Astoria Financial Corp

Astoria Financial — Merger or Acquisition (March 2017)

25 slides from Astoria Financial's merger presentation, Mar 7, 2017

  1. Slide 1: Sterling Bancorp and Astoria Financial to Merge, Creating a High Performing Regional Bank

    Sterling Bancorp and Astoria Financial to Merge, Creating a High Performing Regional Bank March 7, 201 7

  2. Slide 2: Forward Looking Statements

    PAGE 2 Forward Looking Statements The information presented herein contains forward looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 giving Sterling Bancorp (“Sterling” or “STL”) and Astoria Financial Corporation (“Astoria” or “AF”) expectations or predic

  3. Slide 3: Additional Information About the Proposed Transaction and Where to Find It

    PAGE 3 Additional Information About the Proposed Transaction and Where to Find It Investors and security holders are urged to carefully review and consider each of Sterling Bancorp’s and Astoria Financial Corporation’s public filings with the SEC, including but not limited to their Annual Reports on

  4. Slide 4: Transaction Highlights

    PAGE 4 Transaction Highlights Compelling Strategic Rationale Financial Impact ▪ Combination creates a ~$29 billion diversified bank focused on the attractive NYC metropolitan area ▪ Combined franchise will have a Top 6 market share among regional banks in the NYC MSA with ~$19 billion in deposits ▪

  5. Slide 5: Transaction Overview

    PAGE 5 Transaction Overview Consideration Pro Forma Ownership Bank Merger Management and Board Composition Required Approvals Targeted Closing Name ▪ Fixed exchange of 0.875 Sterling shares for each Astoria share ▪ 100% stock ▪ Aggregate deal value of ~$2.2 b illion based on STL closing price of $25

  6. Slide 6: The Combination Creates a High Performing Regional Bank

    PAGE 6 The Combination Creates a High Performing Regional Bank * Pro forma capital ratios estimated at close. Pro forma performance metrics and balance sheet composition are long - term targets . (1) Represents an adjusted non - GAAP financial measure; please refer to Sterling Bancorp’s Earnings Pre

  7. Slide 7: Overview of Astoria Financial

    PAGE 7 Overview of Astoria Financial Astoria has $8.9 billion in deposits and operates in attractive markets that present a substantial growth opportunity Deposit Footprint Market Demographics Deposit Composition County Deposits ($mm) Market Share Pop. (mm) Pop. Change (2017- 2022) Median HHI Median

  8. Slide 8: Highly Attractive Low Cost Deposit Franchise

    PAGE 8 6% 7% 8% 9% 9% 11% 12% 10% 10% 12% 12% 14% 16% 17% 23% 24% 27% 25% 24% 23% 23% 3% 10% 15% 20% 25% 28% 30% 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Money Market Savings NOW / Int. Bearing DDA Non-Interest Bearing Cost of Total Deposits: 1.55% 1.22% 0.91% 0.62% 0.53% 0.41% 0.29% Cost of Non - Time De

  9. Slide 9: Both Companies Operate in Attractive NYC Markets

    PAGE 9 Both Companies Operate in Attractive NYC Markets STL Branch ▪ Long Island, including Kings, Queens, Nassau and Suffolk counties, has significant density with over 7,300 small and middle market commercial businesses New Haven 1,168 Fairfield 1,883 Hudson 817 Essex 1,084 Bergen 2,005 Passaic 63

  10. Slide 10: Combined Company Will Have a Diversified Business Mix

    PAGE 10 Combined Company Will Have a Diversified Business Mix Lending Fee - Based Commercial Lending Commercial Real Estate Lending Asset Based Lending Equipment Finance Healthcare Residential Warehouse Lending Retail and Commercial Depository & Cash Management Wealth Management Payroll Finance Fact

  11. Slide 11: Pro Forma Loan and Deposit Composition

    PAGE 11 Non - Interest Bearing 23% NOW / Int. Bearing DDA 20% Money Market 31% Savings 14% CDs 12% Non - Interest Bearing 12% NOW / Int. Bearing DDA 17% Money Market 30% Savings 23% CDs 18% Non - Interest Bearing 32% NOW / Int. Bearing DDA 22% Money Market 33% Savings 7% CDs 6% C&I 22% CRE 45% ADC 1

  12. Slide 12: Opportunity to Reposition Business Mix Through Integration

    PAGE 12 Opportunity to Reposition Business Mix Through Integration ▪ Focus residential mortgage activity under Sterling’s model; driven by in - footprint financial center activity ▪ Integrate Astoria CRE lenders under Sterling’s team - based, relationship focused model ▪ Accelerate recruitment of ne

