USG — Proxy Contest (April 2018)
22 slides from USG's proxy contest presentation, Apr 17, 2018
Slide 1: Additional Information
3 Knauf has made a preliminary filing with the SEC of a proxy statement and an accompanying GOLD proxy card to be used to solicit votes against the election of certain director candidates nominated by USG for election at the USG’s 2018 annual meeting of stockholders. This communication is not a subs
Slide 2: Knauf Is Voting Against All Four USG Director Nominees
4 Knauf has made a $42 per share offer to USG that presents USG shareholders with substantial cash value after a decade without dividends or meaningful share price appreciation We firmly believe our $42 offer price provides full and fair value relative to any potential value through the cycle and de
Slide 3: Knauf Is a Worldwide Leading Building Materials Business with a Track Record of Success
Knauf Is a Worldwide Leading Building Materials Business with a Track Record of Success 5 The values of the Knauf Group are the basis for sustainable actions: Partnership, Commitment, Entrepreneurship and Humanity 27,000 employees generating revenue in excess of $8Bn in 2017 and EBITDA of approximat
Slide 4: Proposal Summary
Proposal Summary 6 $42 per share in cash 25% premium to unaffected price (1) and 30% premium to 12-month average (2) Price in excess of USG’s highest closing share price over last decade and since financial crisis (3) Attractive 11.2x multiple of 2017 fully adjusted EBITDA (4) Fully reflects value o
Slide 5: USG Has Consistently Traded Below Knauf's Offer Price Over the Last Decade
$ / USG Share – Last 10 Years Over the Last Decade, USG Has Consistently Traded Below Knauf’s Offer Price and Only Briefly Near It Recently 7 Source Capital IQ as of March 23, 2018 Knauf’s Offer: $42.00 Mar-18 Temporary Run-Up (see next page) 25% premium to unaffected (1) 30% premium to 12-month ave
Slide 6: USG stock fell after 4Q17 results
$ / USG Share 8 Source Capital IQ USG reported strong 4Q17 results but the stock fell -6% on the day following earnings call commentary that suggested the quantity and timing of prebuy activity should make 1Q18 a relatively weak quarter. – Citi Research Report by Scott Schrier (Feb 2, 2018) we look
Slide 7: Investment in USG Has Dramatically Underperformed the Market Since 2000
USG Underwent Financial Restructuring 9 Source Capital IQ and Bloomberg Ambitious business plan vs. a history of underperformance (27%) 151% Mar-18 Investment in USG Has Dramatically Underperformed the Market Since 2000 (1)(2) Notes Rebased to USG’s share price on December 31, 1999 of $47.13 Total s
Slide 8: We Believe We Are Offering a Substantial Premium to Relevant Precedents
Aggregate Value / Last Twelve Months EBITDA (x) Source Mergermarket, Company Information, Broker Research, Bloomberg Notes Bloomberg completed building products transactions (excl. cement & aggregates) 1/1/2010 - 2018YTD, US target, transaction value over $100MM Average of post synergy multiples whe
Slide 9: Knauf's Premium Accounts for Potential Positive Future Developments
Knauf’s Premium Accounts for Potential Positive Future Developments 11 Knauf’s offer is at a premium multiple relative: USG recent trading history Closest peer comparable, Continental Building Products Aspirational peer, Armstrong World Industries Source Capital IQ as of March 23, 2018 Notes Chart p
Slide 10: USG Operates in an Inherently Cyclical Business
$MM 12 Historical Adjusted USG EBITDA (2) Source USG 4th Quarter 2017 Update Investor Presentation (Years 1997-2017); USG 4th Quarter 2016 Update Investor Presentation (Years 1995-1996); USG 10-K Filings (Years 1993-1994) (3) Notes As per Bloomberg, approximately 75% of USG's quarterly EBIT actual e
Slide 11: Margin Expansion in the Industry Is Constrained by Overcapacity and Commodity Pricing
