Evans Bancorp Inc

Evans Bancorp — Shareholder Meeting (April 2014)

37 slides from Evans Bancorp's shareholder meeting presentation, Apr 23, 2014

  1. Slide 1: Annual Meeting of Shareholders

    NYSE MKT: www.evansbank.com EVBN Annual Meeting of Shareholders EVANS April 24, 2014 BANCORP inc 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  2. Slide 2: John R. O'Brien, Chairman

    NYSE MKT: www.evansbank.com EVBN John R. O’Brien EVANS Chairman BANCORPinc 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  3. Slide 3: David J. Nasca, President and CEO

    NYSE MKT: www.evansbank.com EVBN David J. Nasca EVANS President and CEO BANCORPinc 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  4. Slide 4: Safe Harbor Statement

    Safe Harbor Statement This presentation includes “forward looking statements" within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements include, but are not limited to, statements concerning future business, revenue and earnings. These statements are not historical

  5. Slide 5: Delivered on our Strategic Initiatives

    Delivered on our Strategic Initiatives » Moving forward — building net income » Approached record results from 2012 » Expanded our customer base Net Income » Strong loan and deposit growth (in millions) >» Scalable infrastructure for $8.1 $7.9 future growth $6.1 $4.9 $4.8 $3.4 p a 2007 2008 2009 201

  6. Slide 6: Creating Value

    Creating Value Focused on Growing Book Value Per Share $19.18 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 EVANS 6 BANCORP we © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  7. Slide 7: Returning Capital to Shareholders

    Returning Capital to Shareholders » Increased semi-annual dividend in 2014 » Accelerated payment of semi-annual dividend in 2012 due to tax concerns ox = $0.62 $0.24 $0.40 $0.40 ae $0.44 $0.26 2010 , 2011 , 2012 . 2013 “2014 Annualized Dividends Paid ‘Accelerated Dividend Payment 7 BANCORP ic © 2014

  8. Slide 8: EVBN Outperforming Peers

    EVBN Outperforming Peers (through 3/31/2014) 50% 7 45% 7 40% + 35% 7 30% 7 25% 7 20% 7 15% 4 10% 4 5% 4 0% 7 7 7 T T 1 1 T T Dec-12. Feb-13. Apr-13.-— May-13 = Jul-13. = Sep-13. Oct-13.» Dec-13. --Feb-14.—s Mar-14 47% EVBN Increase Since 12/31/2012 =="EVBN ===" SNL Bank =" High Performing Peers ===

  9. Slide 9: 2013 Highlights

    2013 Highlights >» Completed facility consolidation = Positioned for long-term, sustainable growth = Improved collaboration = More efficient cost structure EVANS BANCORP inc. © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  10. Slide 10: 2013 Highlights — Alternate Channels

    2013 Highlights — Alternate Channels > 41% of online customers use Evans Mobile Banking | | AID Sime check balances and more, >» Surcharge-free ATM access at all 531 New York pharmacies = 16 Evans-branded ATMs located in WNY area 10 BANCORP nc © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  11. Slide 11: 2013 Highlights - EVANS ONE

    2013 Highlights - EVANS |ONE » Relationship approach to banking » Value Proposition = Premier products and services = Exclusive benefits >» Customer acquisition tool = Differentiates us from competition erience, Aunique wa 2: nse net only you: That's better. _— © EVANS —— eee =| " BANCORP xc © 2014

  12. Slide 12: Notable Recognition

    Notable Recognition Raymond James Community Bankers Cup Ranked second in total dollars and third in number of Top 10% of community SBA loans banks for overall profitability, operational efficiency and balance sheet metrics Nominated for 2014 Western New York competition 12 © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  13. Slide 13: Customer Research

    Customer Research 94% Said Evans Bank was superior to other Banks 96% Would recommend Evans to a friend 98% Evans makes them feel important 13 © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  14. Slide 14: Revitalizing Buffalo

    Revitalizing Buffalo Horsefeathers © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  15. Slide 15: Corporate Culture - Community Focused

    Corporate Culture - Community Focused © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  16. Slide 16: Gary A. Kajtoch, Executive Vice President and CFO

    NYSE MKT: www.evansbank.com EVBN Gary A. Kajtoch EVANS Executive Vice President and CFO BANCORP inc 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  17. Slide 17: Financial Strategies

    Financial Strategies Growing the balance sheet Loan and revenue diversification I Maintain credit discipline he Position for long-term, sustainable growth and value creation - 17 © 2014 by Evans Bancorp EVANS BANCORP inc.

  18. Slide 18: Growing the Balance Sheet: Expanding Asset Base

    Growing the Balance Sheet Expanding Asset Base » Expanding asset base through organic loan growth and small acquisition >» Increasing future earnings power ($ in millions) $809.7 $833.5 $740.9 $671.5 $619.4 7.7% CAGR (2009 — 2013) 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 t Asset growth of 34.6% _ EVANS 18 BANCORP n

  19. Slide 19: Growing the Balance Sheet: Loan Growth

    Growing the Balance Sheet Loan Growth >» High quality in-market commercial loans > Capturing strong credits from larger banks >» Supports core business strategy —— 647.0 ($ in millions) $577.4 $581.3 $ $458.1 9.0% CAGR (2009 - 2013) 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 EVANS 19 BANCORP nc © 2014 by Evans Bancor

  20. Slide 20: Loan Portfolio Diversification

    Loan Portfolio Diversification Focused on C&l Loans Total Loans and Lease Portfolio: Commercial Loans* $647.0 million* Home Equities 8.8% Construction / and Development 4.7% Residential Mortgages** 14.8% a Consumer 0.3% Commercial & Industrial 16.5% *As of December 31, 2013 **Includes construction l

