tronc — Tribune Publishing — Proxy Contest (May 2016)
40 slides from tronc's proxy contest presentation, May 13, 2016
Slide 1: Forward-Looking Statements
Forward-Looking Statements This presentation contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933 and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 that involve risks and uncertainties, including, without limitation, statements regarding the unsoli
Slide 2: Company Snapshot
COMPANY SNAPSHOT Spun-off from Tribune Media on 04-Aug-2014, Tribune Publishing is a multiplatform media and marketing solutions company that delivers innovative experiences for audiences and advertisers The Company’s diverse portfolio of iconic news and information brands includes award-winning dai
Slide 3: Company Snapshot (cont'd)
COMPANY SNAPSHOT (cont’d) Source: Tribune filings, Tribune management projections Note: $ in millions, except per share. 2016E figures reflect the midpoint of Tribune management guidance. 1Net debt includes pension/OPEB benefits payable and investments. New, tech-savvy management team focused on imp
Slide 4: The Future of Tribune Publishing
THE FUTURE OF TRIBUNE PUBLISHING Tribune Publishing is an Iconic Media Company Iconic brands with mass appeal – Los Angeles Times and the Chicago Tribune Approximately 60 million unique monthly online visitors An unparalleled content creation machine However Tribune Publishing has been an underappre
Slide 5: Agenda
AGENDA Corporate Strategy & Investment Highlights Relevant Timeline & Key Facts Gannett’s Opportunistic Raid Tribune Publishing's Highly Qualified Board 1 2 3 4
Slide 6: Corporate Strategy & Investment Highlights
Corporate Strategy & Investment Highlights 1
Slide 7: Tribune Highlights
TRIBUNE HIGHLIGHTS Iconic publishing brands and unique digital assets Vast library of premium content with global appeal Reach covering approximately 60 million monthly unique visitors Management team with technology, content monetization and turnaround expertise Potential to dramatically increase c
Slide 8: Reorganized for the Future
REORGANIZED FOR THE FUTURE TRADITIONAL MEDIA BUSINESS LA TIMES TRONC 96% Non-Digital 4% Digital 93% Non-Digital 7% Digital 100% Digital THREE DISTINCT REPORTING UNITS % of Customer Base
Slide 9: Tribune Publishing Operational Efficiency
TRIBUNE PUBLISHING OPERATIONAL EFFIECINCY – INVEST IN SINGLE CRM, CMS & DIGITAL PLATFORM SUBSCRIBERS UNIQUE VISITORS 58K 1,650K Digital Print 38MM Source: comScore as of March 2016
Slide 10: LA Times: Global Initiative
LA TIMES: GLOBAL INITIATIVE INVEST IN INTERNATIONAL BUREAUS – EXTEND THE FRANCHISE SUBSCRIBERS UNIQUE VISITORS 41K 640K Digital Print 36MM Source: comScore as of March 2016
Slide 11: Tribune Online Commerce
TRIBUNE ONLINE COMMERCE CONTENT REVENUE $60BN MARKET AI CONTENT MONETIZATION ENGINE INVEST IN AI, WIDGETS, CONTENT SYNDICATION, NATIVE ADVERTISING
Slide 12: The New Tribune Landscape
THE NEW TRIBUNE LANDSCAPE INTERNET SOCIAL MEDIA BUSINESS UNIT DIGITAL MEDIA & AD TECH
Slide 13: Digital Revenue Opportunity
DIGITAL REVENUE OPPORTUNITY REVENUE PER USER PER YEAR 2016E REVENUE PER USER PER YEAR 2020E $50 $21 $3 $1 $84 $30 $4 $2 Source: Tribune management and publicly available information Note: Reflects illustrative opportunity – the realized opportunity could be higher or lower.
