Wells Fargo & Company · NYSE:WFC
Wells Fargo & — Shareholder Meeting (April 2017)
37 slides from Wells Fargo &'s shareholder meeting presentation, Apr 12, 2017
Slide 1: Key Findings from Board Investigation, Action Plan Update, and Our Path Forward
Key Findings from Board Investigation, Action Plan Update, and Our Path Forward April 12, 2017 © 2017 Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. All rights reserved. For public use.
Slide 2: Discussion Topics
Discussion Topics Key Findings from Board’s Independent Investigation Action Plan Update Our Path Forward – Building a Better Wells Fargo Corporate Governance, Election of Directors, and Stakeholder Engagement Engagement with Investors and Other Stakeholders Increased Transparency Strong and Effecti
Slide 3: A. Key Findings from Board's Independent Investigation
A. Key Findings from Board’s Independent Investigation
Slide 4: Board Independent Investigation and Report
Board Independent Investigation and Report In September 2016, Wells Fargo’s independent directors launched a comprehensive investigation into our Company’s retail banking sales practices and related matters. Overseen by a special Board committee (“Oversight Committee”) chaired by our Board’s indepen
Slide 5: Key Findings from Board's Independent Investigation
Key Findings from Board’s Independent Investigation* 1 Community Bank sales culture There was a growing conflict over time in the Community Bank between Wells Fargo’s Vision & Values and the Community Bank’s emphasis on sales goals. Aided by a culture of strong deference to management of the lines o
Slide 6: Key Findings from Board's Independent Investigation, cont. (Senior management oversight)
Key Findings from Board’s Independent Investigation, cont. 2 Senior management oversight Mr. Stumpf was Wells Fargo’s principal proponent and champion of the decentralized business model and of cross-sell and the sales culture. His commitment to them colored his response when sales practice issues b
Slide 7: Key Findings from Board's Independent Investigation, cont. (Control function oversight)
Key Findings from Board’s Independent Investigation, cont. 4 Control function oversight The culture of substantial deference accorded to the lines of business carried over into the control functions. Even when senior executives came to recognize that sales practice issues within the Community Bank w
Slide 8: Key Findings from Board's Independent Investigation, cont. (Management reporting to the Board)
Key Findings from Board’s Independent Investigation, cont. 6 Management reporting to the Board Before February 2014, sales practice issues had not been identified to the Board as a “noteworthy risk”. The directors in 2014 received reports from the Community Bank, from Corporate Risk, and from Corpor
Slide 9: Key Findings from Board's Independent Investigation, cont. (Board oversight and performance)
Key Findings from Board’s Independent Investigation, cont. 7 Board oversight and performance The Board’s Oversight Committee believes that the Board’s own actions could have been improved in three respects. Even though the Risk Committee and Board initiated a comprehensive program in 2013 to increas
Slide 10: B. Action Plan Update
B. Action Plan Update
Slide 11: Decisive Actions Informed by Feedback
Decisive Actions Informed by Feedback Our Board and Company Have Taken Decisive Actions. Our Board and our Company have taken decisive and comprehensive actions to address retail banking sales practices issues, work to restore the trust of our many stakeholders, and build a better Wells Fargo for th
Slide 12: Action Plan Update
Action Plan Update Key Findings from Board Investigation How Our Board and Our Company Have Already Been Responding 1. Community Bank sales culture Changed senior management of our Company and the Community Bank Elected Timothy J. Sloan as CEO Named Mary Mack as the head of the Community Bank Elimin
Slide 13: Action Plan Update, cont.
Action Plan Update, cont. Key Findings from Board Investigation How Our Board and Our Company Have Already Been Responding 3. Senior management oversight Board and John Stumpf agreed that he would forfeit all of his unvested equity awards (approx. $41 million) and that he would forgo his salary duri
Slide 14: Action Plan Update, cont.
Action Plan Update, cont. Key Findings from Board Investigation How Our Board and Our Company Have Already Been Responding 6. Management reporting to the Board As discussed under key finding 7 below, the Board enhanced its oversight of conduct risk, including sales practices risk, through the Risk C
Slide 15: Action Plan Update, cont.
