Buffalo Wild Wings — Proxy Contest (February 2017)
51 slides from Buffalo Wild Wings's proxy contest presentation, Feb 22, 2017
Slide 1: Buffalo Wild Wings February 2017
BUFFALO WILD WINGSFEBRUARY 2017
Slide 2: Disclaimer
DISCLAIMER * The views expressed in this presentation (the “Presentation”) represent the opinions of Marcato Capital Management LP and/or certain affiliates (“Marcato”) and the investment funds it manages that hold shares in Buffalo Wild Wings, Inc. (the “Company”). This Presentation is for informat
Slide 3: Certain Information Concerning the Participants
CERTAIN INFORMATION CONCERNING THE PARTICIPANTS * Marcato International Master Fund, Ltd. (“Marcato International”) and the other Participants (as defined below) intend to file a preliminary proxy statement and accompanying proxy card with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) to be use
Slide 4: History of Over-Promising and Under-Delivering with No Accountability
HISTORY OF OVER-PROMISING AND UNDER-DELIVERING WITH NO ACCOUNTABILITY Buffalo Wild Wings has an unfortunate history of misrepresenting that they are on the verge of rolling out new initiatives that will improve performance and shareholder valueThis pattern is observable throughout the business, but
Slide 5: Marcato's Nominees Have Significant Expertise in Critical Business Areas
* MARCATO’S NOMINEES HAVE SIGNIFICANT EXPERTISE IN CRITICAL BUSINESS AREAS LACKING AMONG CURRENT DIRECTORS Source: BWLD 2015 Form DEF-14A filed 3/25/16. Company press releases.
Slide 6: I. 4-Wall Margin Targets
ls “4-wall” margin targets MARCATO
Slide 7: Overview – 20% 4-Wall Margin Targets
OVERVIEW – 20% “4-WALL” MARGIN TARGETS At the 2016 Analyst Day in August, the management team of Buffalo Wild Wings made a commitment to achieving a 20% “4-wall” margin across all company-operated stores This had already been stated as a goal for BWLD during prior presentations and public conference
Slide 8: Without a Plan in Mind, Management Felt Comfortable Articulating Their Target
* WITHOUT A PLAN IN MIND, MANAGEMENT FELT COMFORTABLE ARTICULATING THEIR TARGET “I hope if you took away one thing, it’s that our focus is on getting to 20% restaurant-level margins across the system. We think we have cost of sales in pretty great shape, certainly a focus on labor from hours to depl
Slide 9: 2016 Analyst Day: We're Confident and We're Working on Improving
2016 ANALYST DAY: “WE’RE CONFIDENT” AND “WE’RE WORKING ON IMPROVING” * AS MARCATO NOTED AFTER THE 2016 ANALYST DAY, THE PLAN DID NOT QUANTIFY SPECIFIC AREAS OF OPPORTUNITY “We’re confident that we’ll get to the 20% restaurant-level cash flow that we have historically seen. Our starting point is the
Slide 10: Identified Opportunities for 20% Margin Target Were Incomplete from the Start
* 10/26/16: “EXPECT TO HAVE A QUANTIFIABLE UPDATE ON OUR FEBRUARY EARNINGS CALL” Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. COGS Margin Opportunities Optimized Guest Captain Hours IDENTIFIED OPPORTUNITIES FOR 20% MARGIN TARGET WERE INCOMPLETE FROM THE START—ARE THEY STILL ON THE TABLE? On
Slide 11: Lack of Clarity on Path to 2018 Targets Has Led Analysts to Question
LACK OF CLARITY ON PATH TO 2018 TARGETS HAS LED SELL-SIDE ANALYSTS TO QUESTION WHETHER THE TARGETS ARE EVEN STILL ACHIEVABLE * “With just 10-30 bps of margin expansion targeted this year, the 2018 guide is back-end weighted…Relative to guidance for 20% by the end of 2018, we think it will take longe
Slide 12: Sell-Side Estimates Reveal Absence of Credibility in Management's Targets
SELL-SIDE ESTIMATES REVEAL ABSENCE OF CREDIBILITY IN MANAGEMENT’S STATED TARGETS * Source: Wall Street research following BWLD’s Q4’16 earnings results. Management guidance calls for 10-30bps of “4-wall” margin improvement above the 17.7% result for FY 2016, implying 17.8%-18.0% for FY 2017Estimates
Slide 13: Management Falsely Claimed Its Process Was Just Beginning in Oct. 2016
* MANAGEMENT (FALSELY) CLAIMED THAT ITS PROCESS WAS JUST BEGINNING IN OCT. 2016 “We’re targeting several areas of reduction in operating expense…As we are early in the process on these initiatives, expect to have a quantifiable update on our February earnings call” Source: Q3 2016 earnings call tran
Slide 14: Achieving 20% 4-Wall Margin Was a Long-Standing Goal
IN FACT, ACHIEVING A 20% “4-WALL” MARGIN WAS AN EXPLICIT AND LONG-STANDING GOAL WELL BEFORE THE Q3’16 EARNINGS CALL OR 2016 ANALYST DAY * “Our goal for restaurant level cash flow is 20%... I think for a long-term goal for us, we think it’s pretty accurate, and we think we’re getting very close to be
Slide 15: Shareholders Have a Right to Know: Why Is the Effort Only Starting Now?
