Cogentix Medical — Proxy Contest (May 2016)
13 slides from Cogentix Medical's proxy contest presentation, May 6, 2016
Slide 1: Response to CGNT's ISS presentation - Lewis C. Pell
Cogentix Medical Inc. (CGNT) Response to CGNT’s ISS presentation - Lewis C. Pell May 6, 2016 Exhibit 1
Slide 2: Summary
Summary CGNT is trying to hide behind growth rate numbers. Since the merger (3/31/2015), quarterly revenue run-rate has declined for Urology (-11.6%) and Airway/Industrial (-13.6%) segments. The decline in run-rate is in sharp contract to the trend for these segments prior to the merger – Urology (+
Slide 3: Upward trend in revenue run-rate for VSCI products has reversed
The upward trend in revenue run-rate for VSCI products has reversed under Rob Kill CGNT’s is trying to hide behind growth rates - revenue run-rate has declined under Rob Kill Source: Factset. SEC filings Since the merger (3/31/2015), quarterly revenue run-rate has declined: Urology is down 11.6% and
Slide 4: Revenue run-rate for UPI products has declined or slowed
Revenue run-rate for UPI products has either declined (MPQ) or increased at a much slower pace (UPC) UPI products too have failed to benefit from the merger Source: Factset. See Appendix for TSR peer group
Slide 5: 2016 Guidance
Truth: 2016 Guidance Medtronic’s competitive threat was known even prior to the merger and shareholders approved the merger based on short and long-term guidance provided Aware of the NURO competition, the company provided 2016 revenue guidance in its 3QCY2015 earnings release on Nov. 3, 2015. What
Slide 6: Strategy
Truth: Strategy On Feb 16, Mr. Pell wrote a letter to the board, later filed with the SEC on Feb. 17, stating: “I am deeply disappointed by what I see as the unsatisfactory performance and empty vision of the Company's leadership at both the executive management and Board levels.” How can CGNT claim
Slide 7: Product Pipeline
Truth: Product Pipeline If CGNT’s assertions about product development are true, what is the new product adoption rate and how is it likely to impact revenue growth? The fact that the revenue is trending down, coupled with CGNT’s decision to remove guidance is indicative of lack of product developme
Slide 8: Compensation
Truth: Compensation CGNT is trying to mislead shareholders by comparing the result for the combined company with UPI as a stand-alone entity. The FY2014 revenue of $24.6 million in CGNT’s presentation is for UPI only, whereas the FY16 revenue estimate of $50 million is for CGNT, which includes reven
Slide 9: Governance
Truth: Governance The Governance and Nominating committee is controlled by former Uroplasty directors who have consistently demonstrated an inability to deliver value for shareholders. Mr. Pell vigorously disputes the claim the board size reduction was legal. Mr. Pell has brought a case in the Delaw
Slide 10: Governance (contd.)
Truth: Governance (contd.) The CFO position has been vacant for several months. No candidates were presented to the board prior to the beginning of the proxy campaign. The Nominating committee presented only one CFO candidate for consideration to the board as opposed to a group of qualified candidat
Slide 11: Governance (contd.)
Truth: Governance (contd.) At the 2013 shareholder meeting , 39% of votes cast were AGAINST the Say on Pay proposal. ISS also AGAINST the executive compensation package. At the 2014 shareholder meeting, ISS again recommended AGAINST the Say on Pay proposal. The proposal failed with 52% of votes cast
Slide 12: Additional Information
Additional Information Lewis C. Pell filed a definitive proxy statement, as amended, and an accompanying proxy card with the Securities and Exchange Commission on May 2, 2016 to be used to solicit proxies in connection with the 2016 Annual Meeting of Stockholders (including any adjournments or postp
Slide 13: Cautionary Statement Regarding Forward-Looking Statements
Cautionary Statement Regarding Forward-Looking Statements The information herein contains “forward-looking statements.” Specific forward-looking statements can be identified by the fact that they do not relate strictly to historical or current facts and include, without limitation, words such as “ma