Action Plan Update, cont. Key Findings from Board Investigation How Our Board and Our Company Have Already Been Responding Other Key Company Actions related to Customers, Team Members, and Culture More Generally We are working to complete the requirements of our regulatory consent orders related to
Slide 16: C. Our Path Forward – Building a Better Wells Fargo
C. Our Path Forward – Building a Better Wells Fargo
Slide 17: Engagement with Investors and Other Stakeholders
Engagement with Investors and Other Stakeholders Independent director participation in meetings with stockholders since 2010 Feedback summarized and shared with our full Board Meetings held with institutional investors representing more than 30% of our Company’s outstanding common shares in 2016 and
Slide 18: Increased Transparency
Increased Transparency We are committed to being more transparent about the changes we are making. We launched a new webpage at www.wellsfargo.com/commitment to keep our customers and other stakeholders updated on the latest developments. We are providing monthly updates on the impact of the sales p
Slide 19: Strong and Effective Corporate Governance Practices
Strong and Effective Corporate Governance Practices Key Corporate Governance Highlights Our Board continues to be committed to sound and effective corporate governance principles and practices, including board refreshment, board diversity, and recruitment of new directors to complement the existing
Slide 20: Board Composition Snapshot
Board Composition Snapshot Continued focus on board succession planning in 2017 Results of Board Succession Planning and Refreshment Efforts Highly engaged and independent Board with a diverse mix of qualifications, skills, and experience 15 director nominees for election at our 2017 annual meeting;
Slide 21: Enhanced Board Oversight of Conduct Risk
Enhanced Board Oversight of Conduct Risk Board Level Conduct Risk Oversight Responsibilities (Current) Annually approves enterprise statement of risk appetite (New) Oversees alignment of team member conduct with our risk appetite and our culture as reflected in our Vision & Values and our Code of Et
Slide 22: Board Recommends Vote FOR Each of Our Director Nominees
Board Recommends Vote FOR Each of Our Director Nominees Nominee Age Director Since Principal Occupation or Affiliation # of Other Public Boards Independent Committees (*Chair) John D. Baker II 68 2009 Chairman and CEO**, FRP Holdings, Inc. 1 Yes AEC; CRC; Credit John S. Chen 61 2006 Executive Chairm
Slide 23: Risk Committee
Risk Committee The Board’s Risk Committee includes the chairs of each of our Board’s other standing committees to provide it with a comprehensive perspective on risk across our Company. Formed in 2011 and serves as a focal point for enterprise-wide risks Supports and assists our Board’s other standi
Slide 24: Audit and Examination Committee
Audit and Examination Committee Audit and Examination Committee (AEC) Members: James H. Quigley, Chair* John D. Baker II* Federico F. Peña* Susan G. Swenson* Suzanne M. Vautrinot * Audit committee financial expert Qualifications and Experience Represented on AEC (see Slide 21 for legend) * Meets joi
Slide 25: Human Resources Committee
Human Resources Committee The Board’s Human Resources Committee is comprised of experienced current and former executives who contribute key insights and oversight of our executive compensation, incentive compensation risk management, and human capital management practices. The Board’s Human Resourc
Slide 26: Corporate Responsibility Committee
Corporate Responsibility Committee The Board’s Corporate Responsibility Committee is comprised of Board members with diverse backgrounds, skills, and experience in social responsibility, community and governmental affairs matters. In light of the importance of social responsibility matters to the Co
Slide 27: Executive Accountability Actions
Executive Accountability Actions Annual Incentive Award Forfeitures (approximately $11 million) Long-Term Incentive Forfeitures (approximately $86 million) No 2016 bonuses for John Stumpf, former Chairman and CEO, and Carrie Tolstedt, former head of the Community Bank (target value eliminated = appr
Slide 28: Our Compensation Decision Cycle – CEO Pay
Our Compensation Decision Cycle – CEO Pay July 2014 – Base salary increased to $2 million/year February 2015 – Granted performance shares worth approximately $6.5 million July 2015 – Granted restricted share rights worth approximately $1.5 million February 2016 – Awarded an annual bonus of $1 millio
Slide 29: New Retail Banking Incentive Program
New Retail Banking Incentive Program We introduced a new incentive program in January 2017 for our retail bank team members to focus on the customer experience within our branches. Additional centralized monitoring and controls provide enhanced oversight. We are evaluating feedback, plan performance
Slide 30: Improved Risk Management Organization and Controls
Improved Risk Management Organization and Controls We have made system and process enhancements to add protection measures to new accounts, such as sending automated emails to our customers every time a new personal or small business checking account or savings account is opened; letter acknowledgem
Slide 31: Formed New Office of Ethics, Oversight and Integrity
Formed New Office of Ethics, Oversight and Integrity Wells Fargo’s definition of conduct risk1 “Conduct risk is the risk of customer harm, reputation damage, litigation, regulatory non-compliance, and financial loss arising from unprofessional and unethical actions of business groups or team members
Slide 32: Strengthening Ethics and Culture
Strengthening Ethics and Culture Wells Fargo made Rebuilding Trust our top priority to sharpen our focus on the task ahead, what our Company and team members must accomplish together, and how best to serve customers. We have engaged outside culture experts to help us understand where we have cultura
Slide 33: Management Proposals – Board Recommends Vote FOR
Management Proposals – Our Board recommends that you vote FOR each management proposal Item 1 – Election of 15 directors Item 3 – Advisory Proposal on Frequency of Future Advisory “Say on Pay” Votes (Every Year Recommended) Highly qualified directors with a diverse mix of qualifications, skills, and
Slide 34: Stockholder Proposals – Board Recommends Vote AGAINST
Stockholder Proposals – Our Board recommends that you vote AGAINST each stockholder proposal Item 5 – Retail Banking Sales Practices Report Item 7 – Divesting Non-Core Business Report On April 10, 2017, in connection with its independent investigation, our Board released a Sales Practices Investigat
Slide 35: Stockholder Proposals – Board Recommends Vote AGAINST
Stockholder Proposals – Our Board recommends that you vote AGAINST each stockholder proposal Item 9 – Lobbying Report Item 10 – Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Policy We provide information on our website, available at https://www.wellsfargo.com/about/corporate-responsibility/government-relations/, about
Slide 36: Cautionary Statement About Forward-looking Statements
Cautionary Statement About Forward-looking Statements Forward looking statement disclaimer This presentation contains forward-looking statements about our future financial performance and business. Because forward-looking statements are based on our current expectations and assumptions regarding the
Slide 37: Thank you for your interest in and support of Wells Fargo
Thank you for your interest in and support of Wells Fargo.
Wells Fargo & Company — Shareholder Meeting (April 2017) on 6ix