* SHAREHOLDERS HAVE A RIGHT TO KNOW: WHY IS THE EFFORT ONLY STARTING NOW? Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. “[N]ow is the time to do a thorough review of our cost structure to identify opportunities for new efficiencies. We are currently undertaking an in-depth review of our oper
Slide 16: The Sale & Refranchising of Company-Owned Units Improves Margins
2/7/16: “THE SALE & REFRANCHISING OF [COMPANY-OWNED UNITS] IMPROVES MARGINS” * “We did talk about 20% margin goals…While we want it certainly to be in the area of cost improvement…also the sale and re-franchising of [company-owned restaurants] improves margins” – Q4 2016 Earnings Call Source: Compan
Slide 17: II. International Development
II. International development *
Slide 18: Overview – International
OVERVIEW - INTERNATIONAL The management team of Buffalo Wild Wings has offered the investment community numerous unsolicited promises regarding its development plans outside the United States since 2010Despite advertising their efforts as “active” for 5+ years, Buffalo Wild Wings’ non-U.S. presence
Slide 19: Perpetual Extension of International Targets
PERPETUAL EXTENSION OF INTERNATIONAL TARGETS APRIL 2014: 400 INTERNATIONAL STORES IN 7-10 YEARS (2021-2024) AUGUST 2016: 400 INTERNATIONAL STORES IN 10 YEARS (2026) At the inaugural analyst day in April 2014, BWLD announced a 7-10 year plan to open 400 stores outside of the US and CanadaImplied comp
Slide 20: Canada Development Has Inexplicably Stalled
CANADA DEVELOPMENT HAS INEXPLICABLY STALLED APRIL 2014: 50+ UNIT OPPORTUNITY REMAINING IN CANADA AUGUST 2016: CANADA’S UNIT POTENTIAL STILL FULLY UNTAPPED For years, Canada has been identified as a potential growth market for Buffalo Wild WingsPotential for 50 Canada units to open within five years
Slide 21: 2011: BWLD Targets 50 Units in Canada Over 5 Years
* “Our plan is to…have 50 units opened [in Canada] during the next five years”– Mary Twinem, Cowen Consumer Conference January 2011 2011: BWLD TARGETS 50 UNITS IN CANADA OVER 5 YEARS… BWLD HAS NOT MET ITS ORIGINAL 5-YEAR DEVELOPMENT GOALS FOR CANADA “We…anticipate opening a total of 50 units in Cana
Slide 22: BWLD Is Still Below Its Stated Goal for Canada
* IN FACT, BWLD IS STILL BELOW ITS STATED GOAL FOR CANADA FOR 2013 “We anticipate having 20 locations open throughout Canada by the end of 2013. Ultimately, we believe that…Canada can support 100 restaurants”– Sally Smith, Oppenheimer Consumer Conference June 2011 WITH 14 STORES IN CANADA IN 2013, B
Slide 23: ~6 Years of Promotion Have Yielded Few Results
* ~6 YEARS OF PROMOTION HAVE YIELDED FEW RESULTS Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts.Note: Analysis excludes Oman, Kuwait, Egypt, Lebanon, Turkey, South Africa, Chile, Colombia, Peru, Costa Rica, and Japan, which were referenced on slide 165 of the 2016 Analyst Day presentation, but
Slide 24: Targets Perpetually Pushed Out for Dubai & Saudi Arabia Openings
TARGETS PERPETUALLY PUSHED OUT FURTHER FOR INITIAL DUBAI & SAUDI ARABIA OPENINGS Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. Q2’12 earnings call, 7/24/12 Q4’12 earnings call, 2/12/13 Goldman Sachs Conference, 6/3/13 Q2’13 Earnings call, 7/30/13 Q3’13 Earnings Call, 10/29/13 Q4’13 Earnings
Slide 25: Guidance for Philippines Development Was Similarly Missed
* GUIDANCE FOR PHILIPPINES DEVELOPMENT WAS SIMILARLY MISSED…AND MISSED AGAIN Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. Q2’13 earnings call, 7/30/13 Wells Fargo Retail & Restaurant Summit, 10/1/13 Press Release, 1/27/14 3/13/14 UBS Global Consumer Conference 2014 Analyst Day, 4/2/14 Press
Slide 26: Delays & Target Extensions Despite Dedicated Personnel & Resources
* “We started building an international team over four years ago…Several members of the team have extensive international experience”– Buffalo Wild Wings 2014 Analyst Day, April 2014 DELAYS & TARGET EXTENSIONS DESPITE DEDICATED CORPORATE PERSONNEL & RESOURCES “We have a group of people dedicated to
Slide 27: III. Technology & Innovation
III. Technology & innovation *
Slide 28: Overview – Technology & Innovation
