DuPont de Nemours, Inc. · NYSE:DD
DuPont de Nemours — DuPont — Technical Presentation (2013)
55 slides from DuPont de Nemours's technical presentation, 2013
Slide 1: The 3 Second Myth: FR Compliance vs Protection
THE 3 SECOND MYTH FR Compliance vs Protection 1 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 2: Agenda
AGENDA Industrial fires and standards Why the focus on “flash fires” Where did the 3 second duration come from How FR fabrics work Why exposure duration matters Why exposure intensity matters Testing your FR garments DuPontTM Nomex(R) is a registered trademark of E.I. duPont de Nemours & Company, In
Slide 3: What You Should Know About Industrial Fires and Standards
WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT INDUSTRIAL FIRES AND STANDARDS 3 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 4: Industrial Fire and Standard Misconceptions
INDUSTRIAL FIRE AND STANDARD MISCONCEPTIONS Industry misconceptions may influence FR clothing selection The purpose of flame resistant clothing is to only protect workers from Flash Fire Hazards All, or most, fire hazards: Are short duration (3 seconds or less) Have the same intensity (2 cal/cm2
Slide 5: What Are Industrial Fires?
WHAT ARE INDUSTRIAL FIRES? Types and Sources of Industrial Fires Flash - Rapid Burning of Vapor Cloud Fuel Sources Jet - Burning of Pressurized Fuel Supply Flammable Liquids Pool - Burning of Flammable Liquid Spill Flammable Gases BLEVE - Explosion & Fireball from Catastrophic Failure of Contain
Slide 6: What Are Typical Industrial Fires?
WHAT ARE TYPICAL INDUSTRIAL “FIRES”? There are no “typical” industrial fires Three (3) Main Variables (Duration X Intensity = Magnitude) Duration (Exposure Time, seconds) - 1 sec to “Time to Escape” Intensity (Heat Flux) - <1 to >7 cal/cm2s” Magnitude (Total Exposure Energy) - <1 to >20 cal/cm
Slide 7: Industrial Fires: Recent Industrial Incidents
INDUSTRIAL FIRES Recent Industrial Incidents May 4, 2009 Routine Excavation Veolia Environmental Services Gas Line Ruptured West Carrollton, OH Operator & Rig Engulfed Flammable Release from Waste Recycling Process to Atmosphere 2 Workers Seriously Injured 20 Residences Damaged 7 Copyright© 2013 E.I
Slide 8: Industrial Fires: Recent Incidents, Chemical Safety Board
INDUSTRIAL FIRES Recent Industrial Incidents – Refer to Chemical Safety Board July 19, 2009 Citgo HF Plant – Surveillance Camera Corpus Christi, TX Vapor Cloud + Jet Fire October 6, 2005 Formosa Plastics Point Comfort, TX Propylene Explosion 8 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ T
Slide 9: Safety and Health Program: PPE Is the Last Line of Defense
SAFETY AND HEALTH PROGRAM PPE is the last line of defense Personal Protective Equipment 4. PPE 3. Work Practices Proper Tools Clothing Proper Procedures Eye Protection Foot Protection Head Protection 2. Engineering Technical solutions Hand Protection to make equipment safer Hearing Protection Respir
Slide 10: Employer Responsibilities – PPE Requirements
EMPLOYER RESPONSIBILITIES – PPE REQUIREMENTS OSHA 29 CFR 1910.132 Personal Protective Equipment for General Industry (d)(1) The employer shall assess the workplace to determine if hazards are present, or are likely to be present, which necessitate the use of personal protective equipment (PPE). If s
Slide 11: General PPE Requirements for Employer
GENERAL PPE REQUIREMENTS FOR EMPLOYER OSHA 3151 – Personal Protective Equipment Guide Perform a Hazard Assessment of the Workplace Identify & Control Physical and Health Hazards Identify & Provide Appropriate PPE for Employees OSHA 3151-12R 2003, “…select PPE that will provide a level of protectio
Slide 12: Consensus Standards – Minimum Material Performance
CONSENSUS STANDARDS – MINIMUM MATERIAL PERFORMANCE NFPA 2112: Standard on Flame Resistant Garments for Protection of Industrial Personnel Against Flash Fire Provides Minimum Requirements for FR Garments Design Construction Evaluation Certification Primarily for Manufacturers, not End-Users R
Slide 13: Consensus Standards – Selection, Care, & Use
CONSENSUS STANDARDS – SELECTION, CARE, & USE NFPA 2113: Standard on Selection, Care, Use, and Maintenance of Flame Resistant Garments for Protection of Industrial Personnel Against Flash Fire OSHA Recognized Tool for 29 CFR 1910.132 Perform Fire / Exposure Hazard Assessment Primarily for End-Users P
Slide 14: Industry Focuses on Flash Fires... Why?
