ODP Corp

ODP — Office Depot — Proxy Contest (August 2013)

113 slides from ODP's proxy contest presentation, Aug 2, 2013

  1. Slide 1: Transforming Office Depot: A Plan for Renewal and Reinvigoration

    TRANSFORMING OFFICE DEPOT A PLAN FOR RENEWAL AND REINVIGORATION August 2, 2013

  2. Slide 2: Disclaimer

    DISCLAIMER General Considerations This presentation is for general informational purposes only, is not complete and does not constitute an agreement, offer, a solicitation of an offer, or any advice or recommendation to enter into or conclude any transaction or confirmation thereof. This presentatio

  3. Slide 3: Introduction

    INTRODUCTION • Starboard Value is the largest shareholder of Office Depot, owning approximately 14.6% of the outstanding shares of the Company • We have engaged one of the world’s leading restructuring and turnaround firms • Along with this leading restructuring firm, and our director nominees, we h

  4. Slide 4: Table of Contents

    TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Real change is required at Office Depot A. ODP is losing its customer franchise B. ODP is failing strategically and operationally C. ODP’s new real estate strategy is flawed II. Business model transformation opportunity A. Efficiency and effectiveness initiatives B. Growth Strat

  5. Slide 5: Real Change Is Required at Office Depot

    REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT OFFICE DEPOT

  6. Slide 6: Real Change Is Required at Office Depot

    REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT OFFICE DEPOT The situation is serious - Office Depot is losing its customers, relevancy, and viability as an Office Products and Services retailer The Problem The Answer We have a Winning Plan: • Our Plan is Balanced  Topline Growth  Efficiency & Effectiveness • Our Plan

  7. Slide 7: Leadership destroying shareholder value and losing market share

    REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT OFFICE DEPOT ODP leadership is responsible for destroying shareholder value and continuing to lose market share to its competitors Headlines Market Share • Destroyed $9.3B (86%) in enterprise value Historical North American Retail since 2006 Market Share Office Depot vs. S

  8. Slide 8: ODP has destroyed $9.3B in enterprise value since 2006

    REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT OFFICE DEPOT Since 2006, ODP has destroyed $9.3B (86%) in Enterprise value(1) - Deeper and faster than either competitor ODP Enterprise Value(2) ($ in billions) SPLS Enterprise Value(2) ($ in billions) Memo: Closing Stock Price Memo: Closing Stock Price $12 38.17 $9.3B (86

  9. Slide 9: Weak Historical Operational Performance

    WEAK HISTORICAL OPERATIONAL PERFORMANCE Since 2007, Office Depot’s retail comp sales and sales per square foot have declined dramatically North American Retail Comp Sales % Change North American Retail Sales $ Per Sq Ft (1) 0% $280 $254 -1% $250 -$79 / sqft (1) -2% $220 -3% $190 $175 -4% $160 -5% $1

  10. Slide 10: Weak Historical Financial Performance

    WEAK HISTORICAL FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE Despite a massive revenue decline of $4.8 billion from 2007 to 2012, total G&A expense has actually increased, causing G&A expense as a percentage of revenue to increase from 4.2% to 6.3% and Adj. EBITDA margins to decline from 5.3% to 3.1% over this same time p

  11. Slide 11: Office Depot Has Significantly Underperformed Compared to Peers

    OFFICE DEPOT HAS SIGNIFICANTLY UNDERPERFORMED COMPARED TO PEERS Office Depot’s revenue growth, market share, retail comp sales, and retail sales per square foot have underperformed Staples Revenue CAGR North American Retail Market Share 30% 40% 20% 30% 10% 20% 0% 10% 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 -1

  12. Slide 12: Operating margins below peer levels

    OFFICE DEPOT HAS SIGNIFICANTLY UNDERPERFORMED COMPARED TO PEERS Office Depot’s operating margins are also significantly below peer levels due to higher operating expenses, clearly indicating that the Company has not reduced spending levels sufficiently to offset declines in revenues 2012 Financials

  13. Slide 13: Recent poor performance is particularly alarming

    OFFICE DEPOT’S RECENT POOR PERFORMANCE IS PARTICULARLY ALARMING Recent revenue, same store sales, and operating margins continue to be the worst among OSS peers Avg. 4Q12/1Q13 Revenue %Change Avg. 4Q12/1Q13 SG&A as %Revenue 0% 30% -0.1% 23% 24% -2% 25% 20% 20% -4% 15% -6% 10% -6.5% -8% 5% -10% -8.6%

