Primo Water — Proxy Contest (April 2023)
78 slides from Primo Water's proxy contest presentation, Apr 5, 2023
Slide 1: Primo Water Corporation
Primo Water Corporation (TSX / NYSE: PRMW) www.PurifyThePrimoBoard.com April 2023
Slide 2: Table of Contents
Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 Case for Change 3 Executive Compensation & Governance 4 Directors Targeted for Replacement 5 Legion’s Highly Qualified Nominees 6 Appendix FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 12/31/2022) 2 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 3: Legion Partners
Section Legion Partners 1 Overview ▪ SEC-registered investment advisor based in Los Angeles, CA; founded in 2012 ▪ Investment team with over 45 years combined activist experience ▪ Proven track record of effective shareholder engagement Drive Value Through Activism ▪ Align the interests of company b
Slide 4: Legion Has Led Wide Range of Prior Engagements
Section Legion Has Led Wide Range of Prior Engagements1 1 Strategy & Operations Capital Allocation Leadership Corporate Governance Investor Communication Strategic Alternatives Note: 1. Logos represent examples of exited investments which were selected by Legion Partners Asset Management (LPAM) 4 to
Slide 5: Legion's Nominees Have the Right Mix of Expertise
Section Legion’s Nominees Have the Right Mix of Expertise 1 Legion Nominees: Derek Lewis Tim Hasara Public Board Seasoned beverage operational executive with 35+ Founder, Managing Partner and CIO at Sinnet Capital years of experience at PepsiCo and a recognized with 27+ years of proven investment tr
Slide 6: Business Overview
Section Business Overview 1 Primo Water is a distributor of water and dispensers to consumers and businesses in North America, Europe, and Israel ▪ Portfolio of strong brands across 21 countries ▪ Market leader in Home/Office Delivery (HOD), refill, exchange and water dispensers ▪ Offers water at wi
Slide 7: Primo Provides a Broad Spectrum of Sustainable Water Solutions
Section Primo Provides a Broad Spectrum of Sustainable Water Solutions 1 Primo has full end-to-end offering in water with a business spanning both the “razor” and “razorblade” that should increase household penetration over time Advanced-level – Entry-level – Value Convenience (low cost per gallon)
Slide 8: Campaign to refresh a stale and insular Board
This campaign is about refreshing a stale and insular Board with experts in water delivery, beverage operations, marketing and finance who can immediately begin to help unlock Primo’s full value
Slide 9: Why Are We Running This Campaign?
Section Why Are We Running This Campaign? 1 Board Is Broken & Our Nominees Can Poor Track Record Needs Refreshment Create Value ▪ Long-term TSR underperformance ▪ Board is controlled by two ex-CEOs ▪ Our nominees' experience vs. peers and indices of Legacy Primo and the Company addresses key gaps th
Slide 10: PRMW Shares Have Materially Underperformed
Section PRMW Shares Have Materially Underperformed 1 The Company’s Total Shareholder Returns (TSR) have been disappointing, persistently lagging its peers and relevant indices PRMW Relative TSR vs. Peer Groups and Major Benchmarks PRMW vs. 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year Legion-Selected Peers1 (7%) (22%) (83%)
Slide 11: Primo's Own TSR Report Card Appears to be an F
Section Primo’s Own TSR Report Card Appears to be an “F” 1 The Company’s TSR analysis from 2022 Annual Report $100 invested in PRMW on 12/30/2017 is worth $101 on 12/31/2022. If you invested $100 in the Peer Group over the same period, it would be worth ~70% more at $173 Source: Company Annual Repor
Slide 12: Primo Valuation
Section Primo Valuation 1 We believe improving the Board could allow substantial value creation for shareholders Improve margins ~130% potential Improve organic from optimizing Valuation upside through Status Quo sales growth efficiency and Re-Rating driving growth and rationalizing SG&A profitabili
Slide 13: Substantial Board Refresh is Needed to Unlock Value