  13. Slide 13: Track Record of Delivering Loan Growth

    PAGE 13 Track Record of Delivering Loan Growth Sterling has invested in a diversified asset origination platform with substantial embedded growth opportunities given recent business and team additions 2014 2015 2016 C&I CRE Proven Loan Origination Capabilities ($MMs) Organic Commercial Net Loan Grow

  14. Slide 14: Sterling Has a Proven Track Record of Successful Acquisitions

    PAGE 14 Sterling Has a Proven Track Record of Successful Acquisitions ▪ Sterling has a proven track record of seamless deal execution and integration, including completing an MOE with Legacy Sterling in 2013 ▪ Demonstrated ability to retain key personnel ▪ Senior management team includes members fro

  15. Slide 15: Sterling Has Made a Full and Successful Transformation to a Diversified Commercial Bank

    PAGE 15 Non - Interest Bearing 32% NOW / Int. Bearing DDA 22% Savings 7% MMDA 33% CDs 6% Non - Interest Bearing 32% NOW / Int. Bearing DDA 6% Savings 23% MMDA 15% CDs 24% Sterling Has Made a Full and Successful Transformation to a Diversified Commercial Bank C&I 44% CRE 44% ADC 2% Res. Mortgage 7% C

  16. Slide 16: Key Performance Metrics

    PAGE 16 ($ in millions, except FTE and per share data) Key Performance Metrics 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Total Assets $3,084 $3,790 $6,667 $7,425 $11,956 $14,178 Total Loans $1,776 $2,193 $4,127 $4,816 $7,859 $9,527 Total Deposits $2,136 $2,904 $4,921 $5,212 $8,580 $10,068 Total Revenue $116 $12

  17. Slide 17: Key Elements for Successful Mergers

    PAGE 17 Key Elements for Successful Mergers The combined company is well positioned relative to all key components of a successful merger 1. Strong capital p osition 2. Established ERM systems and platform 3. Positive regulatory relationships 4. Strong operating / earnings performance and internal c

  18. Slide 18: Pro Forma Financial Impact

    | STERLING ( ASTORIA FINANCIAL BANCORP WF CORPORATION Pro Forma Financial Impact

  19. Slide 19: Transaction Assumptions

    PAGE 19 Transaction Assumptions Consideration Merger Related Costs Anticipated Dividend Cost Savings ▪ Fixed exchange of 0.875 Sterling shares for each Astoria share ▪ 100% stock ▪ Aggregate deal value of ~ $2.2 b illion based on STL closing price of $25.05 on March 6, 2017 (1) ▪ Approximately $100

  20. Slide 20: Compelling Cost Savings Opportunity

    PAGE 20 Compelling Cost Savings Opportunity ▪ Expected net cost savings of $100 million with phase - in period of two years ▪ ~35% of Astoria's expense base ▪ Consolidate of 15 - 20% of combined branches and other back office locations ▪ Savings are net of the reinvestment into additional commercial

  21. Slide 21: Pro Forma Financial Impact

    PAGE 21 Pro Forma Financial Impact Transaction Accretion and Returns Expected Capital Position 2018E EPS Accretion ~9% 2019E EPS Accretion ~16% IRR ~19% Tangible Book Value Accretion (at close) ~12% Bank HoldCo Bank HoldCo TCE / TA - 8.1% - 8.0% Tier 1 Leverage Ratio 9.1% 9.0% 9.3% 8.7% Tier 1 Risk

  22. Slide 22: Driving Efficiencies and B/S Repositioning will Achieve Top-Tier Returns

    PAGE 22 0.50% 0.45% 0.10% 0.10% 0.30% 1.45% Astoria 2016 ROATA Net Cost Savings Funding Savings Securities Repositioning Loan Portfolio Repositioning Astoria Adjusted ROATA Driving Efficiencies and B/S Repositioning will Achieve Top - Tier Returns ▪ $100 million of net pre - tax savings represents 3

  23. Slide 23: Due Diligence & Credit Review Highlights

    PAGE 23 Due Diligence & Credit Review Highlights ▪ Credit risk due diligence on Astoria portfolio − Review process conducted mainly by senior credit executives of Sterling with geographic and functional area expertise (CRE, C&I, Resi) − Credit due diligence included review of all criticized and clas

  24. Slide 24: Transaction Summary

    PAGE 24 Transaction Summary ▪ Creates a ~$29 billion premier NYC bank with a diversified balance sheet and income statement ▪ Combined franchise would have a Top 6 market share in NYC among regional banks with ~$19 billion in deposits ▪ Leverage Sterling’s commercial lending expertise with Astoria’s

  25. Slide 25: STERLING

    STERLING BANCORP (i ASTORIA FINANCIAL ‘&F CORPORATION

Astoria Financial — Merger or Acquisition (March 2017) on 6ix