BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust · NYSE:ECAT
BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust — Proxy Contest (June 2023)
35 slides from BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust's proxy contest presentation, Jun 15, 2023
Slide 1: Presentation to Institutional Shareholder Services June 2023
Presentation to Institutional Shareholder Services June 2023 BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust (ECAT) IPO Date: September 2021
Slide 2: The Board's Nominees are highly qualified and focused on creating long-term value
The Boards Nominees are highly qualified and focused on creating sustainable, long-term value for allECAT shareholders The Board has unanimously approved the following Board Nominees to continue to serve Board Saba Nominees Nominees as Trustees of the Trust: Experience with ECAT, " Cynthia L. Egan i
Slide 3: The Board is committed to enhancing shareholder value
The Board is committed to enhancing shareholder value The Fund was designed to benefit all shareholders NAV pricing: To eliminate high upfront fees for investors of the Fund, BlackRock now pays 100% of the offering costs and the Funds initial NAV equals the initial public offering (IPO) price Limite
Slide 4: BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust (ECAT)
BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust (ECAT) IPO Date: September 2021 BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trusts (ECAT) (the Fund) investment objectives are to provide total return and income through a combination of current income, current gains and long-term capital appreciation " The Fund
Slide 5: Rigorous Oversight of ECAT
Rigorous Oversight of ECAT The Board regularly meets with the portfolio management team led by Rick Rieder to scrutinize performance and fund positioning, including private investments As part of the governance structure, Board Members serve on various committees that thoroughly examine different as
Slide 6: Is change warranted?
Is change warranted? No, change is not warranted because ECAT has consistently demonstrated superior results relative to peers since its inception in September 2021 amid heightened market volatility, demonstrating the Boards focus on creating sustainable, long-term value for all ECAT shareholders EC
Slide 7: ISS Five Factor Framework
ISS Five Factor Framework
Slide 8: Total Shareholder Return
Total Shareholder Return Total Return on Market Price Total Return on Net Asset Value #1 #1 ECAT is the top performing fund in the ECAT is the top performing fund in the Morningstar Tactical Allocation category over Morningstar Tactical Allocation peer category the Year-to-Date and 1 Year periods ov
Slide 9: Distributions
Distributions ECAT pays a higher yield relative to peers and has grown its monthly distribution rate by 25% since inception over that period, Tactical Allocation CEFs have reduced distributions by -22% Yield on Net Asset Value Distribution Rate Growth 8.53 8.31 25% ECAT Tactical Allocation CEFs -22%
Slide 10: NAV Premium and Discount
NAV Premium and DiscountECAT and its Tactical Allocation peers have experienced a wide range of valuations since ECATs inception in September 2021 due to changes in investor and market sentiment ECAT has previously traded at a premium and currently trades at a narrower discount than its Tactical All
Slide 11: Fees and Expenses
Fees and ExpensesECATs total expenses1 are the lowest in the Tactical Allocation peer group (1st quartile)ECAT is unique from peers given its unconstrained approach and exposure to private marketsECAT reduced its management fee via contractual waiver with approximately $180k in annual savings for sh
Slide 12: Corporate Governance
Corporate GovernanceFiduciaries seeking to enhance value for all shareholdersExperienced, Diverse and Qualified Liquidity at NAVBoard In 2033, all shareholders will have an Current Board Members are committed to opportunity to receive 100% liquidity at ensuring that the Fund operates in a net asset
Slide 13: Trustee Nominees
Trustee Nominees
Slide 14: The Board's Nominees
The Boards NomineesExperience Diversity IndependenceActing for all shareholders Executing for the long termFormer President of Retirement Plan Services at T. Cynthia L. Rowe Price Group Board Chair for The Hanover Insurance Group and EganLead Independent Director for Huntsman CorporationOver a centu
Slide 15: Investment companies are fundamentally different from operating companies
Investment companies, including CEFs, are fundamentally different from operating companies and should be evaluated based on their distinct attributesOperating Company Closed-End FundRun by internal management and employeesu Board has the primary responsibility for oversight of the funds service prov
Slide 16: Saba's Playbook
Sabas PlaybookSaba is a short-term investor
Slide 17: Saba is a short-term investor
Saba is a short-term investor Saba may attempt to claim that it has been a long-term investor in ECAT; however, the fact is that it took advantage of the current market dislocation to acquire an outsized position in the FundSaba net share purchases by quarter92%of current share ownership3,190,120 2,
Slide 18: Saba has a history of short-term investing
