Atlas Financial — FY2017 Earnings Presentation
13 slides from Atlas Financial's earnings presentation, Mar 2, 2018
Slide 1: Preliminary 2017 Fourth Quarter and Year End Conference Call
NASDAQ: AFH Preliminary 2017 Fourth Quarter and Year End Conference Call March 1, 2018
Slide 2: Forward Looking Statement
Forward Looking Statement 2 Statements in this presentation, including the information set forth as to the future financial or operating performance of Atlas Financial Holdings, Inc., American Country Insurance Company, American Service Insurance Company, Inc., Gateway Insurance Company and/or Globa
Slide 3: Impact of Reserve Strengthening Forecast for 2018
Impact of Reserve Strengthening Forecast for 2018 3 Reserve Changes • Strengthening for older accident years • More current years stable Expected BVPS at December 31, 2017 • $7.25 - $8.00 • Includes approximate $0.55 reduction in Deferred Tax Asset due to tax policy change, unrelated to strengthenin
Slide 4: Pricing Activity And Impact of Predictive Modelling
Pricing Activity And Impact of Predictive Modelling 4 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 Q 1 1 2 Q 2 1 2 Q 3 1 2 Q 4 1 2 Q 1 1 3 Q 2 1 3 Q 3 1 3 Q 4 1 3 Q 1 1 4 Q 2 1 4 Q 3 1 4 Q 4 1 4 Q 1 1 5 Q 2 1 5 Q 3 1 5 Q 4 1 5 Q 1 1 6 Q 2 1 6 Q 3 1 6 Q 4 1 6 Q 1 1 7 Q 2 1 7 Q 3 1 7 Q 4 201 7 Atlas vs ISO Average ISO Reco
Slide 5: Strengthening by Business Segment
Strengthening by Business Segment 5 -$5.0 $0.0 $5.0 $10.0 $15.0 $20.0 2011 & Prior 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Mill io n s ASI Pool Reserve Change by Accident Year (net, after tax) MI Only PA No-MI LI No-MI TA No-MI All Other no-MI -$5.0 $0.0 $5.0 $10.0 $15.0 $20.0 2011 & Prior 2012 2013 2014 2015
Slide 6: Fact Pattern: Positive Changes in Business Which Challenge Near Term Actuarial Work
Fact Pattern Positive Changes in Business Which Challenge Near Term Actuarial Work 6 2015 • Atlas initiated machine learning based predictive analytics as underwriting tool 2016 • Predictive analytics directly integrated into Point of Sale system (AtlasX) and rolled out to agents during year • On Ju
Slide 7: Heavier Reliance on IBNR Pre-Model Transition to Predictive Model Based Case Reserving
Heavier Reliance on IBNR Pre-Model 7 Transition to Predictive Model Based Case Reserving • Under predictive model based case reserving, each claim should be set to ultimate at 45 days of claim age • Reliance on IBNR for to estimate ultimate at year end until AY 2016 • Case reserves for claims too ol
Slide 8: Savings Observed Post Modelling
Savings Observed Post Modelling 8 Indicated Savings of 10% - 17% on similarly scored claims (before and after implementation of predictive model based claim triage) Change observed in allocated loss expense (e.g. defense costs, etc.) also supports view that most challenging claims are being extingui
Slide 9: Compression Resulting From Predictive Model Based Triage/Routing
Compression Resulting From Predictive Model Based Triage/Routing 9 Large percentage of small claims, relatively unchanged Notable shift in settlement time for mid size claims Most significant shift related to larger severity cohort of claims These are the groups intentionally targeted using predicti
Slide 10: Average Paid Severity By Size Cohort
Average Paid Severity By Size Cohort 10 Smaller claims on average have been settling for less Average paid severity on larger claims is not inflating despite earlier closure rate Note: claims in these cohorts are 20X – 30X the large number of smaller claims Notes • Includes all claims closed for the
Slide 11: Claim Closure Patterns
Claim Closure Patterns 11 Rolling 12 Month Claims Presented Open Inventory Inflection Point Evidence of Improved Risk Selection Incoming claim counts are flat despite 20% yr/yr growth In addition, accelerated closure rates are clearing inventory more quickly Traditional actuarial methods are trend b
Slide 12: Adjusted Loss Ratio: Potential Unrecognized Improvements From Predictive Analytics
Adjusted Loss Ratio 12 Potential Unrecognized Improvements From Predictive Analytics Risk Selection (~4%) Severity Reduction (~10%) Accident Year Loss & LAE Ratio 2012 92.8% 2013 73.7% 2014 66.4% 2015 70.9% 2016 67.5% 2017 67.0% Global Liberty Accident Ye r Loss & LAE Ratio 2012 91.7% 2013 95.5% 201
Slide 13: Prior Actions Taken to Address Relative Underperformance Michigan
Prior Actions Taken to Address Relative Underperformance Michigan 13 Prior sequential rate increases actuarially determined to achieve expected profitability targets • Maximum rate supported taken each year 2014: 30% 2015: 25% 2016: 60% 2017: 60% • Year end actuarial work supported incremental rate
Atlas Financial Holdings — FY2017 Earnings Presentation on 6ix