Intact Financial Corporation · TSX:IFC
Intact Financial — Investor Day (April 2006)
67 slides from Intact Financial's investor day presentation, Apr 11, 2006
Slide 1: Analyst Meeting
Analyst Meeting April 11, 2006 p. 1
Slide 2: Agenda
Agenda 9:30 a.m. Introduction / Opening Remarks Charles Brindamour 9:40 a.m. Financial and Capital Management Mark Tullis 10:35 a.m. Investment Management Marc Provost 11:30 a.m. Close Brian Lynch p. 2
Slide 3: Forward-Looking Statement Disclaimer
Forward-Looking Statement Disclaimer Certain of the statements contained in this presentation about our current and future plans, expectations and intentions, results, levels of activity, performance, goals or achievements or any other future events or developments constitute forward looking stateme
Slide 4: Introduction / Opening Remarks
Introduction / Opening Remarks Charles Brindamour, Executive Vice President p. 4
Slide 5: Our Goal
Our Goal • To create a sustainable, superior performance gap, as measured by return on equity, relative to the Canadian property and casualty industry of not less than 500 basis points consistently over time. • Outperform the industry’s growth over time both through organic growth and acquisitions.
Slide 6: Our Strategy
Our Strategy • We will outperform the industry’s ROE over time by at least 500 basis points by: – Leveraging our scale and actuarial strength in pricing and underwriting – Leveraging our scale in claims and efficiency – Superior capital and investment management • We will profitably grow our market
Slide 7: Outperformance To Date
Outperformance To Date ROE Performance of our Insurance Subsidiaries Compared to Canadian P&C Insurance Industry 40% Our OurROE ROE performance performance 11-year avg. has hasexceeded exceeded = 17.4% 30% Canadian Canadianindustry industry by 750 bps by 750 bps on Canadian Industry 20% onaverage av
Slide 8: ING Versus the Industry in 2005
ING Versus the Industry in 2005 • ING Canada’s ROE of 31.6% in 2005 represented a positive performance gap of 1,360 basis points vs. an industry ROE of 18.0%. • The following factors drive the performance gap: – Insurance fundamentals: + 7 ROE points – Capital and Investment Management: + 6 ROE poin
Slide 9: Questions?
Questions? ING 4
Slide 10: Financial and Capital Management
Financial and Capital Management Mark Tullis, Chief Financial Officer p. 10
Slide 11: Mark Tullis
Mark Tullis • Actuary by background • 29 years financial services experience – 6 years with ING Group • On boards of ING Canada or legal entities since 2000 • Stint as CFO of ING’s US operations • Experience in major acquisitions (Seguros Comercial America, ReliaStar, Aetna Financial Services) – Res
Slide 12: ING Canada Has a History of Outperforming the Industry
ING Canada Has a History of Outperforming the Industry (%) ING Canada Combined Ratio vs. Industry ING Canada Premium Growth1) vs. Industry 115 110 400% 10-year CAGR ING Canada’s 105 ING Canada’s premium growth = 13.5% 300% premium growth Industry 1) was 9.2% was 9.2% 100 Outperformed in 2005 Outperf
Slide 13: ING Canada Has a History of Outperforming the Industry
ING Canada Has a History of Outperforming the Industry Performance has been driven by a culture of underwriting discipline and claims expertise, as well as successful acquisition and business integration history p. 13
Slide 14: Financial Focus Will Be to Continue to Improve on Winning Formula
Financial Focus Will Be to Continue to Improve on Winning Formula • Capital management • Strategic support • Continue to build on strength in financial management p. 14
Slide 15: ING Canada Has a Culture of Strong Capital Management
ING Canada Has a Culture of Strong Capital Management • Focus on ROE – goal to outperform industry – Pricing – Management compensation • Alternative management metrics (ROEC, Economic Capital) • Integration of ROE/capital needs with operations (ie, investment decisions) • Participation agreement p.
