SpartanNash — Proxy Contest (May 2022)
58 slides from SpartanNash's proxy contest presentation, May 16, 2022
Slide 1: The Right Team to Deliver Shareholder Value
The Right Team to Deliver Shareholder Value
Slide 2: General Disclaimer: Forward-Looking Statements
General Disclaimer Forward - Looking Statements The matters discussed in this presentation include "forward - looking statements" about the plans, strategies, objectives, goals or expectations of the Company. These forward - looking statements are identifiable by words or phrases indicating that the
Slide 3: Executive Summary: Transformed Board and Management Executing a Winning Strategy
Executive Summary Transformed Board and Management Executing a Winning Strategy to Drive Shareholder Value ▪ Recruited new CEO Tony Sarsam in September 2020; transformed management and organizational structure ▪ Replaced CEO in 2019 following underperformance; exited unsuccessful businesses and dive
Slide 4: Executive Summary (Cont'd.): Macellum and Ancora are Short-Term Investors
Executive Summary (Cont’d.) Macellum and Ancora are Short - Term Investors Fixated on Profit - Taking Versus Sustainable Long - Term Value Creation We Have Sought Constructive Engagement, But Macellum and Ancora Prioritized a Proxy Contest ▪ Macellum and Ancora (“Investor Group”) have demonstrated s
Slide 5: The SpartanNash Board Has Taken Decisive Action
The SpartanNash Board Has Taken Decisive Action The Board has made hard decisions… ...that have led to impressive results Hired New CEO Tony Sarsam in September 2020 Successfully Oversaw New Strategy Development Directed Prudent Capital Allocation Strategy Transitioned Former CEO in 2019 1 2 3 Trans
Slide 6: SpartanNash and Our Winning Recipe
SpartanNash and Our Winning Recipe 4
Slide 7: A Leading Food Solutions Company
A Leading Food Solutions Company Note: All statistics are as of FY2021. (1) Includes both Military and Food Distribution business segments. (2) Total includes Coastal Pacific Foods DC facility partnership in Stockton, CA. ...Supported by National Supply Chain Network and Retail Footprint 71% Two Cor
Slide 8: Highly Synergistic Wholesale and Retail Operations
8.6mm sq.ft. distribution footprint and a fleet of 550 trucks delivering 65,000 SKUs optimized across segments 2,100+ food distribution customers with corporate retail data synthesized into actionable customer insights Best in class shared services deliver operational excellence 145 retail stores ar
Slide 9: Our Refreshed Winning Recipe Defines Who We Are
Our Refreshed Winning Recipe Defines Who We Are Mission Signature Strength Core Capabilities People | Operational Excellence | Insights that Drive Solutions Values We Serve | We Create Solutions | We Win | We Have Fun Vision We Deliver the Ingredients for a Better Life Customer - Focused Innovation
Slide 10: Highly Accomplished, Purpose-Built and Diverse Management Team
Highly Accomplished, Purpose - Built and Diverse Management Team Tony Sarsam President and Chief Executive Officer Adrienne Chance Senior Vice President, Communications and Executive Director, SpartanNash Foundation Arif Dar Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer Jason Monaco Executive
Slide 11: Performance Improvements Are Generating Sustainable Shareholder Value
Performance Improvements Are Generating Sustainable Shareholder Value 9
Slide 12: New Management Team Successfully Executing Turnaround
New Management Team Successfully Executing Turnaround… • The Board has attracted a strong management team that is advancing the Company’s transformation • Our management team brings key skills and qualities : • Deep experience in consumer, retail, and distribution sectors • Diversity : 5 out of 11 s
Slide 13: And Driving Meaningful Improvements in KPIs
... And Driving Meaningful Improvements in KPI’s * See the Appendix for reconciliations of non - GAAP measures to their most directly comparable GAAP measures. Note: All metrics as compared to prior to Tony Sarsam joining as CEO and as of Q1 2022. (1) Preliminary results for Q1 2022. +301bps Q1 2022
Slide 14: 2021 Performance Demonstrates Our Plan is Delivering Results