Section Substantial Board Refresh is Needed to Unlock Value 1 Board Replacement Targets To Retire Jeremy Fowden Billy Prim Eric Rosenfeld Greg Monahan Stephen Halperin Lead Independent Director Director Chairman Director Director ESG/Nom Comm. Chair HR/Comp Comm. Chair Former PRMW CEO Former Legacy
Slide 14: Primo Stakeholders Deserve New Board Leadership
Section Primo Stakeholders Deserve New Board Leadership 1 We believe Primo’s management, employees, customers and stockholders all deserve new Board leadership that is highly experienced ▪ Water Delivery Experience: to evaluate and improve Primo’s operational performance and implement detailed value
Slide 15: Legion's Nominees Bring the Right Skills and Experience to Primo
Section Legion’s Nominees Bring the Right Skills and Experience to Primo 1 Primo’s incumbent directors are far outmatched by Legion’s Nominees whose backgrounds and experience are directly relevant to the Company’s future and integral to its success PRMW Beverage Beverage Finance & ESG & Name Key Ba
Slide 16: Third-Party Analysts Recognize the Need for Change
Section Third-Party Analysts Recognize the Need for Change 1 “Outside of an occasional spasm, Primo Water (PRMW) has basically traded in the mid-teens for the past five years. Some would call that underwhelming. Others would call it “chronic underperformance”…CEO Tom Harrington is 65 “…we think Legi
Slide 17: Legion's Engagement with Primo
Section Legion’s Engagement with Primo 1 100 minutes – that is the sum of the time Primo’s management team wanted to spend answering our questions on their business and performance – we believe this is because they understand our questions are hard to answer given their lackluster performance ▪ We h
Slide 18: Legion Forced to Litigate to Permit Shareholders to Vote
Legion Forced to Litigate to Permit Shareholders to Section 1 Vote on All Four of Its Nominees A Board should not be permitted to weaponize its bylaws to invalidate a nomination – shareholders should have a choice and if a Board believes a nominee is not qualified, it can raise its concerns with sha
Slide 19: Timeline of Recent Entrenchment Tactics
Section Timeline of Recent Entrenchment Tactics 1 Date Event 3/25/21 Company files definitive proxy materials proposing a continuance under the OBCA that is bundled with new bylaws containing more restrictive advance notice bylaw provisions 4/15/21 ISS recommends AGAINST the continuance proposal not
Slide 20: PRMW Needs to #PurifyThePrimoBoard
Section PRMW Needs to #PurifyThePrimoBoard 1 We urge fellow stockholders to vote the WHITE proxy card to elect strong and proven industry leaders to the Board ▪ Legion’s nominees will seek to oversee: ✓ Restore profit and revive growth of Water Direct through improving field sales, addressing custom
Slide 21: Table of Contents
Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 Case for Change 3 Executive Compensation & Governance 4 Directors Targeted for Replacement 5 Legion’s Highly Qualified Nominees 6 Appendix FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 12/31/2022) 21 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 22: Case for Change
Section Case for Change 2 1. Organic growth has not materialized 2. Marketing is broken a. Marketing department has essentially been terminated b. Brand strategy lacks focus and efficiency c. App and digital marketing are broken 3. Capital expenditures have ballooned over time 4. Peer benchmarking i
Slide 23: 1. Organic growth has not materialized
Section 2 1. Organic growth has not materialized 23 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 24: The Water Industry Has Shown Resilient Growth
Section The Water Industry Has Shown Resilient Growth 2 Primo’s management team has repeatedly touted industry growth: However, as we show on the next slides, the growing end market hasn’t translated into any significant growth of any of Primo’s customer or location metrics Source: Company Presentat
Slide 25: Roll Up or Cover Up?