Slide 16: Continuing Focus on Capital Management
Continuing Focus on Capital Management • Excess capital position – Excess capital at insurance companies of $445 million (at 175% MCT) – $590 million investments at holding company – Short term/long term implications of high capital level • Effective management of required capital • Short term deplo
Slide 17: Required Capital Driven by Multiple Factors
Required Capital Driven by Multiple Factors • Rating agencies have proprietary required capital formulas – They also consider regulatory capital requirements to one degree or another • Regulatory capital is defined by Minimum Capital Test (MCT) for Canadian P&C companies (not holdco) – Formula based
Slide 18: Strategic Support Will Continue as a Central Focus
Strategic Support Will Continue as a Central Focus Approximate Size of Acquisition Year of (DPW) 1) Acquisition Acquisition ($ millions) Allianz Canada (Personal and Small to Medium • M&A has been Commercial Lines) 2004 600 historical focus of Zurich (Personal and Small Commercial Lines) 2001 510 Pa
Slide 19: Continued Focus on Strong Financial Management
Continued Focus on Strong Financial Management • Excellent record of disclosure, public reporting • Continued focus on basic building blocks of Financial Management – Treasury – Financial reporting – Expense management p. 19
Slide 20: ING Canada Will Continue Its Track Record of Strong Financial and Capital Management
ING Canada Will Continue Its Track Record of Strong Financial and Capital Management • Strong balance sheet • Conservative positions • Business discipline – Market strategy – Pricing – Underwriting • Capital Management • Emphasis on continual improvement We compare ourselves not just to Canadian P&C
Slide 21: Questions?
Questions? p. 21
Slide 22: Investment Management
Investment Management Marc Provost, Senior Vice President, Managing Director and Chief Investment Officer, ING Investment Management p. 22
Slide 23: Index
Index Organization Chart - ING Investment Management, Inc. Asset Mix Policy Investment Constraints Asset Mix Asset Quality Sectors Bonds Commercial Mortgages Dividend Roll Over Common Stock Equity Market Neutral Preferred Shares Returns Use of Derivatives Impairments p. 23
Slide 24: ING Investment Management, Inc. Organization Chart
ING Investment Management, Inc. Organization Chart MARC PROVOST Senior VP, Managing Director, and CIO Canadian Operations MANON GUINDON CLAUDINE RICHER Executive Assistant Executive Assistant BRANDON BLANT KÉVORK KOKMANIAN OPEN POSITION Director Director, Compliance and Director, Asset Allocation an
Slide 25: Asset Mix Policy
Asset Mix Policy - Reviewed annually by ING Canada's investment committee. - Policy development done in two stages: - create Minimum Risk Portfolio (MRP) --- MRP is a passive portfolio that minimizes risk as measured by safety of capital - MRP is a high quality diversified bond index (Scotia Short T
Slide 26: Policy Value Added (Passive) Versus MRP December 31, 2005
Policy Value Added (Passive) Versus MRP December 31, 2005 ANNUALIZED RATES OF RETURN - As of 12/31/05 TARGET PORTFOLIO MRP Passive Value Added Before Tax After Tax Before Tax After Tax After Tax 1 YEAR 8.86% 6.43% 2.37% 1.56% 4.87% 3 YEARS 9.45% 6.99% 4.18% 2.75% 4.24% 5 YEARS 7.98% 5.94% 5.49% 3.47
Slide 27: Active Management Policy Value Added December 31, 2005
Active Management Policy Value Added December 31, 2005 ANNUALIZED RATES OF RETURN - As of 12/31/05 ACTIVE ING CANADA PORTFOLIO TARGET PORTFOLIO VALUE ADDED Before Tax After Tax Before Tax After Tax After Tax 1 YEAR 9.29% 6.80% 8.46% 6.43% 0.37% 3 YEARS 10.05% 7.48% 9.45% 6.99% 0.49% 5 YEARS 8.37% 6.