Utilization (%) EBITDA Margin (%) Source USG Company Filings and USG 4th Quarter 2017 Update Investor Presentation Notes Effective capacity and industry shipments based on disclosure in USG Investor Presentation; utilization rate (installed) calculated as shipments in given year divided by installed
Slide 12: Residential Construction Spend in $ Terms Is Already Well Above 25 Year Average
14 Residential Construction Spend in $ Terms Is Already Well Above 25 Year Average Source US Census (Annual Average of Seasonally Adjusted Annual Rate of Total Private Residential Construction Put in Place) US Private Residential Construction Spend in $ Terms Private Residential Construction Spend (
Slide 13: After Years of Underinvestment, USG Will Require Significant Investment to Remain Competitive
Capex as % of Sales Source Company Filings, Capital IQ as of March 23, 2018 Notes Based on USG’s disclosure in its 10-K and USG’s 4th Quarter 2017 Update Investor Presentation Excludes L&W capex and sales for all years Peer group consists of Armstrong World Industries (restated for Flooring spin-off
Slide 14: USG Management Has Sold Personal Holdings at Values in the $30s
$ / USG Share – January 1, 2017 to March 23, 2018 16 USG Management Selling Source Capital IQ and USG Company Filings Knauf’s Offer: $42.00 = USG management selling personal holdings USG Management Has Sold Personal Holdings at Values in the $30s
Slide 15: USG Stock Declined ~3% at USG Investor Day
Duration of USG Investor Day Rebased to 100 (1) USG Stock Declined ~3% When Management Rolled Out Strategy at USG Investor Day, Demonstrating Investor Skepticism of Ambitious Targets and Strategy 17 Note Rebased to prior day closing share price on March 7, 2018 of $34.98 and 2,726.80 for USG and the
Slide 16: How We Got Here – USG Refusal to Seriously Engage at Every Step
$ / USG Share – Last Six Months 18 Source Capital IQ as of April 16, 2018 Knauf’s Offer: $42.00 How We Got Here – USG Refusal to Seriously Engage at Every Step 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 11 Nov 29, 2017: Knauf delivers indication of interest at $40.10 per share in cash; requests diligence Dec 20, 2017: USG r
Slide 17: Berkshire Hathaway Intends to Vote Against the Four Directors
19 “Berkshire’s present intention is to vote against the four directors proposed by management.” – Berkshire Hathaway, Schedule 13D/A (Apr 12, 2018) Long-Term Investor Berkshire Hathaway Berkshire Hathaway is the largest and a long-term shareholder (~31% (1)) Berkshire Hathaway publicly filed its of
Slide 18: USG's Standalone Strategy Claims and Structural Defenses
20 USG says it is highly confident its standalone strategy will deliver substantially more value than our offer, and references their strategic plan as an explanation Knauf has offered entering into an NDA to facilitate receipt of further information regarding the value of this strategy, yet USG ref
Slide 19: Additional Materials Appendix
Additional Materials Appendix 21
Slide 20: Advanced Manufacturing Savings Under Pressure from Widely Expected Cost Inflation
Source USG 4th Quarter 2017 Update Investor Presentation (US Wallboard cost structure), BMI Research (US manufacturing industry annual wage inflation), EIA (natural gas Henry Hub spot and forecast), RISI (old corrugated containers, domestic, FOB, OBM, US Southeast) Advanced Manufacturing Savings Und
Slide 21: USG Creates a Distorted Picture of Mid-Cycle
23 We Believe USG Creates a Distorted Picture of Mid-Cycle by Only Focusing on the >58-Year Average While More Recent History Tells a Different Story US Residential Housing Starts Annual Starts (MM) Repair & Remodel Home Improvement Private Residential Fixed Investment as a % of GDP USG’s Quoted Ave
Slide 22: USG Creates a Distorted Picture of Mid-Cycle
We Believe USG Creates a Distorted Picture of Mid-Cycle by Only Focusing on the >58-Year Average While More Recent History Tells a Different Story Us Residential Housing Starts knaur Repair & Remodel Home Improvement ‘Annual Stats (MM) 2,500 2.000 1.500 1.000 Private Residential Fined investment as