Arlington Asset Investment Corp
Arlington Asset Investment — Proxy Contest (May 2016)
60 slides from Arlington Asset Investment's proxy contest presentation, May 13, 2016
Slide 1: Investor Presentation May 2016
Investor Presentation May 2016
Slide 2: Certain Information
1 Certain Information IMPORTANT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION The Company, its directors and certain of its executive officers are participants in the solicitation of proxies in connectio n w ith the Company's 2016 Annual Meeting of Shareholders. The Company has filed a definitive proxy statement and form
Slide 3: Agenda
2 Agenda I. Introduction II. Arlington: Delivering consistently strong dividends and long - term value to shareholders III. Proven track record of investing in high quality, liquid residential MBS that generate superior returns IV. Prudent interest rate hedging strategy protects shareholder capital
Slide 4: Who is Arlington?
3 Who is Arlington? Who we are Arlington Asset Investment Corp. is an internally managed company focused on investing in high quality liquid assets with predictable cash flows and substantial hedge protection We are traded on the NYSE under ticker “AI” with a market capitalization of $297 millio
Slide 5: This is a truly unusual proxy contest
4 This is a truly unusual proxy contest Completely irrelevant industry experience Imation is a ~$60mm market cap IT data storage and security company acting in concert with the Clinton Group, a New York City hedge fund Entered the stock only very recently with little skin in the game Imation / C
Slide 6: Arlington: Delivering consistently strong dividends and long-term value to shareholders
5 Arlington: Delivering consistently strong dividends and long - term value to shareholders
Slide 7: Stable dividends and high dividend yield post the financial crisis
6 – 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% – $0.10 $0.20 $0.30 $0.40 $0.50 $0.60 $0.70 $0.80 $0.90 $1.00 2010Q1 2011Q1 2012Q1 2013Q1 2014Q1 2015Q1 2016Q1 Dividend Dividend yield Stable dividends and high dividend yield post the financial crisis Source: Company Filings, SNL Financial. Arlington has paid divide
Slide 8: Total Shareholder Return compared to Arlington's Core Peers
7 (100.0%) – 100.0% 200.0% 300.0% 400.0% 500.0% 6/30/2009 6/30/2010 6/30/2011 6/30/2012 6/30/2013 6/30/2014 6/30/2015 AI Median 5/11/2016 325.5% 61.7% Total Shareholder Return compared to Arlington’s Core Peers 3 year Total Return as of 5/11/16 5 year Total Return as of 5/11/16 Total shareholder ret
Slide 9: Arlington's Price / TBV ratio has consistently exceeded that of peers
8 0.50x 0.60x 0.70x 0.80x 0.90x 1.00x 1.10x 1.20x 1.30x 1.40x 5/11/2011 5/11/2012 5/11/2013 5/11/2014 5/11/2015 5/11/2016 AI Core median 0.90x 0.80x Arlington’s Price / TBV ratio has consistently exceeded that of peers in recent years Source: FactSet. Note: Market data as of 5/11/16 . Median exclude
Slide 10: Agency MBS Investment Portfolio Overview
9 Fixed - rate agency MBS portfolio - Hedged to mitigate impact of increasing interest rates as economic environment shifts - Hedged agency MBS portfolio enables the Company to earn targeted investment spread over investment cycle despite mark - to - market fluctuations in book value - Specified a
Slide 11: Specified Agency MBS Investment Portfolio
10 Specified Agency MBS Investment Portfolio (1) Specified pools of loans with original balances of up to $150K. (2) Specified pools of loans with original balances between $150K and $200K. (3) Specified pools of loans refinanced through the Home Affordable Refinance Program (“HARP”) with original l
Slide 12: Hedge position overview
11 Hedge position comprised of both longer and shorter term hedges comprised of: - 2 - year interest rate swaps $750mm of notional amount Weighted average pay fixed rate of 1.04% Weighted average remaining maturity of 1.7 years - 10 - year interest rate swaps $1,000mm of notional amount
