Meadowbrook Insurance Group Inc

Meadowbrook Insurance — Investor Presentation (May 2012)

27 slides from Meadowbrook Insurance's investor presentation, May 10, 2012

  1. Slide 1: Investor Presentation First Quarter 2012 Update

    EXHIBIT 99.1 Investor Presentation First Quarter 2012 Update

  2. Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements & Non-GAAP Financial Measures

    Forward-Looking Statements & Non-GAAP Financial Measures Certain statements made by Meadowbrook Insurance Group, Inc. in this presentation may constitute forward-looking statements including, but not limited to, those statements that include the words "believes," "expects," "anticipates," "estimates

  3. Slide 3: Presentation Outline

    Presentation Outline I. Overview of Meadowbrook II. The Meadowbrook Approach III. Financial Review IV. Key Investment Considerations 3

  4. Slide 4: I. Overview of Meadowbrook

    EADOWBROOK” = = Binsurance GRouP |. Overview of Meadowbrook

  5. Slide 5: Overview of Meadowbrook

    Overview of Meadowbrook Specialty niche focused commercial insurance underwriter and insurance administration services company • Founded in 1955, organized as holding company in 1985, IPO in 1995 • Headquartered in Southfield, MI with 34 locations throughout the U.S. and Bermuda and over 1,000 emplo

  6. Slide 6: Overview of Meadowbrook: Key Statistics

    Overview of Meadowbrook Key Statistics • Market Capitalization (at 5/3/2012): $433.4M • Book Value at 3/31/2012: $585.7M • Book Value per Share at 3/31/2012: $11.60 • Excluding unrealized gains/losses, net of deferred taxes: $10.26 • Tangible Book Value per Share: $8.53 • Price to Book (at 5/3/2012)

  7. Slide 7: Capability Building Through Successful Acquisitions

    Capability Building Through Successful Acquisitions Strategic Staging of Acquisitions Retail Agency Only Continued Synergistic Expansion 1955: Founded as a retail insurance agency • Meadowbrook actively reviews acquisition prospects on a strategic basis and enters into Core Capability Build Out tran

  8. Slide 8: We Have Delivered Results Over Time

    We Have Delivered Results Over Time Total Revenue ($M) Net Operating Income ($M) CAGR* (2007 to 2011) = 25% CAGR* (2007 to 2011) = 14% (excludes unusual 2011 storm losses of $9.0M($5.9M after-tax)) GAAP Combined Ratio Shareholders’ Equity ($M) CAGR* (12/31/2007 to 12/31/2011) = 18% *CAGR=Compound an

  9. Slide 9: II. The Meadowbrook Approach

    II. The Meadowbrook Approach 9

  10. Slide 10: The Meadowbrook Approach

    The Meadowbrook Approach We seek to leverage the unique characteristics of our balanced business model to achieve consistent, profitable results across the market cycle. Our Objective: • To deliver consistent earnings, across the market cycle, with a target return on average equity of 10% - 17% • We

  11. Slide 11: Our balanced business model allows us to adapt to changing market conditions

    Our balanced business model allows us to adapt to changing market conditions and deliver more predictable results. • Earned premium from insurance operations Diverse Revenue Sources • Fee revenue from risk management services • Flexibility to utilize multiple distribution channels • Product, program

  12. Slide 12: Diverse Revenue Sources

    Diverse Revenue Sources Diverse revenue sources enhance the durability of our business model. Insurance Operations • Admitted programs & standard products • Main Street Excess & Surplus Lines 2011 • Non-admitted programs Net Earned Premium: $747.6 M • Specialty markets Pre-Tax Net Earned Premium Pro

  13. Slide 13: Admitted Programs & Standard Market Products

    Description Examples Admitted Programs & • Homogeneous specialized programs • Food service industry Standard Market Products • Heterogeneous geographic centers • Educators 2011 GWP: $488M • Promotes specialty agents • Auto re-possessors 2010 GWP: $468M • Includes standard market products • Custom ha

  14. Slide 14: Positioned to Manage Insurance Cycles: Diverse Mix of Business

    Positioned to Manage Insurance Cycles Diverse Mix of Business TTM 3/31/2012 Gross Written Premium Business Mix • We have built our business to create product diversification as indicated by the mix of business • This platform enables us to grow our business opportunistically with a focus on underwri