2021 Performance Demonstrates Our Plan is Delivering Results... $8.9bn 2021 Net Sales $214mm 2021 Adj. EBITDA* 2.3% FY’19 – FY’21 Net Sales CAGR +12.7% FY’21 Retail Comparable Store Sales vs. FY’19 $161mm FY’21 Net Cash from Operations 1.8x FY’21 Net Long - Term Debt to Adj. EBITDA* vs. 3.7x in FY’1
Slide 15: And Wall Street Believes in Our Plan
… And Wall Street Believes in Our Plan (1) Target stock price data calculated as average analyst target price through March 17, 2022 (last trading date before Investor Group’s public campaign). Mar - 19 Sep - 19 Mar - 20 Sep - 20 Mar - 21 Sep - 21 Mar - 22 Average Analyst Target Price $26.80 $17.70
Slide 16: Strong Q1 2022 Results
Strong Q1 2022 Results Driven By: Supply chain transformation including: • Securing $15mm+ in run - rate cost savings and meeting initial full - year commitment of $15mm - $30mm of annualized savings during the first quarter • Delivering an impressive ~7% improvement in throughput rate YoY Building
Slide 17: Total Shareholder Return (TSR) Outperformance
Total Shareholder Return (TSR) Outperformance Note: TSR Data as of March 17, 2022 (last trading date before Investor Group’s public campaign). (1) Represents the median of SPTN Performance Peers, wh ich include: ACI, KR, IMKTA, WMK, SFM, and UNFI. A peer comparison slide is included in the Appendix.
Slide 18: The Board Has Allocated Capital in a Disciplined, Balanced and Prudent Way
37% 15% 48% ~$650mm+ Capital invested and returned to shareholders FY19 – FY21 CapEx and IT Capital Debt Repayment Dividend & Share Repurchase The Board Has Allocated Capital in a Disciplined, Balanced and Prudent Way Source: Historical Company filings. * See the Appendix for reco nciliations of non
Slide 19: Long-Term Strategy Provides Clear Path for Future Growth
Long - Term Strategy Provides Clear Path for Future Growth 17
Slide 20: Delivering on Our Strategic Priorities
Delivering on Our Strategic Priorities Create a People First Culture to Make Us the Employer of Choice 1 Deliver on the Promise to Transform the Supply Chain 2 Act on Insights to Optimize Product Portfolios 4 Launch Customer - Centric Innovative Solutions 5 Elevate Execution to Win the Day 3 Executi
Slide 21: Investing in Our People to Become the Employer of Choice
Investing in Our People to Become the Employer of Choice Executing Turnaround 2020 - 2022 Our Deliberate Actions Have Had a Measurable Impact Extensive Front - Line Training Increased Associate Pay Supervisor Training / Manager Development Implemented Targeting Recruiting Programs Redesigned Benefit
Slide 22: Meaningful Improvements to Gross Margin
• Consumer Based Pricing • Promotion Effectiveness • Enhanced Assortment • Focus on Fresh and Local Initiatives Have Driven Meaningful Improvements to Gross Margin +206bps Gross Margin Expansion from 2019 to Q1 2022 (1) • Price Optimization • Shift Towards Fresh and Value Add • Military Segment Marg
Slide 23: Delivering Promise to Transform Supply Chain
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. Delivering Promise to Transform Supply Chain Executing Turnaround 2020 - 2022 Note: All improvements as of Q1 2022. (1) Network optimization improvements since 2020. (2) Total includes Coastal Pacific Foods DC facility partnership (3) End o
Slide 24: Strategy to Deliver Long-Term Growth: 2025 Outlook
Strategy to Deliver Long - Term Growth 2025 Outlook $10bn+ Net Sales 12% growth from 2021 at 3% CAGR $300mm+ Adj. EBITDA 40% increase from 2021 at 9% CAGR* 3% Adj. EBITDA Margin 25% increase from 2021* Driving Growth Strategy 2022 and Beyond 1 $1bn sales growth from share gains and continued expansi
Slide 25: Growing Our Topline Revenue to $10bn+ by 2025
Growing Our Topline Revenue to $10bn+ by 2025 SpartanNash sees opportunity to grow Net Sales through two major initiatives Driving Growth Strategy 2022 and Beyond Expansion into Value Added Offerings Customer Share Gains Step Change in Sales Growth from New National and Independents Customers $1bn 2
Slide 26: Expanding Our Adj. EBITDA to $300mm+ by 2025