  14. Slide 14: Real Change Is Required at ODP: Conclusions

    REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT ODP Conclusions… • The current leadership team is not capable of producing the transformational change required to position them for omni-channel growth in the future • The company will require radical action to stop losing customers, reverse basket declines, and recover m

  15. Slide 15: ODP Is Losing Its Customer Franchise

    ODP IS LOSING ITS CUSTOMER FRANCHISE

  16. Slide 16: Customer Loyalty Measured by Net Promoter Score

    CUSTOMER LOYALTY CAN BE MEASURED BY THE NET PROMOTER SCORE (NPS) The NPS is a standard retail industry measure used to determine a customers’ loyalty that can provide insight into the customer experience and how likely that customer is to both come back to the store / brand as well as recommend the

  17. Slide 17: ODP's Small Business Customer Loyalty Is Poor

    ODP’S SMALL BUSINESS CUSTOMER LOYALTY IS POOR Office Depot has fewer loyal small business customers than its competitors across its three key categories, Office Supplies, Office Equipment, and Business Services, based on its Net Promoter Scores (NPS)(1), an industry standard metric for loyalty compa

  18. Slide 18: ODP's Consumer Loyalty Is Below Average

    ODP’S CONSUMER LOYALTY IS BELOW AVERAGE Among consumers, loyalty (as measured by Net Promoter Score(1)) to Office Depot is comparable to its peers in Office Supplies, but it is significantly lower in Office Equipment and Business Services Average Target industry rate (>40%) Office Supplies Office Eq

  19. Slide 19: ODP Is Losing Its Customer Franchise

    ODP IS LOSING ITS CUSTOMER FRANCHISE ODP’s most loyal customers are less loyal than the competition’s. The loyalty advantage enjoyed by Staples manifests itself in “customer stickiness,” making Staples customers more intensely loyal to Staples than loyal ODP and OMX customers are to their brands Per

  20. Slide 20: Declining comparable store sales despite management statements

    ODP IS LOSING ITS CUSTOMER FRANCHISE For several years, Office Depot’s comparable store sales have continuously declined, despite management’s repeated optimistic statements about improvement initiatives in the North American Retail Division (NAR) Key Retail Metrics(1)(2) ODP Presentation Transcript

  21. Slide 21: ODP Is Losing Its Customer Franchise: Conclusions

    ODP IS LOSING ITS CUSTOMER FRANCHISE Conclusions… • In a segment with already low customer loyalty, Staples dominates Office Depot across the board • While most all of Office Depot’s loyalty scores are far below both target levels and its competitors levels, Office Depot’s SMB loyalty lags the most,

  22. Slide 22: ODP Is Failing Strategically and Operationally

    ODP IS FAILING STRATEGICALLY AND OPERATIONALLY

  23. Slide 23: ODP Has Poorly Managed Gross Margins

    ODP HAS POORLY MANAGED GROSS MARGINS ACROSS SEVERAL DIMENSIONS ODP has consistently under performed its competitors in recent years in gross margin and operating profitability Gross Margin % Operating Profit % 35% 10% 30% 8% 25% 6% 20% 4% 15% 2% 10% 0% 5% -2% 0% -4% ODP (Adj.) SPLS OMX ODP SPLS OMX

  24. Slide 24: ODP's G&A Expenses Are Bloated

    ODP’S G&A EXPENSES ARE BLOATED From 2007 to 2012, Office Depot’s revenue declined $4.8 billion, yet G&A expenses actually increased $27 million over the same time period. As a result, total G&A expenses increased from 4.2% of revenue in 2007 to 6.3% of revenue in 2012, and G&A expenses per store inc

  25. Slide 25: G&A bloated across IT, Finance and Merchandising

    ODP’S G&A EXPENSES ARE BLOATED Based on our research, we believe that the Company’s G&A expenses are bloated across several categories, including Information Technology, Finance, and Merchandising, and are significantly higher than “median” benchmark performance for global retailers Information Tech

  26. Slide 26: ODP's Advertising Expenses Are Excessive and Inefficient

    ODP’S ADVERTISING EXPENSES ARE EXCESSIVE AND INEFFICIENT Office Depot’s advertising expenses are substantially higher as a percentage of revenue than their peers In 2012, Office Depot spent $372 million, or 3.5% of revenue, on advertising expenses, versus Staples, which spent $534 million, or 2.2% o

