Imation — Proxy Contest (April 2015)
69 slides from Imation's proxy contest presentation, Apr 13, 2015
Slide 1: Enhancing Shareholder Value at Imation Corp.
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Imation Corp. April 2015 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies This presentation shall not constitute an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any securities. Information contained herein is based o
Slide 2: Important Information About This Solicitation
Important Information About This Solicitation CLINTON RELATIONAL OPPORTUNITY MASTER FUND, L.P., CLINTON RELATIONAL OPPORTUNITY, LLC, CLINTON GROUP, INC., GEH CAPITAL, INC. AND GEORGE E. HALL (COLLECTIVELY, "CLINTON") AND JOSEPH A. DE PERIO, ROBERT B. FERNANDER AND BARRY L. KASOFF (TOGETHER WITH CLIN
Slide 3: Agenda
I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Imation III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 3
Slide 4: An Introduction to Clinton Group
An Introduction to Clinton Group • Founded in 1991, Clinton Group is a SEC Registered Investment Advisor, that invests globally across asset classes • Senior investment professionals span a wide range of investment and trading disciplines, bringing diverse expertise to bear in our investment strateg
Slide 5: Overview of Imation Corp.
Overview of Imation Corp. Company Overview Financial Summary Company Overview Capitalization 1 • Based in Oakdale, MN, Imation provides a range of 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 removable data storage media products and consumer Revenue electronics Consumer Storage & Accessories - 775 635 478 394 • Consum
Slide 6: Executive Summary
Executive Summary • Imation’s common stock has performed poorly for shareholders as measured over any relevant period since the onset of the tenure of Chief Executive Officer, Mark E. Lucas – The stock price is down (69.9%) during Mr. Lucas’ tenure and down (31.2%) in 20141 • Financial metrics on an
Slide 7: Imation Has Significantly Underperformed Its Peers
Imation Has Significantly Underperformed Its Peers Imation Has Continually Destroyed Shareholder Value Over Mark Lucas’ Tenure 120% Return: 94% 100% 80% Return: 90% 60% 40% Return: 81% 20% Return: 27% 0% -20% -40% -60% -80% Return: (70%) -100% Mar-10 Aug-10 Jan-11 Jun-11 Nov-11 Apr-12 Sep-12 Feb-13
Slide 8: Issues Under Current Leadership
Issues Under Current Leadership We Believe the Board of Directors Has Failed As Fiduciaries to Shareholders Board Responsibility Results The Board has overseen years of share price degradation and poor financial results Corporate Leadership Overseen a misguided strategy leading to underperforman
Slide 9: The Path Forward
The Path Forward Our Group Has Identified a Clear Plan to Execute Board Responsibility Plans for the Future1 Our nominees have data storage, business turnaround and public and private equity expertise Corporate Leadership Possess the ability to evaluate and seek change in the Company’s executive
Slide 10: Our Vision for a New Board of Directors
Our Vision for a New Board of Directors A Reconstituted Board of Directors Imation Class II and Class III Directors Clinton Group Nominees William G. Geoff S. Anthony T. Robert B. Barry L. Joseph A. LaPerch Barrall Brausen Fernander Kasoff De Perio CEO and Director, SVP and Chief Financial Former CR
Slide 11: Agenda
I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Imation III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 11
Slide 12: Industry Growth Should Have Provided a Tailwind