OVERVIEW – TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION BWLD’s past statements at investment conferences and on earnings calls include numerous unmet and extended deadlines for implementing customer-facing technology initiativesWe believe it is important that management be held accountable for failing repeatedly to achi
Slide 29: Only One of Eight 2014 Analyst Day Initiatives Achieved On-Time
* ONLY ONE OF EIGHT 2014 ANALYST DAY INITIATIVES WAS ULTIMATELY ACHIEVED ON-TIME APRIL 2014 ANALYST DAY | INITIAL TIMELINE FOR IMPLEMENTATION Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. In all stores by YE 2015—for gaming & trivia only—but will need to be replaced to support payments 2/3/1
Slide 30: Unfulfilled Promises: Handhelds
* ACCOUNTABILITY FOR UNFULFILLED PROMISES FROM 2014 ANALYST DAY: HANDHELDS 2014 ANALYST DAY GOAL: HANDHELDS IN ALL CO. STORES INITIAL OUTLOOK “In 2014, we will also begin testing server handheld devices”“Our goal is to roll out these devices to all Company-owned restaurants in 2015”“We will also mak
Slide 31: Unfulfilled Promises: Loyalty
* ACCOUNTABILITY FOR UNFULFILLED PROMISES FROM 2014 ANALYST DAY: LOYALTY 2014 ANALYST DAY GOAL: LOYALTY IS ON THE WAY INITIAL OUTLOOK “We want to build a loyalty program that takes a unique approach and gives us further ways to engage our guests and their experiences”“Our program is under developmen
Slide 32: Unfulfilled Promises: Tablet Ordering
* ACCOUNTABILITY FOR UNFULFILLED PROMISES FROM 2014 ANALYST DAY: TABLET ORDERING 2014 ANALYST DAY GOAL: TABLET ORDERING IMMINENT INITIAL OUTLOOK “And don’t worry, menu ordering is coming. We are testing menu ordering on tablets in the second quarter”“Our goal is to have [ordering] functionality…in a
Slide 33: BWLD Selected a Provider Unproven in Restaurants or Payments
* IN 2014 BWLD SELECTED A COMPANY UNPROVEN IN RESTAURANTS OR PAYMENTS TO DEVELOP ITS TABLET PROGRAM, A CRITICAL PRODUCTIVITY DRIVER IN CASUAL DINING Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. In March 2014, BWLD announced that they would be partnering with NTN Buzztime (AMEX: NTN) as the
Slide 34: Top Leaders in Tablets Have More Experience with Larger Chains
* TOP LEADERS IN TABLETS HAVE SIGNIFICANTLY MORE EXPERIENCE WITH LARGER CHAINS Source: Company filings. If you were a Top-20 national restaurant chain, which technology provider would you go with? Significant Customers Tablet Ordering Rolled Out? National Chains National Chains Smaller Concepts
Slide 35: Buzztime Has Still Not Met Initial Goals for Payment Functionality
* BUZZTIME HAS STILL NOT MET INITIAL GOALS TO ACHIEVE PAYMENT FUNCTIONALITY Source: Company filings. “[VP of Guest Experience and Innovation Ben] Nelsen noted that he expects an ordering and payment feature will be available on the tablets in the second half of 2014”– BWLD Press Release dated 3/6/14
Slide 36: BWLD Has Balked at Seeking a Qualified Tablet Provider
* BWLD HAS BALKED AT SEEKING A QUALIFIED PROVIDER OF TABLET ORDERING & PAYMENT TECHNOLOGY IN ORDER TO AVOID DISAPPOINTING ITS TRIVIA PLAYERS Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. “So ideally, I would love to be ordering and paying right now on tablets at the restaurant…But as we look
Slide 37: Assurances Abound but Results Elude
* ASSURANCES ABOUND BUT RESULTS ELUDE “We are exploring multiple payment platforms in really what is a very unsettled space. And until we have some concrete updates on that, I'm a little reluctant to give a specific date. What we will do is continue to update you as we make progress. But I can tell
Slide 38: Admitting Failure, Management Acknowledges Habit of Over-Promising
* ADMITTING FAILURE, MANAGEMENT ACKNOWLEDGES HABIT OF OVER-PROMISING “If [I knew three years ago what I know about tablets today] we wouldn’t have said a thing on any call, because I think technology changed and now we’re really pleased with where we are, but we set expectations that just weren’t ac
Slide 39: IV. Guest Experience Captains
IV. Guest experience captains *
Slide 40: Overview – Guest Experience Captains
OVERVIEW – GUEST EXPERIENCE CAPTAINS In 2012, BWLD announced the creation of the Guest Experience Captain, a new restaurant role focused on interacting with guests and alleviating the burden on wait staff to execute tasks not related to delivering food, such as changing channels, instructing guests
