Bob Evans Farms — Proxy Contest (August 2014)
33 slides from Bob Evans Farms's proxy contest presentation, Aug 4, 2014
Slide 1: Refresh Bob Evans: Addressing the Company's Misinformation
1 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Refresh Bob Evans Addressing the Company’s Misinformation August 2014 www.refreshbobevans.com
Slide 2: Disclaimer
2 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Disclaimer THIS PRESENTATION WITH RESPECT TO BOB EVANS FARMS, INC . (“BOB EVANS” OR THE “COMPANY’”) IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY . IT DOES NOT HAVE REGARD TO THE SPECIFIC INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE, FINANCIAL SITUATION, SUITABILITY OR
Slide 3: Additional Information Regarding the Solicitation
3 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Additional Information Regarding the Solicitation SANDELL ASSET MANAGEMENT CORP . , CASTLERIGG MASTER INVESTMENTS LTD . , CASTLERIGG INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, CASTLERIGG INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS LIMITED, CASTLERIGG OFFSHORE HOLDINGS, LTD . , CASTLE
Slide 4: Chronic and Severe Stock Price Underperformance
4 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Chronic and Severe Stock Price Underperformance Bob Evans’ Total Shareholder Return Relative to: Proxy Peers Family & Casual Dining Peers 1 Year - 10.0 % - 17.0 % - 9.1 % 3 Year - 48.4 % - 33.4 % - 13.9 % 5 Year - 121.2 % - 130.1 % - 47.9 % 10
Slide 5: A Consistent Track Record of Under Performance
5 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year BJ’s - 0.3% +75.3% - 26.0% - 1.7% Bloomin’ Brands +12.8% NA NA NA Brinker - 18.1% - 50.1% - 117.7% - 3.5% Cheesecake Factory - 6.4% - 3.4% - 40.1% +68.3% Cracker Barrel - 6.4% - 84.3% - 191.2% - 138.7% Darden - 3.9
Slide 6: Yet the Company Claims Their Performance Has Been "Generally In Line"
6 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Yet the Company Claims T hat Their Performance Has B een “Generally In Line” Cherry - picked dates Bob Evans’ exposure to the weather was not unique, and the gross margin at BEF Foods demonstrates that sow costs cannot be blamed for recent und
Slide 7: Bob Evans TSR April 2013 – September 2013, Artificially Inflated and Short-Lived
7 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Bob Evans TSR April 2013 – September 2013, Artificially Inflated and Short - Lived Outperformance 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% Apr-13 May-13 Jun-13 Jul-13 Aug-13 +39.3% April 26 – July 2 : Sandell purchased a sizable stake in Bob Evan
Slide 8: September 2013 – Present, Abysmal Operating Performance Reflected in the Market
8 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. September 2013 – Present, Bob Evans’ Abysmal Operating Performance Is Reflected In the Market -25% -20% -15% -10% -5% 0% 5% Sep-13 Nov-13 Dec-13 Jan-14 Mar-14 Apr-14 Jun-14 Jul-14 - 15.1% Sandell’s suggestions and Bob Evans’ dramatically incre
Slide 9: Underperformance Grid – 1 Year
9 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Underperformance Grid – 1 Year Ended On: 4/25/2013 7/15/2013 8/19/2013 4/23/2014 7/31/2014 BJ’s 39.5% 31.6% 39.0% 17.6% - 0.3% Bloomin’ Brands NA NA - 57.1% 5.6% 12.8% Brinker - 10.0% 0.5% - 1.9% - 22.6% - 18.1% Cheesecake Factory - 17.3% - 9.
Slide 10: Underperformance Grid – 3 Year
10 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. 4/25/2013 7/15/2013 8/19/2013 4/23/2014 7/31/2014 BJ’s 9.8% 53.9% 67.7% 91.1% 75.3% Bloomin’ Brands NA NA NA NA NA Brinker - 66.4% - 56.6% - 83.0% - 57.5% - 50.7% Cheesecake Factory - 1.4% 43.0% 11.3% - 6.4% - 3.4% Cracker Barrel - 33.7% - 1.