Section Roll Up or Cover Up? 2 Primo has executed over 120 tuck-in acquisitions since 2014 and over 70 since 2018, and we estimate that Primo has spent around $220 million on tuck-in acquisitions since 2018 “Tuck-in mergers and acquisitions are part of our DNA. The acquisitions build scale, acquire
Slide 26: Primo Water Direct Has Lost As Many Customers As Acquired
Section Primo Water Direct Has Lost As Many Customers As Acquired 2 Tuck-in acquisitions have resulted in zero customer growth ??? Instead of net 2.4m route-based Primo spent Theoretically, Primo Water Direct organic customer customers pro $220m on 70+ Primo should have has same number increase, Pri
Slide 27: Little Progress Has Been Made on Location Growth
Section Little Progress Has Been Made on Location Growth 2 Growth opportunities seemed to have disappeared – we believe this is because management lacks the ability to sell and not because there are a lack of great location targets At the time of Legacy Primo acquisition: Dispensers Exchange Refill
Slide 28: Primo Has Not Achieved the Acquisition Promise
Section Primo Has Not Achieved the Acquisition Promise 2 Primo has made little progress cross pollinating Water Exchange and Refill locations Cross- pollination opportunity is HUGE “Glacier has broad placements throughout U.S. and within Canada. It is important to note that there is little to no ove
Slide 29: Broken Customer Service Leads to High Attrition
Section Broken Customer Service Leads to High Attrition 2 Primo needs to focus on addressing a flood of customer complaints “Nothing in PRIMO works. They would deliver the water to my front door, back door. etc. Never pick up the empties…I have 12 5-gallon water bottles, empty with $5.00 deposit on
Slide 30: 2a. Marketing department has essentially been terminated
Section 2 2a. Marketing department has essentially been terminated 30 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 31: Marketing Department Has Significant Recent Turnover
Section Marketing Department Has Significant Recent Turnover 2 At least half of the marketing department has left Primo since early 2022, leaving the organization with a significant capability void Left Primo Cate Gutowski COO No Replacement Yet Remains Oct 2021 – Jan 2023 We learned that majority o
Slide 32: It Appears the High-Profile COO Hire Did Not Go Well
Section It Appears the High-Profile COO Hire Did Not Go Well 2 “We think this is an interesting hire for PRMW given Ms. Gutowski’s experience (most of PRMW leadership are legacy Cott/DS/Primo) and likely signals a desire to accelerate digital penetration of the business, as well as further evidence
Slide 33: 2b. Brand strategy lacks focus and efficiency
Section 2 2b. Brand strategy lacks focus and efficiency 33 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 34: Multi-Brand Strategy Seems Problematic
Section Multi-Brand Strategy Seems Problematic 2 We struggle to understand why Primo chooses to keep all 15+ water delivery brands (with less than a handful of marketing people) – we believe consolidating under core brands should improve marketing efficiency and effectiveness Primo Brand Market Posi
Slide 35: 2c. App and digital marketing are broken
Section 2 2c. App and digital marketing are broken 35 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 36: We Find the Sudden Jump in App Ratings Suspicious
Section We Find the Sudden Jump in App Ratings Suspicious 2 We are deeply concerned that the jump in ratings was not a result of customer satisfaction improvement, but potentially a disingenuous artificial inflation My Water+ App My Water+ App Store Ratings & # of Ratings 1st Reset 2nd Reset Rating:
Slide 37: Website is Hard to Navigate and Fails to Engage Consumers
Section Website is Hard to Navigate and Fails to Engage Consumers 2 Primo’s website is inefficient in directing visitors to a service signup – half of the visitors leave after visiting only the homepage www.water.com www.readyrefresh.com Average Monthly Visits 768k 1,272k Average Visit Duration 1 mi
Slide 38: Search Engine Optimization is Way Behind Competitors
Section Search Engine Optimization is Way Behind Competitors 2 Primo lags its core competitor in both organic and paid search Channel Traffic (Mar 2022 – Feb 2023) 1,521,453 water.com 588,356 522,323 37,995 readyrefresh.com Organic Search (Primo 61% Behind Competitor) Paid Search (Primo 93% Behind C