Slide 14: The Tribune Investment Thesis
THE TRIBUNE INVESTMENT THESIS 35% – 40% Tronc 20% – 25% Traditional Media 2020E EBITDA 35% – 40% LA Times BUSINESS TRAJECTORY BUSINESS TRAJECTORY BUSINESS TRAJECTORY $1.6BN – $1.625BN 2016E Revenue $166MM – $172MM 2016E Adjusted EBITDA
Slide 15: Relevant Timeline & Key Facts
Relevant Timeline & Key Facts 2
Slide 16: Timeline of Key Events
TIMELINE OF KEY EVENTS Tribune Publishing Stock Price Performance Source: Tribune filings, Datastream and Capital IQ as of 08-May-2016 Closing Price Date Closing Price Company Event 1 04-Aug-2014 $22.12 Tribune Media completes spin-off of Tribune Publishing 2 07-May-2015 $19.69 Acquisition of San Di
Slide 17: Response to Gannett Proposal Timeline
RESPONSE TO GANNETT PROPOSAL TIMELINE 12-Apr-2016: Gannett Sends $12.25 Unsolicited Proposal 08-Apr-2016: Gannett Closes Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Acquisition 18-Apr-2016: Gannett Demands Response by April 22nd 21-Apr-2016: Tribune Formally Engages Financial and Legal Advisors 23/24-Apr-2016: CEO t
Slide 18: Timeline Comparison
TIMELINE COMPARISON Gannett / Journal Media Group (“JMG”) 12-Apr-2016: Tribune Receives Gannett’s Unsolicited $12.25 Proposal 02-Jul-2015: JMG Receives Gannett’s Unsolicited $11.00 Proposal 04-May-2016: Tribune’s Board Reviews Management’s Strategic Plan Tribune’s Board Unanimously Rejects Gannett’s
Slide 19: Rationale of Merrick Investment & Key Terms
5,220,000 shares of common stock were issued to Merrick Media on 03-Feb-2016 Purchase price of $8.50 per share (16% of outstanding shares; $44.4MM total investment) Merrick shares subject to three-year lock-up until 03-Feb-2019 Michael Ferro appointed as Non-Executive Chairman RATIONALE OF MERRICK I
Slide 20: Case Study: Merge Healthcare
CASE STUDY: MERGE HEALTHCARE Source: Company filings, Datastream and Capital IQ as of 08-May-2016 Note: Market cap taken as of the last day of each respective year, and as of 13-Oct-2015 for 2015. 1 2008 Revenue represents Q1 2008 LTM and market cap as of 04-Jun-2008. Market cap assumes share count
Slide 21: Gannett's Opportunistic Raid
Gannett’s Opportunistic Raid 3
Slide 22: Basis for Rejection of Gannett's Proposal
BASIS FOR REJECTION OF GANNETT’S PROPOSAL The Tribune Publishing Board is open to any credible proposal that it believes to be in the best interests of the Company and its shareholders After thorough consideration, Tribune’s Board unanimously concluded that the $12.25 per share price offered by Gann
Slide 23: Gannett's Proposal in Context
GANNETT’S PROPOSAL IN CONTEXT GANNET’S OFFER OF $12.25 PER SHARE UNDERVALUES TRIBUNE PUBLISHING GANNETT PROPOSAL MULTIPLES TRADING MULTIPLES ACQUISITION MULTIPLES Source: Public filings, Wall Street research based on latest publicly available financial statements, market data as of 29-Apr-2016 Note:
Slide 24: Gannett's Proposal in Context (cont'd)
GANNETT’S PROPOSAL IN CONTEXT(cont’d) Based on the midpoint of management guidance for 2016E EBITDA ($169mm) and Tribune’s 27-Mar-2016 balance sheet, a 1.0x change in EBITDA multiple is equal to $5.18 per share Source: Tribune filings Note: Dollar values in millions, except per share values. The mul
Slide 25: 2016E EBITDA
2016E EBITDA Management 2016E Adjusted EBITDA guidance of $166MM – $172MM consistent with LTM EBITDA 2016E revenue declines driven by secular print pressure, offset by cost reductions Significant standalone margin opportunity given the gap to the comparables BRIDGE TO 2016E GUIDANCE Source: Tribune
Slide 26: Traditional Print Media Trading Multiples
TRADITIONAL PRINT MEDIA TRADING MULTIPLES Gannett claims in its May 6th filing that “the public Company analysis as portrayed by Tribune is misleading as it includes inappropriate non-peer companies which distort the multiple” Gannett’s advisor, Methuselah, provided Journal Media Group (“JMG”) with
Slide 27: Other Precedent Transactions Not Included
OTHER PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS NOT INCLUDED Gannett claimed in its May 6th filing that “Tribune has ignored more than 20 U.S. daily newspaper transactions from the past 24 months that are more appropriate benchmarks” None of the transactions involved newspapers which match the scale, major market expo
Slide 28: Other Gannett Arguments: Premium