Industry Growth Should Have Provided a Tailwind • The digital universe, as defined by the global volume of data created and duplicated on an annual basis, has grown exponentially over the last several years – Since 2000, the total number of exabytes of storage increased by a factor of 450 – Since Mr
Slide 13: Global Data Storage Industry Forecasts Continued Growth
Global Data Storage Industry Forecasts Continued Growth The Digital Universe: 50x Growth, 2010-2020 Rapid Data Growth Drives Storage Demand 40,000 3,200 2,400 30,000 Exabyte Shipment 1,600 Exabytes 20,000 800 10,000 0 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Slide 14: Value Destruction: Stock Price Since the Spinoff from 3M
Value Destruction: Stock Price Since the Spinoff from 3M Since the inception of Imation as a public company, shareholders have seen over $1 billion or 87% of value disappear $50 Chairman / Lead Monahan Henderson Hart Matthews Director: Mark Lucas joins Board in April 2007 $40 Divested Photo Color Sy
Slide 15: Underperformance Against Peers Since the Spinoff
Underperformance Against Peers Since the Spinoff • The Company’s stock price is down (87%) since the spinoff from 3M Co. in July 1996 – Compared to the indices listed in the 10-K, the performance of the S&P Midcap 400 Index, S&P Small Cap 600 Index and ArcaEx Tech 100 Index for the comparable period
Slide 16: Value Destruction: Strategy Changes and Stock Price Performance
Value Destruction: Strategy Changes and Stock Price Performance Three Different Strategies Have Lead to the Same Result $50 Removable Data Storage Media Consumer Storage and Products Technology Driven Data Storage $40 Announces Announces Acquisition of Acquisition of TDK Memorex January $30 2006 in
Slide 17: Historical Strategy: Removable Data Storage Media
Historical Strategy: “Removable Data Storage Media” CEO: Bruce Henderson (May ‘04 – April ‘07) Brief History Track Record • Bruce Henderson was named CEO in May 2004 ($ in mm, except stock price) 2004 2007 Change • The Company had a leadership position in removable data Year End Stock Price $35.37 $
Slide 18: Historical Strategy: Build a Portfolio of Consumer Brands
Historical Strategy: “Build a Portfolio of Consumer Brands” CEOs: Russomanno and Lucas (April ‘07 – February ‘11) Brief History Track Record • Frank Russomanno replaced Henderson as CEO in April ($ in mm, except stock price) 2007 2011 Change 2007 Year End Stock Price $22.55 $6.27 (72%) • In 2009, Ru
Slide 19: Current Strategy: Data Storage, Protection and Connectivity
Current Strategy: “Data Storage, Protection and Connectivity” CEO: Mark Lucas Brief History Track Record • Mark Lucas joined the Board of Imation in April 2007. In ($ in mm, except stock price) 2011 2014 Change March 2009, he was named President and COO and in Year End Stock Price $6.27 $3.22 1 (49%
Slide 20: Underperformance during Mark Lucas' Tenure as CEO
Underperformance during Mark Lucas’ Tenure as CEO • The stock is down (69.9%) during Mark Lucas’ tenure or a negative compound annual decline rate of (22.4%) Return: 120% 94% 100% Return: 89% 80% Return: 60% 65% 40% Return: 20% 27% 0% -20% -40% -60% Return: (70%) -80% -100% Mar-10 Jul-10 Nov-10 Mar-
Slide 21: Stock Price Underperformance Against Peers in Every Period
Stock Price Underperformance Against Peers in Every Period 1-Year Performance 2-Year Performance 3-Year Performance 26% 54% 45% 22% 23% -1% -28% -24% -47% IMN '15 Peer Group '14 Peer Group IMN '15 Peer Group '14 Peer Group IMN '15 Peer Group '14 Peer Group 4-Year Performance Current CEO Tenure Perfo
Slide 22: Financial Performance under Mr. Lucas' Tenure