Slide 11: Underperformance Grid – 5 Year
11 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. 4/25/2013 7/15/2013 8/19/2013 4/23/2014 7/31/2014 BJ’s - 72.0% - 225.1% - 85.4% 19.1% - 26.0% Bloomin’ Brands NA NA NA NA NA Brinker - 28.3% - 60.1% - 57.4% - 89.9% - 117.7% Cheesecake Factory - 16.6% - 77.4% - 89.3% - 113.0% - 40.1% Cracker
Slide 12: Underperformance Grid – 10 Year
12 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. 4/25/2013 7/15/2013 8/19/2013 4/23/2014 7/31/2014 BJ’s - 214.2% - 131.4% - 65.8% - 36.1% - 1.7% Bloomin’ Brands NA NA NA NA NA Brinker - 3.6% 21.0% - 11.8% - 55.5% - 3.5% Cheesecake Factory 16.1% 31.4% 27.8% 11.9% 68.3% Cracker Barrel - 106.1
Slide 13: One Year Total Shareholder Return vs. Peers
13 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. One Year Total Shareholder Return vs. Peers 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50% Apr-13 Jul-13 Oct-13 Jan-14 Bob Evans Proxy Peers Cracker Barrel Family & Casual Dining Peers Proxy Peers + 28.4% Family & Casual Dining + 20.4% +21.3% + 11
Slide 14: Three Year Total Shareholder Return vs. Peers
14 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. -40% -20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 160% Apr-11 Apr-12 Apr-13 Apr-14 Bob Evans Proxy Peers Cracker Barrel Family & Casual Dining Peers Proxy Peers +87.5% Family & Casual Dining +68.0% Three Year Total Shareholder Return vs. Peers + 10
Slide 15: Five Year Total Shareholder Return vs. Peers
15 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Five Year Total Shareholder Return vs. Peers -50% 0% 50% 100% 150% 200% 250% 300% 350% Apr-09 Apr-10 Apr-11 Apr-12 Apr-13 Apr-14 Bob Evans Proxy Peers Cracker Barrel Family & Casual Dining Peers Proxy Peers +237.5% Family & Casual Dining + 15
Slide 16: Ten Year Total Shareholder Return vs. Peers
16 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Ten Year Total Shareholder Return vs. Peers -100% -50% 0% 50% 100% 150% 200% 250% 300% Apr-04 Apr-05 Apr-06 Apr-07 Apr-08 Apr-09 Apr-10 Apr-11 Apr-12 Apr-13 Apr-14 Bob Evans Proxy Peers Cracker Barrel Proxy Peers +239.4% Family & Casual Dinin
Slide 17: The Real Fundamental Choice: Credibility
17 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. The Real Fundamental Choice: Credibility Despite what the Company claims, the Bob Evans 2014 Annual Meeting is NOT about any specific transaction The Bob Evans 2014 Annual Meeting is about the credibility of directors to represent the best in
Slide 18: Questioning the Independence of the Shareholder Nominees
18 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. How does Bob Evans Have the Audacity to Question the Independence of the Shareholder Nominees? The slate of nominees put forward by Sandell have truly outstanding, unimpeachable reputations and longstanding track records of creating sharehold
Slide 19: Bob Evans Accuses Sandell of Making Misleading Statements
19 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Bob Evans Accuses Sandell of Making Misleading Statements See our response on pages 20 - 21 to the Company’s attempt to distort the reality of its excessive SG&A The Company’s repeated excuses of cold weather and sow costs do not in anyway ab
Slide 20: Attempt by Bob Evans to Distort SG&A Reality
20 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Attempt by Bob Evans to Distort SG&A Reality It is truly unbelievable to us when Bob Evans claims that their SG&A expenses as a percentage of revenue are “more in line with the peer average .” In our opinion, Bob Evans has manipulated its “fa
Slide 21: Restaurant Segment SG&A
21 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Restaurant Segment SG&A (For those who include advertising) $ in millions, last fiscal year Average ex - BOBE Revenue $956.6 $4,129.2 $6,285.6 $1,017.2 SG&A (Inclusive of advertising ) 112.8 268.9 663.5 124.3 SG&A as a % of Revenue 11.79% 6.5
Slide 22: Hockey Stick Goals and No Believable Plan
22 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Hockey Stick Goals and No Believable Plan Why would shareholders trust Bob Evans’ “hockey stick” projections when the Company has consistently missed consensus earnings estimates and repeatedly reduced their guidance? Source: Bob Evans Invest
Slide 23: Is This the Company's Plan?
