The Pantry — Pantry — Proxy Contest (February 2014)
49 slides from The Pantry's proxy contest presentation, Feb 19, 2014
Slide 1: Enhancing Stockholder Value at The Pantry
The Pantry, Inc. Concerned Pantry Shareholders February 2014 Enhancing Stockholder Value at The Pantry 1
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer This presentation is for discussion and general informational purposes only. It does not have regard to the specific investment objective, financial situation, suitability, or the particular need of any specific person who may receive this presentation, and should not be taken as advice o
Slide 3: Table of Contents
Table of Contents I. Why We are Invested in The Pantry II. History of Poor Performance and Undervaluation III. Concerned Pantry Shareholders (CPS) Has a Better Plan IV. Our Nominees Are More Qualified Appendix Company / Industry Overview 3
Slide 4: Why We are Invested in The Pantry
Why We are Invested in The Pantry • We began researching The Pantry in April 2012 and our research indicated that an opportunity existed to create significant value for Pantry shareholders • Change is necessary at the Company given its terrible performance over the past several years across almost a
Slide 5: Why We are Invested in The Pantry
Why We are Invested in The Pantry Change is urgently needed at The Pantry. After 10 years the Board has repeatedly failed to produce shareholder value after multiple attempts. We have nominated directors who are highly- highly qualified and offer a better plan for the future of The Pantry. There is
Slide 6: Our Nominees Can Create Positive Change
Our Nominees Can Create Positive Change • Our Nominees have corporate governance experience, experience capital allocation experience, operating experience, and will explore all options to unlock value. value We believe these are all necessary to execute on a new plan for The Pantry. – Todd Diener -
Slide 7: Why We are Invested in The Pantry
Why We are Invested in The Pantry The current Board is composed of Directors who have continuously failed to create value for shareholders over the past 10 years. Ed Holman, Thomas Murnane, Murnane and Robert Bernstock have been on the Board for 9 - 12 years and are responsible for overseeing terrib
Slide 8: History of Poor Performance Compels Change on the Board
History of Poor Performance Compels Change on the Board 8
Slide 9: 10 Years of Poor Performance
10 Years of Poor Performance • This performance demonstrates in our view that the Board of Directors’ interests have not been aligned with shareholders – our nominees are committed to increasing shareholder value Share Price Performance (1) 1-Year 3-Year 5-Year 10-Year S&P 500 19% 36% 116% 57% Russe
Slide 10: 10 Years of Poor Performance (cont.)
10 Years of Poor Performance (cont.) • The Pantry has underperformed its direct competitors by a wide margin • Our nominees offer a better plan to create shareholder value 10 Year Share Price Performance % PTRY SUSS ATD/B CASY 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 - 10
Slide 11: 10 Years of Poor Performance (cont.)
10 Years of Poor Performance (cont.) • The Pantry’s most similar competitors which are public companies include Casey’s, Susser and Alimentation Couche-Tard Tard • The Pantry’s long-term stock price underperformance has significantly lagged its peers and the relevant stock indices • We believe there
Slide 12: 10 Years of Poor Performance (cont.)
10 Years of Poor Performance (cont.) • The Pantry’s stock price has declined more than 30% cumulatively in 10 years. During this time, The Company has generated a total of $1.5 billion in cash flow from operations and spent approximately $900 million in capital expenditures • The Pantry has produced
Slide 13: Historically Poor Capital Allocation
Historically Poor Capital Allocation • Over the last 10 years the Company has spent more than $900 million in total capital expenditures and failed to create any shareholder value • Additionally, the Company has generated $1.5 billion in cash flow from operations which has also been reinvested into
Slide 14: Historically Poor Capital Allocation (cont.)
Historically Poor Capital Allocation (cont.) The Pantry has spent a total of +$900 million on Acquisition Related capital expenditures in the last 10 years buying +600 stores which has not created any shareholder value Year Total Capital Expenditures Acquisition Related Total Capex + Acquisitions EB
Slide 15: Historically Poor Capital Allocation (cont.)
Historically Poor Capital Allocation (cont.) • For FY 2014 the Company has forecasted $110 million in capital expenditures. We don’t believe this Board has proven it is capable of overseeing such a large capital outlay – The Company has not clearly stated its expected return on these investments • T
Slide 16: Poor Performance = Poor Shareholder Return
Poor Performance = Poor Shareholder Return • The Pantry trades at a significant discount given its poor capital allocation and poor operating performance over the last 10 years • Without significant change in The Pantry’s capital allocation strategy, the discount to its peers and the broader market
Slide 17: Fuel Declines Are Concerning
Fuel Declines Are Concerning • Fuel volumes have declined over the last five years • We believe the Board is neglecting these declines and not paying adequate attention to competitors such as Sheetz and QuickTrip as they appear to be taking market share • The Pantry has underperformed its peers Same
Slide 18: Fuel Declines Are Concerning (cont.)
