First Mercury Financial Corp

First Mercury Financial — Investor Presentation (April 2008)

30 slides from First Mercury Financial's investor presentation, Apr 2, 2008

  1. Slide 1: Investor Presentation April 2008

    Investor Presentation April 2008

  2. Slide 2: Forward-looking Statements

    Forward-looking Statements This presentation may include forward-looking statements. These forward-looking statements include comments with respect to our objectives and strategies, and the results of our operations and business. By their nature, however, these forward-looking statements involve num

  3. Slide 3: Business Overview, Platform, Strategic Advantage, Financial Review, Concluding Remarks

    Business Overview Platform Strategic Advantage Financial Review Concluding Remarks

  4. Slide 4: First Mercury's Business

    First Mercury’s Business Provide insurance products and services in specialty commercial insurance markets, focusing on niche and underserved customers Operate as an Excess & Surplus lines company (rated “A-” by A.M. Best) in 49 states, the District of Columbia, and the Virgin Islands, underwriting

  5. Slide 5: Differentiated Operating Platforms

    Differentiated Operating Platforms First Mercury American Emerald Insurance Management CoverX Services Corporation (“FM Emerald”) (“AMC”) E&S general liability Recently hired E&S Leading MGA focused coverage for security underwriting team focused primarily on niche fuel classes on complementary exce

  6. Slide 6: Differentiated Operating Platforms (continued)

    Differentiated Operating Platforms (continued) Contract ARPCO Underwriting 5 MGA relationships Provider of third party focused on niche administration services for underwriting classes not risk sharing pools of in competition with other governmental entity risks FMR business Legend: Risk-bearing ent

  7. Slide 7: Key Investment Highlights

    Key Investment Highlights Disciplined, data-driven underwriting approach results in superior underwriting profitability Cost-efficient operating structure provides an advantage Growth strategy fueled by implementation of significant pipeline of opportunities Well positioned in the surplus lines mark

  8. Slide 8: Platform

    Business Overview Platform Strategic Advantage Financial Review Concluding Remarks

  9. Slide 9: Premiums Produced and Gross Written Premiums by Source

    Premiums Produced and Gross Written Premiums by Source Premiums Produced ($ in millions) Gross Written Premiums ($ in millions) $400 $400 20%+ 20%+ Growth Over Growth Over $350 $350 2007 2007 R R $300 AG $300 AG C $1.3 $276.0 C $271.5 + + $1.3 0% 5% $250 2 $250 3$52.1 $47.6 $230.1 $218.2 $20.0 $8.1

  10. Slide 10: Security Classes

    Security Classes 2007 premiums by class through 12/31 Overview General liability coverages, each policy Alarm 30% individually underwritten Security Guard • Customized policy forms and exclusions 41% • Analyze data and results intensely to Safety drive underwriting decisions Equipment 29% 13 underwr

  11. Slide 11: Security Premium by State — 2007

    Security Premium by State — 2007 Top 20 States Represent Approximately 91% of CoverX Security premium Washington 10.3% Montana Maine North Dakota Oregon Minnesota Vermont 3.3% Idaho New Hampshire Wisconsin Massachusetts South Dakota New York Michigan Rhode Island Wyoming Connecticut Iowa Pennsylvani

  12. Slide 12: Specialty Classes

    Specialty Classes 2007 premiums by class through 12/31 Overview All general liability coverages; same Other Roofers fundamental underwriting characteristics 45% 35% and targets as Security classes · Same customized policy forms and exclusions • Same focus on underserved accounts Carpentry Habitation

  13. Slide 13: Specialty Premium by State — 2007

    Specialty Premium by State — 2007 Top 20 States Represent Approximately 93% of CoverX Specialty Premium 17.7% Washington Montana Maine North Dakota Minnesota 10.3% Oregon Vermont Idaho New Hampshire Wisconsin Massachusetts South Dakota New York Connecticut Rhode Island Wyoming Michigan Iowa Pennsylv

  14. Slide 14: Specialty Class — Contractor Book

    Specialty Class — Contractor Book 2007 premiums by class through 12/31 2007 contractor premiums by state Total 2007 premiums = $142.3mm WA Other 19% 28% Roofing Other 33% 38% TX 13% Carpentry CA Excavation 9% 2% 8% AZ Plumbing Masonry FL 12% 3% 6% Metal Works Drywall/Plaster 10% NY 3% 6% 10%

  15. Slide 15: First Mercury Emerald Insurance Services

    First Mercury Emerald Insurance Services Hired an underwriting team led by Kevin Brooks in July 2007 Offices in New York, Atlanta, and Los Angeles Have hired 21 underwriters and underwriting assistants, with an average of 20 years experience Business consists of 3 units: • Excess/Umbrella Casualty p

  16. Slide 16: Contract Underwriting Programs

    Contract Underwriting Programs Programs Opportunities Program 1: Lawyers Professional Liability Approach to adding new programs: Program 2: Hospitality / Habitational Small Accounts • Due diligence and personnel background checks • Data verification and loss experience analysis Program 3: GL Habitat

  17. Slide 17: American Management Corporation

    American Management Corporation Acquired in February 2008 Leading MGA focused primarily on niche fuel related marketplace for over 20 years 87% of 2007 premiums written on an admitted basis Source of fee based income Currently written on third-party paper with the opportunity to write business on FM

  18. Slide 18: Strategic Advantage

    Business Overview Platform Strategic Advantage Financial Review Concluding Remarks

  19. Slide 19: Positioned for Profitable Growth Across Market Cycles

    Positioned for Profitable Growth Across Market Cycles Premium growth in 2008 will be driven by strategic initiatives undertaken in 2006 and 2007 Premium production is expected to be flat as we maintain our commitment to underwriting CoverX discipline 9 Small account focus insulates us from the broad

  20. Slide 20: Embedded Growth Opportunities

    Embedded Growth Opportunities $300 $271.5 $1.3 $250 $47.6 $218.2 $8.1 $200 $175.9 $8.8 $155.6 $142.9 $0.3 $150 $5.4 $155.9 $22.9 $138.2 $105.7 $97.2 $5.0 $100 $91.1 $93.4 $59.5 $50 $69.9 $71.9 $66.7 $41.2 $46.4 $39.0 $0 GWP NWP GWP NWP GWP NWP 2005 2006 2007 Security Specialty Contract Underwriting

  21. Slide 21: Approach to Growth

    Approach to Growth Strategic Approach Representative Execution Hire experienced underwriters 9 7 additional underwriters hired in 2007 9 Opened office in Irvine, California (December 2006) Expand geographically in specialty classes 9 Consolidated Southeast underwriting operations in Atlanta, GA 9 Op

  22. Slide 22: Financial Review

    Business Overview Platform Strategic Advantage Financial Review Concluding Remarks

  23. Slide 23: Financial Overview — Summary

    Financial Overview — Summary $ in millions For the year ended December 31, 2007 2006 % growth Premiums produced $276.0 $230.1 20 % Net premiums earned 169.1 110.6 53 Net investment income 16.3 9.7 68 Net income 41.7 21.9 90 Operating net income1 $41.7 $21.5 94 %Loss ratio 52.1 % 8 50. % Net expense

  24. Slide 24: Prudent Loss Reserve Philosophy

    Prudent Loss Reserve Philosophy Extensive, on-going, in-house loss experience monitoring • Hired two credentialed actuaries in 2007 Quarterly internal and semi-annual external actuarial reviews Case vs. IBNR reserves, net of reinsurance 100% 42.1% 35.7% 30.1% 29.1% 75% 49.5% 50% 57.9% 64.3% 69.9% 70

  25. Slide 25: Prior Years' Reserve Development During 2007

    Prior Years’ Reserve Development During 2007 Favorable (Unfavorable) $ in Millions Accident Years 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 All Losses and ALAE Security $ (1.2) 7) $ (1. $6 0. $4) (0. $3 0. $1 0. $2 3. $0.9 Specialty (0.7) 8) (0. 3) (0. 1) (1. 8) (2. 5) (2. 6 7. $ (0.6) Total Losses and ALA

  26. Slide 26: Investment Portfolio Characteristics

    Investment Portfolio Characteristics Investment portfolio is actively managed by advisors AAM, Portfolio Composition JP Morgan, MD Sass and Zazove Associates Convertible Securities Other 3.3% 7.9% S&P weighted average credit quality of AA+ for fixed income portfolio ABS & CMBS 8.9% Municipal Tax-eff

  27. Slide 27: Structured Products

    Structured Products Analysis as of 12/31/2007 24.0% of portfolio in Mortgage and Asset backed securities • 98.3% are AAA rated • $1.9 million rated below AAA have significant credit support and low delinquency and foreclosure rates • Residential Mortgage Backed Securities and Home Equity Asset Backe

  28. Slide 28: Reinsurance Program / Mainframe Treaties

    Reinsurance Program / Mainframe Treaties Overview Mainframe reinsurance structure as of January 2008 High quality reinsurance partners Reinsurance 5,000,000 $5,000,000 xs $1,000,000 A.M. Best Recoverables only Munich Re: 76.5% Name rating ($MM) FMIC: 10% Retention Swiss Re USA: 13.5% Ace Ltd. A+ $72

  29. Slide 29: Concluding Remarks

    Business Overview Platform Strategic Advantage Financial Review Concluding Remarks

  30. Slide 30: Concluding Remarks

    Concluding Remarks Proven track record over 34 years High quality management team closely aligned with shareholders Business model designed for profitable growth across market cycles Highly disciplined underwriting approach using data-driven analysis to generate superior loss ratios Cost-efficient o

First Mercury Financial — Investor Presentation (April 2008) on 6ix