23 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. “Our number one complaint on Broasted Chicken was out of stock. So that just goes to show you the power of what this can do for us if we get the operations right .” - Steven Davis, Chairman & CEO of Bob Evans Bob Evans Q4 2014 Earnings Call (
Slide 24: Failing On All Fronts to "Drive Stockholder Value"
24 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Failing On All Fronts to “Drive Stockholder Value” Bob Evans Restaurants delivered - 2.1% “growth” in same store sales in FY 2014 The “rigorous and disciplined process” employed by the Bob Evans Board has proven itself to be highly flawed The
Slide 25: Misleading Representation of "Farm Fresh Refresh" Results
25 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Misleading Representation of “Farm Fresh Refresh” Results Note that the Company shows incremental same store sales and not ACTUAL same store sales We believe the Company seeks to camouflage the disastrous “Farm Fresh Refresh” remodeling resul
Slide 26: The History of Mimi's Café: Failed Board Stewardship
26 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. The History of Mimi’s Café: Failed Board Stewardship of the Highest Order ▪ The six Directors shown to the left, in addition to two other current Directors, have all been on the Board since FY 2008 , during the time when Mimi’s Café started i
Slide 27: The History of Mimi's Café: A Stunning Admission
27 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. The History of Mimi’s Café: A Stunning Admission Source: Bob Evans Investor Presentation (July/August 2014) The implications behind this statement are staggering – this Board, and specifically eight current Directors on this B oard since to a
Slide 28: Bob Evans Routinely Claims a Commitment to Corporate Governance Best Practices
28 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Bob Evans Routinely Claims a Commitment to “Corporate Governance Best Practices” Should a Company that claims to embrace good governance wait to get sued by multiple shareholders before overturning an entrenching bylaw amendment? Source: Bob
Slide 29: How Can Bob Evans Claim "Transparency" and "Fresh, Independent Thinking?"
29 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. How Can Bob Evans Claim “Transparency” and “Fresh, Independent Thinking?” Source: Bob Evans Investor Presentation (July/August 2014) We believe that Bob Evans perverts the English language by claiming its commitment to “transparency and fresh
Slide 30: "Transparency?"
30 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. “Transparency?” ■ In November of 2011, the Board sought to impose an improper Bylaw restriction on shareholders that would have further entrenched the Board by severely limiting the ability of shareholders to effect change by amending the Com
Slide 31: "Fresh?"
31 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. “Fresh?” What about this Board signals “fresh?” Director Year Appointed Tenure (Years) TSR Relative to Family & Casual Dining Peers that are not majority - franchised 1 TSR Relative to Cracker Barrel 1 Larry C. Corbin 1981 33 - 800.1% - 5,117
Slide 32: "Independent Thinking?"
32 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. “Independent Thinking?” Key United Way Central Ohio The James Foundation The Columbus Academy Vorys, Sater Greif, Inc. State Auto Columbus College A&D Kraft Foods, Inc. The Ohio State Univ. JobsOhio Gordon Gee Mary Haben Eileen Mallesch Paul
Slide 33: Investor and Media Contacts
33 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Investors : MacKenzie Partners, Inc . Dan Burch or Larry Dennedy (212) 929 - 5500 Press/Media : Sloane & Company Elliot Sloane or Dan Zacchei (212) 446 - 1860 or (212) 446 - 1882