FY2015A net sales of $5,363mm and average of low and high estimate of $5,400 and $5,600 per FY2015 10-K. Implied growth based on FY2016A net sales of $5,369mm and average
Slide 16: And Unrealistic Expectations for Go-Forward Performance
…And Unrealistic Expectations for Go-Forward Performance 1 ___________________________ Note: Company filings. Reflects traditional office product and JanSan category sales. Last Year / This Year NEGATIVE Future Forecast POSITIVE? Represents EBITDA contribution from cost-cutting EBITDA Margin: 4.9% 3
Slide 17: ESND's Core Product Categories Are Facing Long-Term Secular Decline
ESND’s Core Product Categories Are Facing Long-Term Secular Decline 2 ___________________________ Source: 2018 IBIS Industry Reports, 2018 Technavio Industry Reports, IDC Industry Reports; “Other” assumed to grow at 0% given flat performance of the segment in recent years. Ongoing Market Declines We
Slide 18: ESND's Management Has Consistently Cited Secular Industry Decline to Explain Underperformance
ESND’s Management Has Consistently Cited Secular Industry Decline to Explain Underperformance 2 “Looking ahead, we continue to face a challenging industry dynamic, which will impact our business in 2017… Over time, we expect to fundamentally improve the value we bring to the marketplace and the prof
Slide 19: Even With Unrealistic Projections, ESND Shareholders Will Be Left Owning a Flat EBITDA Business
Even With Unrealistic Projections, ESND Shareholders Will Be Left Owning a Flat EBITDA Business (Pre-Synergies)… 2 S.P. Richards weighs on the outlook of the Combined Company ___________________________ Source: Company filings. EBITDA figures calculated using LIFO. ’17 – ‘20 CAGR 6.2% 1.3% Combined
Slide 20: EBITDA Projections Depend on Cost Cuts and Synergy Plans with Zero Margin for Error
…and EBITDA Projections Depend on Cost Cuts and Synergy Plans with Zero Margin for Error 3 Significant downside to earnings if management fails to meet its cost cutting expectations ___________________________ Source: Company filings. Stated in 8K filed on July 26, 2018 that ESND will deliver more t
Slide 21: Pro Forma Company is Over-Levered Relative to its Peers
Pro Forma Company is Over-Levered Relative to its Peers 3 ___________________________ Source: Company filings. Factset. CY2018E EBITDA for peers reflect consensus median estimates as of 8/24/2018 and latest available balance sheet information. As reported, not pro forma for the announced transaction
Slide 22: ESND / SPR Pro Forma Multiple Guidance Has No Basis
ESND / SPR Pro Forma Multiple Guidance Has No Basis 4 ___________________________ Source: Company Filings. CapitalIQ. Market data as of 4/11/2018, one day prior to announcement of entry into definitive agreement, multiples based on daily trading data. Genuine Parts Company press release, 5/16/2018.
Slide 23: Proposed RMT is An Unjustifiable Transfer of Value from ESND to GPC
Proposed RMT is An Unjustifiable Transfer of Value from ESND to GPC… 4 ___________________________ Source: Company Filings. Factset Note: Market data as of 4/11/2018, one day prior to announcement of entry into definitive agreement. Based on ESND 2018E Adjusted EBITDA (LIFO) of $112mm. Based on merg
Slide 24: While Staples Offers Superior Value for ESND
…While Staples Offers Superior Value for ESND 4 $11.50 per Share All-Cash Offer Provides Greater Value and Certainty versus ESND / SPR or Standalone ESND ___________________________ Source: Company Filings. CapitalIQ. $879mm of Pro Forma Net Debt and 40.2 million shares issued per the S-4/A filing o
Slide 25: Staples' Proposal Offers Greater Certainty Given All-Cash Consideration
Staples’ Proposal Offers Greater Certainty Given All-Cash Consideration 4 Deal with GPC Offers Consideration to ESND Entirely in Stock vs. All-Cash Staples Proposal ___________________________ Source: Company Filings Based on announcement materials of 4/12/2018. Fully committed financing represents
Slide 26: Staples' Proposal Is a Good Deal for ESND Shareholders
Staples’ Proposal Is a Good Deal for ESND Shareholders
Slide 27: Staples' Offer is Extremely Attractive by Any Measure
Staples’ Offer is Extremely Attractive by Any Measure… Staples’ $11.50 offer provides a compelling valuation and an attractive premium to ESND’s unaffected stock price 7.9x EV/2017A EBITDA, 1.2x higher than ESND’s 2-year historical average EV/LTM EBITDA trading multiple of 6.7x(1) 36% Premium to ESN
Slide 28: and Is Immediately Actionable
…and Is Immediately Actionable Staples owns 4.2mm shares in ESND, representing 11.15% of the basic share count, and is the 3rd largest investor in ESND Staples has delivered a fully actionable offer and merger agreement to ESND’s board Staples is prepared to sign a definitive agreement immediately S