Financial Performance under Mr. Lucas’ Tenure Net Revenue Growth (4 Yr CAGR) 1 Gross Profit Growth (4 Yr CAGR) 1 TBV Growth (4 Yr CAGR) 1 25% 1% 2% 31% 21% 23% -24% -12% -16% IMN '15 Peer Group '14 Peer Goup IMN '15 Peer Group '14 Peer Goup IMN '15 Peer Group '14 Peer Goup Change in EBITDA Margin (‘
Slide 23: The Last Two Years Have Deteriorated
The Last Two Years Have Deteriorated Net Revenue Growth (2 Yr CAGR) 1 Gross Profit Growth (2 Yr CAGR) 1 TBV Growth ( 2 Yr CAGR) 1 16% 31% 15% 10% 18% 3% -15% -14% -23% IMN '15 Peer Group '14 Peer Goup IMN '15 Peer Group '14 Peer Goup IMN '15 Peer Group '14 Peer Goup 2014 EBITDA Margin 2014 SG&A Marg
Slide 24: Performance has Deteriorated Since Mr. Lucas Became CEO
Performance has Deteriorated Since Mr. Lucas Became CEO • Since the onset of Mr. Lucas’ tenure, revenue has declined by a nearly (16%) compound annual decline rate since 2010, despite significant investment in R&D and acquisitions Revenue Operating Income Return on Equity 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 $1
Slide 25: The Last Two Years Have Deteriorated
The Last Two Years Have Deteriorated • Over the last two years, Imation has seen a further deterioration in its operating performance across many metrics – Revenue has fallen by 21% between Q4 ‘14 and Q3 ‘13 on a last twelve month basis – Furthermore, Imation has failed to report either positive ope
Slide 26: Costs Are Bloated; Historical Cost Reductions are Unobservable
Costs Are Bloated; Historical Cost Reductions are Unobservable • “we embarked on a restructuring program that has taken out over $100 million in legacy costs…” (Imation’s 2015 Preliminary Proxy) Result: Our Take: SG&A as % of Revenue 26.0% 23.9% 23.9% • SG&A increased 1,000 basis points • SG&A shoul
Slide 27: Evaluating Execution Against Management's Plan: Traditional Storage
Evaluating Execution Against Management’s Plan: Traditional Storage Management’s Plan Actual Results – Optical Media / Tape • We believe Imation has maintained its dominant market share in optical media. However, the business is declining 25-30% a year making supply chain management and expense mana
Slide 28: Evaluating Execution Against Management's Plan: Audio / Video Information
Evaluating Execution Against Management’s Plan: Audio / Video Information Management’s Plan Actual Results • Management has backed away from the consumer business • The audio group has experienced recent growth due to interest in the Company’s bluetooth products • Imation is reliant on the TDK brand
Slide 29: Evaluating Execution Against Management's Plan: Secure and Scalable Storage
Evaluating Execution Against Management’s Plan: Secure and Scalable Storage Management’s Plan Actual Results • Acquisitions have been unsuccessful, and it is unclear to us what Imation’s product roadmap is that combines the acquired technology into a cohesive and exciting technology • RDX appears to
Slide 30: Most Recent Example of Poor Capital Allocation
Most Recent Example of Poor Capital Allocation Nexsan Has Underperformed, Cost More Money than Expected and Led to a $35 million Writedown Transaction Summary Nexsan’s Strategy from their S-1 (March 2011) • Nexsan is a provider of disk-based storage systems for mid-sized • Provide an optimal entry p
Slide 31: Optimism for Nexsan Met with Poor Execution
Optimism for Nexsan Met with Poor Execution What Management Said Results • “Imation’s acquisition of Nexsan is an exciting next step in our strategic • 2013 Nexsan revenue declined (12.6%) from 2012 transformation, which includes investing in growth platforms in data storage • 2014 Storage and Secur
Slide 32: Nexsan – Life as a Small Storage Company