OTHER GANNETT ARGUMENTS: PREMIUM The premium was based on an depressed trading value for Tribune Tribune Publishing was impacted by the elimination of the dividend, disclosure of a material accounting weakness (each of which forced certain funds to exit their entire positions) Gannett's view of the
Slide 29: Shareholder Rights Plan
SHAREHOLDER RIGHTS PLAN Rights Plan received unanimous Board approval on 08-May-2016 The Tribune Board and management became aware that Gannett was continuing to accumulate Tribune stock and was approaching Tribune employees about the impact of a combination The second largest shareholder, Oaktree C
Slide 30: Tribune Publishing's Highly Qualified Board
Tribune Publishing's Highly Qualified Board 4
Slide 31: Depth and Breadth of Directors
DEPTH AND BREATH OF DIRECTORS 3 4 7 5 8 6 7 6 Leadership experience required to bring unique perspectives and challenge the status quo Critical experience needed to make decisions and create shareholder value Important experience in light of global expansion and high growth technology initiatives In
Slide 32: New Independent Directors Are Highly Qualified
NEW INDEPENDENT DIRECTORS ARE Highly Qualified Carol Crenshaw Director Joined April 2016 CFO and VP, Finance for The Chicago Community Trust Previously an auditor with KPMG Donald Tang Director Joined April 2016 Founder and Managing Partner of Tang Media Partners Previously Vice Chairman of Bear Ste
Slide 33: Tribune Board Overview
TRIBUNE BOARD OVERVIEW GIVEN THE QUALITY / STRENGTH OF THE INDEPENDENT DIRECTORS, IT IS NOT CLEAR WHY GANNETT FEELS DISPROPORTIONATE CONTROL WAS CONVEYED NAME AGE YEAR JOINED Independent?1 BACKGROUND MICHAEL FERRO, JR. 49 2016 Chairman of Tribune; CEO of Merrick Media; Chairman of Merge Healthcare;
Slide 34: Tribune Board Overview
GIVEN THE QUALITY / STRENGTH OF THE INDEPENDENT DIRECTORS, IT IS NOT CLEAR WHY GANNETT FEELS DISPROPORTIONATE CONTROL WAS CONVEYED INDEPENDENT?! MICHAEL FERRO, JR. JUSTIN DEARBORN CAROL CRENSHAW DAVID DIBBLE PHILIP FRANKLIN EDDY HARTENSTEIN RICHARD RECK DONALD TANG RENETTA MCCANN ij ELLEN TAUS triDU
Slide 35: Key Takeaways
KEY TAKEAWAYS Tribune is not opposed to a sale – the Board is always open to evaluate any credible proposal that it reasonably believes, in good faith, to be in the best interests of the Company and its shareholders However, the Company is opposed to a steal – Gannett’s proposal is an opportunistic
Slide 36: Key Takeaways
KEY TAKEAWAYS * Tribune is not opposed to a sale — the Board is always open to evaluate any credible proposal that it reasonably believes, in good faith, to be in the best interests of the Company and its shareholders * However, the Company is opposed to a steal — Gannett’s proposal is an opportunis
Slide 37: Setting the Record Straight
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT Important Facts Regarding Gannett’s Unsolicited Proposal MYTH $12.25 must be reasonable in May since Merrick invested at $8.50 in February FACT: A minority investment does not compare to an all cash takeover proposal Merrick Media invested $44.4MM in new growth capital AN
Slide 38: Setting the Record Straight (cont'd)
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT (cont’d) Important Facts Regarding Gannett’s Unsolicited Proposal MYTH Tribune refused to engage with Gannett FACT: Gannett’s Chair / CEO did not ask for a meeting with Tribune’s Chair and CEO prior to launching hostilities Tribune responded to each of Gannett’s inquiries
Slide 39: Setting the Record Straight (cont'd): Adjusted EBITDA
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT (cont’d) Adjusted EBITDA Adjusted EBITDA is not a recognized term under generally accepted accounting principles in the United States (US GAAP). Adjusted EBITDA is defined as net income before equity in earnings of unconsolidated affiliates, income taxes, loss on early de
Slide 40: Setting the Record Straight (cont'd): Adjusted EBITDA
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT ccm) Adjusted EBITDA Adjusted EBITDA is not a recognized term under generally accepted accounting principles in the United States (US GAAP). Adjusted EBITDA is defined as net income before equity in earnings of unconsolidated affiliates, income taxes, loss on early debt e