Slide 13: Financial results and footnotes
12 (1) Excludes net long TBA position and associated dollar roll income . (2) Includes interest expense incurred from short - term debt and net interest expense incurred from interest rate swap agreements . Excludes the economic cost or benefit of hedging instruments other than interest rate swap ag
Slide 14: Proven track record of investing in high quality, liquid residential MBS
13 Proven track record of investing in high quality, liquid residential MBS that generate superior returns
Slide 15: Portfolio transitioned to increased agency assets
14 Arlington has transitioned its portfolio to include increased agency assets to achieve the highest risk adjusted returns 2009 2011 2013 Agency MBS 11% Private - label MBS 89% Agency MBS 36% Private - label MBS 64% Agency MBS capital allocation Private - label MBS capital allocation Arlington co
Slide 16: Targeted Private-Label MBS Investments
15 Targeted Private - Label MBS Investments - Focus on underlying collateral of high quality prime jumbo and Alt - A loans - No subprime or option ARM loans - Floating rate MBS composed of mezzanine interests in re - REMIC securities collateralized by senior class REMIC securities Exceptional Un
Slide 17: Superior asset selection has driven high agency yields versus peers
16 Arlington’s superior asset selection has driven high agency yields in comparison to peers Portfolio specifically selected for relatively lower propensity for prepayment Lower prepayment speeds drive superior agency MBS investment yields Arlington’s average yield of 2.95% is above the peer m
Slide 18: Prudent interest rate hedging strategy
17 Prudent interest rate hedging strategy protects shareholder capital over the long - term and positions Arlington to generate consistent spread earnings
Slide 19: Spread history since 2000
18 Spread h istory since 2000 Source: Bloomberg. Spreads widen and contract (MBS yields vs. 3 month Libor Funding) due to changing economic cycles Spreads usually widen during Fed Easing cycles and tighten during Fed Tightening cycles – 1.00% 2.00% 3.00% 4.00% 5.00% 6.00% 7.00% 8.00% 9.00% Inter
Slide 20: Agency MBS investment/hedging strategy delivers consistent spread earnings
19 Agency MBS investment/hedging strategy provides ability to deliver consistent spread earnings over long - term cycle Arlington's investment/hedging strategy delivers consistent spread earnings over the long - term cycle Tighter spreads (Rise in interest rates) Wider spreads (Fall in interest rate
Slide 21: Hedges are positioned for tighter spreads as interest rates rise
20 Arlington's hedges are positioned for tighter spreads as interest rates gradually rise Arlington’s interest rate hedges on its agency MBS portfolio have been positioned for tighter spreads as interest rates gradually rise and more so than its core peer group - In quarters of a significant rise
Slide 22: Internal management and disciplined compensation
21 Internal management and disciplined compensation align management with shareholder interests
Slide 23: Benefits of internal management structure
22 Benefits of internal management structure Source: Wall Street research, Thomson. Operational & strategic considerations x Superior alignment of management and shareholder interests x Reduce management conflicts of interests as external manager is incentivized to raise capital even if not value ac
Slide 24: Externally managed structure commentary
23 As a result of the externally - managed structure at CommonWealth and other REITs advised by RMR, analysts at Green Street have lo ng deemed the ‘RMR managed’ REITs to be ‘uninvestable ’. Green Street Advisors, 06/13/13 Full internal management provides several benefits for stockholders. We gain
Slide 25: Externally managed companies trade at discounts