  27. Slide 27: Advertising mix is inefficient

    ODP’S ADVERTISING EXPENSES ARE EXCESSIVE AND INEFFICIENT Furthermore, the mix of Office Depot’s advertising expenditures is inefficient • We believe that the vast majority of Office Depot’s advertising dollars are spent on expensive, low ROI channels including television and print (including catalog

  28. Slide 28: Advertising expense above benchmarks across segments

    ODP’S ADVERTISING EXPENSES ARE EXCESSIVE AND INEFFICIENT Across all three of its business segments, we estimate that Office Depot’s advertising expense-to- revenue ratios are also significantly higher than industry benchmarks Advertising Expenses Opportunities ($ in thousands) 2012 ODP ($000) NAR BS

  29. Slide 29: ODP's Distribution Expenses Are Well Above Peer Levels

    ODP’S DISTRIBUTION EXPENSES ARE WELL ABOVE PEER LEVELS ODP has an opportunity to improve profitability by implementing key actions to achieve “median” benchmark performance for Distribution expense ODP’s distribution and warehouse network is less efficient than peers due to: • Reliance on expensive

  30. Slide 30: Failure to Implement Effective SKU Rationalization

    MANAGEMENT HAS FAILED TO IMPLEMENT EFFECTIVE SKU RATIONALIZATION ODP is over-assorted in stores and under-assorted online • With approximately 10,000 SKUs per store, Office Depot is carrying more SKUs in its stores relative to Staples at approximately 7,000 SKUs, resulting in slower inventory turns,

  31. Slide 31: Potential SKU and Supplier Count Opportunity

    POTENTIAL SKU AND SUPPLIER COUNT OPPORTUNITY By rationalizing its excessive SKU count and supply base, Office Depot has an opportunity to improve profitability by $33 million SKU Count Opportunity ($ in thousands) NAR BSD Total 2012 Revenue(1) $4,458,000 $3,215,000 $7,673,000 COGS (2) $3,044,000 $1,

  32. Slide 32: Private Label Strategy Is Flawed – Direct Sourcing

    ODP’S PRIVATE LABEL STRATEGY IS FLAWED – DIRECT SOURCING Office Depot’s direct sourcing mix of private label products is too low, which indicates that gross margins and profitability should also be higher • The margin benefit of direct sourced, private label SKUs is approximately 400 to 600 basis po

  33. Slide 33: Private Label Strategy Is Flawed – SKU Differentiation

    ODP’S PRIVATE LABEL STRATEGY IS FLAWED – SKU DIFFERENTIATION Further, the execution of Office Depot’s private label program does not provide a clear value alternative to the customer, resulting in customer confusion and possible lost sales • Note the convoluted shredder offerings at Office Depot sto

  34. Slide 34: Private label pricing lacks logic versus national brands

    ODP’S PRIVATE LABEL STRATEGY IS FLAWED – SKU DIFFERENTIATION We also observed some Private Label products being priced at or higher than some of the national brands with superior features Lack of Pricing Logic between Different Private Label and National Brand Products (1) Capacity Brand Price ($) C

  35. Slide 35: ODP Has a Low Mix of High-Margin Services

    ODP HAS A LOW MIX OF HIGH-MARGIN SERVICES Office Depot is significantly underpenetrated in the sale of high-margin services, including copy and print, shipping and tech support • Services generally carry gross margins of approximately 60% compared to Office Depot’s average store gross margins of app

  36. Slide 36: High Mix of Low-Margin Enterprise Customers

    ODP HAS A HIGH MIX OF LOW-MARGIN ENTERPRISE CUSTOMERS The mix of large, low-margin enterprise customers in Office Depot’s Business Solutions Division is significantly higher than the competition Business Solutions Division Customer Mix (1) • Office Depot has a long history of incentivizing its BSD s

  37. Slide 37: Incentivizing on Profit Rather Than Revenue

    INCENTIVIZING BASED ON PROFIT RATHER THAN REVENUE CAN RESULT IN SIGNIFICANT IMPROVEMENT IN FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE • W.B. Mason is a distributor of office products to businesses in New England and other states on the East Coast • By focusing on the SMB and incentivizing its sales force based on operat

  38. Slide 38: ODP's Web Capability Lacks Key Features

    ODP’S WEB CAPABILITY LACKS KEY FEATURES AFFECTING PROFITABILITY There are weaknesses in the current website(s) that result in reduced site traffic, reduced conversion/sales, and higher operational costs than competitors Weakness Implication • No personalization evident on Personalization website & •