Slide 28: Combined (Passive and Active) Annualized After-Tax Value Added
Combined (Passive and Active) Annualized After-Tax Value Added As of December 31, 2005 From Active From Policy Total Management 1 Year 4.87 % 0.29 % 5.16 % 3 Years 4.25 % 0.45 % 4.70 % 5 Years 2.46 % 0.36 % 2.82 % 7 Years 2.35 % 0.40 % 2.77 % 10 Years 2.29 % 0.26 % 2.55 % p. 28
Slide 29: Significant Investment Constraints By Asset Sector
Significant Investment Constraints By Asset Sector FIXED INCOME ¾ Duration must remain within +/- one year of the benchmark duration. ¾ Maximum corporate issuer exposure: limited to <= “AAA” 5%, “AA-” to “AA+” 5%, “A-” to “A+” 3%, “BBB-” to “BBB+” 2%, “BB-” to “BB+” 0.5%. ¾ Corporate exposure limite
Slide 30: Asset Mix – December 31, 2005
Asset Mix – December 31, 2005 Shares Short term 21.0% 2.0% Preferred Shares 19.9% Private Placements Bonds 0.5% 55.5% Commercial Mortgages 1.1% p. 30
Slide 31: Asset Mix
Asset Mix December 31/04 December 31/05 ALLOWED ING PORTFOLIOS ING PORTFOLIOS ASSET MIX RANGE ASSET CLASS (MV) Million $ % Million $ % % SHORT TERM 217 3.5% 135 2.0% 1-3 COMMERCIAL MORTGAGES 83 1.3% 73 1.1% 0-2 PRIVATE PLACEMENTS 38 0.6% 30 0.5% 0-2 BONDS 3,733 59.8% 3,691 55.5% 51 - 61 PREFERRED SH
Slide 32: Capital Required – OSFI As of December 31, 2005
Capital Required – OSFI As of December 31, 2005 Average Capital MV Actual Required Required ($ Mln) Weight Capital (%) (1) ($ Mln) Short Term Investments & Cash 135.2 2.0% 0.0% 0.0 Fixed Income Bonds, ABS, CMBS & MBS 3690.5 55.5% 0.7% 24.7 Commercial Mortgages 72.6 1.1% 8.0% 5.8 Private Placements 3
Slide 33: Asset Quality
Asset Quality December 31/04 December 31/05 ING PORTFOLIOS * ING PORTFOLIOS Public Fixed Income by Credit Quality (BV) Million $ % Million $ % AAA 646 17.3% 764 20.7% AA 448 12.0% 321 8.7% A 2,322 62.2% 2,126 57.6% BBB 317 8.5% 476 12.9% BB 0 0.0% 0 0.0% B 0 0.0% 0 0.0% <B 0 0.0% 0 0.0% Total Rated
Slide 34: Sectors
Sectors As of December 31, 2004 As of December 31, 2005 Top Ten Sectors BV % of BV MV BV % of BV MV Banks 636.2 10.6% 674.1 827.8 12.3% 895.2 Diversified Financial Services 1,321.4 22.0% 1,379.6 701.2 10.4% 734.3 Utilities 435.3 7.2% 461.9 449.7 6.7% 482.1 Insurance 246.3 4.1% 266.7 361.2 5.4% 392.3
Slide 35: Top Ten Holdings - December 31, 2005
Top Ten Holdings - December 31, 2005 Company Market Value Book Value Internal Max OSFI Max ($ Million) ($ Million) Book Allowed * (5% TA) A 392.4 371.5 385.1 496.3 B 311.2 282.4 370.4 496.3 C 214.1 219.0 390.2 496.3 D 196.2 187.6 385.7 496.3 E 181.6 169.7 247.1 496.3 F 136.4 126.7 215.7 496.3 G 127.