INDUSTRY FOCUSES ON “FLASH FIRES”……WHY? 14 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 15: What Is a Flash Fire?
WHAT IS A FLASH FIRE? Flash Fire: A non-explosive combustion of a vapor cloud from a release of flammable material into the open air Its duration, intensity, and magnitude depend on many factors Flammable gas generation rate (discharge rate) Total vapor cloud mass released (prior to ignition) Disper
Slide 16: Why Focus on Flash Fire? Historical Reference
WHY FOCUS ON FLASH FIRE? Common industry term when standards developed HISTORICAL REFERENCE “Flash Fire” was a common industry term used for fire events when the NFPA & CGSB standards were first developed in 2000. NFPA 2112 NFPA 2113 CGSB 155.20 16 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company
Slide 17: Why Focus on Flash Fire? Standard Evolution
WHY FOCUS ON FLASH FIRE? NFPA 2112 and 2113 standard evolution NFPA 2112 & 2113 have been moving towards recognizing all fire/thermal hazards not just flash fires The wording in the standards purpose statement has added the term “short duration thermal exposure” NFPA 2112 – 2012, 1.2.1* This standar
Slide 18: The Origin of 3 Seconds
THE ORIGIN OF 3 SECONDS 18 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 19: The 3 Second Misconception
THE “3 SECOND” MISCONCEPTION Why the industry thinks workers only need protection for 3 seconds? Early editions of NFPA 2113 described a flash fire as typically lasting 3 seconds in the appendix, this has since been removed The OSHA 2010 memo to the Oil & Gas market indicated flash fires can last
Slide 20: Aren't All Flash Fires 3 Seconds or Less?
AREN’T ALL “FLASH” FIRES 3 SECONDS OR LESS? Actually, no (and flash fire is not defined this way per NFPA) 3.3.13* Flash Fire. A fire that spreads by means of a flame front rapidly through a diffuse fuel, such as dust, gas, or the vapor of an ignitable liquid, without the production of damaging pres
Slide 21: Where Did 3 Seconds Originate?
WHERE DID 3 SECONDS ORIGINATE? Testing helicopter pilot flight suit materials for the military 1970’s - U.S. military ran a test to determine total heat exposure received by pilots escaping through the burning fuel of a helicopter crash Sensored and clothed manikin was pulled through burning pool
Slide 22: Why Is 3 Seconds Used in the Manikin Test?
WHY IS 3 SECONDS USED IN THE MANIKIN TEST? Standardized test method to reach minimum 6 cal/cm² protection value DuPont developed the manikin test to provide a repeatable test method that can easily and safely generate 6 cal/cm² total energy exposure needed by the military Propane is a common, easi
Slide 23: Flash Fire Duration Misconception
“FLASH” FIRE DURATION MISCONCEPTION Consider Research Conducted by the U.S. Department of Energy1 In the graph of these tests, burn times reached more than 15 sec. Highlights the need to understand the hazard The Fire Protection Engineering handbook has vapor cloud fire models2 Various flammable
Slide 24: Flash Fire Intensity Misconception
“FLASH” FIRE INTENSITY MISCONCEPTION All “Flash” fires are 2 cal/cm²s -> the intensity used in the NFPA 2112 thermal manikin test Experimental data1,3 has shown potential for significantly higher values DOE China Lake Experiments with Liquid Natural Gas Vapor Cloud Fires Measured peak heat flux va
Slide 25: How Flame-Resistant Fabrics Work: All FR Is Not Created Equal
HOW FLAME-RESISTANT FABRICS WORK ALL FR IS NOT CREATED EQUAL 25 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 26: Purpose of Flame Resistant (FR) Fabrics
PURPOSE OF FLAME RESISTANT (FR) FABRICS Reduce Burn Injury and Increase Chance of Survival Does Not Ignite and Continue to Burn Does Not Melt and Drip Maintains a Barrier Insulates the Wearer from Heat Resists Breaking Open Provides Valuable Escape Time However, Burn Injuries Can Occur In Spite Of T
Slide 27: Types of Flame Resistant (FR) Fabrics
TYPES OF FLAME RESISTANT (FR) FABRICS Not All FR Is Made The Same Inherent (e.g. Nomex®, Kevlar®, PBI®, Kermel®, etc) FR performance is present in the DNA / chemistry of the fiber at the time of production Fiber molecular structure does not support combustion Inherent Blends (e.g. Nomex® MHP , Tecas
Slide 28: Nomex – Proven Performance
NOMEX® - PROVEN PERFORMANCE Hazards are Unpredictable. Nomex® is Not. Heritage: 40 years of proven performance 40+ years of the best thermal protection Inherent flame-resistant protection Protection from heat & flame, arc, and welding Inherent (Not Treated) lightweight protection Lightweight single
Slide 29: Why Does Exposure Duration Matter?