Nexsan – Life as a Small Storage Company Comparison of Nexsan and a Key Competitor Our Beliefs • As a standalone entity since its inception, Nexsan did not possess differentiated technology in “spinning disk” Product Name NST6000 VNXe3300 compared to its peers System Form Factor 6U 6U • Nexsan was a
Slide 33: Recent Performance vs. Analyst Estimates
Recent Performance vs. Analyst Estimates Management Acknowledges Underperformance Analysts Pessimistic About Management Capability • “We have not yet achieved our previously forecasted year-over- • “We believe the announcement of the adviser engagement was year growth.- Scott Robinson, Q3 '14 Earnin
Slide 34: Management's Goals and Results On Its Own Scorecard
Management’s Goals and Results On Its Own Scorecard • Imation has meaningfully missed almost all of the financial performance goals laid out in its strategic plan from February 2011 Long Term Goals Status as of 2014 Achieved Four Years Later – Management’s 2011 Goals Have Not Been Achieved 20%+ Gros
Slide 35: Mr. Lucas' Assessment on the Turnaround
Mr. Lucas’ Assessment on the Turnaround Positive Stock Return to Return Beat CEO’s Declaration Source Performance Revenue Peers? Since? Growth? Twin Cities “In the short term, the [stock] market probably doesn’t like what we’re doing. Business No No No But we have new investors coming in who are ver
Slide 36: Board Decisions Have Destroyed Value
Board Decisions Have Destroyed Value Board Responsibility Decision Made Consequences for Stockholders Data Storage, Protection Setting Strategy -63% shareholder returns since January and Connectivity Strategic 2011 Plan in 2011 Memorex, TDK Life on $326 million in write-downs, Approving Acquisit
Slide 37: Is the Current Board Equipped to Evaluate Corporate Strategy?
Is the Current Board Equipped to Evaluate Corporate Strategy? • While the Directors may be fine executives in their fields, we believe a majority of the independent directors lack the expertise in the Company’s industry of focus, which is necessary to address the current problems of Imation Secure &
Slide 38: Agenda
I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Imation III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 38
Slide 39: Executive Compensation During Mark Lucas' Tenure
Executive Compensation During Mark Lucas’ Tenure • Since 2010, the Company has paid its named executive officers (“NEOs”) a total of $37.9 million or 88% of the Current Enterprise Value – an average of nearly $9.0 million per year – Mr. Lucas represents 40.0% of the total compensation Stock/Option E
Slide 40: Board Compensation During Mark Lucas' Tenure
Board Compensation During Mark Lucas’ Tenure • Since 2010, the Company has paid its Board of Directors a total of $9.8 million or 22.2% of the Current Enterprise Value – an average of $2.0 million per year – Mr. Matthews represents 20.0% of the total compensation Director Cash Stock Awards All Other
Slide 41: Cumulative Board and Executive Compensation vs. Market Cap
Cumulative Board and Executive Compensation vs. Market Cap • Since the onset of Mr. Lucas’ tenure as CEO, the decline in market value of equity is $301.2 million, versus total compensation to the Board of Directors and NEOs of $47.7 million Cumulative Compensation (Actual Dollars) vs. Declining IMN
Slide 42: The Board's Views on Bonus Payments
The Board’s Views on Bonus Payments 2014 Bonus Compensation Does Not Seem to Match Shareholder Value Creation – Payouts over 100%++ of Base Executive Title Bonus Target Payout as % of Base Total Mark E. Lucas CEO $2,340,785 EBITDA ($36.5) million; Payout 126%; Robinson/Zeller(1) CFO 692,684 FCF ($38
Slide 43: Has Bonus Pay Been Aligned with Shareholder Results?
