Comerica — Q4 2023 Earnings Presentation
24 slides from Comerica's earnings presentation, Dec 5, 2023
Slide 1: Fourth Quarter 2023 Financial Review
Comerica Incorporated Fourth Quarter 2023 Financial Review January 19, 2024 Safe Harbor Statement Any statements in this presentation that are not historical facts are forward-looking statements as defined in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Words such as “anticipate, assume, be
Slide 2: 2023 Review and FY23 Results
2023 Review Advanced our corporate priorities while navigating industry disruption Significant Achievements Awards & Recognition 9 Record average loan balances & net • 2023 Impact Award Winner from interest income Datos Insights in Product Development 9 Outstanding rating for CRA exam for Maximize P
Slide 3: Notable 4Q23 Items and 4Q23 Results
Notable 4Q23 Items Subject1 4Q23 Accounting Impact 4Q23 EPS Impact (pre-tax) (net of tax) FDIC special assessment +$109MM noninterest expense ($0.62) -$91MM other noninterest income +$3MM net interest income Impact of BSBY cessation announcement ($0.52) =$88MM net non-cash, pre-tax impact Note: The
Slide 4: Loans and Deposits
Loans Strategic optimization efforts prioritized relationships; positioned for enhanced returns & growth Loans Average loans decreased $1.2B1, or 2.2% ($ in billions) - $543MM Mortgage Banker (strategic exit) - $433MM General Middle Market 55.4 54.0 - $361MM Equity Fund Services 52.4 53.5 52.8 53.4
Slide 5: Liquidity and Securities Portfolio
Liquidity Enabled wholesale funding repayments; maintain significant capacity Source (12/31/23) Amount or Total Remaining Loan to Deposit Ratio Below Historical Average $ in billions Capacity Capacity (period-end) Cash 7.9 7.9 130% 0% 120% FHLB (securities & loan collateral) 17.1 9.5 110% 100% BTFP1
Slide 6: Net Interest Income and Interest Rate Sensitivity
Net Interest Income Remained effectively rate neutral; NIM benefited from wholesale funding repayments Net Interest Income $601MM 3Q23 2.84% ($ in millions) - 13MM Loans - 0.02 742 708 - 22MM Lower balances - 0.07 + 6MM Higher rates, incl. swaps + 0.04 621 601 + 3MM BSBY Cessation + 0.01 584 - 1MM S
Slide 7: Credit Quality and Noninterest Income
Credit Quality Modest net charge-offs below historical levels; migration remains manageable Net Charge-Offs (Recoveries) Criticized Loans1 Below Historical Level ($ in millions) ($ in millions) 2,290 2,405 12.00 20 12.00 1,918 2,048 10.00 10.00 1,572 8.00 6 8.00 6.00 4.3 4.6 3.5 3.7 6.00 4.00 4.00 2
Slide 8: Noninterest Expenses and Expense Re-Calibration
Noninterest Expenses Actions expected to enhance earnings power & drive efficiency Increased $163MM Noninterest Expenses1,2 ($ in millions) + $113MM FDIC insurance (includes special assessment, $109MM) 718 + $44MM salaries & benefits (includes Ameriprise, -$2MM) + $23MM severance costs (includes exp
Slide 9: Capital Management and Outlook
Capital Management Maintained capital position above target CET1 of ~10%1 CET12 Tier 12 Accumulated Other Comprehensive Estimated Change in AOCI Derived Income3 Simulated Sensitivity Analysis for 10.80% 11.09% 11.61% ($ in billions) Projected1 Securities & Swap Portfolios 11.30% (1.7) (1.5) Est. AOC
Slide 10: Our Differentiated Value Proposition
Our Differentiated Value Proposition A Leading Bank for Business complemented by strong Retail & Wealth Management Distinctive Commercial Complementary fee & Robust, low-cost Efficient technology & Franchise relationship products deposit base operations Long-standing, trust- Distinctive Treasury Dee
Slide 11: The Right Balance and Diversified Businesses
The Right Balance Positioned to effectively meet the unique needs of our target customers Full suite of products & services Tailored solutions & including credit capacity, treasury customized product offerings management, & capital market to meet our customers needs solutions Experienced & tenured L
Slide 12: Diversified Geographic Footprint
Diversified Geographic Footprint Predominance of middle market companies Large, higher growth urban markets Highly integrated, cost-effective platform & wealth management opportunities Texas Offices Across U.S. Southeast • Established: 1988 Primary Markets Other Markets Office Locations • Strong pop