Fuel Declines Are Concerning (cont.) • The effects of volume decreases have constrained fuel gross profit at The Pantry, while Susser, Casey’s and Couche-Tard Tard have enjoyed healthy cash flows • Susser has increased fuel cash flows more than 104% over the last 10 years • Casey’s has increased fue
Slide 19: Fuel Declines Are Concerning (cont.)
Fuel Declines Are Concerning (cont.) With the debt covenant issues The Company is having, we are concerned the Board is not focused on the possible issues with Letters of Credit for fuel • Meanwhile, in much of The Pantry's core terrain, top-scale top operators are ramping up new retail models and o
Slide 20: EBITDA Declines are Concerning
EBITDA Declines are Concerning • EBITDA has decreased over the last 10 years and capital allocation has produced no return to shareholders • Ed Holman, Thomas Murnane and Robert Bernstock have overseen this decline EBITDA 300,000 250,000 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 - 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Slide 21: 4 CEOs in 5 Years – Continued Management Turnover
4 CEOs in 5 Years – Continued Management Turnover • 2002 – Thomas Murnane Joins Board “This cultural success is about people. • 2005 – Ed Holman and Robert Bernstock Join Board It’s most important that people understand where we’re going and are focused along that clear path. It’s • 2009 – Ed Holman
Slide 22: More Senior Management Turnover
More Senior Management Turnover • On February 3, 2014, P. Joseph Venezia, Venezia Senior Vice President, Operations, resigned from The Pantry effective February 14, 2014 to pursue another career opportunity • As Senior Vice President of Operations Joe Venezia was an integral part of the team and one
Slide 23: Board Has Overseen Poor Performance
Board Has Overseen Poor Performance • Six members of the Board have served for more than 7 years and have overseen The Pantry’s poor performance • Chairman of the Board is one of the longest tenured persons on the Board • Our Nominees would bring operating expertise, capital allocation experience an
Slide 24: Concerned Pantry Shareholders (CPS) Plan
Concerned Pantry Shareholders (CPS) Plan 24
Slide 25: Opportunities to Create Value
Opportunities to Create Value 1. Reassess Capital Expenditures • Closely monitor the proposed remodel program until ROIC is clearly articulated • Suspend New Store Program until ROIC is clearly articulated • Focus on Capital Expenditures that will generate meaningful ROIC 2. Real Estate Monetization
Slide 26: 1. Reassess Capital Expenditures
1. Reassess Capital Expenditures • The Pantry has forecasted to spend $110 million in capital expenditures for 2014 • The Pantry continues to spend millions without exhibiting any increase in EBITDA • “We completed 28 remodels during the first quarter. These remodels were focused in our high potenti
Slide 27: 2. Real Estate Monetization
2. Real Estate Monetization • The Company currently owns 410 sites of the more than 1,500 sites • Buyers of convenience store properties have indicated approximately $500 to $600 million value in 300 of the +400 owned stores • This valuation confirms our belief that good stores, with no environmenta
Slide 28: 2. Real Estate Monetization (cont.)
2. Real Estate Monetization (cont.) • A significant portion of The Company’s store leases are up for renewal within the next four years • The Company should monetize underperforming stores – we believe these stores could account for up to 300 – 500 stores Lease Expiration With Renewal Options Withou
Slide 29: 2. Real Estate Monetization (cont.)
2. Real Estate Monetization (cont.) • Many of the acquisitions through which the Pantry has grown were accomplished by a combination of (i)) cash payment to the prior owner and (ii) leasing the prior owner’s owned properties under long-term term leases at high rents • Several critical variables affe
Slide 30: 2. Real Estate Monetization (cont.)
2. Real Estate Monetization (cont.) • The Pantry has a substantial amount of value embedded in its owned real estate, leases and company owned stores • Our nominees will work to unlock this value Estimated Estimated Estimated 100% Sale 50% Sale 50% Sale of Real Estate of Real Estate REIT/MLP Formati
Slide 31: 3. Restructure Store Base
3. Restructure Store Base • The Company has a significant amount of Charlotte (474 stores) Jacksonville (269 stores) value in these 6 #1 #2 #3 #1 #2 #3 Metropolitan Areas. • Charlotte, Jacksonville and Columbia are their strongest MA’s Columbia (241 stores) Nashville (162 stores) • Some markets are
Slide 32: 4. Implement A Better QSR Plan
4. Implement A Better QSR Plan • The implementation of quick service restaurants in convenience stores over the last 10 years has been a significant traffic and cash flow driver for competitors such as Susser and Casey’s • While The Pantry does have quick service restaurants, many of their competito
Slide 33: 4. Implement A Better QSR Plan (cont.)
4. Implement A Better QSR Plan (cont.) Our nominees will take advantage of this opportunity in an urgent manner • A significant profit opportunity through % Foodservice / Total Merchandise QSR growth 17% • The current Board doesn’t have the background to address this opportunity 11% 11% • The Pantry
Slide 34: ANALYSIS: Can The Pantry Be Saved?
ANALYSIS: Can The Pantry Be Saved? Saved CSP Daily News Independent convenience store news agrees • “Others are suggesting The Pantry downsize to its regional strengths, to withdraw from markets where it is No. 3, 4 or 5 in consumer choice and shift capital into the Carolinas and Florida and a handf
Slide 35: Change at the Board is Long Overdue
Change at the Board is Long Overdue • Concerned Pantry Shareholders (CPS) is committed to realizing full value for all shareholders • We are significant shareholders whose interests are aligned with all shareholders – We have been purchasing shares of The Company. The current directors have been net
Slide 36: Our Board Nominees: Highly Qualified and Independent
Our Board Nominees: Highly Qualified and Independent • Todd Diener Former President of Chili’s Grill & Bar – Former executive officer of Brinker International, Inc. (“Brinker”) where he most recently served as the President of Chili’s Grill & Bar (“Chili’s”) and On the Border restaurants. During thi
Slide 37: Our Board Nominees: Highly Qualified and Independent
Our Board Nominees: Highly Qualified and Independent • James Pappas Chairman of the Board, Morgan’s Food’s Managing Member, JCP Investment Management, LLC • + 70 Restaurants • Ohio, Pennsylvania, – Goldman Sachs, Banc of America Securities West Virginia, New York, – 10 years of investment banking, i
Slide 38: Our Board Nominees: Highly Qualified and Independent
Our Board Nominees: Highly Qualified and Independent • Joshua Schechter Managing Director, Steel Partners – Experienced value investment manager – 10 years of investment management experience – Served on board of directors of Handy and Harmon, Puroflow, Jackson Products and Aderans Co., Ltd – Signif
Slide 39: Board Incumbents Have Not Created Value in 10 Years
Board Incumbents Have Not Created Value in 10 Years The majority of the Board has overseen negative shareholder returns over the past 10 years Since the beginning of 2010, The Pantry’s directors have sold 22,096 shares of common stock in the open market and have purchased only 2,535 shares, accordin
Slide 40: Director Pay is Excessive Given Performance
Director Pay is Excessive Given Performance Board compensation has increased consistently, every year since 2007 for a total increase of 44% or 6.3% compounded over the last 6 years • From 2007 to 2012 the Board was paid $4.3 million in cash pay and $4.2 million in stock compensation for a total of
Slide 41: We Have Tried to Reach a Mutually Agreeable Resolution with Pantry
We Have Tried to Reach a Mutually Agreeable Resolution with Pantry CPS has invested significant time and effort in an attempt to reach a settlement agreement with The Pantry. • We are seeking to work constructively with the rest of the Board and management • Our Nominees have corporate governance ex
Slide 42: Nominees Are Ready to Create Value
Nominees Are Ready to Create Value High management turnover proves this Board has not found a solution despite multiple attempts Each of our nominees is highly capable and qualified to help turnaround The Pantry having restaurant operations, capital allocation and corporate governance experience The
Slide 43: Appendix
Appendix * JCP “8 LONE STAR VALUE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT
Slide 44: Company Profile
Company Profile • Headquartered in Cary, North Carolina, State FY 2013 % Stores Florida 24.2 Pantry has 90% of its stores in Florida, North Carolina 22.5 North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, South Carolina 17.2 Alabama, Tennessee and Mississippi Georgia 7.2 Alabama 7.1 Tennessee 6.3 • Started in
Slide 45: Revenue Contribution
Revenue Contribution Category Sales1 QSRs Currently over 220 in-store QSRs World’s 5th largest operator of Subway Other Non-Food Services restaurants Merchandise 4% 5% Other Tobacco 6% Cigarettes 30% Packaged Beverage 16% Services ATMs Foodservice 11% Grocery Lottery 13% Beer/Wine Car wash 15% Prepa
Slide 46: GAAP Financials
GAAP Financials ($ in thousands) Twelve Months Ended September 24, September 30, September 29, September 27, June 27, 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Adjusted EBITDA $ 283,541 $ 239,848 $ 231,728 $ 210,126 $ 206,152 Impairment charges (2,084) (267,079) (12,555) (6,257) (5,469) Gain (loss) on extinguishment
Slide 47: ISS Follow Up Materials
The Pantry, Inc. Concerned Pantry Shareholders February 2014 Enhancing Stockholder Value at The Pantry ISS Follow Up Materials 1
Slide 48: Competitors Have Had Huge Success
Competitors Have Had Huge Success • 10 Years ago The Pantry boasted the 2nd largest store base • The Pantry has produced negative returns to shareholders over this time period • Direct competitors have had a tremendous amount of success End of Period Store Base EBITDA Year PTRY SUSS(1) CASY ATD/B Ye
Slide 49: Need to Drive Traffic to the Stores
Need to Drive Traffic to the Stores • Merchandise gross profit remains the largest driver of overall cash flow in the convenience store space. Currently, The Pantry generates 75% of gross profit from inside sales • Driving total site traffic to the stores is essential to success % of Gross Profit Fu