Slide 41: Captains Rolled Out Despite Unclear Intent or Ability to Drive SSS
“The primary goal is to make sure that you can get the TV changed to your channel if you wanted to[; if] you want to do a Blazin' Challenge, [that] somebody is going to make that happen…So some of it's [trial of food], but it isn't approached…as a sales driver”– UBS Global Consumer Conference, 3/13/
Slide 42: Increasing Captains' Role in Local Marketing Discussed for 3 Years
“[N]ow we will be looking…also [at] community outreach…are there dollars that were typically or historically marked for local store marketing that we can shift to that [Captain]?”– Q1’15 Earnings Call, 4/28/15 “But ultimately the Guest Experience Captain has to pay for itself…and part of that is…the
Slide 43: Mgmt. Unable to Isolate Impact of Captains from Other Initiatives
* WHEN ASKED, MGMT. IS UNABLE TO ISOLATE IMPACT OF CAPTAINS FROM OTHER INITIATIVES, OR QUANTIFY THE PROFITABILITY OF THE INITIATIVE Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. Will Slabaugh, Stephens : “[O]n the Guest Experience Captain, in your view, has this been a big success? Has this
Slide 44: Financial Results Do Not Support Economic Impact of Guest Captains
* ULTIMATE FINANCIAL RESULTS DO NOT SUPPORT ECONOMIC IMPACT OF GUEST CAPTAINS Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. “And as to the results, I would say it's mixed…[W]hen I say the results are mixed, the financial metrics are mixed. I would say that the guests love it. I have never he
Slide 45: Expectations That Incremental Labor Would Leverage Never Materialized
* EXPECTATIONS THAT INCREMENTAL LABOR WOULD “LEVERAGE” NEVER MATERIALIZED Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts.Note: Q3 2012 represents quarter immediately prior to announcement of the creation of the Guest Captain position.(1) Average Unit Volumes. Refers to Company-owned units only
Slide 46: Leverage in Q4'16 Was Only Due to Rolling Back Captain Hours
* “LEVERAGE” OBSERVED IN Q4’16 WAS ONLY DUE TO ROLLING BACK CAPTAIN HOURS IMPROVEMENT IN Q4’16 DUE TO LOWER CAPTAIN STAFFING -23bps On the Q3’16 earnings call, management announced that they planned to reduce / “optimize” Guest Captain hours to achieve 30bps of margin improvement, of which 23 bps ma
Slide 47: Management Has Been Refining Guest Captain Hours for Four Years
* MANAGEMENT HAS BEEN “REFINING” GUEST CAPTAIN HOURS FOR FOUR YEARS Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. 2/12/13: “Now we want to tweak the hours. We’ve found we don’t necessarily need that full complement perhaps at the lunch hour” 4/29/13: “We continue to refine the number of hour
Slide 48: After Years of Unfulfilled Promises, What Makes This Time Different?
“We plan to evolve the Captain position”“We are working on improving our productivity, consistently adjusting our labor-to-sales trends and using our Captain hours more efficiently and effectively”“I think we’ve also got certainly the Operations Team focused on…taking a look at the Guest Experience
Slide 49: Mgmt. Now Sees Reducing Captain Hours as Margin Opportunity
* REALIZING PROGRAM IS UNECONOMICAL, MGMT. NOW SEES REDUCING CAPTAIN HOURS AS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR MARGIN IMPROVEMENT Source: Company filings and presentation transcripts. “We’re optimizing the hours of our Guest Experience Captains based on restaurant sales levels. We estimate this will improve our l
Slide 50: History of Over-Promising and Under-Delivering with No Accountability
HISTORY OF OVER-PROMISING AND UNDER-DELIVERING WITH NO ACCOUNTABILITY Buffalo Wild Wings has an unfortunate history of misrepresenting that they are on the verge of rolling out new initiatives that will improve performance and shareholder valueThis pattern is observable throughout the business, but
Slide 51: Marcato's Nominees Have Significant Expertise in Critical Business Areas
* MARCATO’S NOMINEES HAVE SIGNIFICANT EXPERTISE IN CRITICAL BUSINESS AREAS LACKING AMONG CURRENT DIRECTORS Source: BWLD 2015 Form DEF-14A filed 3/25/16. Company press releases.