Slide 13: Full Year and Quarterly Average Loans
Full Year Average Loans Business Line 2023 2022 By Market 2023 2022 Middle Market Michigan $12.3 $12.0 General $12.6 $12.7 California 18.7 17.7 Energy 1.5 1.4 Texas 12.3 10.2 National Dealer Services 5.8 4.6 Entertainment 1.2 1.1 Other Markets1 10.6 10.6 Tech. & Life Sciences 0.9 0.9 TOTAL $53.9 $50
Slide 14: Full Year and Quarterly Average Deposits
Full Year Average Deposits Business Line 2023 2022 By Market 2023 2022 Middle Market Michigan $22.9 $26.6 General $17.0 $20.4 California 16.8 22.5 Energy 0.6 1.0 1.0 1.5 Texas 9.8 11.5 National Dealer Services Entertainment 0.3 0.3 Other Markets2 12.0 14.1 Tech. & Life Sciences 3.6 6.5 Finance / Oth
Slide 15: Attractive Deposit Profile and SNC Relationships
Attractive Deposit Profile Further enhanced our strong deposit franchise Stronger Profile than Pre-Pandemic ($ in billions) YE 2019 YE 2022 12/31/2023 Deposit portfolio has better risk characteristics Loan-to-Deposit Ratio 88% 75% 78% • Less concentrated in more vulnerable businesses • Lower price s
Slide 16: The Retail Bank and Commercial Real Estate Business
The Retail Bank: More than a Leading Bank for Business Banking Personal and Small Business customers in growth markets across the US 18% 37% of Bank’s Total Deposits Small Business Customers Aspirational Target for Small Business: Alternative Channels: Top 10 market share in all major markets; curre
Slide 17: Total Office Portfolio and Multi-family Portfolio
Total Office Portfolio Not a primary strategy Geographic Diversification By State Key Office Portfolio Metrics $ millions 12/31/23 $ millions 12/31/23 9/30/23 California $393.5 Total Loans $823.7 $824.9 Texas 236.8 Washington 39.7 Avg Loan Outstanding $5.6 $5.6 Michigan 37.9 Arizona 32.4 Net Charge
Slide 18: Energy and National Dealer Services
Energy Primarily E&P exposure Period-end Loans ($ in millions) • Exposure $3.3B / 42% utilization 1,480 • Hedged 50% or more of production 1,415 1,402 1,437 1,382 • At least one year: 60% of customers 312 • At least two years: 34% of customers 253 276 310 312 • Focus on larger, sophisticated E&P and
Slide 19: Technology & Life Sciences and Equity Fund Services
Technology & Life Sciences ~30 years of deep expertise & strong relationships with top-tier investors Average Loans Average Deposits Stable since mid-May ($ in millions) ($ in millions) 943 931 909 6,000 5,241 832 791 5,000 4,443 4,000 3,408 3,281 3,312 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 4Q22 1Q23 2Q23 3Q23 4Q23 4
Slide 20: Environmental Services Department and Direct Express
Environmental Services Department Experienced team; Specialized industry, committed to growth • 15+ year experienced team with 20+ year management tenure Average Loans ($ in millions) • Dedicated relationship managers advise & guide customers on profitably growing their business by providing banking
Slide 21: Core Values and Descriptions of Notable Items
Comerica’s Core Values To raise expectations of what a bank can be for our colleagues, customers & communities Trust Act Own ©2024, Comerica Inc. All rights reserved. 41 Descriptions of Notable Items Subject Description • CMA recorded expense related to the FDIC’s Deposit Insurance Fund (DIF) specia
Slide 22: Details for Outlook and Reconciliations
Details for Outlook Financial Metric Full Year 2023 + / - Adjustments Identified on Outlook Slide • +$91MM non-cash BSBY cessation loss Noninterest Income • -$23MM full-year salaries & commissions for Ameriprise partnership prior to presentation impact • -$109MM special one-time FDIC assessment Noni
Slide 23: Reconciliations Continued and Holding Company Debt Rating
Reconciliations Continued Uninsured Deposits Comerica believes that the presentation of uninsured deposits adjusted for the impact of affiliate deposits provides enhanced clarity of uninsured deposits at risk. Total uninsured deposits as calculated per regulatory guidance and reported on schedule RC
Slide 24: Bank Debt Rating
Bank Debt Rating Senior Unsecured/Long-Term Issuer Rating Moody’s S&P Fitch Cullen Frost A3 A - Fifth Third A3 A- A- Huntington A3 A- A- M&T Bank Baa1 A- A BOK Financial Baa1 A- A Regions Financial Baa1 A- A- Citizens Financial Group Baa1 A- BBB+ Comerica Baa1 BBB+ A- KeyCorp Baa1 BBB+ BBB+ Webster