Has Bonus Pay Been Aligned with Shareholder Results? Bonus Compensation Does Not Seem to Match Shareholder Value Creation Executive Bonus Total Comp Bonus Payout as % of Base Stock Price Performance Mark E. Lucas 2014 $2,340,785 $4,796,515 Payout 126% -19.0% 2013 1,379,433 2,416,014 Payout 75% 0.2%
Slide 44: Imation's Change of Control Payments – Single Trigger
Imation’s Change of Control Payments – “Single Trigger” Stated Intent or Policy Our Group’s Observations • The Company awards change of control severance • We do not believe that Executives should be rewarded in the event they payments to executives in both “Single Trigger” and retain their employme
Slide 45: Peer Comparison
Peer Comparison 2 • Imation’s Compensation Mkt Cap 2014 2014 Avg. Director Comp. 3 Return During Committee repopulated its Company Ticker 12/12/2014 Revenue 2 Cash Non-Cash Total Lucas Tenure peer group for 2015 Plantronics, Inc. PLT $2,219 $873 $74 $127 $201 96% VOXX International Corporation VOXX
Slide 46: Stock Ownership Among Directors and NEOs
Stock Ownership Among Directors and NEOs Imation’s Policy: Our Take: • NEOs have five years to meet their ownership guidelines • The guidelines for stock ownership should only be related of a multiple of base pay to open market purchases • CEO - 3x, CFO - 2x, SVPs and VPs - 1x • The guidelines shoul
Slide 47: Other Troubling Features of the Company's Compensation Practices
Other Troubling Features of the Company’s Compensation Practices Stated Intent or Policy Our Group’s Views • The Board spent $310,700 in 2014 on advice from a • $367,700 for compensation advice is excessive compensation consultant, AonHewitt • Given the fee amount, AonHewitt may be conflicted • Mana
Slide 48: Derivative Action in Delaware Chancery Court
Derivative Action in Delaware Chancery Court • According to the Company’s 2014 Form 10-K Filing, Spear Point Capital and its affiliates have filed a complaint in Delaware Chancery Court alleging: – Breach of Fiduciary Duty – Waste of Corporate Assets – Unjust Enrichment • The Defendants are the Boar
Slide 49: Agenda
I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Imation III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 49
Slide 50: We Believe A Reconstituted Board Can Right the Ship
We Believe A Reconstituted Board Can Right the Ship Robert B. Fernander Barry L. Kasoff Independent CEO, Storage President, Realization and Software Industry Services, Inc. CEO Experience in Data Storage Restructuring Expertise Strategic Product Development Consulting Expertise to Business Builder D
Slide 51: Plan Going Forward
Plan Going Forward We believe the new Board of Directors will correct previous mistakes Board Responsibility Previous Decisions The New Direction(1) Rehab the overall product strategy and Investing in Data Storage and development of Nexsan Security Solutions Setting Strategy Evaluate cash flow g
Slide 52: Our Nominees' Commitment to an Evaluation Process
Our Nominees’ Commitment to an Evaluation Process Comprehensive Business Review Executive Team Evaluation • On-site review of all the business lines with a fresh • On-site review of all executive perspective personnel • Understanding of key revenue drivers and fixed and • Interviews with business li
Slide 53: Reorganization into Two Business Units
Reorganization into Two Business Units Legacy Disk Businesses Storage • Commercial storage media business • Nexsan • Consumer storage business • Imation Mobile Security – IronKey, MXI and • Audio accessories business Encryptx • Appoint Chief Restructuring Officer to lead • Appoint Business Leader •
Slide 54: Restructuring of Legacy Business Segment
Restructuring of Legacy Business Segment • Our goal of the restructuring process is to deliver a business segment optimized for free cash flow generation from continuing operations and a harvesting of working capital Evaluation Action Plan Optimization and Progress • Appoint a Chief Restructuring •
Slide 55: Three Pillars of Our Disk Based Strategy
Three Pillars of Our Disk Based Strategy • Our nominees will commit to evaluating the Disk Based Strategy with an open mind along the following three pillars of strategy • Our intent is to not disrupt an ongoing turnaround that may be working or any operating momentum in any of the product lines Pro
Slide 56: Our Views and Approach On Existing Product Platforms