  39. Slide 39: ODP Is Failing Strategically and Operationally: Conclusions

    ODP IS FAILING STRATEGICALLY AND OPERATIONALLY Conclusions… • ODP failed to move deep enough and fast enough on operating expense reductions • Assortment optimization, direct sourcing, and SKU right-sizing can produce significant margin improvement • ODP’s Private Label strategy must be overhauled •

  40. Slide 40: Summary of Efficiency & Effectiveness Opportunities

    SUMMARY OF EFFICIENCY & EFFECTIVENESS OPPORTUNITIES In $ Million $600 $38 $503 $500 $33 $122 $400 $95 $300 $215 $200 $100 $0 G&A Advertising Distribution SKU/Supplier Direct Total E&E Rationalization Sourcing Opportunity 40

  41. Slide 41: ODP's New Real Estate Strategy Is Flawed

    ODP’S NEW REAL ESTATE STRATEGY IS FLAWED

  42. Slide 42: Current North American Retail Real Estate Strategy Has Failed

    ODP’S CURRENT NORTH AMERICAN RETAIL REAL ESTATE STRATEGY HAS FAILED • According to ODP’s 10-Q SEC filing for Q3, 2012: – In the third quarter of 2012, impairment charges were taken for 360 stores, over 30% of total 1,114 stores – Approximately 230 stores will be reduced to salvage value of $7 millio

  43. Slide 43: ODP Plans to Dramatically Alter Its Real Estate Footprint

    ODP PLANS TO DRAMATICALLY ALTER ITS REAL ESTATE FOOTPRINT • A significant number of ODP stores have leases for renewal over the next 5 years – At end of 2012, ODP operated 1,112 stores in North America – Over the next three years, approximately 440 stores (40% of store base) have leases up for renew

  44. Slide 44: ODP Has Outlined Optimistic Financial Benefits

    ODP HAS OUTLINED OPTIMISTIC FINANCIAL BENEFITS • According to ODP(1), after remodeling, small stores (6,000 sqft footprint) will: – Retain 90% of revenue – Reduce SKU count per store by as much as 50% – Achieve significant savings in rent expenses due to smaller store footprint • ODP believes that t

  45. Slide 45: These Assumptions Are Unrealistic

    THESE ASSUMPTIONS ARE UNREALISTIC The assumption by Office Depot that it will retain 90% of its sales in its small store format (6,000 square feet), implies that revenue per square foot will be $600, compared to the current format of only $175 per square foot Store Format Square Foot Rev / Store ($K

  46. Slide 46: Questioning Profitability of Small Format Stores

    WE QUESTION THE ACTUAL PROFITABILITY OF ODP’S SMALL FORMAT STORES Assuming a more realistic, but still difficult to achieve revenue per square foot for the small format store of $300/sqft, which is still higher than that of Staples and off-price stores leader TJ Maxx (both at $285/sqft) and 70% high

  47. Slide 47: Medium-Format Conversion Has Better Chance of Success

    THE CONVERSION TO MEDIUM-FORMAT STORES HAS A FAR BETTER CHANCE OF SUCCESS Our initial analysis suggests that converting current stores to a medium size format (with $267 sales / sqft) has a much better chance of success, and will be accretive to ODP’s profitability All $ figures are in thousand exce

  48. Slide 48: Impact to Operating Profit

    IMPACT TO OPERATING PROFIT If the current store strategy is executed as planned, ODP will spend $300 million in capital expenditures over 5 years and result in a negative annual impact of $103 million in operating profit (note: 2012 adjusted operating profit is $96 million) All $ figures are in thou

  49. Slide 49: Conclusion on Current Real Estate Strategy

    CONCLUSION ON CURRENT REAL ESTATE STRATEGY • Current strategy has low likelihood of success – Large scale success for small format stores requires heretofore unachieved sales productivity by any OSS retailer – Small format stores may work in selected locations to replace current underperforming stor

  50. Slide 50: Total Margin Improvement Opportunities

    TOTAL MARGIN IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES After implementing our plan, we believe that ODP has the opportunity to achieve $776 million in annual EBIT (7.3% margin) after full implementation of the Efficiency & Effectiveness Initiatives and the Growth Strategy Annual EBIT Run Rate After Full Implementat

  51. Slide 51: Efficiency and Effectiveness Initiatives Details

    EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS INITIATIVES DETAILS

  52. Slide 52: Potential G&A Expense Opportunity

    POTENTIAL G&A EXPENSE OPPORTUNITY We believe Office Depot has a significant opportunity to improve profitability by approximately $215 million by implementing key actions to achieve “median” benchmark performance for G&A expense G&A Expense Opportunity ($ in thousands) Total 2012 Sales: $10,695,000

  53. Slide 53: G&A Key Action Levers

    POTENTIAL G&A EXPENSE OPPORTUNITY Key action levers to achieve benchmark performance include: Key Action Levers Details Global service delivery model rationalization • Expansion of shared services to support NAR, BSD and INT • Rationalize/consolidate local support • Expand global transaction process

  54. Slide 54: Potential Advertising Expense Opportunity

    POTENTIAL ADVERTISING EXPENSE OPPORTUNITY We believe Office Depot has a significant opportunity to improve profitability by approximately $95 million by reducing advertising expenses and more effectively allocating advertising dollars, with a focus on ROI Advertising Expense Opportunity ($ in thousa

  55. Slide 55: Advertising Key Action Levers

    POTENTIAL ADVERTISING EXPENSE OPPORTUNITY Key action levers to achieve benchmark performance include: North American Retail Key Action Levers Details Evaluate media mix / efficacy (e.g., print, TV, online) • Evaluate return / lift of media spending by type • Determine appropriate allocation of adver

  56. Slide 56: Potential Distribution Expense Opportunity

    POTENTIAL DISTRIBUTION EXPENSE OPPORTUNITY We believe Office Depot has a significant opportunity to improve profitability by approximately $122 million by addressing its relatively high distribution expenses ODP’s distribution and warehouse network is less efficient than peers due to: • Reliance on

  57. Slide 57: Distribution Key Action Levers

    POTENTIAL DISTRIBUTION EXPENSE OPPORTUNITY Key action levers to achieve benchmark performance include: Key Action Levers Details Increasing direct import volume • Reduce or eliminate reliance on third party logistics service providers for imported products Facility consolidation • Reduce number of U

  58. Slide 58: Potential Private Label Direct Sourcing Opportunity

    POTENTIAL PRIVATE LABEL DIRECT SOURCING OPPORTUNITY We believe Office Depot has an opportunity to improve profitability by approximately $38 million by significantly increasing its mix of direct sourced, private label SKUs • We believe there is an opportunity to increase direct sourced, private labe

  59. Slide 59: Private Label Direct Sourcing Actions

    POTENTIAL PRIVATE LABEL DIRECT SOURCING OPPORTUNITY Office Depot must: Key Action Levers Details Drive direct sourcing as the preferred alternative to • Expand and accelerate direct sourcing capabilities sourcing through agents, with select exceptions based • Assign aggressive targets by category fo

  60. Slide 60: Potential SKU and Supplier Count Opportunity

    POTENTIAL SKU AND SUPPLIER COUNT OPPORTUNITY By rationalizing its excessive SKU count and supply base, Office Depot has an opportunity to improve profitability by $33 million SKU Count Opportunity ($ in thousands) NAR BSD Total 2012 Revenue $4,458,000 $3,215,000 $7,673,000 COGS (1) $3,044,000 $1,969

  61. Slide 61: SKU and Supplier Key Improvement Actions

    POTENTIAL SKU AND SUPPLIER COUNT OPPORTUNITY Key Improvement Actions: Key Action Levers Details Realigning the private label strategy • Develop a “good, better, best” product assortment • Develop a more effective line logic • Standardize pricing standards Consolidating the supplier base to reallocat

  62. Slide 62: Potential Services Opportunity

    POTENTIAL SERVICES OPPORTUNITY We believe Office Depot has an opportunity to improve profitability by approximately $16 million to $47 million by significantly increasing its mix of high-margin services as a percentage of revenue The analysis below shows the operating income benefits if service reve

  63. Slide 63: Potential Business Customer Mix Opportunity

    POTENTIAL BUSINESS CUSTOMER MIX OPPORTUNITY By increasing Business Solutions Division’s (BSD) mix of highly-profitable SMB customers, and decreasing the mix of low-margin enterprise customers, by 10% to 15%, we estimate that Office Depot could improve profitability by $32 million to $48 million The

  64. Slide 64: Summary and Risk Adjustment – Efficiency & Effectiveness

    SUMMARY AND RISK ADJUSTMENT – EFFICIENCY & EFFECTIVENESS OPPORTUNITIES In $ Million $600 $38 $503 $178 $500 $33 $122 $400 $325 $95 $300 $215 $200 $100 $0 64

  65. Slide 65: Growth Strategy

    GROWTH STRATEGY

  66. Slide 66: Significant Opportunities With Existing Asset Base

    THERE ARE SIGNIFICANT OPPORTUNITIES WITH THE EXISTING ASSET BASE TO DRIVE SUBSTANTIAL GROWTH Office Depot should not only focus on operational improvement, but also explore opportunities to reach more customers and offer solutions rather than simply products or services • Core assets already in plac

  67. Slide 67: Becoming a Complete Solutions Provider to SMB

    BECOMING A COMPLETE SOLUTIONS PROVIDER TO SMB Office Depot should focus on building and extending it customer appeal through enabling omni- channel capabilities combined with new solutions and solutions focus • Develop omni-channel capabilities to serve SMB’s and other customers regardless of how th

  68. Slide 68: Opportunities on Internet Platform

    OPPORTUNITIES ON INTERNET PLATFORM Office Depot has an opportunity to leverage its on-line platform to provide more products and services to SMB’s and consumers • Although it is the 5th largest online retailer, Office Depot lags Staples (#2 behind only Amazon) in expanding into the internet platform

  69. Slide 69: Driving New Value Within ODP

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP Our vision is to focus on the needs of the SMB target customer, deliver crisp value propositions to serve their needs, and draw others who are attracted to the value propositions Mix of Segment Revenue (1) Margin Rate 35% +1000 bps 35% SPLS35% ODP 65% SPLS 65% 65% SMB Al

  70. Slide 70: SMB Core Needs From Focus Groups

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP SMB’s have told us what a provider needs to demonstrate to win their loyalty We conducted focus groups, online surveys, and individual interviews of SMB owners and purchasing managers, and heard the following: Respect Me and My Time CORE NEEDS Reward Me $ “I wouldn’t go

  71. Slide 71: Four Growth Strategy Pillars

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP To address the SMB’s core needs, ODP must implement four Growth Strategy to reposition themselves as the provider of choice Core Needs • Respect Me and My Time • My Business is My Life • Reward Me GROWTH STRATEGY TO ADDRESS CORE NEEDS Services / Engagement True Omni- Rei

  72. Slide 72: New Engagement Model

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – NEW ENGAGEMENT MODEL Our changes will transform the customer relationship with ODP from “Order Taking” to “Solution Selling” • Declining average order value • Declining traffic • Interaction with staff in stores and BSD Evidence of • Online lack of personalization/ rec

  73. Slide 73: New Engagement Model: Revenue and Operating Profit Impact

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – NEW ENGAGEMENT MODEL Our changes will transform the customer relationship with ODP from “Order Taking” to “Solution Selling” Revenue and Operating Profit Impact $500 $442 $400 $290 $ in millions $300 $164 $200 $66 $54 $89 $100 $12 $22 $- $(17) $(1) $(100) 2013 2014 201

  74. Slide 74: New Engagement Model Key Action Levers

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – NEW ENGAGEMENT MODEL Key action levers to achieve benchmark performance include: Key Action Levers Details Institutionalize a selling culture • Implement customer selling and engagement model • Align store labor model and schedule to emphasize customer engagement Deplo

  75. Slide 75: True Omni-Channel Presence

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – TRUE OMNI-CHANNEL PRESENCE In the new ODP Omni-Channel model, associates will have real-time, in depth knowledge of individual customers in order to better serve them regardless of channel • Online performance lagging those of industry leaders • Low presence of SMB in

  76. Slide 76: Omni-Channel: Revenue and Operating Profit Impact

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – TRUE OMNI-CHANNEL PRESENCE In the new ODP Omni-Channel model, associates will have real-time, in depth knowledge of individual customers in order to better serve them regardless of channel Revenue and Operating Profit Impact $250 $198 $200 $144 $ in millions $150 $93 $

  77. Slide 77: Omni-Channel Key Action Levers

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – TRUE OMNI-CHANNEL PRESENCE Key action levers to achieve benchmark performance include: Key Action Levers Details Customer experience in all channels will be uniquely • Implement tailored customer engagement model tailored to their needs and preferences based on segment

  78. Slide 78: New Loyalty Program

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – NEW LOYALTY PROGRAM The new ODP loyalty program is simple to understand, convenient to use, and drives increased shopping frequency and spend • NPS scores and customer interviews demonstrated that Evidence of there is little loyalty in this industry, and customers woul

  79. Slide 79: Loyalty Program: Revenue and Operating Profit Impact

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – NEW LOYALTY PROGRAM The new ODP loyalty program is simple to understand, convenient to use, and drives increased shopping frequency and spend Revenue and Operating Profit Impact $350 $267 $297 $326 $300 $250 $ in millions $219 $200 $150 $118 $100 $22 $24 $27 $50 $5 $16

  80. Slide 80: Loyalty Program Key Action Levers

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – NEW LOYALTY PROGRAM Key action levers to achieve benchmark performance include: Key Action Levers Details Create an industry-leading customer loyalty program • Eliminate points and redemption process that is easy to understand and easy to use • Implement standard perce

  81. Slide 81: Service / Category Extensions

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – SERVICE / CATEGORY EXTENSIONS ODP will add key adjacent products/services to increase their share of the customers’ spend • Percent of sales in services and high margin products is low Evidence of compared to major competitors and industry leaders Problem • Enter / acc

  82. Slide 82: Service / Category Extensions: Revenue and Operating Profit Impact

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – SERVICE / CATEGORY EXTENSIONS ODP will add key adjacent products/services to increase their share of the customers’ spend Revenue and Operating Profit Impact $1,000 $938 $714 $800 $ in millions $600 $514 $400 $317 $245 $177 $179 $200 $39 $59 $12 $- 2013 2014 2015 2016

  83. Slide 83: Service / Category Extensions Key Action Levers

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP – SERVICE / CATEGORY EXTENSIONS Key action levers to achieve benchmark performance include: Key Changes Details Enter / accelerate adjacent categories with growing • Mobile phones and activation in store demand among SMB’s – Partner with mobile service providers to provi

  84. Slide 84: 14 Tests to Uncover Winning Propositions

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP In addition to addressing the enablers, ODP must immediately begin conducting tests to determine customer and market acceptance Enablers 14 Tests to Uncover Winning Propositions Immediately My Office In-store Promising Solution Preferred Engagement Away From Workshops Bu

  85. Slide 85: Description of Concepts to Be Tested

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP Description of concepts to be tested Today ODP does not easily allow the customer to visualize and • Provide complete solution understand all the pieces and parts that make a complete solution. ODP Solution bundles at package can create visual displays in store and onlin

  86. Slide 86: Description of Concepts to Be Tested

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP Description of concepts to be tested • Appointment-based Small businesses and entrepreneurs often don’t have the resources and access to expertise that larger companies provide. The Business access to professionals Pro network, an appointment-based service in store and o

  87. Slide 87: Description of Concepts to Be Tested

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP Description of concepts to be tested Business customers prefer to do most of their business supplies, • Club-like model equipment and services online and/or with a preferred supplier (with or without an account). But every need isn’t predictable and some stuff can’t • Co

  88. Slide 88: Description of Concepts to Be Tested

    DRIVING NEW VALUE WITHIN ODP Description of concepts to be tested • Setup your web and Most small businesses need help when they are starting out with website design, logo creation, and business cards. But how do they social networking get word out to their target customers that they are in business

  89. Slide 89: We Believe...

    WE BELIEVE... • ODP needs to focus on SMB as the target customer • Sustaining the current operating model will not address the SMB’s needs • There are four transformational enablers that ODP must address to set the stage for growth • There is room in the industry for a new player who will change the

  90. Slide 90: New Real Estate Strategy

    NEW REAL ESTATE STRATEGY

  91. Slide 91: New Real Estate Strategy – Medium Size Stores

    NEW REAL ESTATE STRATEGY – MEDIUM SIZE STORES • Our initial analysis suggests that converting current stores to medium size format has much better chances of success, and will be accretive to ODP’s profitability All $ figures are in thousand except square footage & Current Store (1) Medium Format St

  92. Slide 92: Replace Large Store With Smaller/Medium Stores in Selected Markets

    NEW REAL ESTATE STRATEGY – REPLACE LARGE STORE WITH 2 OR MORE SMALLER/MEDIUM STORES IN SELECTED LOCAL MARKETS • In markets with high customer density, it may be advantageous to have two or more smaller stores instead of one giant store – Proximity to more customers in the area – More flexibility in

  93. Slide 93: Allocate Part of Large Store Footprint to Online Orders

    NEW REAL ESTATE STRATEGY – ALLOCATE PART OF THE LARGE STORE FOOTPRINT TO FULFILL ONLINE ORDERS • For large stores with long-term leases, part of the store may be converted to warehouses to fulfill local online orders – Exploit “comparative” fulfillment advantage based on proximity to customers – Bet

  94. Slide 94: 100 Day Plan

    100 DAY PLAN

  95. Slide 95: Our Plan Is Urgent – Run-Rate Within 12-18 Months

    OUR PLAN IS URGENT – WE INTEND TO ACHIEVE RUN-RATE VELOCITY WITHIN 12-18 MONTHS Subsequent planning and implementation work will follow the initial 100 Days that will be required to achieve run rate savings within a 12 to 18 month time frame I. Strategic and II. Optimize Current Refine Operational S

  96. Slide 96: Total Margin Improvement Opportunities

    TOTAL MARGIN IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES After implementing our plan, we believe that ODP has the opportunity to achieve $776 million in annual EBIT (7.3% margin) after full implementation of the Efficiency & Effectiveness Initiatives and the Growth Strategy Annual EBIT Run Rate After Full Implementat

  97. Slide 97: Summary Level Plan

    SUMMARY LEVEL PLAN The work plan is aligned against the business case objectives and organized by our major efficiency & effectiveness initiatives and the strategic growth enablers Potential Day 1 Day 100 EBIT Improvement $M Business Unit Strategic Review --- Efficiency & Effectiveness G&A $215 Adve

  98. Slide 98: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Business Unit Strategic Review Assess North American Retail Business Unit Strategy review and SWOT Current/Project Performance P&L/Assets/Operational Metrics Forecast/Trajectory review Capabilities review Organization and Talent

  99. Slide 99: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s G&A Review current investment portfolio Capital and Expense IT new development Store capital - Open, Close, Reset Web Other Build revised/realigned Investment Portfolio u Assess internal general and administrative data Review fi

  100. Slide 100: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Create action plans against G&A targets By Corporate Functional area Retail Field organization Regional District Retail Stores Time Allocation assessment - % cust facing Large format Small format BSD Field organization Direct Co

  101. Slide 101: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Advertising Assess current spend and effectiveness Measure effectiveness and historical trend By Advertising channel Print TV/Radio Web Mobile Social Validate against hypotheses u Advertising Agency assessment Benchmark agency e

  102. Slide 102: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Store Model - U.S. Footprint Assess store performance of various models/sizes current deployed Against competition Customer perception of each Risk adjust based on length of time in market Validate against hypothesis u Against p

  103. Slide 103: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Real Estate - U.S. Quick-Hit Real Estate assessment Review current Real Estate plan Pareto assessment By market penetration versus competitor By lease length and strength By store size Validate against hypotheses Prioritize chan

  104. Slide 104: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Distribution Assess Physical Supply Chain DC and Transportation Network Design Transportation Inbound from Supplier DC and Direct to Store Reverse Logistics Carrier Management Distribution ` Receiving, Putaway, Picking, Fulfillm

  105. Slide 105: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Merchandising - Pricing, Buying, Sourcing Assess Merchandising effectiveness Against Price, Mix/SKU Rationalization, Sourcing Across direct, web, retail Across branded and private label Validate against hypotheses Assess Merchan

  106. Slide 106: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Merchandising - Store Reset Process Assess Store Merch Reset capability Review current store level merch reset process Against internal goals and external benchmarks Cost, Lift, Operational execution Create action plans and asse

  107. Slide 107: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Merger Planning and Preparation External Assessment of Merger Partner Similar Diligence Process to ODP Assessment Research to Understand Current Customer Validate Assumptions in Merger Business Case Assess Strategic Consideratio

  108. Slide 108: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Engagement Model Assess Sales Effectiveness BSD selling model Retail selling model Validate against hypotheses Compensation and incentive model Services delivery effectiveness Internally delivered 3rd Party delivered Assess Cust

  109. Slide 109: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Omni-Channel Assess core capabilities Scalability/Flexibility/Horizontal integration By sales channel By customer experience Create Capability map Assess core Systems Assess key systems required to support change Stability/Scala

  110. Slide 110: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Loyalty Program Assess internal customer data and insights Validate against hypotheses Compare to brand promise Compare to competitors Measure all significant change plans against VPs Create Customer Segments Perform a customer

  111. Slide 111: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s Services / Category Extensions Select new Categories Review currently in-process innovation pipeline Validate against hypotheses u Select new Services Compensation and incentive model ` Services delivery effectiveness Internally

  112. Slide 112: Detailed Level Plan

    DETAILED LEVEL PLAN Week Statu Owner 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 s 100 Day Plan Deployment Implement Program and Project Management Teams and tools in place Change Management process in place Put Governance in place Decision making, scorecarding, reporting Steering Committee assigned and up and

  113. Slide 113: The End

    STARI BOARBAYALU Ee THE END 113

Office Depot — Proxy Contest (August 2013) on 6ix