Slide 36: Bonds
Bonds p. 36
Slide 37: Asset Class Management – Dec. 31, 2005
Asset Class Management – Dec. 31, 2005 BONDS - $3.7 Billion; 55.5% WTG. - Benchmark duration 6.51 years (allowable range +/- 1 year max.) · Actual duration 6.37 years - Individual issuer limits by credit quality - Average credit quality of A+ Actual Benchmark Credit Quality Short Term 3.4 0.0 Rating
Slide 38: Triple Bs on Uptrend
Triple Bs on Uptrend Triple Bs on uptrend Corporate issue as a percentage of the Scotia Universe Index 30 4.7 25 4.6 2 4.6 1.4 4.2 20 1.3 15 1.1 10.9 15.7 17.2 16.7 15.2 0.6 16.1 0.6 8.8 10 7.9 6.7 6.9 5 8.4 6.5 6.2 6 5.7 6 4.8 4.1 3.2 3.7 0 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 AA/AAA A
Slide 39: Duration History of Various Scotia Indices
Duration History of Various Scotia Indices Scotia Indices Duration Information 7 6.5 6 5.5 5 4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 Jul-97 Jul-98 Jul-99 Jul-00 Jul-01 Jul-95 Jul-96 Jan-98 Jan-99 Jan-00 Jan-01 Jan-02 Jul-02 Jul-94 Jan-03 Jul-03 Jul-04 Jan-96 Jan-97 Jan-95 Jan-04 Jan-05 Universe Benchmark Mid Benchmark Sh
Slide 40: Duration of the Bonds, Prefs and ABS
Duration (years) 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 8.5 juin- 97 oct-9 7 févr- 98 juin- 98 oct-9 8 févr- 99 juin- 99 oct-9 9 févr- 00 juin- 00 oct-0 0 févr- 01 p. 40 juin- 01 oct-0 1 févr- 02 juin- 02 Duration oct-0 2 févr- 03 juin- 03 oct-0 3 févr- 04 juin- 04 oct-0 4 févr- 05 juin- 05 Duration of
Slide 41: Duration of Different Asset Classes
Duration of Different Asset Classes (Monthly From January 2002; Quarterly Before 2002) 11.0 10.0 9.0 Duration(years) 8.0 7.0 6.0 5.0 4.0 3.0 2.0 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 juin-9 juin-9 juin-9 juin-0 juin-0 juin-0 juin-0 juin-0 juin-0 déc- déc- déc- déc- déc- déc- déc- déc- déc- Bo
Slide 42: Bond Portfolio – Rules and Constraints (February 28, 2006)
Bond Portfolio – Rules and Constraints (February 28, 2006) 3.4.2 Asset Composition Portfolio weight (%) Min (%) Max (%) Benchmark assets 88 80 100 Non-benchmark assets 12 0 20 Benchmark Portfolio weight (%) weight (%) Min (%) Max (%) Benchmark assets 88 100 80 100 Government 38 49 24 100 Provincial
Slide 43: Common Stock
Common Stock p. 43
Slide 44: Asset Class Management – Dividend Rollover
Asset Class Management – Dec. 31, 2005 DIVIDEND ROLLOVER - $1,3 Billion; 19.8% - Objectives: - create a portfolio of liquid high (dividend) yielding Canadian common shares - generate a high level of dividend income - potential for capital appreciation - expected current after tax yield: - passively,
Slide 45: Asset Class Management – Dividend Rollover
Asset Class Management – Dec. 31, 2005 DIVIDEND ROLLOVER - Active Management - the stocks are actively traded, sector weights remain close to the benchmark - one objective is to capture more dividend income than the benchmark by "rolling" the stocks from one dividend period to another, taking taxati
Slide 46: Asset Class Management – Dividend Rollover
Asset Class Management – Dec. 31, 2005 DIVIDEND ROLLOVER - "Roll Ratio" - Measures the dividend income of the portfolio relative to that benchmark 2005 Actual 1.67 Target 1.35 - Risk / Return comparison vs S&P TSX Return (% ) Standard Deviation (% ) DROP S&P TSX VA DROP S&P TSX 1 Year 25.89 24.18 1.
