Benihana — Proxy Contest (September 2010)
25 slides from Benihana's proxy contest presentation, Sep 14, 2010
Slide 1: Presentation to RiskMetrics
Presentation to RiskMetrics September 14, 2010 Alan B. Levan Richard C. Stockinger Lewis Jaffe
Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements
Forward-LookingStatements Except for the historical matters contained herein, statements in this press release are forward-looking and are made pursuant to the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Investors are cautioned that forward-looking statements invo
Slide 3: Company overview
Company overview • NASDAQ GS: BNHN and BNHNA • Founder Rocky Aoki introduced Japanese FY2010 food to America in 1965 • Now,leadingoperatorofJapanese theme and sushi restaurants • Famous for entertaining chefs who present and prepare delicious Teppanyaki entrees at hibachi tables, as well as sushi an
Slide 4: Current board and management creating shareholder value
Currentboardandmanagementcreating shareholdervalue • Took right steps to turn company around • RenewalProgramisworking • Launched process to explore strategic alternatives, including potential sale • Responsivetoinvestors Counterproductive to jeopardize progress at critical point in process 4
Slide 5: Benihana legacy business
Benihanalegacybusiness • State of the business in 2008 with respect to: – P&Lresponsibility – Consistency – Economies of scale – Sales – Guestcount – Overtimehours – Corporate overhead – New unit expansion 5
Slide 6: Board willing to take decisive action
Board willing to take decisive action • In 2008, Board acted to improve performance • Removed prior management team • Recruited experienced, proven team – Led by CEO Richard Stockinger • At Board’s direction, new team designed, launched and implemented comprehensive Renewal Plan – Advised by leading
Slide 7: Overhaul of management team
Overhaul of management team • RICHARD C. STOCKINGER, President and Chief Executive Officer Mr. Stockinger previously served as the President of Patina Restaurant Group (formerly Restaurant Associates –Patina Group) from October 2003 through April 2008 and served as Restaurant Associates’ Vice Presid
Slide 8: Third party support for Renewal Program
3 rd party support for Renewa lProgram • “The Renewal Plan is a comprehensive management action plan introduced by the new CEO to address the myriad operational deficiencies of Benihana and its corporate functions. ” – CRG Partners, January 2010 Interim Report to Benihana • “We believe the food and
Slide 9: Renewal Program
Renewal Program • Turnaround of an iconic brand during the most challenging macro-environment ever for restaurant industry • Return to high standards of founder Rocky Aoki • Comprehensive in scope: rebuilding every function of company and restaurant operations from inside-out • Guest-centric: accomp
Slide 10: Renewal Program: Objectives
Renewal Program: Objectives • To improve: – Operational accountability – Guest experience – Food quality, consistency, and creativity – Financial controls • Shift business from a collection of units to a true restaurant chain to drive shareholder value 10
Slide 11: Renewal Program: Operational accountability
Renewal Program: Operational accountability • Revamped senior management team – Appointed Chris Ames COO – Created direct lines of accountability for operations to Richard and Chris • Incentivized operational management – Created regional management – Created general manager position • Overhauled hu
Slide 12: Renewal Program: Guest experience
Renewal Program: Guest experience • Updated and repaired facilities – Retail Eyes (mystery shopping service) and Ever clean (health & sanitation) scores much improved • Retrained staff in cooking techniques, service standards • Ensured consistency and superiority of experience across locations • Rei
Slide 13: Renewal Program: Guest experience (cont.)
Renewal Program: Guest experience(cont.) Mystery Shopper Improvement 13 Source: Retail Eyes
Slide 14: Renewal Program: Food quality, consistency, creativity
Renewal Program: Food quality, consistency, creativity • Raised quality of products and ingredients – Reintroduction of higher quality beef, shellfish, desserts, etc. – Guest satisfaction • Enhanced beverage program • Financed menu upgrades by centralizing purchasing to gain economies of scale 14
Slide 15: Renewal Program: Financial controls
Renewal Program: Financial controls • Corporate level – Reduced corporate overhead – Outsourced accounting & finance function • Restaurant level – Used scale more effectively to gain purchasing leverage – Instituted P& L responsibility for GMs – Implemented POS system – Implemented labor management
Slide 16: Results: Improving performance already
Results: Improving performance already • Higher revenue and total guest count, trending upwardsoverlastyear Source: Benihana Inc. 16
Slide 17: Results: Improving performance already (cont.)
Results: Improving performance already (cont.) • Dramatic reduction in overtime hours Overtime Hours - 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 Teppan * 43,091 35,844 22,556 15,016 36,296 21,555 27,115 22,371 17,668 22,671 22,389 19,723 19,012 RA 7,221 5,515 5,911 5,181 5,527 5,388 5,641 6,561 6,70
Slide 18: Results: Improved performance against peers
Results: Improved performance against peers • Consistent ou t performance of brand against peers Q1 FY10 Q2 FY10 Q3 FY10 Q4 FY10 Q1 FY11 18 Source: Benihana Inc. and Jefferies
Slide 19: Results: Improved performance for shareholders
Results: Improved performance for shareholders 69.9%ReturnYTD (through 9/13/10) 19 Source: Thomson Reuters
Slide 20: Next steps underway
Next steps underway • Company now well-positioned to deliver sustainable profitable growth • To build on momentum, over next several months: – Extend purchasing consolidation efforts to sushi and beverages – Explore ways to extend Teppan and RA experiences into different day- parts – Continue to bui
Slide 21: Strategic process to maximize value for shareholders
Strategic process to maximize value for shareholders • Board committed to exploring all alternatives, including potential sale • Continuing to pursue organic growth strategy 21
Slide 22: Track record of responsiveness to investors
Track record of responsiveness to investors • Strategic process is one of many examples, including: – Adding new directors with outside perspectives • Lewis Jaffe, first elected in 2004 as a nominee of BOT • Adam Gray of Coliseum • Extensive attempts to reach agreement with BOT • Following last Risk
Slide 23: Shareholders cannot afford the disruption BOT seems intent on pursuing
Benihana shareholders cannot afford the disruption that BOT seems intent on pursuing • BOT has chosen a proxy contest despite: – the Board’s actions to overhaul management and launch successful Renewal Program – the Board’s responsible process and decisions regarding capital and strategic alternativ
Slide 24: Director nominees
Director nominees • RICHARD C. STOCKINGER --President and Chief Executive Officer, Benihana. Extensive Restaurant management experience prior to appointment at Benihaha. • LEWISJAFFE– Consultant with clients including LG Electronics, Famous Dave’s BBQ Restaurants and Johnny Carino’s Italian Restaura
Slide 25: Conclusion
Conclusion • Board and Management have clear track record of doing right thing for Benihana shareholders • Renewal Program is working, and we believe our performance will continue to improve and accelerate as guests return to Benihana • Strategic process offers alternative avenues for maximizing sha