Saba has a history of short-term investing and has never provided a long-term solution to narrow discountsSaba submitted its notice of intent to nominate persons to ECATs Board of Trustees less than one year after initiating a position in the Fund and never reached out to the Board or BlackRock to d
Slide 19: Saba claims to be focused on governance but focuses on liquidity
Saba claims to be focused on governance but actually focuses its efforts on liquidity, illustrating its true intentions Saba Proxy Campaign HistoryDirector nominee 17 12 5 campaigns Settled / withdrawn Directors not elected Directors seatedGovernance 6 2 5 proposals Settled / withdrawn Proposal fail
Slide 20: Saba uses the same playbook to enrich itself
Saba uses the same playbook to enrich itself and harm the fund and other shareholdersSabas playbook Saba ownership1) Acquire an outsized positionto exert to control when market sentiment is where settlement negative and discounts are temporarily wide reached or Saba 2) Hedge to limit exposure only t
Slide 21: Tender offers benefit short-term investors like Saba
Tender offers benefit short-term investors like Saba at the expense of long-term shareholders1Tender offers increase volatility& &and dont add value for long-term shareholders-4.5% -12.0%Current average discount Average change in discount after tender offer expiration2Case Study: Delaware Investment
Slide 22: Appendix A Trustee Nominee Biographies
Appendix ATrustee Nominee Biographies
Slide 23: Cynthia L. Egan
Cynthia L. EganCynthia L. Egan brings to the Board a broad and diverse knowledge of investment companies and the retirement industry as a result of her many years of experience as President, Retirement Plan Services, for T. Rowe Price Group, Inc. and her various senior operating officer positions at
Slide 24: Catherine A. Lynch, CFA
Catherine A. Lynch, CFACatherine A. Lynch, who served as the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Investment Officer of the National Railroad Retirement Investment Fund, benefits the Board by providing business leadership and experience and a diverse knowledge of pensions and endowments. Ms. Lynch is a
Slide 25: Stayce D. Harris
Stayce D. HarrisThe Board benefits from StayceD. Harriss leadership and governance experience gained during her extensive military career, including as a three-star Lieutenant General of the United States Air Force. In her most recent role, Ms. Harris reported to the Secretary and Chief of Staff of
Slide 26: Lorenzo A. Flores
Lorenzo A. FloresThe Board benefits from Lorenzo A. Floress many years of business, leadership and financial experience in his roles at various public and private companies. In particular, Mr. Floress service as Chief Financial Officer and Corporate Controller of Xilinx, Inc. and Vice Chairman of Ki
Slide 27: Appendix B ECAT Overview
Appendix BECAT Overview
Slide 28: BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust (ECAT)
BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust (ECAT)Unconstrained investment strategy ESG focus across industriesInvests across all asset classes and Looks at sustainable investments and aims geographies to capitalize on untapped opportunities emerging across industriesAccess to private markets Risk m
Slide 29: ECAT is managed by a winner of the Morningstar 2023 Outstanding Portfolio Manager Award
8ECAT is managed by a winner of the Morningstar 2023 Outstanding Portfolio Manager Award for Investing ExcellenceRick RiederChief Investment Officer of Global Fixed Income, Head of Fundamental Fixed Income, and Head of the Global Allocation Investment TeamLead Portfolio Manager of ECAT36 years exper
Slide 30: Experienced and Well-Resourced ECAT PM Team
Experienced and Well-Resourced ECAT PM TeamRick Rieder is the lead portfolio manager of ECAT, along with Russ Koesterich, David Clayton and Kate Moore. The team leverages ESG expertise across the firm, including Ashley Schulten, who leads ESG investing across the Fixed Income platform. ECAT is well
Slide 31: Appendix C CEF Market Dynamics
Appendix C CEF Market Dynamics
Slide 32: Three structural advantages of CEFs
Three structural advantage of CEFsCLIENT BENEFITStay fully investedClosed structure allows for greater flexibility in the types of Efficient investment strategies that can be used and helps portfolio 1 managers stay invested for the long term without forced selling structureHigher potential income &
Slide 33: CEFs can trade at premiums or discounts to net asset value
CEFs can trade at premiums or discounts to net asset value NAV, primarily driven by market sentiment20-Year Historical Premiums and Discounts of CEFs5 0 -5-102013 - 2015 2018 2022 Premium/Discount Taper Tantrum Trade Wars Rising Rates-152008 - 2009 2020 Global Financial Crisis COVID-19 Pandemic-2020
Slide 34: Appendix D Morningstar Tactical Allocation category
Appendix D Morningstar Tactical Allocation category
Slide 35: Tactical Allocation CEF Peer Group
Tactical Allocation CEF Peer GroupName Ticker Morningstar Category BlackRock Capital Allocation Term Trust BCAT US CE Tactical Allocation BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust ECAT US CE Tactical Allocation Clough Global Dividend and Income Fund GLV US CE Tactical Allocation Clough Global Oppo
BlackRock ESG Capital Allocation Term Trust — Proxy Contest (June 2023) on 6ix