24 Externally managed companies trade at discounts Source: SNL Financial, FactSet. Note: Market data as of 5/11/16 . (1) Internal hybrids / agency made up of CIM, MFA, RWT, NYMT, DX, AI, CYS and CMO. External hybrids / agency made up of NRZ, TW O, IVR, PMT, MTGE, EFC, AMTG, MITT, ZFC, CHMI, OAKS, NL
Slide 26: Operating expense percentage significantly lower than peers
25 2.4% 2.2% 2.4% 2.9% 3.0% 3.4% 6.1% 6.3% 6.8% 2013 2014 2015 AI Core peer median Proxy peer median 1.8% 2.2% 2.6% Arlington’s operating expense percentage is significantly lower than that of peers Source: SNL Financial, FactSet . Note: Average equity calculated as the average of the quarterly aver
Slide 27: Compensation Policies are Aligned with Shareholders
26 Arlington’s Compensation Policies are Aligned with Shareholders Arlington has designed its management compensation and incentive plans with the overarching goals of linking pay to performance and aligning the interests of management with those of shareholders Key elements of our compensation
Slide 28: Grant Value vs. Expected Realizable Value of NEO Stock Awards
27 2013 PSUs Grant Value (1) 2014 PSUs Grant Value (1) 2014 RS Grant Value (1) 2014 RS Value (3) 2015 PSUs Grant Value (1) 2015 PSU Value (2) $- $1,000,000 $2,000,000 $3,000,000 $4,000,000 $5,000,000 $6,000,000 $7,000,000 Original Grant Value of Stock Awards Current Expected Realizable Value of Stoc
Slide 29: Total compensation and TSR vs. proxy peers
28 (37%) (36%) (6%) (3%) (2%) (2%) (1%) 4% 15% 23% 42% 44% 50% 95% RAS NEWS RWT DX AI REXI TCAP CMO ACAS MAIN HTGC STAR ABR NRF 4% $16.4 $21.5 $21.6 $22.9 $24.0 $28.6 $28.9 $29.1 $29.7 $37.8 $38.5 $47.6 $93.0 $239.0 DX NEWS RAS AI CMO TCAP ABR REXI MAIN HTGC STAR RWT ACAS NRF $29.1 Total compensatio
Slide 30: Accountability and oversight by a qualified Board of Directors
29 Accountability and oversight by a highly qualified and experienced Board of Directors
Slide 31: Diversified Board with strong real estate and mortgage experience
30 Arlington has a diversified Board with strong real estate and mortgage experience Board independence 6 of 8 directors are independent, with a lead independent director - The only non - independent directors are the CEO and executive chairman All Board committees are composed entirely of indep
Slide 32: Proactive Approach to Enhancing Board and Management Team
31 Arlington’s Board Deploys a Proactive Approach to Enhancing its Board and Management Team Arlington is focused on enhancing its Board and management team to continue to deliver value to shareholders - Appointed a new CEO in June 2014 and a new CFO in March 2015 - Proactively reduced the average
Slide 33: Directors are meaningful shareholders and experienced leaders
32 Ownership Name Title Tenure Shares (000's) % O/S Audit Comp Nom & Gov Other pub co Board Exec & Ops leadership RE & SpecFin Inv. Mgt. Fin srvs Audit com fin exp Eric F. Billings Executive Chairman 27 186.2 0.8% x x x x x J. Rock Tonkel, Jr. CEO / Director 9 313.8 1.4% x x x x Daniel J. Altobello
Slide 34: Directors own more than 60x Imation Group's shares
33 Our directors own more than 60x the amount of Arlington common stock held by the Imation Group and its nominees Each independent director is required to retain all equity awards until leaving the Board Executive officers are required to retain 50% of all equity awards (1) until the achievem
Slide 35: Board of Directors
34 Board of Directors J. Rock Tonkel, Jr. Extensive experience in financial services companies, the mortgage industry, the investment banking industry and capital markets Current CEO of our Company Former President and Head of Investment Banking at FBR & Co. (NASDAQ: FBRC), an investment banking
Slide 36: Board of Directors (cont'd)