  15. Slide 15: Positioned to Manage Insurance Cycles: Diverse Geographic Distribution

    Positioned to Manage Insurance Cycles Diverse Geographic Distribution Our regional perspective provides the infrastructure to achieve geographic diversification, while maintaining our effective local touch. Bermuda 9 6 8 7 9 5 1 3 Meadowbrook locations 10 Top 10 production states (2011) TTM 3/31/12

  16. Slide 16: Culture of Disciplined Underwriting, Claims Handling & Reserving

    Culture of Disciplined Underwriting, Claims Handling & Reserving Our diverse mix of business, combined with our disciplined underwriting and low loss retention levels enhances the predictability of our loss reserves. (Favorable) Unfavorable Development 0.2% 0.9% (2.7%) 0.2% 0.8% 0.6% Between Estimat

  17. Slide 17: Favorable/Unfavorable Development Since 2009

    Culture of Disciplined Underwriting, Claims Handling & Reserving Our diverse mix of business, combined with our disciplined underwriting and low loss retention levels enhances the predictability of our loss reserves. (Favorable) Unfavorable Development Since 2009 $ in ‘000s Average = (0.3%) Standard

  18. Slide 18: Conservative Investment Philosophy

    Conservative Investment Philosophy We maintain a high-quality, low-risk investment portfolio. • Low equity risk exposure • 98% fixed income and Portfolio Allocation and Quality cash • 2% equity Gross % Unrealized Allocation Gain Avg. Avg. $’s in (000’s) 03/31/2012 Fair Value Position Moody's S&P • H

  19. Slide 19: High quality investment portfolio matched to loss reserves

    Our high quality investment portfolio is well matched to our loss reserves and generates a predictable stream of income. • Net investment income Pre-tax Net Investment Income ($ in M) and Average has grown to $55M (TTM Investment Yield 3/31/12) from $37M in 2008 • Invested asset base increased to $1

  20. Slide 20: III. Financial Review

    EADOWBROOK” = = Binsurance Group ill. Financial Review

  21. Slide 21: Financial Highlights - First Quarter Update

    Financial Highlights - First Quarter Update While our first quarter results were impacted by unfavorable development, our current accident year performed in line with expectations. Highlights ($ in M, except per share amounts) * 2011 results presented above reflect the adoption of new accounting gui

  22. Slide 22: Expense Ratio Analysis

    Expense Ratio Analysis Reduction in internal expense ratio reflects a reduction in variable compensation and a shift in mix of business resulting in a lower commission expense. Net earned premium $170.7M $192.8M Policy acquisition $58.2M(1) $63.1M and other u/w expenses Expense ratio 34.1% 32.7% 201

  23. Slide 23: Loss & LAE Ratio Analysis

    Loss & LAE Ratio Analysis The increase in the GAAP loss & LAE ratio reflects a change in development in 2012 as compared to 2011, while the accident year loss and LAE ratio for both periods was similar. GAAP Loss & LAE Ratio AY Loss & LAE Ratio 23

  24. Slide 24: Underwriting & Pricing Actions Taken

    Underwriting & Pricing Actions Taken We actively manage our business to achieve profitable results. Recent Actions Taken: • Took action on certain workers’ compensation programs securing significant rate increases, as well as restricting business from certain states and classes of business • Since 1

  25. Slide 25: 2011 Results and 2012 Guidance

    2011 Results and 2012 Guidance Looking ahead, we believe our balanced business model positions us well to continue to deliver predictable earnings Driving Long-term 2011 Results 2012 Guidance Enterprise Value Gross Written Premium Gross Written Premium • Leverage multiple revenue sources and diverse

  26. Slide 26: IV. Investment Considerations

    IV. Investment Considerations 26

  27. Slide 27: Investment Considerations

    Investment Considerations • Balanced business model delivers consistent, profitable results • Average GAAP combined ratio of 95.5% (2007-2011) • GAAP combined ratio standard deviation of 2.6% (2007-2011) • Average ROAE (net operating income)10.2% (2007-2011) • Proven history of generating profitable

Meadowbrook Insurance Group — Investor Presentation (May 2012) on 6ix