Our Views and Approach On Existing Product Platforms The Premise • The Assureon 8 solution brings secure automated archiving to mid-sized organizations to optimize storage infrastructure based upon the use of an object store Key Questions We Have to Evaluate Prospects • What is the underlying softwa
Slide 57: Our Views and Approach On Existing/Future Product Platforms
Our Views and Approach On Existing/Future Product Platforms The Premise • SDMA proposes a method to manage high-value data files and protect them from tampering, destruction, loss or leakage. SDMA provides policy management for the protection of high value data Key Questions We Have to Evaluate Pros
Slide 58: Our Views and Approach On Existing/Future Product Platforms
Our Views and Approach On Existing/Future Product Platforms The Premise • Windows To Go is a fully manageable, corporate image installed on a bootable certified USB drive Key Questions We Have to Evaluate Prospects • How does this compete with other virtualized desktop infrastructure platforms and s
Slide 59: Corporate Overhead Rationalization
Corporate Overhead Rationalization • Evaluating the consolidation of the Company’s satellite locations • Rationalization of all critical functions within corporate including finance, legal and investor relations • The sale or sale/leaseback of the Company’s headquarters and relocation within the are
Slide 60: Recalibrating Compensation Practices
Recalibrating Compensation Practices • We would propose the following changes to the compensation practices for both executives and Directors • Our goal would be to get a +90% affirmative vote on “Say on Pay” versus Imation’s last year result of 50.1% • Our nominees will evaluate status of the stock
Slide 61: Proposed Changes to Compensation
Proposed Changes to Compensation • Our nominees are committed to seeking the following corporate governance changes: • Extensive stock ownership guidelines (open market purchases) for all directors and officers commensurate with annual compensation and tenure • Removal of directors for any reason •
Slide 62: 100+ Day Plan
100+ Day Plan May 2015 June 2015 July 2015 August 2015 M T W T F M T W T F M T W T F M T W T F 27 28 29 30 1 1 2 3 4 5 29 30 1 2 3 27 28 29 30 31 4 5 6 7 8 8 9 10 11 12 6 7 8 9 10 3 4 5 6 7 11 12 13 14 15 15 16 17 18 19 13 14 15 16 17 10 11 12 13 14 18 19 20 21 22 22 23 24 25 26 20 21 22 23 24 17 18
Slide 63: Agenda
I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Imation III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 63
Slide 64: The Company's Proxy – What We Are Asked to Believe
The Company’s Proxy – What We Are Asked to Believe • We have read the Company’s definitive proxy dated April 10, 2015 • The document is in total 77 pages (including annexes), 62% of which contains discussion on executive and director compensation – Pages 15-20 are devoted to a discussion on director
Slide 65: A Summary of Imation's Strategy Transformation
A Summary of Imation’s Strategy Transformation • Over the past nine years, Imation has shifted its strategy twice • Neither strategy transformation has worked as evidenced by shareholder returns Previous Strategy - Build a Portfolio of Consumer Brands Key Components of Strategy Chairman / CEO Shareh
Slide 66: Our Vision for a New Board of Directors
Our Vision for a New Board of Directors A Reconstituted Board of Directors Imation Class II and Class III Directors Clinton Group Nominees William G. Geoff S. Anthony T. Robert B. Barry L. Joseph A. LaPerch Barrall Brausen Fernander Kasoff De Perio CEO and Director, SVP and Chief Financial Former CR
Slide 67: Our Nominees will be Fiduciaries to All Shareholders
Our Nominees will be Fiduciaries to All Shareholders Existing Paradigm Strategy Change from Consumer Products to Disk Board Faces Proxy Contest Based Storage Company Underperforms on a variety of fronts Strategic Alternatives, i.e. Aggressively Deploy Capital in Acquisitions Turnaround stalls “Sell
Slide 68: Conclusion
Conclusion • In the boardroom, the Company’s fiduciaries appear to believe they are truly doing what is right for stockholders, but financial results and stock price performance have been dismal • In the executive suite, the Company’s fiduciaries believe that they are the athletes on the field that
Slide 69: Contact Information
Contact Information Clinton Group Okapi Partners 601 Lexington Avenue 437 Madison Avenue 51st Floor 28th Floor New York, New York 10022 New York, New York 10022 Joseph A. De Perio, Senior Portfolio Manager Bruce Goldfarb, President and CEO Tel: +1 (212) 825 0400 Tel: +1 (212) 297 0720 [email protected]