35 Board of Directors (cont’d) Daniel Berce Extensive large cap public company and C - suite experience in the specialty finance sector Current CEO and President of General Motors Financial Company, a captive finance company and a wholly - owned subsidiary of General Motors Company (NYSE: GM) with
Slide 37: Board of Directors (cont'd)
36 Board of Directors ( cont’d ) Ralph Michael Extensive public company, regulatory and C - suite experience in large financial institutions Current CEO of Fifth Third Bank, Greater Cincinnati, and EVP and Group Regional President of Fifth Third Bancorp (NYSE: FITB) Former Director, President an
Slide 38: Imation and Clinton Group proposals DO NOT serve shareholder interests
37 Imation and Clinton Group proposals DO NOT serve shareholder interests
Slide 39: Imation Group owns less than 0.05% of Arlington
38 The Imation Group collectively owns only 11,000 shares, or less than 0.05%, of Arlington common stock, all purchased in March 2016 Who is the Imation Group? Imation Corp. is an IT data storage and data security company formed in 1996 as a result of a spin - off of 3M Company (“Imation ”) - Imat
Slide 40: Clinton Group track record of value destruction
39 41% 38% 9% (74%) (10%) (5%) (36%) 6% (11%) 13% (33%) (18%) 8% 36% 26% (60%) 2% (100%) (19%) 44% (54%) (49%) (81%) 20% (8%) 16% 41% 33% 1% (16%) 51% 36% 6% (8%) 4% 14% 1% 43% 60% (3%) 7% 11% 65% 12% (42%) 7% 11% 6% (10%) (33%) 15% 7% 6% 44% 4% (8%) (11%) Clinton Group has a track record of value d
Slide 41: Imation stock has lost nearly 65% since Clinton won its proxy fight
40 11-May-15 23-Jul-15 2-Oct-15 16-Dec-15 26-Feb-16 11-May-16 (100.0%) (80.0%) (60.0%) (40.0%) (20.0%) 0.0% 20.0% ImationCorp. S&P500 Since the Clinton Group won its proxy fight at Imation , Imation's stock has lost nearly 65.1% of its value - Imation now trades at just $1.60 with a market capital
Slide 42: Imation's Q1'16 earnings solidify track record of value destruction
41 Imation’s Q1’16 earnings further solidifies its track record of value destruction Performance X Imation lost $91.1mm in Q1 2016 , including an operating loss from continuing operations of $16.4mm X Adjusted EBITDA for the quarter of NEGATIVE $8.9mm X RSI (Barry Kasoff’s consulting firm) received
Slide 43: Clinton Group Has Taken Complete Control of Imation
42 The Clinton Group Has Taken Complete Control of Imation and Now Uses it as its Personal Investment Vehicle Since taking control of Imation’s board of directors in August 2015, the Clinton Group’s nominees have been appointed to Imat ion ’s executive suite and have engaged in frequent related pa
Slide 44: Clinton Group's Self-Dealing Transactions
43 The Clinton Group’s Self - Dealing Transactions T otal More than 80% of Imation’s Market Capitalization of ~$60mm After the Clinton Group nominees gained control of Imation’s board in August 2015, the Clinton Group and the Imation director s engaged in a number of self - dealing transactions over
Slide 45: Clinton Group and Imation Make Promises But Don't Deliver
44 Clinton Group and Imation Make Promises But Don’t Deliver Clinton Group and its nominees made promises to Imation’s shareholders during and after its proxy fight, but in our view have only delivered disruption and shareholder value destruction What They Said What They Delivered “ Our goal is simp
Slide 46: Imation Group's Proposals Do Not Serve Shareholders' Interests
45 The Imation Group’s Proposals for Arlington Do Not Serve Shareholders’ Interests Source : Company Documents . Despite our repeated attempts to engage with the Imation Group, they provided only vague details regarding the operational an d strategic plans for Arlington The Imation Group has now
Slide 47: Imation/Clinton's Proposals Would Cause Significant Harm
46 Source : Imation SEC filings . We Believe Imation / Clinton’s Proposals Along with Their Track Record Would Cause Significant Harm to Arlington Shareholders Externalization of management Investments in unspecified “new businesses” Liquidate portfolio or change hedging strategy Clinton has destroy
Slide 48: Do not Allow the Imation Group Nominees to Repeat this Disaster
47 Do not Allow the Imation Group and its Nominees to Repeat this Disaster at Arlington Scott Arnold Managing Director and Senior Portfolio Manager at Clinton Group Employee of Clinton Group intermittently for over 10 years Director nominee by Clinton Group at Campus Crest Communities in 2015
Slide 49: Track Record of the Imation Group's Nominees
48 Arlington’s Shareholders Should be Aware of the Track Record of the Imation Group’s Nominees Source : Public records . Barry L. Kasoff Barry Kasoff has a history of underperformance and questionable actions that have led to multiple lawsuits Was a director at EveryWare Global at a time when the
Slide 50: Imation Group's False Attacks vs. the Facts
49 Do Not Be Misled by Imation Group’s False Attacks vs. the facts Source : Company Documents, Imation SEC filings . Note : Market data as of 5 / 11 / 16 . Imation Group’s False Attacks The Facts Arlington has delivered p oor financial performance Wrong. Arlington has delivered more than 325% total
Slide 51: Imation/Clinton's Settlement Offer Would Disenfranchise Shareholders
50 Imation / Clinton’s Settlement Offer Would Significantly Disenfranchise the Remaining Arlington Shareholders without Giving Them Any Premium Implications for Arlington shareholders May 6, 2016 offer On May 6, a representative of Imation Group proposed a settlement to Arlington Imation would i
Slide 52: Conclusion
51 Conclusion
Slide 53: The Board's Nominees are the Right Directors for Arlington
52 The Board’s Nominees are the Right Directors for Arlington Arlington’s publicly articulated strategy has delivered robust, long - term shareholder returns through multiple economic cycles Entire Board is elected annually by shareholders Arlington has a proven track record of investing in high
Slide 54: Appendix
53 Appendix
Slide 55: Selected recent analyst commentary
54 Selected recent analyst commentary Source: Wall Street Equity Research. “ Arlington Hold - rated Arlington Asset (AI - $ 12 . 72 ) received a letter from a shareholder who intends to nominate a controlling slate of directors, though the activist shareholder group has yet to propose a strategic pl
Slide 56: Two sets of peers
55 ABR $ 2.5bn Two sets of peers; necessitated because we are internally managed Proxy peers for compensation comparison Core peers for performance comparison Arlington’s core peers were selected based on a combination of the following characteristics: hybrid / agency RMBS investment strategy, man
Slide 57: Case studies
56 Case studies
Slide 58: Clinton Group campaign at EVINE Live
57 Source: FactSet and Company filings. Clinton Group campaign at EVINE Live 30-Oct-13 2-May-14 3-Nov-14 7-May-15 6-Nov-15 11-May-16 (100.0%) (80.0%) (60.0%) (40.0%) (20.0%) 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 10/30/13: ClintonGroup confirmedithad 5.8%stakein ValueVisionmedia andsentletterto theBoardcalling fora
Slide 59: Violin Memory total return since Clinton Group initial buy-in
58 Source: FactSet and Company filings. Violin Memory total return since Clinton Group initial buy - in Clinton Group bought in to VMEM in December of 2013 Clinton launched an effort to engage with Violin in July of 2015 Imation corp. bought Violin Memory stock in December of 2015 Clinton Gr
Slide 60: Clinton Group's Investment at EveryWare Global led to bankruptcy
59 Clinton Group’s Investment at EveryWare Global Inc. led to the company’s bankruptcy Source: FactSet, company filings. Note: Market data as of June 2, 2015, last available date. 1-Jan-13 9-Aug-13 18-Mar-14 24-Oct-14 2-Jun-15 (120%) (100%) (80%) (60%) (40%) (20%) 0% 20% 40% 60% (99.3%) 47.9% EveryW
Arlington Asset Investment — Proxy Contest (May 2016) on 6ix