Slide 47: Asset Class Management – Market Neutral
Asset Class Management – Dec. 31, 2005 MARKET NEUTRAL - $34.2 Million capital employed ; 0.5% Capital approved: $110M as of March 1st - OSFI approved Objectives - create a portfolio of long and short Canadian and US common shares that is uncorrelated with equity market movements - dollar neutral - m
Slide 48: Asset Class Management – Market Neutral Performance
Asset Class Management – Dec. 31, 2005 MARKET NEUTRAL Performance October 2001 to December 2002 Annualized 1.93% Minimum monthly performance -9.82% Maximum monthly performance 4.72% Annualized Standard deviation 14.84% January 2003 to December 2005 (with new guidelines) Annualized return 5.03% Minim
Slide 49: Preferred Stock
Preferred Stock p. 49
Slide 50: Asset Class Management – Preferred Shares
Asset Class Management – Dec. 31, 2005 PREFERRED SHARES - $1.3 Billion; 19.9% - Offer: - advantageous tax treatment for P & C companies (I.e. tax free dividends) - high after tax spread - Various share structures: - Retractable (33.4% of ING portfolio) - fixed term/fixed rate dividend - redeemable b
Slide 51: Canadian Preferred Shares – Quoted Market Value
Milliards 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 1-Oct-93 2-Feb-94 6-Jun-94 6-Oct-94 7-Feb-95 9-Jun-95 11-oct-95 12-févr-96 13-juin-96 15-oct-96 14-févr-97 18-juin-97 20-oct-97 19-févr-98 23-juin-98 Source: Desjardins Securities, Global Insight, November 2005 23-oct-98 24-févr-99 28-juin-99 p. 51 28-oct-9
Slide 52: Approximate Size of Asset Classes in Canada as of November 2005
Approximate Size of Asset Classes in Canada as of November 2005 Preferred Shares 1.24% Government Debt 31.34% S&P TSX 47.33% Corporate Debt 11.81% CDNX 2.14% Income Trusts 6.14% Source: Desjardins Securities, Global Insight, November 2005 p. 52
Slide 53: Canadian Preferred Shares – Active Preferred Share Issues since 1976
0 50 100 150 200 250 1976-01-02 1977-01-02 1978-01-02 1979-01-02 1980-01-02 1981-01-02 1982-01-02 1983-01-02 1984-01-02 1985-01-02 1986-01-02 1987-01-02 1988-01-02 Source: Desjardins Securities, Global Insight, November 2005 1989-01-02 1990-01-02 Unique Firms p. 53 1991-01-02 1992-01-02 1993-01-02 1
Slide 54: Canadian Asset Class Performance from April 1975
Canadian Asset Class Performance from April 1975 Compound Annual Growth Annualized Standard Asset class Rate (%) Deviation (%) S&P / TSX (Common Equity) 10.82 16.13 Canadian Preferred Shares 9.11 6.83 Long Government Bonds 11.71 10.19 Government T-bills 8.44 1.15 Source: Desjardins Securities, Globa
Slide 55: Evolution of the Duration of Preferred Shares Portfolio
Duration (years) 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 janv- 02 mar s -02 mai -0 2 juil-0 2 sept- 02 n ov- 02 janv- 03 mar s -03 mai -0 3 juil-0 3 Shares Portfolio sept- 03 ING n ov- 03 janv- p. 55 04 mar s -04 mai -0 4 juil-0 4 sept- 04 Benchmark n ov- 04 janv- 05 mar s -05 mai -0 5 juil-0 5 s
Slide 56: Percentage of Fixed Rate Perpetuals and Retractables in the Preferred Shares Portfolio
Percentage of Fixed Rate Perpetuals and Retractables in the Preferred Shares Portfolio Percentage of Fixed Rate Perpetuals and Retractables in the Preferred Shares Portfolio (Monthly from June 1997 to February 2006) 80% 70% 60% 50% % 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 7
Slide 57: Historical Yield Spread
Historical Yield Spread p. 57
Slide 58: P&C Investment Monitor - extracts
P& C Investment Monitor - extracts Made by Canadian Mgr Search December 31,2005 p. 58
Slide 59: ING Canada Total Fund - Annualized Relative Rates of Return
ING Canada (Compagnies d’assurance I.A.R.D.) Total Fund - Annualized Relative Rates of Return Compared by Portfolio Size (>$250 Million) December 31, 2005 12.0% 10.0% ° @ING Canada o ° ” o o ° e 8.0% ° . ° 6.0% 4.0% bd 2.0% e 0.0% -2.0% Last Annualized Periods Ending December 31, 2005 Quarter 6Month
Slide 60: ING Canada Canadian Equity - Annual Relative Rates of Return
ING Canada (Compagnies d’assurance I.A.R.D.) Canadian Equity - Annual Relative Rates of Return December 31, 2005 40.0% o @SPTSX 30.0% e $ @ ING Canada 8 20.0% eo @ s 10.0% O e C4 * ° 0.0% -10.0% e e -20.0% Last Six Calendar Years Quarter Months YTD 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 Top 5 % 46% 176% 29.2
Slide 61: ING Canada Risk vs. Return - Total Fund
ING Canada (Compagnies d’assurance I|.A.R.D.) Risk vs. Return - Total Fund Four Years Ending December 31, 2005 Return (% p.a.) More Return, Less Risk More Return, More Risk e 10.5% e e 9.5% e ING Canada 8.5% e 7.5% e e e 6.5% 6 eo Wedian 5 e e = e 5.5% 7 e e D Less Return, Less Risk Less Return, Mor
Slide 62: Percent Allocation to Short Term & Cash
ING Canada (Compagnies d’assurance |.A.R.D.) Percent Allocation to Short Term & Cash December 31, 2005 25.0% @ING Canada 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% o 5.0% e je o o e e . ry o 0.0% As of December 31 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998 1997 1996 Top 5% 16.1% 11.1% 13.3% 17.7% 18.9% 11.9% 12.7% 22.9% 16.4%
Slide 63: Percent Allocation to Bonds & Debentures
ING Canada (Compagnies d’assurance I|.A.R.D.)} Percent Allocation to Bonds & Debentures December 31, 2005 100.0% 90.0% @ING Canada 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% o o 50.0% e o 40.0% * ; ° ° e 30.0% id 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% As of December 31 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998 1997 1996 Top 5% 85.0% 87.2% 79.7% 80
Slide 64: Percent Allocation to Preferred Shares
ING Canada (Compagnies d’assurance |.A.R.D.) Percent Allocation to Preferred Shares December 31, 2005 45.0% o 40.0% @ING Canada 55 gor, o % ° * o ° 30.0% ° 25.0% 20.0% ° o 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 0.0% As of December 31 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998 1997 1996 Top 5 % 17.5% 16.0% 18.7% 23.8% 24.5%
Slide 65: DBRS – Dominion Bond Rating Service
DBRS – Dominion Bond Rating Service • In accordance with DBRS recent credit rating report, Investment Management is one of the 5 key strengths of ING Canada • Rating Considerations - strengths – Market leader and scale economies – Strong focus on underwritting and claims management – Diversified by
Slide 66: Questions?
Questions? p. 66
Slide 67: Coming May 11, 2006
Coming May 11, 2006 Q1/06 Earnings Release and Conference Call Conference Call Phone Number: 1-800-706-7749 (toll-free in North America) or 617-614-3474 password: 51957322 Phone Number and Access Code for Replay: 1-888-286-8010 (toll-free in North America) or 617-801-6888 password: 68623645 p. 67