Driving Growth Strategy 2022 and Beyond Expanding Our Adj. EBITDA to $300mm+ by 2025 Deliver on Insights for Richer Retail Experience Capitalize on Best - in - Class People and Operational Excellence Capabilities Continue to invest in front line associates to improve acquisition and retention Increa
Slide 27: Capacity to Execute and Integrate M&A
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. Capacity to Execute and Integrate M&A History and Preparation for Next Phase of Inorganic Growth Driving Growth Strategy 2022 and Beyond Retail Bolt - Ons Wholesale Geographic Expansion Strategic Fit Standalone Attractiveness M&A Criteria V
Slide 28: Our Board Has Taken Decisive Action to Create Shareholder Value
Our Board Has Taken Decisive Action to Create Shareholder Value 26
Slide 29: Board with Highly Relevant Skills and Experience
We Have Assembled a Board with Highly Relevant Skills and Experience Board appointee in 2022 Douglas A. Hacker Independent Director, Board Chair Former CFO and EVP of Strategy for United Airlines; President of UAL Loyalty Services Joined boards of Columbia Seligman Premium Technology Growth Fund
Slide 30: Executing Ongoing Board Refreshment
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. Executing Ongoing Board Refreshment In 2018, SpartanNash resumed a board refreshment process. This refreshment process continues to be a priority today with three new independent directors added in February 2022. (1) Mr. Tanner passed away
Slide 31: Actively Refreshed the Board to Meet Changing Dynamics
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. Douglas Hacker Independent Chair Tony Sarsam President, CEO, Director Shan Atkins Independent Director Matthew Mannelly Independent Director Julien Mininberg Independent Director Jaymin Patel Independent Director Hawthorne Proctor Independe
Slide 32: Creating an Effective Board with the Right Mix of Expertise
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. Creating an Effective Board with the Right Mix of Expertise Our Board has diverse skillsets that complement our long - term food solutions focused strategy Other Key Points Our Board also has valuable experience in both military logistics a
Slide 33: Macellum and Ancora Are Targeting the Directors Who Led Positive Changes
Macellum and Ancora Are Targeting the 3 Directors Who Have Led Positive Changes at SpartanNash ▪ As Chairman, Mr. Hacker has led the Company’s Board through comprehensive transformation, as well as overseen SpartanNash through successful executive leadership upgrades ▪ Extensive public company leade
Slide 34: Directors Have a History of Maximizing Shareholder Value through M&A
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. SpartanNash’s Directors Have a History of Maximizing Shareholder Value through M&A SpartanNash is at risk of losing Board members with extensive M&A acumen $4.7bn Patel $4.4bn Hacker $7.4bn Hacker $11.4bn Atkins $0.4bn Voss $1.6bn Hacker $1
Slide 35: Governance Overview
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. Governance Overview Separation of Chair and CEO Roles 8 of 9 Independent Directors 5 Directors Joined in Past 5 Years 44% Diverse Directors (1) Presents the approximate average tenure for all director nominees as of April 1, 2022 measured s
Slide 36: Core Capabilities Aligned with ESG Priorities and UN SDGs
Our Core Capabilities Are Aligned with Our ESG Priorities and the UN Sustainability Development Goals SpartanNash published its inaugural ESG Report in March 2022, building on prior CSR reporting SpartanNash ESG Priorities UN SDG Goals Key Accomplishments 2021 to Present We keep Associates healthy a
Slide 37: Executive Compensation Program Designed to Align Pay with Performance
117% 80% 65% 46% 66% 144% 110% 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Executive Compensation Program Designed to Align Pay with Performance When performance is low, executive compensation follows Shareholders provided robust support of executive compensation program and stock incentive plan 95.8% Suppor
Slide 38: Macellum and Ancora Have Prioritized Short-Term Gains
Macellum and Ancora Have Prioritized Short - Term Gains Over Sustainable, Long - Term Value Creation for All Shareholders 36
Slide 39: Do Macellum and Ancora Have SpartanNash's Best Interest in Mind?