WHY DOES EXPOSURE DURATION MATTER? 29 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 30: Duration Is a Variable of Total Exposure
DURATION IS A VARIABLE OF TOTAL EXPOSURE You can generate total exposure by changing duration Heat Flux / Intensity Total Exposure Duration (sec) X (cal/cm²s) = (cal/cm²) 2.5 2.0 5.0 NFPA 3.0 2.0 6.0 2112 3.5 2.0 7.0 4.0 2.0 8.0 Total Exposure Energy = Duration X Intensity 7 oz/sy FR Treated Cotton
Slide 31: Duration & Intensity Impact Predicted Body Burn Injury %
DURATION & INTENSITY IMPACT PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % You can generate total exposure by changing duration or intensity NOMEX® IIIA - 6 oz/yd2 88/12 FR Treated Cotton / Nylon – 7 oz/yd2 3 seconds @ 2.02 cal/cm2s 3 seconds @ 2.02 cal/cm2s Total Exposure: 6.06 cal/cm2 Total Exposure: 6.06 cal/cm2 1
Slide 32: Duration & Intensity Impact Predicted Body Burn Injury %
DURATION & INTENSITY IMPACT PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % You can generate total exposure by changing duration or intensity 32 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed writt
Slide 33: Impact of Hazard & Apparel Selection on Survivability
IMPACT OF HAZARD & APPAREL SELECTION ON SURVIVABILITY At NFPA 2112 conditions – Less variation in FR fabric performance EXAMPLE Total Exposure Energy: 6 cal/cm2 88/12 FRTC (7 oz) 12 99.5 Testing conditions: (ASTM F1930) Intensity: 2 cal/cm2sec 4% variance Duration: 3 seconds Nomex® (6 oz) 16 99
Slide 34: Duration and Predicted Body Burn Injury %
DURATION AND PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % You can generate total exposure by changing duration NOMEX® IIIA - 6 oz/yd2 88/12 FR Treated Cotton / Nylon – 7 oz/yd2 4 seconds @ 2.06 cal/cm2s 4 seconds @ 2.06 cal/cm2s Total Exposure: 8.24 cal/cm2 Total Exposure: 8.24 cal/cm2 43.4% Predicted Body Burn Inj
Slide 35: Duration and Predicted Body Burn Injury %
DURATION AND PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % You can generate total exposure by changing duration 35 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 36: Predicted Body Burn Injury % at Increased Duration
PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % AT INCREASED DURATION NOMEX® IIIA, 6 oz/yd2 4 seconds @ 2.06 cal/cm2s Total Exposure: 8.24 cal/cm2 Predicted Burn Injury: 43.4% 88/12 FR Treated Cotton / Nylon, 7 oz/yd2 4 seconds @ 2.06 cal/cm2s Total Exposure: 8.24 cal/cm2 Predicted Burn Injury: 77.9% 36 Co
Slide 37: Impact of Hazard & Apparel Selection on Survivability
IMPACT OF HAZARD & APPAREL SELECTION ON SURVIVABILITY Your chance of surviving doubles with garments made of Nomex® EXAMPLE Total Exposure Energy: 8 cal/cm2 88/12 FRTC (7 oz) 42 78 Testing conditions: Intensity: 2 cal/cm2s 35% variance Duration: 4 seconds Nomex® (6 oz) 43 91 Body burns vary by 3
Slide 38: Total Heat Exposure From Industrial Fires Can Be Variable
TOTAL HEAT EXPOSURE FROM INDUSTRIAL FIRES CAN BE…… Real world fires (flash fire or other) 6 cal/cm2 Exposure (per NFPA 2112) Body burns 12 – 16% Survivability 99% + Regardless of FR fabric type 8 cal/cm2 Exposure Body burns 43 – 78% Survivability 42 – 91% Depends on FR fabric type NFPA 2112
Slide 39: Why Does Exposure Intensity Matter?
WHY DOES EXPOSURE INTENSITY MATTER? 39 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 40: Intensity Is a Variable of Total Exposure
INTENSITY IS A VARIABLE OF TOTAL EXPOSURE You can generate total exposure by changing duration or intensity Heat Flux / Intensity Total Exposure Duration (sec) X (cal/cm²s) = (cal/cm²) 3.0 1.75 5.25 NFPA 3.0 2.0 6.0 2112 3.0 2.33 7.0 3.0 2.67 8.0 Total Exposure Energy = Duration X Intensity 7 oz/sy
Slide 41: Intensity and Predicted Body Burn Injury %
INTENSITY AND PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % FR Treated Cotton at 3 seconds with varying intensity 88/12 FR Treated Cotton / Nylon – 7 oz/yd2 88/12 FR Treated Cotton / Nylon – 7 oz/yd2 3 seconds @ 2.02 cal/cm2s 3 seconds @ 2.36 cal/cm2s Total Exposure: 6.06 cal/cm2 Total Exposure: 7.08 cal/cm2 11.5% P
Slide 42: Intensity and Predicted Body Burn Injury %
INTENSITY AND PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % FR Treated Cotton at 3 seconds with varying intensity 42 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 43: Intensity and Predicted Body Burn Injury %
INTENSITY AND PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % NOMEX® IIIA at 3 seconds with varying intensity NOMEX® IIIA - 6 oz/yd2 NOMEX® IIIA - 6 oz/yd2 3 seconds @ 2.02 cal/cm2s 3 seconds @ 2.36 cal/cm2s Total Exposure: 6.06 cal/cm2 Total Exposure: 7.08 cal/cm2 16.4% Predicted Body Burn Injury 43.4% Predicted Body
Slide 44: Intensity and Predicted Body Burn Injury %
INTENSITY AND PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % NOMEX® IIIA at 3 seconds with varying intensity 44 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 45: Intensity and Predicted Body Burn Injury %
INTENSITY AND PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % You can generate total exposure by changing intensity NOMEX® IIIA - 6 oz/yd2 88/12 FR Treated Cotton / Nylon – 7 oz/yd2 3 seconds @ 2.36 cal/cm2s 3 seconds @ 2.36 cal/cm2s Total Exposure: 7.08 cal/cm2 Total Exposure: 7.08 cal/cm2 43.4% Predicted Body Burn I
Slide 46: Intensity and Predicted Body Burn Injury %
INTENSITY AND PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % You can generate total exposure by changing intensity 46 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 47: Predicted Body Burn Injury % at Increased Intensity
PREDICTED BODY BURN INJURY % AT INCREASED INTENSITY NOMEX® IIIA, 6 oz/yd2 3 seconds @ 2.36 cal/cm2s Total Exposure: 7.08 cal/cm2 Predicted Burn Injury: 43.4% 88/12 FR Treated Cotton / Nylon, 7 oz/yd2 3 seconds @ 2.36 cal/cm2s Total Exposure: 7.08 cal/cm2 Predicted Burn Injury: 83.6% 47 C
Slide 48: Impact of Hazard & Apparel Selection on Survivability
IMPACT OF HAZARD & APPAREL SELECTION ON SURVIVABILITY Chances of surviving nearly triples with garments made of Nomex® EXAMPLE Total Exposure Energy: 7.08 88/12 88/12 FRTC FRTC (7 (7 oz) 31 oz) 84 cal/cm2 Testing conditions: 41% variance Intensity: 2.36 cal/cm2sec Duration: 3 seconds Nomex® (6 N
Slide 49: Key Duration & Intensity Takeaways
KEY DURATION & INTENSITY TAKEAWAYS Industrial fires do not have a consistent duration and intensity Using 3 seconds as a “general rule of thumb” is not an accurate way to establish the level of protection workers need The 3 seconds concept is rooted in a test method developed for the military; and t
Slide 50: DuPont Thermo-Man: How You Know You Picked the Right FR Clothing
DUPONT THERMO-MAN® How you know you picked the right FR clothing 50 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 51: Why Do We Use DuPont Thermo-Man?
WHY DO WE USE DUPONTTM THERMO-MAN®? When it comes to fire protection, companies need to be prepared for the worst-case scenario, not the best A UL manikin testing facility certified to NFPA 2112 Used for NFPA 2113 clothing performance assessments Enables a direct comparison of materials under the sa
Slide 52: How Thermo-Man Helps You With NFPA 2113?
HOW THERMO-MAN® HELPS YOU WITH NFPA 2113? Clothing systems designed to address your hazards Visit our Thermo-Man® facility in Richmond, VA Attend or host a Thermo-Man® event at your facility or conference with DuPont’s one of a kind traveling unit You can use the video and data from the testing to e
Slide 53: Conclusions
CONCLUSIONS NFPA 2112 compliance may not mean adequate protection Fires are unpredictable – duration and intensity matter Thinking all fires last 3 seconds is a misconception Thinking all fire intensities are equal (2 cal/cm2s) is a misconception NFPA 2112 garment compliance/certification does not m
Slide 54: Thank You for Attending!
Thank You for Attending! For additional questions, please visit www.nomex.com 54 Copyright© 2013 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company. “ This material is only intended for this (webinar) and may not be used for any other purpose without the expressed written consent of DuPont”
Slide 55: Substantiation
SUBSTANTIATION “This information corresponds to our current knowledge on the subject and may be subject to revision as new knowledge becomes available. It is your responsibility to investigate other sources of information on this issue that more appropriately addresses your product and its intende