  21. Slide 21: Maintaining Solid Credit Fundamentals

    21 Maintaining Solid Credit Fundamentals NPAs to Total Loans + OREO Net Charge Offs to Average Loans 5.00% 4.00% 3.00% 2.00% 1.00% 0.29% —_ 0.10% 0.26% 0.04% _-0.05% 00% 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 =Q1 2014 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Q1 2014 == EVBN == Banks > $500 Million & < $1 Billion in Assets* >» Bo

  22. Slide 22: Growing the Balance Sheet: Low Cost Core Deposit Growth

    Growing the Balance Sheet Low Cost Core Deposit Growth > 4.6% increase since 2012 in regular savings, demand deposits and NOW deposits > 2013 deposit costs: 0.34% (excluding time deposits) ($ in millions) ane ie NOW $679.0 $7066 _ $544.5 aGIG2 Time Deposits $499.5 : 16% 9.1% CAGR (2009 — 2013) 2009

  23. Slide 23: Positioned for Long-term Growth: Strong Revenue Growth

    Positioned for Long-term Growth Strong Revenue Growth >» Diversified revenue sources: 30% of revenue from non-interest sensitive relationships Revenue (in millions) $40.6 $41.3 $36.0 3.5% CAGR (2009 — 2013) 2009* 2010 2011 2012 2013** * Excludes $0.7 million gain on bargain purchase ** Excludes hist

  24. Slide 24: Positioned for Long-term Growth: Stabilized Net Interest Margin

    Positioned for Long-term Growth Stabilized Net Interest Margin > Q4 2013 net interest margin 7 basis points above Banks >$500M and <$1B in assets Quarterly NIM 4.50% - 4.00% - 3.50% BANCORP inc. 24 © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  25. Slide 25: Revenue Diversification

    Revenue Diversification Focused on Non-!nterest Income >» 30% of total revenue in 2013 . . _ Bank-owned » Fee income less rate sensitive Life Insurance 4% » Increased cross-sell Other Income 25% F. ($ in millions) 13.4 | $12.6 $12.4 $12.8 2009* 2010 2011 2012 Bank Charges $13.0 16% Insurance Service

  26. Slide 26: Strong First Quarter 2014 Results

    Strong First Quarter 2014 Results (in millions, except per share data) Revenue Non-Interest Expense $10.1 $10.7 $7.1 $7.6 $3.3 | $3.4 Q1 2013 Q1 2014 Q1 2013 Q1 2014 ™ Net Interest Income ™Non-Interest Income Net Income Earnings Per Share (dilutea) $2.0 $0.43 $0.47 $1.8 Q1 2013 Q1 2014 Q1 2013 Q1 20

  27. Slide 27: Improved Capital Structure

    Improved Capital Structure Evans Bancorp — March 31, : Regulatory” : Risk-Based Capital Ratios : Guidelinesfor : 2014 2013 2012 : Well Capitalized : Tier 1 leverage ratio 5.00% | 10.20% | 9.87% | 9.74% | Tier 1 risk-based capital 6.00% | 13.44% | 14.02% | 12.96% | Total risk based capital 10.00% | 1

  28. Slide 28: A better way. Forward.

    NYSE MKT: www.evansbank.com EVBN A better way. Forward. EVANS BANCORPixc © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  29. Slide 29: 2014 Considerations

    2014 Considerations Interest rate environment — margins remain tight WNY among one of the most competitive markets in the U.S. Continued growth will require: * Proactive sales and market share capture ¢ Alternative distribution « Maintaining investment in people, processes and systems 29 © 2014 by E

  30. Slide 30: Opportunity: Market Share by Deposits

    Opportunity Market Share by Deposits a evans >» Focused on market share Others A. 70 expansion Sis / Bank of » Market places value on community centric approach 2.0% 1.1% 201 3 2008 2013 $33.0B Total Deposits Source: FDIC, as of June 30, 2013 EVANS 30 BANCORP ixc © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  31. Slide 31: 2014 Strategic Plan Well Underway

    2014 Strategic Plan Well Underway Refocus Community y Banking Model Effective Risk Fee Based Management Income Growth Optimize Effective Technology Lending Strategy Strengthen | Operating Model EVANS at BANCORP ic

  32. Slide 32: 2014 Projects

    2014 Projects a. to all of our p; mle? , ery <<, wis milestone po, § e sie = Commercial Lending Team. © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  33. Slide 33: Banking Insurance Investments

    BANKING INSURANCE INVESTMENTS EVANS BANCORP inc. © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  34. Slide 34: Investment Highlights

    Investment Highlights 34 Diverse revenue mix, strong operating fundamentals Strong and growing franchise in resurgent WNY Sophisticated / experienced management team Jy a yt yt Solid capital base Quality core deposit and loan growth Lower-risk balance sheet Shareholder return orientation _ Historica

  35. Slide 35: Questions

    NYSE MKT: www.evansbank.com EVBN Questions EVANS BANCORPixc E © 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  36. Slide 36: Results of the Election

    NYSE MKT: www.evansbank.com EVBN Results of the Election EVANS BANCORPixc 2014 by Evans Bancorp

  37. Slide 37: Annual Meeting of Shareholders

    NYSE MKT: www.evansbank.com EVBN Annual Meeting of Shareholders EVANS April 24, 2014 BANCORP inc 2014 by Evans Bancorp

Evans Bancorp — Shareholder Meeting (April 2014) on 6ix