Slide 39: Social Accounts Lack Real Followers or Engagement
Section Social Accounts Lack Real Followers or Engagement 2 Primo Water’s Facebook and Instagram accounts have minimal engagement despite having many followers, suggesting that Primo may have purchased fake followers to artificially boost their social media status and misrepresent its true influence
Slide 40: 3. Capital expenditures have ballooned over time
Section 2 3. Capital expenditures have ballooned over time 40 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 41: CapEx Guidance Has Significantly Increased
Section CapEx Guidance Has Significantly Increased 2 Primo’s CapEx guidance revealed in November 2021 was substantially higher compared to the post-COVID guidance published in August 2020 Revenue Growth & CapEx Guidance August 2020 November 2021 Annual Revenue Growth % 5.0% 8.0% (High single-digit)
Slide 42: CapEx for 2022 and 2023E is Bloated and Unfocused
Section CapEx for 2022 and 2023E is Bloated and Unfocused 2 Primo spent an extra $50 million in 2022 and plans an incremental $30mm in 2023 and 2024 – for projects that have not been well articulated to investors 2022 and 2023 CapEx 2022 Actual 2023 Projection (Mid-point) Revenue ($m) $2,215 $2,325
Slide 43: 4. Peer benchmarking indicates bloated cost structure
Section 2 4. Peer benchmarking indicates bloated cost structure 43 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 44: Peer Benchmarking Shows Substantial Inefficiencies
Section Peer Benchmarking Shows Substantial Inefficiencies 2 Casella Peer Waste Republic Waste Waste PRMW Average Systems Services Conn. Mgmt. Cintas UniFirst Rollins Date TTM # 10/1/22 12/31/22 12/31/22 12/31/22 12/31/22 11/30/22 11/26/22 12/31/22 Employee count 9,240 3,200 35,000 22,109 49,500 43,
Slide 45: 5. ROIC indicates prolonged value destruction
Section 2 5. ROIC indicates prolonged value destruction 45 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 46: The 2024 12% ROIC Promise Has Evaporated
Section The 2024 12% ROIC Promise Has Evaporated 2 The 12% ROIC target for fiscal 2024 debuted on the November 2021 Investor Day However, in the January 2023 ICR Presentation, the 12% 2024 ROIC target became part of a “Long-Term Growth Algorithm Outlook” without a specific year Source: Company Prese
Slide 47: Has Primo Realized It's Impossible to Achieve 12% by 2024?
Section Has Primo Realized It’s Impossible to Achieve 12% by 2024? 2 Primo’s ROIC has been particularly poor for years and not once exceeded its WACC, which we calculate at 7%1 Fiscal Year ($mm) 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 … 2024 Net Sales $1,791 $1,795 $1,954 $2,073 $2,215 $2,471 Gross Profit $1,024 $
Slide 48: 6. Operational metrics need significant improvement
Section 2 6. Operational metrics need significant improvement 48 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 49: Primo Has a History of Publishing Confusing Charts
Section Primo Has a History of Publishing Confusing Charts 2 Primo has repeatedly provided graphs that are unintelligible and misleading y-axis – appears to be manufactured to disingenuously imply growth x-axis – starting dates cherry-picked (inconsistent dates deeply impacted by the pandemic) Chart
Slide 50: Primo Has Avoided Reporting Key Operational Metrics
Section Primo Has Avoided Reporting Key Operational Metrics 2 Primo offers few KPIs on an inconsistent basis, fewer than legacy businesses – we see big room for improvement Current Metrics Key Metrics Missing ▪ Total Customers ▪ Net Customer Growth (Organic Vs. Acquired) Water Direct ▪ Net New Custo
Slide 51: 7. ESG and DEI miss an ocean of opportunities
Section 2 7. ESG and DEI miss an ocean of opportunities 51 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 52: Primo Should Focus More on ESG and DEI Efforts
Section Primo Should Focus More on ESG and DEI Efforts 2 Upgrades in ESG and DEI efforts should offer huge opportunities for Primo if execution improves and story matches promises ▪ Primo spends millions of dollars annually on carbon offsets to achieve carbon neutrality, but has given minimal effort
Slide 53: Table of Contents
Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 Case for Change 3 Executive Compensation & Governance 4 Directors Targeted for Replacement 5 Legion’s Highly Qualified Nominees 6 Appendix FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 12/31/2022) 53 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 54: Compensation Structure Lacks Shareholder Alignment
Section 3 Compensation Structure Lacks Shareholder Alignment Primo’s compensation program needs a major upgrade in metrics and substantial improvement in disclosures of targets and calculations to produce better alignment with shareholders PRMW Metrics (Weight) Alignment Concerns Proposed Metrics (W
Slide 55: Pattern of Lowering LTIP Target is Alarming
Section 3 Pattern of Lowering LTIP Target is Alarming We were shocked to discover that Primo has revised its LTIP Adj. Pre-Tax Income target downwards significantly for divestitures every year over the past 6 years, BUT has not once adjusted the target upwards for major acquisitions that cost over $
Slide 56: Net Customer Growth Was A Legacy Metric
Section Net Customer Growth Was A Legacy Metric 3 Primo dumped any measure of net customer count additions, which is a key business metric, after finding difficulty in achieving any tangible success on this measure Costco Relationship Compensation Metric ▪ DSS CEO performance-based RSUs to vest over
Slide 57: Better to Be a PRMW Director Than a Shareholder
Section Better to Be a PRMW Director Than a Shareholder 3 PRMW Directors’ base compensation rocketed by 96% from 2009 to 2022, while the Company’s Earnings Per Share1 crashed 83% from $1.08 in 2009 to $0.18 in 2022 Base Director Compensation (in '000) vs. PRMW Diluted EPS $250 $1.08 $235 $1.25 $225
Slide 58: Board Has Weaponized Its Bylaws to Entrench Itself
Section Board Has Weaponized Its Bylaws to Entrench Itself 3 ▪ On November 8, 2022, the Board adopted its most recent iteration of the Bylaws, without shareowner approval, which contain an aggressive form of US-style advance notice provisions, including requiring the completion by nominees of the Co
Slide 59: Table of Contents
Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 Case for Change 3 Executive Compensation & Governance 4 Directors Targeted for Replacement 5 Legion’s Highly Qualified Nominees 6 Appendix FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 12/31/2022) 59 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 60: The Incumbent Board is Misaligned with Shareholders
Section The Incumbent Board is Misaligned with Shareholders 4 Board Chairman, Lead Independent Director and other long-tenured directors sold stock totaling $12.4 million within 20 days of announcing targeted 2024 Adjusted EBITDA on November 4, 2021 – the average selling price of $18.70 was near PRM
Slide 61: Chairman of the Board – Jeremy Fowden
Chairman of the Board – Jeremy Fowden – Section 4 Richly Rewarded for Horrendous Performance As CEO, Jeremy Fowden presided over a failed soft drink and juice strategy, and collected over $47m for these efforts – why he remains on the Board and its Chairman is a total mystery ▪ Fowden has been richl
Slide 62: Billy Prim – Led Legacy Primo's Poor Performance
Section Billy Prim – Led Legacy Primo’s Poor Performance 4 Billy Prim undermanaged Legacy Primo and the stock price under his watch was lackluster at best – we believe he sold Legacy Primo to avoid accountability for his performance ▪ Prim served as CEO of Legacy Primo o From founding Legacy Primo i
Slide 63: Eric Rosenfeld – An Ineffective Lead Independent Director
Section Eric Rosenfeld – An Ineffective Lead Independent Director 4 Eric Rosenfeld joined Primo’s Board at a time when his fund owned a significant stake in Primo – that stake was wound down over a decade ago and yet shareholders are still stuck with him ▪ Rosenfeld originally joined the Board as pa
Slide 64: Greg Monahan – Another Board Fee Collecting Machine
Section Greg Monahan – Another Board Fee Collecting Machine 4 Greg Monahan has received over $2.8m in board fees since joining Primo’s Board, and was oddly awarded extra “special fees” for overseeing acquisitions on several occasions ▪ Monahan was added to the Board with Eric Rosenfeld in 2008 in co
Slide 65: Table of Contents
Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 Case for Change 3 Executive Compensation & Governance 4 Directors Targeted for Replacement 5 Legion’s Highly Qualified Nominees 6 Appendix FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 12/31/2022) 65 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 66: Legion Partners' Nominee: Derek R. Lewis