We believe Macellum and Ancora’s demands are self - interested and not in the best interest of all shareholders Do Macellum and Ancora Have SpartanNash’s Best Interest in Mind? (1) Reflects TSR as of April 29, 2022 from respective nominee board exit. Big Lots serves as a cautionary tale on Macellum
Slide 40: A Large Sale-Leaseback Would Have a Materially Negative Financial Impact
A Large Sale - Leaseback Would Have a Materially Negative Financial Impact on SpartanNash * See the Appendix for reconciliations of non - GAAP measures to their most directly comparable GAAP measures. Source: ISS Report, Public Filings, Macellum March 18, 2022 Letter to SPTN, FactSet and Bloomberg a
Slide 41: Macellum's Director Appointees Have Destroyed Shareholder Value
Macellum’s Director Appointees Have Destroyed Shareholder Value Macellum directors have led to declines in shareholder value and negative TSRs in past investments * Indicates campaigns that were jointly run by Macellum and Ancora * * Relative TSR Since Director Appointment vs S&P Retail (93%) (1) (6
Slide 42: Does Ancora Have the Time to Focus on SpartanNash?
Does Ancora Have the Time to Focus on SpartanNash? Source: FactSet as of May 1, 2022. Ancora has launched 9 activism campaigns in the 2022 proxy season Ancora has NEVER reached out to or spoken with SpartanNash Notably, SpartanNash was not aware Ancora was involved in this campaign until their name
Slide 43: Our Nominees Have Superior Skills and Experience
Our Nominees Have Superior Skills and Experience to Those Proposed by Macellum and Ancora Dissident Nominee versus SpartanNash Nominee Skills Matrix Business Operations And Leadership Food or Consumer Product Industry Sales and Marketing Supply Chain / Logistics Strategic Transaction / M&A Financial
Slide 44: SpartanNash Would Lose Integral Board Expertise and Diversity
Fleming had “a rocky track record, including a failed attempt to take the Wal - Mart brand upscale in 2005.” (2) SpartanNash Would Lose Integral Board Expertise and Diversity if Macellum and Ancora’s Nominees are Elected Jonathan Duskin Nominee Qualification Concerns SpartanNash’s Considerations Joh
Slide 45: Macellum Prioritized a Proxy Contest; Ancora Never Contacted Us
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. Macellum Prioritized a Proxy Contest, and Ancora Never Contacted the Management Team or Board We Have Taken Every Possible Action to Engage with Macellum and Ancora Constructively… We spoke with Macellum 4 times through calls or meetings be
Slide 46: Setting the Record Straight
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. Setting the Record Straight Macellum and Ancora’s Myths Facts No strategy ▪ As discussed in prior earnings calls, going into 2022, SpartanNash has a new corporate identity that sets a strategic direction for growth and stewardship Sale - Le
Slide 47: SpartanNash's Board is Committed to Shareholder Value Creation
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. SpartanNash’s Board is Committed to Shareholder Value Creation ▪ Turnaround is Generating Performance Momentum and Driving Shareholder Value ▪ Long - Term Strategy Provides Clear Path for Growth for 2022 and Beyond ▪ Highly Engaged and Refr
Slide 48: Appendix
Appendix 46
Slide 49: A Refreshed Board with Strong, Experienced Directors
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. A Refreshed Board with Strong, Experienced Directors Mr. Hacker serves as the Board Chair of SpartanNash, where he has led the Board as it has gone through comprehensive transformation and oversaw the Company through extensive executive lea
Slide 50: A Refreshed Board with Strong, Experienced Directors
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. A Refreshed Board with Strong, Experienced Directors Mr. Mannelly bring 36 years of extensive marketing, sales, retail and consumer goods experience, including ten years of food distribution experience ▪ Mannelly is the former CEO of Presti
Slide 51: A Refreshed Board with Strong, Experienced Directors
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. A Refreshed Board with Strong, Experienced Directors Maj. Gen. (Ret.) Proctor brings over 30 years in food distribution and more than 15 years in retail and consumer goods ▪ Proctor currently serves as Managing Partner of Proctor & Boone LL
Slide 52: Performance Peer Set Evaluation and Selection
© Copyright 2022 SpartanNash. Proprietary and Confidential. Performance Peer Set Evaluation and Selection (1) As set forth in the Investor Group Definitive Proxy Statement, filed on April 19, 2022. Macellum's Peer Groupings 2021 ISS Peers Retail Food Dist. Overall x x x x x x x x x x Company Sector
Slide 53: Grocery Distributors and Retailers Are Our Most Relevant Peers
Grocery Distributors and Retailers Are Our Most Relevant Peers 1 2 3 We operate grocery distribution and grocery retail businesses, and therefore consider grocery distributors and grocery retailers as our Operational Peers – and most relevant when benchmarking operational and share price performance
Slide 54: Adj. EBITDA, Adj. EBITDAR and Adj. EBITDA Margin 2017–2021
Adj. EBITDA, Adj. EBITDAR and Adj. EBITDA Margin 2017 – 2021 Note: The Company is unable to provide a full reconciliation of the GAAP to non - GAAP measures used in the fiscal 2022 outlook and long - term targets disclosed in this presentation without unreasonable effort because it is not possible t
Slide 55: Net Long Term Debt and Net Long Term Debt to Adj. EBITDA
Net Long Term Debt and Net Long Term Debt to Adj. EBITDA 2017 - 2022 Net Long - Term Debt to Adjusted EBITDA (2017 - 2021) (In thousands) Net long - term debt $ 395,058 $ 466,541 $ 664,381 $ 679,475 $ 734,284 Adjusted EBITDA 213,706 239,059 177,945 209,421 236,002 Net long - term debt to adjusted EB
Slide 56: IT Capital 2020-2021
IT Capital 2020 - 2021 54 IT Capital (2020 - 2021) (In thousands) Purchases of property and equipment $ 79,427 $ 67,298 Plus: Cloud computing spend 6,364 11,634 Capital expenditures and IT capital $ 85,791 $ 78,932 2021 (52 Weeks) 2020 (53 Weeks)
Slide 57: Q1 2021 Adj. EBITDA and Q1 2022 Adj. EBITDA Range
Q1 2021 Adj. EBITDA and Q1 2022 Adj. EBITDA Range (In thousands) Net earnings $ 18,706 $ 19,656 $ 19,516 Income tax expense 4,800 5,100 6,356 16 Weeks Ended April 23, 2022 April 24, 2021 Low High Actual Other expenses, net 3,950 4,000 4,323 Operating earnings 27,456 28,756 30,195 Adjustments: LIFO e
Slide 58: Q1 2022 Military Segment Adj. EBITDA Margin Range
Q1 2022 Military Segment Adj. EBITDA Margin Range 56 16 Weeks Ended April 23, 2022 (In thousands) Low High Military: Operating earnings $ 1,305 $ 1,530 Adjustments: LIFO expense 2,540 2,555 Depreciation and amortization 4,190 4,205 Cloud computing amortization 95 100 Organizational realignment, net