Section Legion Partners’ Nominee: Derek R. Lewis 5 We believe that Mr. Lewis’ extensive experience in the beverage industry with significant leadership skills in sales and operations coupled with his experience building development programs for multicultural communities and employees make him a valu
Slide 67: Legion Partners' Nominee: Timothy Hasara
Section Legion Partners’ Nominee: Timothy “Tim” Hasara 5 We believe that Mr. Hasara’s extensive successful investment experience of nearly 30 years investing in small cap companies and engaging on key issues around margin improvement, capital allocation and disclosures would make him a valuable asse
Slide 68: Nominee Ready to Serve: Henrik Jelert
Section Nominee Ready to Serve: Henrik Jelert 5 We believe that Mr. Jelert’s experience leading sustainable and significant growth and profitability expansion at Nestlé Waters, coupled with his substantial operational expertise in water delivery would make him a valuable asset to the Board ▪ Henrik
Slide 69: Nominee Ready to Serve: Lori T. Marcus
Section Nominee Ready to Serve: Lori T. Marcus 5 We believe that Ms. Marcus’ public board experience, comprehensive beverage industry experience in marketing including digital and social channels as well as general management along with her executive coaching skills would make her a valuable asset t
Slide 70: Table of Contents
Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 Case for Change 3 Executive Compensation & Governance 4 Directors Targeted for Replacement 5 Legion’s Highly Qualified Nominees 6 Appendix FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 12/31/2022) 70 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 71: LTIP Target – Legion Estimates
Section 6 LTIP Target – Legion Estimates 3 years ending: 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Actual 3-year cumulative pre-tax income reported $117 $111 $117 $125 $160 $240 Original 3-year pre-tax income target $130 $166 $158 $174 $213 $212 Payout % with original target 80% 0% 48% 43% 50% 153% Legion revis
Slide 72: LTIP Payout – Legion Estimates
Section 6 LTIP Payout – Legion Estimates 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Original target: Adjusted pre-tax income (3Y) Vest 200% >=125% of Target $162 $208 $198 $218 $266 $265 Vest 100% 100% of Target $130 $166 $158 $174 $213 $212 Vest 40% 70% of Target $91 $116 $111 $122 $149 $148 Vest 0% < 70% of Ta
Slide 73: Primo's Customer Service Is Broken
Section Primo’s Customer Service Is Broken 6 We believe Primo is plagued by poor customer service and this likely drives substandard customer satisfaction and ultimately low retention Customers who wanted water delivery couldn’t get delivery… “I have not received water service since December 2022. I
Slide 74: Primo's Own Analysis Explains Its High Attrition
Section Primo’s Own Analysis Explains Its High Attrition 6 “Worst company ever. Only lasted 1 month as a customer. They gave me a defective k cup brewing dispenser and the hot water didn’t work. I called you guys 5 times to replace the dispenser and you lied saying they were on their way. I canceled
Slide 75: Primo Taps Employees to Resolve Its Lack of Engagement Issue
Section Primo Taps Employees to Resolve Its Lack of Engagement Issue 6 A considerable proportion of comments and likes on Primo’s LinkedIn account come from employees – what’s the point of having social media presence to mainly engage with yourself while claiming to attract business customers? 75 So
Slide 76: PRMW Peer Sets
Section PRMW Peer Sets 6 Legion primarily utilizes a peer set that includes route-based and beverage companies for benchmarking, and uses ISS peers as well as PRMW’s self-selected peers for TSR comparison Legion-Selected Peers Company-Selected Peers ISS Peers 1. FIZZ 7. KD 13. ARMK 1. UNF 7. FELE 13
Slide 77: Disclaimer – Important Information
Disclaimer – Important Information The materials contained herein (the “Materials”) represent the opinions of Legion Partners Holdings, LLC and the other participants (collectively, “Legion Partners”) named in definitive proxy statement filed by Legion Partners with the Securities and Exchange Commi
Slide 78: CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY